![]() | Association for Participatory Democracy | Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md Original: /en/e-journal/20040915/index.shtml |
Activity of public institutions
1.1. Reshuffles
On September 2, Government appointed Elena Mocanu, Nicolae Esanu and Ion Dron as Deputy Ministers of Justice and ousted Nicolae Taran from his position as General Director of the State Agency for the Protection of Industrial Property as the agency was liquidated.
At the initiative of the Supreme Security Council that found deficiencies in the security of flights from the Chisinau International Airport, on September 3 Government ousted several officials in the Security Department of the State Civil Aviation Administration (SCAA) and police. For the same reasons, Government decided on disciplinary sanctions for Ion Crohin, Director of SCAA and Vladimir Botnari, Senior Deputy Prime Minister.
Also, Government replaced Valeriu Starenco with Boris Cojuhari as plenipotentiary representative of the Republic of Moldova to the General Shareholder Assembly of CIS Mir TV station.
1.2. Decisions
The move is worthwhile especially since from 1999 on European integration was declared as Moldova's top interest, however there was no Moldovan Mission to further this goals. Recent developments of the European continent - EU enlargement, EU becoming a world player, new cooperation mechanisms within "new neighbourhood" - further support the need to open the mission. Hopefully, EU would follow the initiative and open a similar Mission in Chisinau to strengthen the ties with the Republic of Moldova.
The move is quite opportunist considering that the Government is responsible for drawing annual budgets, based on the previous revenues from privatization.
Under the Government motion, the two central thermo stations CET-1 and CET-2, Telenesti Diary Factory, Auto company of the Chisinau Industrial Zone, Factory for fast freezing based in Chisinau, Bottling Factory of the "Dacia-Fenix" Winery from Ialoveni, Wine warehouse in Suruceni, two brick factories in Chisinau and Cahul, and other social companies are to be excluded from the privatization process.
2.1. State Budget for 2005
During a meeting with decision makers, President Voronin outlined the requirements state budget should meet. President believes "State budget of the Republic of Moldova should be objective and should seek to further the strategic goals of the country. Budget priorities should follow the objectives included in the Poverty Reduction Strategy". According to the press service, President also pointed to the need of consolidating mechanisms of economic growth and supporting profitable branches of the national economy, i.e. winery, tobacco, sugar beat and farming. Further, the need of social orientation of the state budget was mentioned, namely healthcare, education, science, gas supply, water supply, road infrastructure.
1. Republic of Moldova's economic security
In a recent report by International Labour Office (ILO) "Economic Security for a Better World" Republic of Moldova ranks 43rd with a 0.495 point rating, i.e. low economic security level. Seven different criteria were used in developing the report, in particular job market, social security, etc. In the context of the Central and Eastern Europe and CIS, the report reads that the situation in Republic of Moldova, Azerbaijan, Russia and Ukraine is worse-off than the official statistics data. Eastern Europe is viewed as a region having a lower economic security recently.
According to the ILO's estimates, Republic of Moldova follows Russian Federation and Belarus but outruns Romania. Sweden has the highest rating (0.977 points) followed by Finland (0.947 points) and Norway (0.926). The report includes estimates for countries representing more than 85 per cent of the world's population, and says such economic security -coupled with democracy and government spending on social security - not only benefits growth but can also promote social stability.
According to another ILO report released in 2003, workers in the Republic of Moldova work 500 hours more than their EU colleagues. Under Moldovan Labour Code total work hours per year amount to 2,000 hours, while in Germany and France no more than 1400-1500 hours. Finally, according to a study by European Employers Federation Moldova has the lowest average salary, i.e. 0.32 Euro per hour, only 1.14% of the maximal European salary; and the lowest GDP per capita of only 230 Euro.
2. Deficiencies in the foreign trade
According to the latest report of the Statistics and Sociology Department, trade deficit is growing and has reached 380 million USD in the seven months of the year. In January - July exports grew by 33.4% and have outran imports that increased by 31.5%. Albeit exports grew faster than imports, trade deficit swelled by 28.9%, whereas the ratio of exports covering imports has reached 58.8% in the seven months of the year.
In the same period Republic of Moldova registered a trade deficit with EU countries - 135.1 million USD, with CIS - 129.3 million USD, Central and Eastern Europe - 37.1 million USD and with other countries - 77.6 million USD. Moldova has the highest negative balance with Ukraine, worth 189 million USD. Experts explain this trend by the growing imports of energy, raw materials and other goods. In January - July 2004, Moldova's foreign trade reached 1461.7 million USD. Moldova's exports of goods and services amounted to 541.3 million USD, whereas imports 920.4 million USD.
Government forecasted for this year exports worth 900 million USD and imports worth 1,525 million USD, and a 625 million USD deficit. Independent experts have their own takes on the subject. According to their forecasts, imports would continue to grow at a faster pace (26.3%) than exports (22.8%) and therefore the trade balance deficit would reach 810 million USD by the end of the year.
3. Macroeconomic forecasts
Government counts on a 5% economic growth throughout 2005-2007, according to Mid-term expense estimate for 2005-2007 (MEE), published in September "Official Monitor". A tentative forecast for 2005-2007 developed by the Ministry of Economy reads that in case of the moderate scenario a 5% annualized economic growth is to be expected, as well as a 5% inflation drop by 2007 and slow depreciation of the exchange rate to 15.8 Lei per USD by the end of 2007.
According to the same document in 2005 GDP would reach 34.9 billion Lei, in 2006 - 38.8 billion, and 42.8 billion Lei in 2007 (currently 1 USD~12.12 Lei). A 8.9% inflation rate is forecasted for 2005, 6.9% for 2006 and 5.5% for 2007.
Exports would surge to 1.02 billion USD in 2005, 1.14 billion USD in 2006 and 1.265 billion USD in 2007. Imports of goods worth 1.632 billion USD is forecasted for 2005, 1.73 billion USD for 2006 and 1.825 billion USD in 2007.
Ministry of Economy says this is a tentative forecast, which might be adjusted later on, as was the case with the 2004 forecasts. While developing the budget for this year a 5% economic growth and a 4.5% inflation rate have been used, later on however the figures were adjusted to 8%, and 10% respectively. Draft budget for 2005 is based on a 6% economic growth, one percent above the MEE's tentative forecasts.
GDP estimated for the first half of the year surged by 6.1% in real terms over same period in 2003, more than one point above Government predictions. Given the record high cereal harvest and high expectations over the overall harvest, no one doubts that Moldova would indeed register a 6% growth this year. At the same time, despite this growth inflation rate for the first half of the year was 13.3%, Moldova ranking the second among CIS countries, closely following Belarus with 20.3%. Anyway, data on the GDP evolution in the six months of the year handily outstrip all the forecasts, be it domestic or foreign, on the evolution of Moldovan economy this year and this largely due to the boom registered in the second quarter. Noteworthy, great many international financial institutions forecasted a 5% growth for Moldova this year.
Despite statements made earlier by the break away leader Igor Smirnov that all the schools from the Transnistrian region will start the new academic year under normal conditions, two of the eight Moldovan Latin script school - the lyceum "Evrica" from Ribnita and the school no. 20 from Tiraspol, where about 1200 children are taught, continue to be sealed, and the orphanage in Tighina (Bender) is still disconnected from the water supply.
This has determined the Moldovan authorities to call upon the international community and the mediators in the Transnistrian conflict resolution to step up efforts to influence the Transnistrian authorities to solve the schools issue, whereas the OSCE Mission in Moldova called once more upon the two parties to resume negotiations in the five-sided format and said that the schools issue that has served as a trigger in stalling the negotiations process is far from being settled.
Meanwhile, the Tiraspol authorities celebrated on 3 September the 14th anniversary of the "independence" of the self-proclaimed "moldovan transnistrian republic" and organised a military parade to assert once more their self-sufficiency and show its honourable guests from Russia, Ukraine, South Ossetia and Abkhasia, as Smirnov himself put it, that at present Transnistria is able to resist any military aggression with its own means.
A few days later, the forces with special destination and the Transnistrian militia engaged in another demonstration of force, this time in a real life situation, and took by siege the railway station and the railway depots in Tighina (Bender), whereby they aggressed physically several employees of the Moldovan railways and arrested the chief engineer of the Tighina (Bender) station and a journalist from the Moldova 1 TV Channel. The sentence of the two arrested to 15 days of detention was condemned by the Moldovan authorities, and the Moldovan General Prosecutor's office opened a criminal investigation in the case of the siege of the railway station and depots in Tighina (Bender) and the arrest of the Moldovan journalist.
The tensioned situation in the Transnistrian region was discussed on 9 September within the meeting of the OSCE Permanent Council in Vienna, which, according to a communique by the Moldovan Foreign Affairs Ministry, "vehemently condemned the actions of destabilisation" by the Transnistrian administration and called for the unconditioned reopening of the schools in Tiraspol and Ribnita, the resumption of the normal activity of the railways in the eastern areas of Moldova and the stabilisation of the situation in the security zone.
Also on 9 September Petar Stoyanov, special envoy of the Bulgarian Chairmanship of the OSCE, arrived in Chisinau for a two-day visit. The visit is part of the OSCE efforts to encourage negotiations on the Transnistrian problem and included meetings with the Moldovan President Voronin, Ministry of Reintegration Sova, other Moldovan officials and members of the Transnistrian administration. At the end of the visit, Stoyanov said he was deeply concerned about the continuing deterioration of relations between Chisinau and Tiraspol and called upon the two parties to overcome their divergences at the negotiations table.
The repeated calls by the OSCE and other European organisations to resume negotiations seem though to reach only Tiraspol, where recently the breakaway leader Igor Smirnov has declared that he is ready to carry talks with Chisinau within the five-sided format, because "there is no other perspective to settle the Moldovan-Transnistrian conflict than dialogue". On the other hand, the official Chisinau preserves its intransigent position as expressed by President Voronin on 27 August and according to which the Moldovan officials will no longer talk to the Transnistrian leaders, but "just with those who Tiraspol obeys to in the most direct way." In Chisinau's view, thus, there is no other way of overcoming the current critical situation but through the "concerted and sustained" efforts of the international community, including the organisation of an international conference on Moldova and the signature of the Pact of Stability and Security for Moldova as proposed by President Voronin to the mediator states, the US, EU and Romania.
1. Reunion of the CIS member states Interstate Council for state of emergency
On September 7 and 8 Chisinau hosted the reunion of the CIS member states Interstate Council for states of emergency. Representatives from 10 countries flew to Chisinau to sign a string of agreements and protocols, such as: Agreement on establishing CIS reserve fund to help countries affected by the state of emergency, Conception of cooperation in monitoring and predicting states of emergency, Normative and legal Convention in preventing and eliminating state of emergency aftermath, and Joint Action Plan on scientific research to prevent states of emergency.
2. Stability Pact for South-Eastern Europe
Once Moldova signed Free Trade Agreements with all countries members of the Stability Pact for South-eastern Europe and ratified all of them (except for the one with Bulgaria), it designated its representatives to the Joint Intergovernmental Commission entrusted to oversee the implementation of agreements. Commission is responsible for analyzing and overseeing the enforcement of bilateral agreements, considering cooperation projects in various fields among the countries members of the Stability Pact and providing assistance in their implementation.
Recent State Initiative on Land Consolidation
Felicia Izman
The second attempt, in a more explicit form, came out in January 2004 in form of two legal documents "The State Program on Agricultural Land Organization and Arrangement" and "The Law on Agricultural Land Organization and Arrangement". A revised (more focused and detailed) draft version of these documents was then released in mid-April 2004 and circulated among various ministries. As of today, no final document on this highly controversial issue of land consolidation has been approved yet.
The released documents, particularly the State Program (SP), call for embarking upon a major sector restructuring through encouraging the creation of "consolidated enterprises" (basically production cooperatives). The implementation mechanisms described consist of a series of wide-ranging actions including redrafting of major laws, creation of new commissions and adoption of tax, pricing, crediting, marketing and land policies. The documents also call for elaboration of a new Land Code that "would serve better the needs of the sector in the present post-privatization phase" (quotation from SP). Such a code is currently under elaboration within the Ministry of Agriculture and no draft has been released yet.
According to the draft SP, the GOM's reasons for undertaking land consolidation are based on a number of key assumptions that: (i) land fragmentation that occurred as a result of NLP is currently excessively high in Moldova; (ii) individual agriculture is inefficient and uncompetitive; (iii) only optimal-size consolidated agricultural enterprises will be able to produce a high-quality and competitive output; and (iv) creation of consolidated enterprises will create new jobs, increase labor productivity and stop the population outflow from the rural areas.
A rough analysis of these key assumptions easily reveals their un-sustainability and false nature. First, regarding the claimed high fragmentation of agricultural land, we shall take a look at the statistical figures that disclose the following picture of agricultural land tenure in 2003: 54% of the total land fund distributed during the privatization period is currently utilized by relatively large-scale corporate farms (mainly LTDs, but also production coops and joint stock companies) that have in use between 100 to 1000 ha. It is therefore clear that the quickly emerging land lease markets have already resolved to a great extent the fragmentation problem and will continue so as the land market develops further. The second statement with regard to the inefficiency of the individual agriculture is totally wrong provided that today the individual sector2 produces as much as 75% of the total agricultural output by the use of only 56% of total agricultural land, thus exhibiting a significantly greater productivity than the large corporate sector.
The third assumption stating that only consolidated enterprises would be capable of producing a competitive and high-quality output can be easily refuted by the evidence of the mid 90s when the existing kolhozes and sovhozes were loss-making bankrupt entities that kept accumulating more and more debt every year. It thus seems that the GOM proposes to solve the issue of rural poverty by returning to a failed economic system, which was unsustainable in the past and will certainly be so in the future.
And last but not least, while the creation of consolidated enterprises may initially create some new jobs (which shall not be a goal by itself in a country with half of the population involved in farming!), it is not at all clear how this would contribute to labor productivity growth, as according to the laws of economics it would rather do the opposite: the inflow of new labor would only worsen the already low labor productivity indicators of the Moldovan agriculture sector. Moreover, it would certainly not stop the population outflow from the rural areas for the simple reason that these enterprises won't be able to pay a wage anywhere close to the competitive wage range. What would really improve the standard of living of the rural population is the opportunity for people to find jobs outside the agricultural sector, which would ensure labor outflow from the sector, thus contributing to both land and labor productivity growth in agriculture. So, focusing on the real problems of the agricultural sector, such as the underdeveloped markets and services, as well as finding ways to develop and expand the non-agricultural part of the Moldovan economy should actually be the major GOM's concern nowadays (see also Box 1).
| Box 1. From the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) "A backward step for agriculture": "Assuming that the CPM administration proceeds as planned, the results are almost certain to be negative. The CPM's program reflects its ideological antipathy towards private agriculture, and the solutions it offers stem from a misdiagnosis of the agricultural sector's problems." |
A recent study4, which attempted to spot farmers' attitude toward this land consolidation idea found that 76% of landowners/lessors and 82% of lessees would not agree to transfer their land to a consolidated enterprise. Typical reasons given for not wanting to do this were "won't be able to pass my land over to my heirs", "the collective farm will not be more efficient and the employees will be irresponsible", "can sell my land anytime now", or "am satisfied with my land lease contract".
It is thus a pity that the GOM, blinded by its short-sighted political motives, does not want to see the long-term negative consequences of such disturbing policies, including the worsening of the investment and business environment due to insecure property rights, an even further drop in the currently depressed private investments, reduction of external financial inflows, etc. Luckily, it is not at all clear how the Government will get hold of the necessary resources to finance this costly program estimated at 70-90 million lei ($6-8 million). According to EIU, "this represents the best hope by far for preventing its implementation, given that the government is effectively broke." External donors will most probably not show eager to provide
Concerns on the eve of elections
Igor Botan
This estimation is logical and at the first glance seems accurate. Arguments cited by those who claim election date would be set for the end of May or even June cite, derive from the supposed interests of the ruling party. It is believed that Party of Communists would like to exploit for propaganda purposes April religious holidays (Easter) and turn again bringing the Holy Fire from Jerusalem into a political show. Celebration of the 60th anniversary of the victory day on May 9, in the middle of electoral campaign, promises additional political dividends. The more so as the CIS chief of states were already invited by President Putin to celebrate the anniversary in Moscow. The latter might prove to be crucial in convincing a 30% Russian-speaking electorate that President Voronin is on good terms with the Russian leadership.
It is said that by mid-May electorate gets more tolerant with the ruling elite as the hardships of winter are long forgotten. This time however winter promises to be particularly hard due to the forecasted shortages of electricity and natural gas as a result of the would-be "adequate measures" undertaken by Transdnistrian authorities in response to so-called "economic blockade" from Chisinau. Given the string of provocations contrived by the Tiraspol leaders, it may well happen that the "adequate measures" would be scheduled precisely for the cold period of the year, i.e. during pre-electoral campaign and would therefore considerably tarnish ruling party's rating.
Those expectations led some newspapers into believing that worsening relations between Moldova and Transdnistria might serve grounds for the governing to declare a state of emergency, which would allow it to postpone elections a month or two for a more favourable period. In addition, it is said that ruling party would seek to amend Constitution so as the President be elected directly by people.
Those speculations should be viewed with scepticism. For a start, the latter supposition is no longer valid as according to Article 143 (1) of the Constitution "Parliament has the right to pass a law for revising the Constitution after no less than 6 months from the date when the revising initiative was submitted." Article 74/2 of the Law on Parliament Regulation provides that debates on constitutional laws may start only "after six months after the submission of the relevant draft law together with the Constitutional Court endorsement". So far no such draft was submitted to the Constitutional Court. Therefore, ruling party simply does not have the six months necessary for the Constitution revision, as its mandate expires in five months and a half, when it would no longer be able to adopt or amend Constitution or any organic law.
As for the speculations on declaring a state of emergency, we better not disregard those arguments but rather take them seriously. On top of worsening relations between Chisinau and Tiraspol, a string of events have happened and numerous quite suggestive laws have been passed. Thus, on May 24 President signed a Decree on establishing Supreme Security Council (SSC). Opposition dubbed it as President's "politburo" or "pet government" seeking to replace Government and "serve dictatorial ambitions and usurpation of state power" and having the function of electoral headquarters entrusted to bring the victory to the ruling party in the 2005 parliamentary elections. One month later, on June 24, 2004 Parliament passed the Law no. 212-XV on the State of Emergency, Siege and War. About the same time government affiliated media predicted that opposition would stage a putsch right on the eve of elections, the so-called "Sun Flower" (Moldovan version of the 2003 Georgian scenario)1. And finally on September 13 the Director of Information and Security Service (ISS) announced that "Five persons, including Defence Ministry officials were detained in suspicion of embezzling large quantities of weapons from the National Army warehouses"2. ISS Director noted "it is quite symptomatic that the theft coincided with the escalation of the Transdnistrian conflict and activation of certain socio-political forces". In fact it is as symptomatic that SSC Director's statement regarding "separatist authorities' inclination towards violent actions" was published on the front page of the governmental "Moldova Suverana" besides the editorial where the author referring to Russian Federation's support to Transdnistrian regime claimed that "all the appeals by the international community to Russian Federation are made to it as a guarantor-country, but they should be made to an aggressor state, as it was publicly acknowledged in the ECHR' judgement on Ilascu case". Quite bold allegations from official press given the approaching negotiations between Moldovan Government and Gazprom on the country's debt on gas.
Insinuation on "activation of socio-political forces" is also quite obvious, referring to the opposition parties' support to Teleradio-Moldova journalists in strike. Major opposition parties voiced their support to the protesting journalists and pointed that upcoming elections would not be free and fair unless Teleradio-Moldova issue is settled, meaning it is no longer under governors' control. To maximize protest actions that are going on for two months now, it was planned to move them downtown close to main public institutions. Under those circumstances, when governors identified their domestic foes (opposition and Transdnistrian regime) and foreign ones (Romania -" the last European empire", Ukraine - allowing smuggling from Transdnistria through its 460 km border with Republic of Moldova and Russia - "aggressor-state which the West refuses to treat accordingly"), a dramatic deterioration of socio-political situation is to be expected right on the eve of elections.
Going back to the date of elections, it is worth mentioning that the aforesaid arguments do not take into account some important political and legal factors. Firstly, they ignore Resolution no.31 of 10.11.1997 of the Constitutional Court providing that "Parliament mandate commences on election day and ends after 4 years". This ruling is quite interesting, meaning that for about a month there are in fact two Parliaments in the Republic of Moldova. The new one, whose mandate commences on election day and the old one whose mandate is extended for about one month until the former convenes on its first session. In fact, this curiosity does not bear any risk. Anyway Constitutional Court rulings are final and binding for all. In this particular case, Court's ruling narrows only by one month the berth for manoeuvres to ruling party in setting election date. However, in line with Article 2 of the Law on the Procedure of Electing the President of the Republic of Moldova, presidential elections are to be held "at most 45 days prior to mandate expiry of the incumbent President". The first article of the same law, amended in June, provides that "Parliament of the same legislature gets to elect the President of the Republic of Moldova only once". The incumbent Parliament has already elected the President once, therefore by April 8, 2005 when the President's mandate expires, a new Parliament should be elected so as to be able to elect a new President within the time frame allotted by the law.
Therefore if the governors were to abide Constitutional provisions and electoral law on parliamentary and presidential elections, then by the end of its session in December Parliament would set the date for parliamentary elections. The latter would therefore be held in the last Sunday of February or any Sunday in the first half of March, i.e. February 27 - March 13, 2005. And this because sufficient time should be allotted: to tabulate election results, Constitutional Court to validate election results, President to convene the newly-elected Parliament, Parliament to elect its governing bodies, establish Special Commission for the Presidential Elections, and conduct those elections by April 8, 2005. Most importantly, Constitutional Court ruled in its Resolution no. 4 of 12.01.2001 that terms for presidential elections specified in an organic law should be strictly observed.
Under the given circumstances, Government would better dispel lingering concerns, rapidly settled Teleradio Moldova conflict, and conduct elections under the aforesaid terms. It would be a terrible mistake for the main state institutions - Parliament and Presidency - to operate longer under expired mandates and respectively limited prerogatives, especially given tensed relations between Chisinau and Tiraspol pushed to the brink of renewed conflict.
|
© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT" Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated | e-mail: [email protected] |