![]() | Association for Participatory Democracy | Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md Original: /en/e-journal/20040225/index.shtml |
Activity of public institutions
Dissention on political scenery
Suspending the immunity of a number of Christian-Democrats deputies has been on the top agenda of the Parliament over the last two weeks. Christian-Democrats are persecuted for organizing protest rallies at the Russian Embassy and National TV as well as for unauthorised protest rallies. At the call of the Prosecution Office, Communists backed by independent deputies voted in favour of suspending the immunity of Iurie Rosca, Vlad Cubreacov, Stefan Secareanu, and Valentin Chilat.
Legal acts
Via the Law on the modification of the Law on Government, the Parliament decided on the re-organisation of the Ministry of Environment, Constructions and Territory Planning into two separate structures: Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources, and Department for Constructions and Territory Planning. This restructure comes only weeks after President Voronin dubbed the Ministry as a "monster" failing to handle all the tasks it was entrusted and after Gheorghe Duca was elected Chair of the Academy of Science.
Under the modifications to the Law on the modification of the Labour Code, the provision obliging employers applying for licensing to have a prior permission of the work protection bodies, was excluded. The Government lobbied the amendment with a goal to reduce the number of legal acts required for licensing and thereby boost small business.
The Resolution on 645-th anniversary of the Moldovan state provides for the celebration of the 645th anniversary of the Moldovan state via numerous events at the national and local level, which is of paramount importance for the "steadiness of the Moldovan nation. The document does not specify on the territory where the celebrations are to be held, between Prut and Dniester or on the whole area known as Moldova. The decision was passed in order to consolidate "multinational Moldovan" society, accelerate the restoration of the territorial integrity, and Moldova's affirmation in European community. The document does not provide any clear mechanisms for pursuing the said goals.
Moreover, Parliament ratified a number of international acts, such as Agreement on free trade between Republic of Moldova and Ukraine; Resolution of the CIS Governmental Council on the remuneration in the community bodies, providing for a wage increase to the officials working in the CIS structures so as to adjust them to the general living standards; Status of the Intra-European Organisation of Fiscal Administrations, which promotes co-operation and exchange of experience between fiscal authorities of the member states; Stockholm convention on organic pollution, aimed at protecting peoples' health and environment against organic pollution.
Last week Parliament passed the Law on the modification of legal acts regulating pharmaceutical industry, forbidding the sale or exchange of medications among wholesalers. Also medications and drugs are to be only imported directly from producers or their authorised dealers.
Also Parliament appointed Valeriu Gurbulea as Senior Deputy to the Prosecutor General, previously Secretary of the Supreme Security Council of the Moldovan Presidency, and confirmed the membership of the General Prosecution College.
Reshuffles
On February 11, Government ousted two Deputy Ministers of Foreign Affairs, namely Ion Stavila and Vitalie Slonovschi. The two will be replaced by Eugenia Kistruga, former Foreign Policy Councillor to the Presidency, and Sergiu Stati, former consultant. The move comes only two weeks after Andrei Stratan replaced Nicolae Dudau as Foreign Affairs Minister.
One week later, Victor Zlacevschi, Parliament representative at CIS Inter-parliamentary Assembly was appointed Republic of Moldova's Ambassador to Romania. Also, Anatol Dubrovschi, former Culture, Education and Science Councillor to the Presidency was appointed Deputy Minister of Education, whereas Valeriu Lazar, Director of the "Intelligent Service" was appointed Deputy Minister of Economy.
Decisions
At the request of the liquidation commission of the "Teleradio-Moldova" state company, on February 11 Government decided to liquidate the company for it to be reorganised into a public institution. Once the decision is approved by the Parliament it would be interesting to see whether journalists not exactly loyal to the Company leadership would be invited to join the team of the public TV.
To keep its promises to employers and trade unions, last week Government ruled that as of February 1, 2004 monthly tariffs for 1st degree employees of the self-sustainable economic units would be 440 Lei and 360 Lei for the same category employees in public medical institutions and agriculture. For the latter, the deadline for enforcement will be stretched, but only until September 1, 2004.
Government also approved on February 18, a program on the development of the pharmaceutical industry throughout 2004-2006. In particular the program provides for developing pharmaceutical research, extension of the medical supply network on the entire soil of the Republic, ensuring high quality medicines. Within two weeks, relevant Ministries should come up with another plan that would allow "for at least one state-owned pharmacy to be opened in each locality and hospital".
Under another draft law, a 85 km gas pipeline is to be build from Causeni to Chisinau, worth 25 million USD. It is believed the pipeline would provide greater energetic security to the capital city and bring gas to around 20 localities.
Government also endorsed a Regulation thereby public vacancies are to be filled based on competition. The applicants would have to pass a written test and an interview, and also pay an admission fee.
National Commission for European Integration
On February 14, National Commission for European Integration and decision-makers from relevant ministries and departments followed on the Individual Action Plan Republic of Moldova - EU. The propositions made by them are to be discussed with European experts during the second round negotiations scheduled for February 23 in Brussels. Vasile Tarlev was quoted as saying "Action Plan should provide for specific actions aimed at developing the PRSP, Partnership and Cooperation Agreement, and co-operation within Stability Pact for South-Eastern Europe". The press release reads "top priorities should include inauguration of a permanent EU office in Chisinau, signing an asymmetric free trade agreement and an stabilisation and association agreement based on the four core liberties: free circulation of goods, money, services and citizens".
Building an information society
Free Internet connectivity to secondary schools and libraries has been on the agenda of a session convened by President Voronin. He was quoted as saying "building an information society should become a national priority as part of European integration efforts. Joining EU is not possible unless we meet European standards, especially in the social-economic, educational and informational fields". In this respect decisive and innovative measures were needed to make a big step towards informational society, pointed the President, adding that there were conditions in place for that to happen.
The President called for a plan to be developed outlining how to build an informational society, the first stage thereof being free internet connectivity to all secondary schools and libraries by the end of 2005. A Task Fore was established under the auspices of the Ministry of Education to co-ordinate and monitor the plan enforcement.
A new plan on Transnistria settlement
Upon the request of the Bulgarian chairmanship of the OSCE, the OSCE Mission in Chisinau published on 16 February the Transnistrian settlement plan drafted by the mediators last autumn, which plan was presented to the Moldovan and Transnistrian sides for feedback and comments earlier, according to an agreement reached by the mediators in Sofia last month. The document entitled "Proposals and recommendations of the mediators from the OSCE, the Russian Federation, Ukraine with regards to the Transnistrian settlement" does not determine a definite deadline for the conclusion of negotiations or for the adoption of the federal Constitution. It only makes general references to the structure of the future federal state and of the Parliament and to the method of electing the President. Thus, the reintegrated Republic of Moldova is o be a federal state, with one federal subject - Transnistria. The federal subject may leave the federation should Moldova lose its current status under international law or join another state. The plan provides for a series of political, economic, humanitarian and military guarantees. The latter are to be provided in the form of international peace keeping troops under an OSCE mandate. The plan grants more powers to the federal bodies than the one proposed by the Russian Federation last November, as well as significant leverages over the federal subjects. The Federal Parliament will have two chambers, of which the upper chamber will be elected on the basis of the territorial-administrative principle, and the head of state will be elected either through direct vote or through the vote of the Parliament.
The two sides have already submitted their proposals to the mediators on the plan. These will be discussed on 24 February in Belgrade during a new three sided meeting of the mediators. The date for resuming the negotiations is to be established afterwards.
The withdrawal of Russian weaponry from Transnistria
The Russian Defence Minister Serghei Ivanov told the annual NATO Conference in Munich on 6-7 February that Russia might ask for the re-negotiation of the Istanbul agreements, in particular of the Treaty of Conventional Forces in Europe (CFE). According to Ivanov, the EFE Treaty will loose its capability of maintaining stability and the balance of interests in Europe once new seven states join NATO, some of which do not participative in the CFE. Under these new politico-military conditions, Russia believes it justified to re-negotiate the terms of withdrawal of its troops and weaponry from Georgia and Moldova.
A few days later, the Russian Ambassador to Moldova Iuri Zubakov told a press conference in Chisinau that Russia has fully fulfilled its obligations under the CFE with regards to the Republic of Moldova, and that the Russian military contingent stationed in Transnistria will be evacuated as soon as the necessary conditions are in place. According to Zubakov, the two month pause in the withdrawal process is due to some "complications" related to the failure of the Russian-proposed federalisation plan last November, and to the pending issue of financial compensations demanded from Russia by the Transnistrian authorities.
In reply to the statements of Ambassador Zubakov, the Moldovan Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a communique in which it said that the issue of the political resolution of the Transnistrian conflict may in no event be synchronised with the evacuation of Russian troops and munitions from the territory of the Republic of Moldova, and urges the Russian Federation to fulfil its Istanbul commitments without further delay. According to the communique, any relationship between the failure to sign the Russian proposal and the pause in the evacuation of Russian munitions "is counterproductive to the resolution of conflict and may only have negative repercussions on the behaviour of the Transnistrian authorities at the negotiations table".
It appears, however, that the Transnistrian authorities do not share these statements, as they have recently declared that they want Russia to maintain its military presence in the region until the final resolution of the conflict between Chisinau and Tiraspol.
The dispute around the Moldovan police commissariat in Tighina (Bender)
The situation around the Moldovan police commissariat and the penitentiary for TBC infected inmates from Tighina, both institutions administratively subordinated to the Moldovan authorities, has significantly deteriorated during the period covered in this e-journal. The local authorities have for several years demanded that the two institutions be evacuated from the town, and since August 2003 have disconnected them from the town water and energy supply. Since several rounds of negotiations on this issue within the Joint Control Commission have failed, the local authorities have reverted last week a series of actions o forceful evacuation of the Moldovan police from Tighina (Bender). After having dismantled the windows and doors of half of the building, where among other institutions the Moldovan police commissariat is based, they have dismantled the roof over part of the building, including some offices of the commissariat. Although the incident has not resulted in any violent clashes between the workers of the commissariat and the team of repair workers, it has left its mark over the already tensioned relations between Chisinau and Tiraspol. The Moldovan Reintegration Minister Vasile Sova called the actions of the Tighina (Bender) authorities a flagrant violation of the ceasefire agreement of 1992 and a provocation to Chisinau. On the other hand, the OSCE Mission in Moldova has called upon the Transnistrian authorities to refrain from unilateral actions that might destabilise the situation.
Preparations for elections
Igor Botan
Albeit there is almost one year left until electoral campaign officially starts, parties are already warming up. So far, possible electoral alliances and relations between power and opposition have been topping the agenda of the would-be electoral contestants. Therefore, the legal framework, which would govern the electoral process, has been totally neglected.
For a start, one should bear in mind that the time left until next elections is not enough time for a cardinal revision of the electoral law. Electoral Code passed in November 1997 and viewed by international experts as a quite good document as compared to other similar laws in CIS or South-Eastern Europe, does no longer meet the standards in as far as election administration, voting procedures, transparency of the campaign finance, and campaign coverage in mass media, are concerned. Just for the sake of comparison, in Russian Federation electoral law has been revised practically after each election campaign or electoral cycle, whereas in Moldova the numerous amendments operated to the Electoral Code resumed to clarifying existing norms, providing favourable playing field to the ruling parties or coalitions, and raising obstacles to would-be competitors. For instance, the threshold of representation for political parties was raised from 4% to 6%, and later it was raised for electoral blocs to 9% and 12%, depending on the number of parties entering the bloc.
Still, in the time left until the next elections, it would be wise to bring the law in line with OSCE recommendations, at least. It is known for a fact that the Communist faction is currently working on amendments to the Electoral Code, however it remains tight-lipped about the articles they had set their eyes on.
Secondly, after Constitution had been amended in 2000 and the country turned to a parliamentarian form of governing, the 5th title of the Electoral Code referring to the presidential elections was excluded. In September the same year, the Law on Election of the President of the Republic of Moldova was passed, thereby the President was not elected directly by people, but rather by the Parliament. The law was passed in a big hurry, only several months prior to the expiration of the President's mandate, and therefore was not well thought out.
The experience of the 2001 parliamentary and then presidential elections is not relevant either for us to claim that such legal clashes are excluded in the future. Thus, last presidential elections had been firstly set for December 1, 2000 the very same day the four-year presidential mandate expired. Under article 78(5) of the revised Constitution, Parliament's failure to elect a new President after two consecutive attempts led to its dissolution on December 31, 2000 by the incumbent President, whose mandate had already expired. Although presidential seat was vacant (under Article 90(1), and the President was to be elected "within two months of the day the position became vacant". However, under Article 90(4) of the Constitution the President's mandate was extended for another 4 months, "until the newly elected President is sworn in". Thus, the President was finally elected on April 4, 2001 by the newly elected Parliament.
The aforesaid example tests the applicability of the revised Constitution and the Law on Election of the President of the Republic of Moldova in cases when President mandate and that of the Parliament expire on different terms (more than a year apart). In cases when both mandates expire almost at the same time, as it would be the case in 2005, the things wouldn't be so crystal clear, especially due to the discrepancies between the revised Constitution and the Law on Election of the President of the Republic of Moldova.
b) Wide berth for manoeuvres
To avoid possible conflicts between political forces on the eve of 2005 elections, certain things should be clarified right now. For a start, under the Constitution (Article 61 (3)) and Electoral Code (Article 76), parliamentary elections are to be held within three months after the expiration of its mandate, whereas according to Article 2 (1) of the Law regulating presidential elections the President is to be elected within 45 days prior the expiration of his/her mandate.
Constitutional Court ruling no. 31 of 10.11.1997 reads "Parliament mandate commences on the election day and ceases upon the expiration of 4 years". The incumbent Parliament was elected on February 25, 2001, therefore according to the Constitution and Electoral Code the next parliamentary elections should be scheduled for any Sunday between February 26 and May 26, 2005. On the other hand, elections of the President whose mandated commenced on April 7, 20001 (the day he took the oath) should be scheduled sometime between February 22 and April 7, 2005. Those dates should be reconciled so as to avoid any violation of the Constitution and laws on elections.
Normally, given that the duration of Parliament and President mandates coincide, one legislature should only elect one President. If this principle is observed, then the Law on Election of the President of the Republic of Moldova would considerably reduce the 3 months period allotted by Constitution for Parliamentary elections, which would have to be scheduled sometime between February 27 and March 27, 2005, so that the new legislature would have enough time to convene (one month) and to elect the President by April 7, 2005 as required by law. This is the ideal scenario from a legal point of view.
On the other hand, the said principle (one legislature elects one President) is neither provided for in the Constitution nor in any other law, leaving the Parliament a wide berth for deciding the order of electing the new Parliament and the new President.
Majority faction in Parliament (including the incumbent one) or any other coalition not certain of its ability to secure 3/5 of the votes necessary to elect a President may want to exploit this, by electing the President prior to parliamentary elections. And they would encounter not a single obstacle in this respect. Once its mandate expires, Parliament may not amend Constitution nor could it amend or adopt organic laws, however it may pass ordinary laws and resolutions. Under the Law on the Election of the President of the Republic of Moldova (Article 11) "Parliament passes a resolution confirming that the President of the Republic of Moldova was elected". And then, (according to Article 79 (1)) Constitutional Court is to validate election results.
c) Conclusions
In principle the ruling party may set the date of parliamentary elections so as to avoid any scandals related to parliamentary or presidential elections (from the end of February to March 2005) and to abide Constitution and the Law on the Election of the President of the Republic of Moldova.
However, the experience of CIS, which Moldova is a part of, indicates that the temptation is too high for political leaders to take advantage of any deficiencies in the legislation. The most recent example is Ukraine, where Constitutional Court did find enough "arguments" to allow President Kucima to run for his third mandate, albeit Constitution clearly states that one person may exercise the function of President only for two mandates.
Having said that, any temptations should be eliminated even if the incumbent majority in Parliament has given no grounds for suspecting it of ill intentions. In this respect, it is necessary to amend only two articles in the Law on the Election of the President of the Republic of Moldova.
Article 2(1) of the law should be modified as follows: "Elections of the President of the Republic of Moldova shall be held within two months after the expiration of the mandate".
Article 11(2) should be modified as follows: "Parliament passes an organic law to confirm the election of the President of the Republic of Moldova".
Arguments:
Discord among authorities and domestic producers
Iurie Gotisan
Albeit Commerce and Industry Chamber and National Association of Producers had hoped to show the potential of Moldovan industry, in the end the only thing this event did show was that national producers and Government were still on different sides of the battlefield and that they still had very few in common.
It's easy to criticise the state for its incoherent policies, however there is plenty room for criticising the businessmen as well. For a start, they want the state to protect them from unwanted international competition, by taking protectionist measures, which is quite a task especially since Moldova joined WTO. On the other hand, many industrialists still refuse to acknowledge their obligation to reward the protectionism the state had granted them, by paying taxes. What's also strange is that great many businessmen ranted about the high fines levied for non-compliance with the law, rather than about high taxes. This reasoning is inherent to the soviet-time style of making money, when the businessmen contribute towards social welfare by building overly sumptuous villas.
In its turn, Government seeks to keep economy under control. To cite just the pressure wielded on the foreign investors, or the Communist Party electoral program, reading "the end goal of the Communist Party is for the state to take over the means of production and establish a socialist economic system". Cosmetic measures undertaken by the Government to show business community that "country leadership is on their side" cannot possibly handle the toughest challenge Moldovan economy is facing - shadow economy. According to a recent UNDP report, shadow economy in Moldova accounts for 50% of GDP. Businessmen and Government alike agree that it's their shared responsibility. The former, used to the state merciless, does not dare to go in the open. The state, wrongly assuming that high taxes mean higher revenues, refuses to cut taxes, which for more than a decade now are the highest among the transition countries.
For instance Hungary and Poland due to join EU soon, lure investors by low income taxes of up to 20%. Having said that, what "carrots" does Moldova have to lure foreign capital? The recent reformatory law package passed by the Slovakian Parliament reduced the income tax to 19%. A single taxation quota is used in Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Russia (13% income tax and no social payments), and Ukraine as well, whereas Baltic countries make their "fiscal offer" even more attractive by further cutting the taxation basis. Those regional tendencies to reduce the fiscal burden would most likely affect Republic of Moldova in terms of attractiveness to investments, unless the country comes with a competitive advantage.
Taxes in the region are well bellow those in Moldova. Therefore, Government would have to take a raft of measures to preserve its economic competitiveness. For some political reasons, Government's fiscal strategy overlooked the "investment magnet" that works so well in Central and Eastern Europe. Too much of a fiscal burden is similar to a too high interest rate, when it affects the balance sheet of indebted companies. A slight drop in the corporate income tax from 25% to 22%, as provided for in the 2004 budget, is not enough to decrease the number of businesses in "shadow". Although apparently they understand this, authorities refrain from taking the path of fiscal reform for fear to loose the meagre revenues they currently collect and that are necessary to fund the populist social policies promised by the ruling party during the electoral campaign.
Going back to the event that determined me to put down some thoughts about the state of Moldovan business, I should acknowledge that the problems raised by the business community are already know, i.e. obligatory inspection before expedition (in the eyes of many stymieing Moldovan business), high energy costs included in the final product price, pressure wielded by the bureaucrats and excessive state control. Some of the aforesaid problems have already become inherent, especially when it comes to high energy cost. The latter is due not only to obsolete equipment and distribution networks, but also to worn out production lines and technology - common feature of the great majority of businesses present at the exhibition. This has lead to a paradox - the share of energy consumed by Moldovan industry in the growth industrial product is one of the highest in Europe, whereas the share of energy consumed by the citizens is the lowest in Europe.
Exhibition was held under the auspices of Prime Minister Tarlev, who also heads the National Producers' Association. Probably Tarlev's unspoken message at the reunion was "I used to be a businessmen myself, so I do know business problems far too well". What's striking is that although Tarlev comes from business community, his former fellow colleagues agree that the tensions between state and producers have never been higher. Business' response to the governmental interventions in economy was quick: in January the revenues to state budget dropped sharply as compared to last year.
Although, high taxes were in the spotlight throughout the entire exhibition, in a recent interview to "Economic Overview" the Chief of State Fiscal Inspection stated that the Fiscal Code in force at the moment was the best possible option. Therefore, my dear businessmen mind your own business, as the fiscal revolution has been adjourned!
|
© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT" Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated | e-mail: [email protected] |