![]() | Association for Participatory Democracy | Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md Original: /en/e-journal/20040428/index.shtml |
Activity of public institutions
1.1. Incidents one after another
After Christian-Democrats were denied the right to address questions and inquiries to Government on the grounds confrontation was to be avoided on the eve of Easter, they were again denied this right the week that followed. As Parliament convened on Friday, it was possible to avoid the Government interpellation usually scheduled for Thursdays. Lack of Government interpellation for two weeks in a row determined Christian-Democrat leader to ask the floor right at the beginning of the plenary session. As he was denied, Iurie Rosca blocked the central tribune and one of the microphones in the hall. Therefore the session was held using the other microphones. At the end of the session, Iurie Rosca read a declaration accusing the Speaker of breaching oppositions' rights and concealing information requested by opposition.
During the next session on April 22 Christian-Democrats again blocked the tribune and called on Speaker Ostapciuc's resignation. In an altercation, Communists took deputy Vlad Cubreacov by force out of the plenary hall. The session continued despite the fact that the tribune had been blocked. At the end of the session, Eugenia Ostapciuc announced that during the next session Parliament regulation should be amended to include emergency procedures to allow police to intervene against deputies who obstruct Parliament activity.
1.2. Legal acts
Despite the rich harvest of criticism and objections, still, the Parliament passed the Law on Offshore Tax. The law perfected and clarified on quite contradictory provisions. The law defines offshore tax and offshore zone. The list of offshore zones is to be approved by the Government. The law also outlines the subjects of taxation, namely legal or natural entities, residents of the Republic of Moldova falling in the categories outlined in fiscal legislation, engaged in trade and financial transactions via offshore zones. The law also outlines which particular operations shall be subject of taxation.
Off-shore tax shall be paid to the state budget by the residents of the Republic of Moldova, subject to taxation, in MDL at the official National Bank exchange rate equal to 15%. Offshore tax shall be considered part of general and administrative expenses and shall be deducted from the income subject to taxation when calculating income tax. In case of delay to pay the offshore tax in due time a fine shall be calculated in line with the Fiscal Code provisions. Failure to comply with reporting regulations shall be also sanctioned.
It is worth mentioning that one of the major objections to the law was that it would propel fuel prices upwards, as well as prices on other imported goods; affect current and would-be investors; raise contradictions between national law and international treaties providing for elimination of double taxation, etc.
Resolution on approving Regulation on spending funds from the Agriculture Development Fund adopted by the Parliament regulates the method of spending the agriculture development fund worth 36 m MDL. Under the Regulation approved by the Parliament, 22 m MDL shall be administered by the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry and be used to subsidize and support crediting of enterprises producing agriculture products by commercial banks, savings and loan association and Rural Financing Corporation. Another 14 m shall be administered by "Moldresurse" State Enterprise and be used to build agricultural machinery centres. The regulation also provides that subsidies granted to one enterprise shall not exceed 85 thousand MDL per year.
(For further details on Parliament activity see http://www.e-democracy.md/en/comments/legislative/)
2.1. Decisions
So far, the company managed to pay back 56% of the total debt. Under the Memorandum, the entire debt is to be paid by June 30, 2005. A study of the economic and financial situation of the company found that it wouldn't manage to pay back the debt in due time. Noteworthy, "Covoare-Ungheni" is a private company. In 2003 its net sales reached 75 m MDL, a 3.7 m surge over the previous year. Last year the company had a 6.8 m MDL gross profit.
Another modification reduces and merges types of activity subject to the Law. Currently the law provides for 58 types of activity subject to licensing, whereas under the draft only 47. Such activities as judicial expertise, archaeological research, etc are excluded.
To de-bureaucratise licensing, it is proposed to exclude the obligation to submit a certificate to the effect that applicant has not outstanding debts to the state budget or social insurance fund. According to Zinaida Chistruga Chief of the Licensing Chamber, currently the law provides that if the applicant has such outstanding debts the license should be withdrawn. Also the move, would enable applicants to save money as authentication of relevant documents would no longer be needed.
3.1. Fighting corruption
President Vladimir Voronin met Holly Wiseman, American expert on fighting corruption that coaches the Centre for Fighting Economic Crime and Corruption (CFECC) in its restructuring efforts. Also present at the meeting was US Ambassador Heather M. Hodges. At issue were ways of making the Department's activity more efficient. President Voronin underlined that fighting corruption was topping authorities agenda and he asked for expertise of the National Strategy of Preventing and Fighting Corruption and Action Plan to enforce it. Noteworthy, the two documents were adopted during the recent session of the Supreme Security Council. Their aim is to put an end to corruption, which according to President Voronin "impedes social-economic development of our country, undermines any reform in the Republic of Moldova, and has become a real issue for state security".
President reiterated his harsh position towards CFECC on April 23. During the Centre's session President Voronin severely criticized CFECC for falling short of the very purpose it had been established for. To eliminate the flaws President recommended streamlining Centre's activity, its active participation in improving the legal framework so as to eliminate sources generating corruption, concentrating on analytical work and preventing corruption, and closer co-operation with law-enforcement forces.
3.2. Top priority of the Republic of Moldova's home and foreign policy
President Voronin took part in the graduation ceremony of the European integration courses by 35 public officers working in various ministries and state departments. On this occasion President once again reiterated European integration as a top priority of Moldova's home and foreign policy, which is quite opposite from what he stated on February 21 during a Government session called to prioritize tasks for 2004. Back then President outlined "social modernisation of the state" as a top priority. As for European integration, it ranked the second among the Government's priorities together with "modernizing economy" followed by "country reintegration and state security". At the end of that session President said "members of the Government should solve the problems outlined by being accountable and committed as a statesman should be, understanding that there are no insignificant details in exercising power" (Moldova suverana, #29 (20431), 24 February 2004).
1. Foreign economic relations
An official delegation of the Republic of Moldova headed by Minister of Economy Marian Lupu flew to London for the annual reunion of the ERBD Board of Governors on April 18-20. Marian Lupu made a presentation on the country's economic success throughout 2003. Afterwards he met businessmen - potential investors for Moldova.
As part of the ERBD reunion, Moldovan delegation had a number of important meetings, among others with ERBD President, Jean Lemierre; Director General of the UK International Development Department, Nicola Brewer; representatives of European Commission; as well as official delegations of Romania, Russia, Ukraine, Armenia, Netherlands and Japan.
Republic of Moldova was short listed for larger financial aid from ERBD. The bank is set to increase its investments from 90 m to 150 m Euro per year for the seven most poor former soviet republics, namely Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kyrgyzstan, Republic of Moldova, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan, declared ERBD's President Jean Lemierre.
The initiative provides among others increasing investments in private sector, granting credit lines to local banks, easing trade, and investments into the public services. ERBD is ready to grant credits with no state guarantees. A recent ERBD report predict a 4.9% economic growth this year in Eastern Europe and former USSR. This would be the fifth year of economic growth in the region.
In the 11 since it granted the first loan project in the Republic of Moldova, ERBD's projects reached a total of 170 m USD. It is the only foreign investor that invested both in governmental and private sector. Moldova accounts for only 0.9% out of the total 29 projects credited by ERBD in transition countries both in Central and Eastern Europe and Central Asia. In Moldova the greatest bulk of investments worth 50 m USD went to financial and banking sector and infrastructure.
ERBD provides project financing for banks, industries and businesses, both new ventures and investments in existing companies. It also works with publicly owned companies to support privatisation, restructuring state-owned firms and improvement of municipal services. It was established in 1991 by 40 European states. It invests only in Central and East European countries with 60% of the funds going to the private sector and 40% to public sector, especially for infrastructure.
2. Privatization
Parliamentary Commission on economy, industry, budget and finances announced discussions on the draft law on modifying the Law on Privatization for this week. According to the draft "state shall not guarantee property rights over units located to the east of Dniester and Bender town that were privatised without a prior consent of Chisinau governmental authorities".
Several opposition deputies, members of the Commission, stated the initiative is useless since Transdnistria is not subordinated to Chisinau. Nevertheless, Communist deputies endorsed the draft. According to the Commission Chair Nicolae Bondarciuc, the draft law was "a warning" to foreign investors willing to invest in Transdnistrian region. In response to Bondarciuc, another deputy Valeriu Cosarciuc rightly pointed that one of the functions of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Moldova was to inform foreign investors on the risk of loosing their properties in Transdnistria, unless it was agreed upon with Chisinau.
1. Transnistrian settlement talks
The OSCE Mission in Chisinau has announced the resumption of talks on the Transnistria settlement on Monday, 26 April, when representatives of the mediators from Russia, Ukraine and the OSCE are to meet. These will draft the agenda for a five-sided meeting including Moldovan and Transnistrian representatives that will take place on the next day in Chisinau. This will be the first meeting in the five-sided format after the interruption of talks five months ago following the failure of the Russian proposal on the future federal state also known as the Kozak Memorandum.
At the same time, during the period covered here we learned that the Russian Ambassador with Special Missions, Alecsandr Novojilov, who for many years led the Russian delegation within the negotiations, has been replaced by another Russian diplomat, Valeri Nesteruskin. The information has been only confirmed unofficially by the OSCE Mission and the Russian Embassy. The Russian Foreign Ministry has not given any explanation for this replacement.
It seems that due to this change of staff the negotiations did not resume on 21 April, as previously announced by the Transnistria leader Igor Smirnov. The latter, while on a visit to Moscow a week ago, had announced that the Transnistrian side was to present to the meeting its proposals on the political plan drafted by the mediators under the OSCE aegis last autumn. According to Smirnov, those proposals drew largely on the Kozak Memorandum.
During the same visit to Moscow, Smirnov attended a closed meeting of the Parliamentary Group "Rodina" in the Russian State Duma, to which he made a presentation on the political and economic situation in Transnistria. Also in Moscow, unofficial sources have reported, Smirnov was given the award "Slava Rosiyi", a Russian Federation civic award acknowledging outstanding achievements in the business, scientific research, civic, etc. fields. Although the fact that Smirnov got the award was not officially confirmed either by the Russians or by the Transnistrians, the event has irritated the Moldovan authorities, mostly due to the fact that reportedly the award was handed in to Smirnov by the Russian President Advisor Serghei Samoilov.
Local observers have noted that the visit of Igor Smirnov to Moscow just before the resumption of the political negotiations denotes Moscow's tacit support for the break away regime, but also Moscow's intention to further promote the Kozak Memorandum as the basis for future political talks between Chisinau and Tiraspol.
2. American diplomat specifies the US position on the Transnistria settlement
Stephen Pifer, Deputy Assistant to the US State Secretary, reaffirmed during a press conference held at the end of his visit to Moldova on 22-23 April that the US supports the current format of talks on Transnistria as the optimal one, but that at the same time the US and its partners from the EU are looking for ways to bolster the work of the format.
In reference to the Kozak Memorandum Pifer reminded that the US, as well as other OSCE Member States uphold their objections to the plan, in particular with regard to its provisions on the division of power between the central authorities and the federal subjects. Pifer appreciated Moscow's efforts at speeding up the resolution of the Transnistria conflict but said the US will make sure that all such efforts are being channelled through the OSCE.
3. Privatisation in Transnistria
Despite the fact that the Moldovan authorities do not recognise the privatisation process in Transnistria, the Tiraspol administration has announced that another 40 economic units will be added to the list of companies put up for privatisation this year, given the great interest that foreign companies have expressed in buying these.
1. Chairmanship of the CIS Council of Government Heads
Prime-minister Vasile Tarlev has taken over the Chairmanship of the CIS Council of the Governmental Heads at its April 16 reunion at Ciolpon-At (Kyrgyzstan), after Iuri Iarov, Chairman of the CIS Executive Committee officially asked for President Voronin's endorsement in this respect.
A raft of agreements were signed during the reunion aimed at boosting co-operation within CIS, among others: Agreement on introducing international certification for weighting vehicles; Resolution on complying with financial pledges by CIS member states; Resolution on financial measures required for establishing a unified anti-aircraft defence system, etc.
2. Republic of Moldova - EU Action Plan
Republic of Moldova's top priority, i.e. to join EU, outlined by President Voronin during the graduation ceremony of European integration course, was once again reiterated by Minister of Foreign Affairs, Andrei Stratan in an interview to "Radio-Moldova" on April 24. "Individual action plan Republic of Moldova - European Union might be signed in June this year by diplomats in Brussels and Chisinau and later on adopted by the EU's Ministerial Political Committee [probably referring to General Affairs and External Relations Council - ADEPT comment] and Moldovan Government" said Stratan.
Noteworthy, the Action Plan was due to be approved in May this year. The delay was largely due to the adjournment of the third round of negotiations, which was initially scheduled for mid-March and was to be resumed at the end of March or early April.
1000 and 100 days of the Government of V. Tarlev
Anatoli Gudim
This is mainly due to unfailing mechanisms of the vertical line of power - President, Parliament and Government as an executive body. Private sector (circa 80% of GDP) - entrepreneurs that seem to have adapted to market conditions over the decade of reforms - also backed up the stability. Plus, the yearly country's financial support of 300-500 mil USD from Moldovan citizens working abroad.
How can one assess quality of the Government's activity? My opinion is that it can be done first of all based on three most important criteria:
As regards the first two criteria, according to sociological polls, 2/3 of the population evaluate the situation in the country as satisfactory that, understandably, political scientists and sociologists, let alone opposition parties, do not mainly confirm.
But the main slogan of the Government's activity programme was "revival of the economy - revival of the country". And this was supposed to be achieved through "strengthening the role of the state in providing for sustainability of socio-economic development". What resulted from the above-mentioned can be seen from the table comprising the key macroeconomic indicators.
|
Inconsistency between indicators is evident. On the one hand, there certainly was a GDP growth (21.6% over three years) that began to show as far back as the pre-crisis 1997 (+1.6%) and recommenced in 2000 (+2.1%). The National Bank controlled the Moldovan lei's exchange rate, while the Ministry of Finance controlled the balance of incomes and expenditures. Average wages and pensions increased (in 2003, for instance, by 31% and 28% correspondingly). 53.7% of all expenditures of the consolidated budget went to social sphere.
On the other hand - acute lack of investments (a start for the future!), huge trade balance deficit, slow export growth, burden of external and internal debt. And� danger of an inflation outburst.
The list of what had to be changed or improved is well-known both to the population, Government and its advisers from IMF and WB. It includes: quality of economic growth (now, only 1/3 of the GDP growth is being formed in real sector); nature of relations between the state and entrepreneurship, situation of the competition and business climate; division of power between central and local authorities; creation of new workplaces as a counteraction to the mass migration; restoration of free movement of persons and goods with Transnistria; fight against corruption and criminality; targeting of social aid to the poor.
In order to solve all these difficult tasks the Government will have to rise to another, higher level of initiative and creative work. After all, the most part of positive results achieved over these three years was due, as the President V. Voronin stated, "to the administrative resource". But this resource, state intervention into the economy has its limits. The more so since we are trying to revive the country with the help of the state apparatus that has not been reformed yet.
It is not excluded that the Government will estimate in May its activity during 2001-2003, including advantages and defects, and will rebut the opinion of the last IMF mission that reforms in Moldova have slowed down and, in some spheres, have even reversed.
In the meantime, Government in a regular manner set through its decision #351 of April 2, 2004 "the top-priority tasks of activity of the executive power for 2004" and an action plan of 177 (!) clauses to boot. These actions include suggestions of ministries and departments, while priorities seem to have been formulated "at the top".
Attention now! "The following is to be considered as the top-priority tasks of activity of the executive power for 2004:
And all these lofty and general formulations are priorities for the final dash of the current Government, aren't they? What have the previous three years been spent for then? After all, it has been April 19, 2001, when each of these general tasks was set before the Government. And where is the "fighting poverty" idea from the most important, as the Government used to say, PRSP Strategy for 2004-2006?
But this decision is still useful: the Government gave the country a telling argument in favor of the pressing necessity to reform the state apparatus.
NATO is expanding, whereas Moldova ...shrinking?
Viorel Cibotaru
Now the question is, where would the three Western former soviet republics of the Community of Independent States end up? On the one hand, elites in Ukraine and Moldova have reiterated on numerous occasions their intentions to join EU. On the other hand, Belarus speaks of unifying with Russia. The developments in the three countries would definitely affect regional security. In this respect, neither important Ukraine nor tiny Moldova stand a chance to keep good ties with the West, while their military forces and other "armed structures of the state" remain largely unreformed and while their conduct of security affairs continues to be characterized by a conspicuous lack of transparency.
As for Moldova, the inevitable question arises - what actions should be taken to reform security sector and raise its transparency? However, to answer that question one fact should be considered, i.e. Transdnistrian conflict is by far Moldova's biggest challenge when it comes to security. In addition, one should not forget that as long as Russian Federation is supporting secessionist regimes, there is always the risk that Moldova, which has stepped on the path of European integration, would step out or even turn back.
Having said that, yet another question arises: what kind of military forces does Moldova really need? Supposedly, an answer is to be found in the 2002 Conception of Military Reform. However, uncertainty and bleak political development make it quite onerous to enforce the concept itself.
As part of a recent NOSTRUM project "Needs and Options for Security-Sector Transparency and Reform in Ukraine and Moldova" (NOSTRUM, for short), supported by Moldovan authorities and by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands and implemented jointly by the Centre for European Security Studies (CESS) in Netherlands and Institute for Public Policy of Moldova, foreign experts came up with a raft of recommendations - steps necessary to undertake on short and mid term.
What can Moldova do to escape this deadlock? One option is to wait and see how events unfold. This strategy would imply assessing regional security after NATO and EU enlargement, assessing the impact of Union's 'wider Europe' policy on Moldova's strategic orientation towards EU. In the end it would bring new solutions and bolster security sector reform in Moldova.
The alternative to waiting supine would be to do things that should be done, regardless of Transdnistrian conflict developments. The strategy would also have to look at the impact of EU and NATO's extension. The aforesaid recommendations for short and mid term refer in particular to:
However, all of these remain quite uncertain as long as on the one hand military reform policies are drafted and on the other, ideas like total or "partial" "demilitarisation" of the "reunited state" are promoted and even provided for in the "Kozak plan" and other similar documents drafted by OSCE. As a result, nobody knows how a security system should look like in Moldova.
Speaking of transparency, one should remember a recent example when during the annual evaluation session of the Ministry of Defence College late last year, the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces, President Vladimir Voronin asked military officials to come up with recommendations on reforming the main units of the National Army, such as artillery and air force brigades and anti-aircraft defence. Two weeks later a press release issued by the Presidency read that propositions of the Ministry of Defence on restructuring military units were approved during the Supreme Security Council meeting. Once Government endorses them they would be submitted for Parliament approval. Restructuring, or as the President put it "� let's get rid of old equipment", actually means selling munitions and military equipment that our country might no longer need, namely: 6 MiG-29 aircrafts; a few helicopters; armoured machines - 209 units (BTR-80, ��B-71, BMP, BMD; cannons - 79; trench mortar - 115; installations for general discharge - 12; anti-tank cannons - 36; anti-tank guided missiles - 118; anti-tank unguided missiles -113; installations for anti-aircraft missiles - 3; installations of anti-aircraft artillery - 23; "Igla", "Strela" mobile installations - 66 units. It is known for a fact that some of Moldovan businessmen have been contracted in the past by interested parties in Africa, North Korea, Iran, etc. That is why such deals should be very transparent so as not to tarnish Republic of Moldova's image.
|
© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT" Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated | e-mail: [email protected] |