ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20040929/index.shtml


e-journal, II year, no. 38, 13-26 September, 2004

Activity of public institutions

Economic polies

Transdnistrian Conflict

Foreign affairs

Studies, analyses, comments

I. Activity of public institutions

1. Parliament

1.1. A new legislative session

On September 23, the fall-winter session of the Parliament started. In her inauguration speech the Speaker made several key points, namely "continuing economic and social reforms", "pursuing European integration, not to the detriment of cooperation with CIS", etc. Speaker also called deputies to work constructively, to honour their obligations in front of their people, not to "get involved in the electoral campaign yet", and not seek to gain political dividends in the last days of their mandate.

However, the first session of the legislature dispelled any hopes that the conflicts within the Parliament would be settled. It took two hours to decide on the Parliament agenda for the first two weeks of its activity. Opposition started the debates by suggesting special parliamentary committees to be formed to examine the conflict around Teleradio-Moldova and Moldovan Latin script schools in Transdnistria.

Still, practically all the deputies agreed to address the issue of schools in Transdnistrian region by issuing a joint declaration. It reads that Parliament of the Republic of Moldova is deeply concerned about Tiraspol's actions thwarting educational process in the schools studying according to Republic of Moldova curricula. Parliament called Council of Europe, Parliaments of the EU and CIS countries and international organisations to take a stance in view of settling the problem. Moreover, Parliament addressed Parliaments of guarantor countries - Russian Federation and Ukraine - to actively take part in the settlement of that problem.

1.2. Legal acts

Law on the Modification of Fiscal Code provides that assets included in the privatisation program, where the state holds more than one quarter of the registered capital shall be sold by the Privatization Department, as is the procedure for the privatization of public patrimony. Currently, the law provides that Privatization Department only deals with the sale of assets arrested from the enterprises included in the privatization program.

Law on Modification of the Code on Civil Procedure was amended so that during the hearing of a cause the presiding chair would be allowed to limit the time allotted to the parties, if the latter digress from the subject and their arguments are not relevant to the recourse.

Parliament also passed the Law on Interpreting Code on Penal Procedure. It was important to pass the law as a number of cases were registered when the Code was not duly enforced. The law includes several provision explaining the provisions of the Code.

Parliament passed the Law on Ratification of the Free Trade Agreement between Republic of Moldova and Bulgaria. The document ratified on the eve of official visit of Bulgarian President to Moldova, stems from WTO requirements. The goal of the Agreement is to: promote bilateral trade and boost economic relations; ensure level playing field for the trade between the two countries; abolish tariff and other barriers; set the framework for bilateral cooperation in various fields. With this, Moldova has concluded ratifying Free Trade Agreements with the countries members of the Stability Pact for South-Eastern Europe.

(For further details on Parliament activity see http://www.e-democracy.md/en/comments/legislative/)


2. Government

2.1. Reshuffles

During the period covered Mihail Stirban was ousted from his position as Deputy Director of the Department of Constructions and Territory Planning as was Gheorghe Stratan from his position as Counsellor to Senior Deputy Prime Minister.

2.2. Decisions


3. Presidency

3.1. Decrees

President Vladimir Voronin ousted Alexandr Petkov from his position as Councillor to the President of the Republic of Moldova on foreign affairs, also he ousted Eugeniu Clim as Chairman of the Central Electoral Commission. The decrees read that both officials were ousted at their own initiative, the latter due to poor health condition.


II. Economic polies

1. Prices on gas might go down

Moldova and Russian Federation proceeded to renegotiate Protocol on Amending the Agreement on VAT on gas and oil products. During their informal meeting at the Astana Summit Prime-Minister Tarlev and his Russian counterpart Mikhail Fradkov, decided to revise Agreement on general principles of indirect taxation in the near future. Under that document, VAT is applied according to destination principle to all goods, except for natural gas and oil products. Russian side agreed with Moldova's initiative to abolish the 18% VAT tax on natural gas and petrol products.

A worthwhile decision and if the Agreement is amended, the prices on natural gas might go down. Moreover, Chisinau's initiative comes at the time Fiscal Code of the Russian Federation is being amended, namely exported goods shall be subject to 0% VAT.

Another factor greatly influencing whether the prices would go down or not is the progress of negotiations between Moldovagaz and Russian Gazprom, who has recently insisted on raising the price for the natural gas supplied to the Republic of Moldova.

2. Wage arrears surging

Recently a working group has been established at the initiative of the Prime Minister including representatives of various Ministries and Departments. The WG is entrusted oversee wage payment and wage arrears, after Statistics and Sociology Department reported wage arrears. Officials in the Ministry of Finance reported that commencing March 2002 there were no arrears on pensions and wages for state employees, historic debts were settled while wages were paid monthly in cash.

According to Prime-Minister the WG should undertake "extraordinary and urgent measures" to liquidate wage arrears, in case such cases are found. WG would oversee wage payments by employers and would mobilize all enterprises, relevant institutions and trade unions to pay wages on time in line with the law.

According to Statistics and Sociology Department total wage arrears per economy amounted 187 million Lei as of August 1. The highest wage arrears are in agriculture with 95.16 million Lei; in education wage arrears surged by 1.5 million Lei. Average salary per economy equalled 1,150 Lei (95 USD). Employers of banking sector and financial institutions had the highest salaries in August, an average of 3,583 Lei. Average salary in education and in healthcare were 716 Lei and 863 Lei respectively. In August consumer basket reached 1,386 Lei (116,13 USD).

3. Foreign debt

Republic of Moldova's gross foreign debt amounted to 1 billion 896.32 million USD as of July 30, 2004 according to the findings of a National Bank report on the evolution of foreign debt. Government debt accounts for 36.2% of the total debt, National Bank - 7%, commercial banks - 2.4% and other sectors - 54.4%. The report also estimates the debt on imported energetic resources worth 295.26 million USD. Guaranteed public debt, which also includes Government and National Bank debts plus private debt guaranteed by the Government, is worth 874.62 million USD. Loans and interest rate arrears account for 71.4% of the total debt.

Post-war history is full of examples when countries lacking financial resources chose foreign debt as a temporary measure to recover and boost domestic economy. This is not the case of Moldova. Its foreign debt of 1.9 billion USD represents 84% of the GDP for 2003, well above the average for subdeveloped countries boasting just 35%. Draft budget for 2005 endorsed by the Government last week allocates 31.2 million USD to servicing foreign debt; while for servicing foreign debt guaranteed by the Government a total of 28.8 million USD; for interest rate payments - 2.4 million USD. In the last years, technically Moldova was insolvent, fact that it acknowledged every time it postponed disbursing debt until the settling day, or when it requested another debt restructuring.

4. Good agricultural year does not slow down inflation

Record high grain harvest (830 thousand tones), coupled with swelling consumption, would help Republic of Moldova speed up economic growth. Authorities forecast a 7% GDP growth, well over the 6% this year, even over the 6.5% forecasted earlier. A good agricultural year would definitely have a positive impact, however less so on inflation rate.

Despite record high harvest, prices on agricultural and food products did not go down. An overall 0.2% price hike in the industry has been registered, the highest hike was registered on meat (3.4% on pork, 1.8% on beef, 1.3% on meat products). Accordingly, inflation rate dropped slightly to 0.5% in August, from the record high 1.3% in July, still it was 0.2% higher than same time last year. Annualized inflation rate was also propelled further upwards to 12.4% in August.

Besides price hike on agricultural and food products, inflation was further sent up by the rising price of imported oil products. Fuel price has raised by 12%. Drivers were the first ones to be hit by the price hike and to adjust fuel consumption to the money in their pockets. As the price of transportation would grow, so would the goods as all of them have transportation costs included in the price. On average, transportation cots would raise by 2 - 5%, while prices of goods would raise accordingly.

Certainly, manufacturers and retailers would venture to raise prices even higher, however they stand little chance of success. Market is settled and does not accept 30% price hikes on the grounds costs are high. Albeit elections are coming, governors would be forced to raise the price on public transportation. Sooner or later they would have to adjust the price to the growing fuel price. So far, the latter affected businesses that struggle to lower the costs or cover them by raising the product price.

In the first half of the year prices rose amid a 9% consumption growth, all of which has sent GDP 6.1% up in the first six months of the year. Sales rose by 14.1%. Unfortunately this growth comes mainly from the sale of imported goods. Imports surged exceeding by far exports with a 380 million USD trade balance deficit.


III. Transdnistrian Conflict

One month after the beginning of the academic year, the lyceum "Lucian Blaga" from Tiraspol and the Romanian lyceum from Ribnita remain closed and the parents of almost 1200 pupils of these two schools are being subjected to continuous harassment by the Transnistrian break-away authorities, ranging from threats of criminal prosecution and deprivation of parental rights to administrative fines for failure to transfer their children to other schools.

The EU, OSCE, COE and the mediator states have renewed their calls upon the Transnistrian authorities to reopen the two schools, while the Moldovan Parliament has finally adopted a statement condemning the actions of the Transnistrian authorities against the Romanian schools and have decided to send a delegations of deputies to Moscow at the end of September to discuss the schools issue with their Russian colleagues. Meanwhile, the Moldovan Ministry of Education has adopted a plan of measured in support of the eight Moldovan Latin script schools from the Transnistrian region. These include upgrading the material and technical situation of the schools, provision to the schools of teaching and didactic literature, provision of financial aid for the renovation of school premises, and free meals to pupils of grades 1 to 4. At the end of September, a delegation of Moldovan parliamentarians is to visit Moscow to discuss the schools issue with their Russian counterparts.

As the situation on the ground has seen few developments over the past two weeks, the Transnistrian issue has featured in a number of high-level statements made in Moldova and abroad. At a press-conference held on 16 September within the CIS Summit in Kazakhstan, the Russian President Vladimir Putin said that although Russia would not oppose the enlargement of the current negotiations format, this would be a useless move that might turn the negotiations into some "talking shop". Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma shared his Russian counterpart's view on changing the negations format, and deplored the failure of the Moldovan Government to sign the Kozak Memorandum, which, to Kuchma, was a real opportunity for the two sides to end the crisis situation. Moreover, Kuchma said that the conflict could not be solved through economic sanctions or military means and that Ukraine did not support the economic blockade instituted by the Moldovan authorities against Transnistria.

In the meantime, the Moldovan President Voronin, who did not attend the CIS Summit in Astana on grounds that the Summit did not discuss issues important enough, has called repeatedly on the international community to get involved in solving the Transnistrian conundrum. He has advocated for the institution of an international monitoring mission along the Transnistrian segment of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border and for the replacement of current peacekeepers, who are "siding with the Transnistrian regime", with international blue helmets.

The Transnistrian issue has been one of the main themes of the one-day visit to Moldova of the NATO Secretary General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer on 23 September. After meetings with President Voronin, Foreign Minister Stratan and Defence Minister Gaiciuk, de Hoop Scheffer held a press conference, to which he told that the international community should get involved in the Transnistrian conflict resolution. Although NATO does not have a direct role in the Transnistrian crisis, it is committed to finding a fair and final resolution of the conflict. He reiterated NATO's traditional position that Russia should observe its 1999 Istanbul commitments and withdraw its troops and weapons from Moldova accordingly, and committed to assist Moldova in its efforts to determine Russia to evacuate its military and arms from the Moldovan soil.

President Voronin's failure to attend the Astana CIS Summit has been interpreted by many observers as a demonstration of Voronin's break up with the East and reorientation to the West in his efforts at resolving the Transnistrian conflict. This move has been welcomed by a large part of the Moldovan political opposition and is well received by such important western figures as the NATO Secretary General. At the same time, President Voronin denies any possibility of negotiating with the Transnistrians and has accused on a number of occasions the two mediator states - Russia and Ukraine - of supporting the Transnistrian regime. His statements in this sense seem to be inspired from the commentaries of the analyst from The Wall Street Journal, Vladimir Socor, a renowned critic of Russia and proponent of the internationalisation of the conflict resolution efforts, whose commentaries are regularly published by the Moldovan Governmental newspaper "Moldova Suverana". Thus by making the stake only on the western vector and at the same time antagonizing the main players, it seems that the Moldovan authorities are running out of opportunities to solve a multidimensional crisis with important regional ramifications as is the Transnistrian issue.


IV. Foreign affairs

1. CIS Summit

On September 15-16, CIS Summit was held in Astana. Moldovan delegation was headed by Prime-Minister Tarlev, while President Voronin's refusal to attend the event rose some eyebrows in the society. President Voronin and Turkmen President were the ones who did not show up at the reunion. As it was to be expected, Prime-Minister Tarlev criticized the state of affairs in CIS which "failed to become an efficient mechanism ensuring mutually advantageous partnership and bringing nations and countries together". In this respect, Tarlev stated "so far CIS agreements on free trade are not fully enforced, as is the agreement on adjusting economic law and coordination in economic spheres" and pointed to the fact that the potential of CIS countries in this respect was not fully exploited. Consequently, Moldovan Prime-Minister complained about numerous tariff and non-tariff barriers in bilateral trade, failure to honour economic obligations and lack of efficient system of payments within CIS.

Prime-Minister Tarlev recommended speeding up enforcement of documents already signed and joining efforts to abolish bureaucratic and trade barriers. According to Tarlev this might be done by adopting WTO standards in CIS.

General impression of the Astana Summit is that CIS has turned into a political debate club, useful solely for the sake of debate, but completely useless when it comes to economy and trade. For that particular reason, Moldova should turn towards EU, which is more efficient in economic and trade terms. At the same time, Moldova may preserve its Eastern markets by means of bilateral relations, without being part of CIS.

As was the case of informal CIS Summit held in Moscow in July 2004, a Declaration to OSCE was adopted. It reiterates the need for all OSCE member states to ratify Agreement on Adaptation of the Treaty on Conventional Armed Forces in Europe, for OSCE to get involved in fighting terrorism, and recommends OSCE to "constructively" take part in the settlement of the regional conflicts within the existing negotiation format and mechanisms. Although President Voronin mentioned on numerous occasions that the existing negotiation format on Transdnistrian conflict should be revised, Moldova subscribed to the Declaration.

2. GUUAM

Shortly after Moldovan Government endorsed the draft law on ratifying Agreement on Free Economic Zones in GUUAM countries, on September 23 a delegation of Moldovan Parliament headed by Deputy Speaker Mihail Camerzan attended the founding session of the GUUAM Parliamentary Assembly. The documents and regulation were signed by Azerbaijan, Georgia, Moldova and Ukraine.

Founding documents provide that Parliamentary Assembly would contribute to perfecting legal framework regulating trade, culture, and political sphere; to enforcing the decisions of the head of states members of GUUAM; to consolidating and developing democratic institutions in the region. The same documents provide that Assembly shall convene once a year and that a Bureau shall be established consisting of three specialised committees, i.e. political-legal, trade, and cultural-humanitarian.


V. Studies, analyses, comments

Indebtedness threatens the stability of domestic economy
Iurie Gotisan

As in many other transition economies, in Moldova there is a huge difference between state-owned and private companies when it comes to honouring obligations to the state budget. To put it differently, fighting arrears should be backed up by imposing budgetary restraints so that companies (especially state-owned ones) pay taxes to state budget. Having said that, last week Government's ordinance on cancelling debts worth 107.5 million Lei (http://www.azi.md/news?ID=30915) incurred by a number of agricultural companies, is yet another illustration of the differentiated approach. The thing is there is a clear case of discrimination of private companies not entitled to fat benefits against state-owned companies that are.

The draft law developed by the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry and endorsed by the Government provides for writing-off the debts to the state budget (as of January 1, 2004) for 30 agricultural entities, great many of them sovkhozs, kolkhoz and production cooperatives. Furthermore, the draft obliges local government to take "measures in the next years in view of totally or partially writing-off historic debts incurred by the economic entities subject of this law". No wonder the list of those entities was never made public, nor were details of the would-be writ-off; however one may only guess who would be the lucky ones. Indeed, this draft law would prove quite handy to moguls in Government or Parliament, who are in fact behind those entities.

Probably, officials refrained from making public the data not for the fear of westerns, but rather for fear of their own people! It comes as no surprise that Communist ruling has made keeping secret or even distorting data a daily business. Specifically, information impossible or not advisable to hide was "cosmeticised". Writing-off arrears as well as restructuring state-owned companies' debts may ruin all official forecasts on inflation, say analysts. To give just an example, according to Sociology and Statistics Department inflation rate for the first half of the year was 13.3%, Republic of Moldova ranking the second after Belarus (20.3%) among CIS countries as regards rising pattern for inflation. Experts claim the psychological threshold of 10% inflation rate would never be reached, unless of course "official data are falsified". Officials though stay calm and see no harm in soaring debt.

No one could asses precisely the impact of those write-offs and restructuring, as nobody works seriously on economic models in Moldova and there are no sufficient statistics (there are even some gaps). Having said that, authorities are walking in darkness when making their economic forecasts. In the end inflation rate is much lower in the statistics than in the peoples' pockets, as is economic growth much more significant than the one felt in economy and state budget. On the contrary, "disturbing" data not included in the obligatory reports were simply forgotten. Still, what happened with data on arrears per economy was far too much. Communist Party 2001 governing program pointed to the dangerously high arrears incurred during the previous rulings, claiming that they had reached 30% of the GDP in 2001. Hence, data related to arrears are classified. Not even annual reports of the Ministry of Finance were published, not even an official estimate of the arrears was released. The reasons are easy to guess: during the incumbent ruling arrears continued to grow and probably at a faster pace than before! If they had dropped, the data would have been made public long ago and listed under new governing "achievements".

Normally, during incumbent ruling arrears continued to soar due to some objective as well as subjective factors. On the one hand, a string of constraints from outside imposed either a massive restructuring, or pushed suppliers and state to go for non-payment. Companies have chosen the second, especially as there was a political consent to that. Banking sector restructuring shut the doors to bank financing for bankrupt and inefficient state-owned enterprises. On the other hand, never was the state more tolerant towards non-payment of financial obligations. All kind of schemes for restructuring debts, providing additional benefits, or even writing-off historic debts provided current debts were paid, have been put in place. Noteworthy, last week Government together with the State Creditors Council passed a resolution on restructuring historic debt to state budget for two CET (thermo-electric plants) worth 187.5 million Lei. Moreover, one month ago Government and State Creditors Council froze the historic debt of seven tobacco companies worth some 25 million Lei.

Worryingly, manufacturing based on indirect financing was encouraged, namely from fiscal credits (non-payments of obligations to public budgets) or from state aid (non-payment of financial obligations by state-owned energetic units). Never bad debtors enjoyed such a heaven having a political blessing from the top. All of the aforesaid propelled the arrears to public budgets further upwards (that were turned into heaven for tax dodging), as well as to energy suppliers, which being state-owned were not allowed to cut supplies to bad-debtors.

One year ago, total arrears per economy were 4.5% higher over the end of 2001, i.e. 200 million USD, according to IMF report. Anyway, out of the total arrears estimated at 30% of the GDP, budget arrears do not account for more than 3%, according to the Ministry of Finance. On the contrary, scoring high after arrears to public entities are arrears to public budgets, in which bad-debtors found the perfect loophole.

High rate of bad-debts has determined banks to raise interest rate. Noteworthy, even though a growth of industrial output has been registered in the last two years, cross debts among business plus debts of the latter to commercial banks is estimated at 4 billion Lei, i.e. 14% of the GDP in 2004. Excessively high rate of bad debts in financial institutions undermines economy, whereas the level of obligatory reserves, an instrument used by National Bank to control liquidity, raises the cost of commercial banks, thereby making crediting of real sector more onerous. On top of that, the cost of a credit in national currency is more expensive, and this amidst over-appreciation of national currency that neglects its real value. This is why other than governmental credits in foreign currency show signs of growth and according to National Bank amounts 200 million USD.

As of August 1, companies' debt to consolidated budget reached 1,059 million Lei (88.2 million USD) a 9% increase (87.5 million Lei) since early this year, reads a press release of the State Fiscal Department. Bad debts account for 72% of the total debt. Bad debtors include businesses that are not operational for more than three years - 226 million Lei, litigating businesses - 102 million Lei, bankrupt businesses - 97.5 million Lei, as well as businesses having no assets - 100.7 million Lei. Thermo-energetic sector owes another 228 million Lei to the consolidated budget.

However governmental program does not refer to areas to state budget. It envisages decreasing new arrears that annually add up 4% of the GDP to the historic arrears. The latter more or less equals the amount public budgets and entities are supposed to get. By reducing "historic" debts one does not really diminish the arrears. One might only diminish them by reducing new debt that adds up. In this respect, Ministry of Finance failed to honour its obligations. It comes as no surprise that IMF opposed Ministry of Finance initiative to use additional budget revenues coming from economic growth for social spendings. If not for other things, at least IMF has the merit of disclosing figures and actions authorities remained tight lipped about. Finally, if freezing debts shall not be accompanied by payment of current debts, in a year or so Moldovan economy would be on the verge of collapse, while the debt burden would be so great that it would likely suffocate state budget and private sector.


Astana Summit: an evidence to the CIS crisis
Igor Botan

President Voronin's ostentatious absence from CIS Summit

President Voronin's absence from the Astana Summit held on September 15-16 is an illustration of the worsening relations between Republic of Moldova and Russia.

The reasons cited by Voronin for not attending the Summit indicate his elaborate and consistent position on Community of Independent States (CIS). One year ago, during the Yalta Summit Vladimir Voronin severely criticized Single Economic Area (SEA) established by four industrialized CIS states: Russia, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, and Belarus, seeking to create mutual benefits that other CIS members were denied. Back then Moldovan President warned that SEA would undermine CIS itself and would turn it into a mere discussion club. In his latest interview to Novosti-Moldova Agency reprinted by the governmental Moldova Suverana1 Vladimir Voronin reiterated the same arguments pointing that the four countries had some common pragmatic interests, that is, to synchronize their economic policies in view of joining WTO. In Astana leaders of the four SEA founders had a separate agenda, which included: follow up on the enforcement of the Yalta agreements; defining priorities and documents that are to be signed in the future; developing a single mechanism for VAT taxation; and simplifying travel and communications between those countries. The rest of CIS heads of states had to simply confine themselves with the status of Russia's loyal partners, who in the aftermath of terrorist attacks sought to fight terrorism, organized crime, drug smuggling and illegal migration - issues that topped the agenda of the Astana Summit. Under those circumstances, President Voronin decided that Prime Minister was suited enough to tackle those issues.

Still those excuses are not compelling enough. And there are a number of reasons for this. Firstly, great majority of the CIS states, who were also not invited into SEA, did attend Astana Summit, including Caucasus countries that are struggling with the same kind of secessionism problems Moldova is, whose resolution greatly depends on Russia.

Secondly, following July informal CIS Summit in Moscow there were all the reasons to expect that Azerbaijan and Georgian Presidents, and not Moldovan President, would not show up at the Astana Summit. The former refused to sign the Declaration criticizing OSCE, drafted at the initiative of President Putin. Probably they realized that despite OSCE' deficiencies, its documents (including Final Act and those signed at 1999 Istanbul Summit) were the cornerstones of regional security. Albeit anti-OSCE Declaration did not target the gist of the organization, but only some of its facets, the two Caucasus Presidents struggling with secessionism refrained from signing it. Having said that, one may well understand why Armenian President allied with Russia against OSCE, as did other countries that do not struggle with secessionism and have Russian troops stationed on there soil, however one fails to comprehend Moldovan President's decision to endorse the document, even if only conditionally.

Thirdly, neither of the Caucasus President ever voiced their attachment to CIS in general, and Russia in particular, as did President Voronin. Nevertheless, they flew to Astana to discuss issues of common interest, while Georgian Mihail Saakashvili even conditioned his solidarity with Russia in its efforts to fight terrorism by its refraining from double standards when resolving secessionist conflicts it had inspired. The contrast with the behaviour displayed by Moldovan President becomes even more striking if considering Article 27 of the Treaty on Friendship and Cooperation between Republic of Moldova and Russian Federation, thereby contracting parties undertake to cooperate within CIS, or Article 14 of the same document thereby they undertake to cooperate in fighting "terrorism, drug smuggling" etc. Those were exactly the issues topping the agenda of the last CIS Summit. Therefore Voronin's absence may only be viewed as an ostentatious dodge from his obligations undertaken via the Law on Ratifying the Friendship and Cooperation Treaty. Still there is much more to this.

Russia's aspirations and their impact

Astana Summit was held just after the series of terrorist attacks by Chechen secessionists in Russia, from the murder of the Chechen President Akhmad Kadyrov on May 9 to Beslan tragedy in early September. That is why Russia needed CIS heads of states to commit fighting terrorism. At the very same time, Russian leadership and its foreign affairs took actions and made statements highlighting their attitude towards secessionist regimes throughout CIS.

For instance, secessionists in Abkhazia and North Osetia enjoy the support of the Russian Duma Deputy Speaker, Dmitriy Rogozin. During Ajara crisis last spring two of the forefathers of the Transdnistrian secessionist regime - member of the State Duma Victor Alksnis and General Iurii Netkacev, former commander of the 14th Army - flew to Batumi to share "positive experience" of the Transdnistrian success story. However Russian officials' cynicism reached its highest at the time terrorists held more then one thousand hostages in a Beslan school. At that time Transdnestrian separatist regime was celebrating the 14th anniversary of its independence. Deputy Speaker of the Russian State Duma, Serghei Baburin, attending the ceremony stated: "Assessing the situation on Dniester, we should acknowledge the reality: Moldova consists of two states - Dniester Moldovan Republic and Republic of Moldova, Transdniestrians have proven already that they have the right to their own destiny � Neither economic blockade nor the attempts to withdraw from the Memorandum where Dniester Moldovan Republic is acknowledged as a state, would change the reality"2. Yet another Deputy Speaker of the Russian Duma, Vladimir Jirinovski, sent his congratulations to Transdnistrian leader Igor Smirnov reading "by joining our efforts we would be able to get Dniestrian Moldovan Republic recognized and later on joined to Russian Federation"3. Thus, secessionist leaders presenting themselves as internationalists have the committed nationalists in Russia among their supporters.

Indeed, Baburin, Rogozin, Jirinovskii (all Deputy Speakers of the Russian Duma sharing nationalist and chauvinist ideals) are so-far marginal political players; however in the past they were voicing things Kremlin would not dare as it was bound to diplomatic etiquette. All of the aforesaid is already known, though under crisis those facts look different. President of the National Strategy Institute, Serghei Belkovski, boasting his closeness to Kremlin, explained why Russia needs secessionist regimes throughout CIS, namely "Unknown states are the ones enabling Russia to keep the levers of influence tight in its hands, to take the role of arbitrator and mediator in conflicts throughout post-Communist area, and keep its military presence in the farthest corners of CIS, which results in a mono-polar structure in CIS. The belt consisting of unrecognized states is nothing but a tool for securing Russia's presence in the trouble spots of the former URSS. Once this belt disappears Russia would loose its role as a moderator in the post-soviet area. Under given circumstances, CIS would break apart and would be replaced by a conglomerate of 12 equal countries, each of them directly addressing its problems together with global players (USA, EU, China) or regional ones (Turkey, Iran), while Moscow would no longer be an attraction pole for them"4. Of course, political scientist's words should also be taken with a grain of salt; still the judgement of the European Court for Human Rights on "Ilascu case" proves that he was right.

On the other hand, the main Kremlin strategist, President of the Efficient Policy Foundation, Gleb Pavlovski, identified the main foes in the aftermath of Beslan and explained why Russia would not allow conflicts it had inspired and frozen throughout CIS to be defrozen: "It's hard to identify the enemy in a modern world. Individuals and organizations, which in some cases are our diplomatic partners, in others support killers, like Brussels which legitimizes them by calling them insurgents. Another example - strengthened EU promotes an enlargement doctrine, raising the issue of defreezing old conflicts in Caucasus and Black Sear. As the notion of security is an essential one for Brussels, it is also applied to the neighbouring territories, i.e. Bessarabia, Transdniestria, Abkhazia, South Osetia, and Armenia so as to take an account of the territories at its borders. Those conflicts were frozen by us as part of another approach - national security that operated in the last 10 years. Saakashvili that plays the card of defreezing conflicts does it because he needs US and Europe support and is trying to get them in the game. In fact Basaev was the one to benefit from Saakashvili defreezing the conflict. Russia is entitled to rephrase the question to Saakashvili as follows: we are certain that those who plotted Beslan terrorist act wouldn't have chosen North Osetia as their target, if Georgia had not defrozen South Osetia conflict"5.

Pavlovski's statement came immediately after Beslan and on the eve of CIS Summit. In Astana Georgian President picked up the issues raised by Pavlovski saying "It is important not to apply double standards in addressing problems under litigation. We know far too well who the terrorists are. Let's take Basaev. In mid 90's he was a hero for secessionists in Abkazia, whose hands a stained in blood"6. In response Vladimir Putin indicated that "economic sanctions and military pressure wouldn't bring any results. This is not the path leading to the House of God". The curious thing here is that West has been sending this message to Putin for some time now when referring to ways of settling Chechen conflict, however it declined it. Thus, what is Russia may do in Chechnya, Georgia may not in South Osetia and Abkhazia. Russia may venture to inspire secessionist movements that it would later freeze so as to keep its military presence in CIS countries, whose independence and sovereignty it recognized. However CIS countries are not allowed to defreeze conflicts on its soil if it does not suit Russia's interests. Those who make such attempts are viewed as enemies. Under those circumstances, Russian officials call on the West to give up on "double standards"7. On September 23, Russian Foreign Minister, Serghei Lavrov, introduced a UN draft resolution "On better interaction in fighting global terrorism". Albeit it is a very important, one should not forget that in the case of Russia terrorism is deeply rooted in secessionism. That is why one should not confuse the cause and effect, that is, the correct wording of the draft resolution should be "in fighting secessionism and terrorism". Russia wants to exploit the interference of secessionism and Islamic terrorism so as to replace the former with the latter. Obsession about Western "double standards" would simply vanish if Russia was to apply the same criteria in dealing with secessionist conflicts in CIS.

Conclusions

Clearly, the way political and economic issues are addressed in CIS greatly undermine the future of this structure. The fate of SEA remains unclear due to the economic selfishness of Russia. Elections in Kazakhstan, electoral campaign in Ukraine, and referendum initiated by Lukashenko in Belarus on extending the number of presidential mandates - all of them indicate that they slide towards authoritarianism as is Russia. It is all-too-clear that "verticals of power" generates new conflicts. As for the three Central Asian countries, they are confronted with too specific problems to contribute to CIS stability.

As for the Caucasus countries, they don't place much hope in the CIS development, but rather hope Russia would play a positive role in settling the conflicts they are trying to get to grips. "I believe Russia should play a positive role in conflict resolution. There is potential for negotiations" those were the words of President Saakashvili at the Astana Summit.

The fact that President Voronin did not use the CIS Summit as an opportunity to talk with President Putin and Kucima about Transdnistrian conflict resolution signals that the potential for negotiations in the current five-sided format with the participation of Russia and Ukraine has been fully exhausted. Voronin's absence at Astana comes as a surprise, considering his statement on Independence Day "There would be no negotiations with Tiraspol. We would only continue the dialogue with those whom Tiraspol reports directly to". Refraining to mention who they are, President Voronin claims the 460 km border with Ukraine are open to smuggling "bringing dividends to Tiraspol, Ukraine, and Russia to such an extent as it defies international law". On September 1 in an interview to BBC President Voronin reiterated "Transdnistrian regime is a marionette one controlled by Russia and Ukraine". Therefore, one may well understand why President Voronin refuses to sit at the negotiation table with "Tiraspol marionette", however it's strange why he refuses to talk to "puppeteers from Moscow and Kiev" as he had promised in his message on Independence Day.

In fact, in his statement Voronin accused Russia of violating Article 5 of the Friendship and Cooperation Treaty signed by the Republic of Moldova and Russian Federation on 19.12.2001, providing that "Parties condemn secessionism in all its forms and undertake to refrain from supporting secessionist movements". By doing so he probably wanted to anticipate any accusations to Moldova alleging it failed to comply with its cooperation obligations within CIS. The move would have some serious consequences which would be the subject of separate consideration.


1 "Integrarea Moldovei in structurile europene nu necesita iesirea din cadrul CSI" (Joining European structures does not require Republic of Moldova to leave CIS), Moldova suverana, nr.155, 16.09.2004

2 http://www.olvia.idknet.com/ol13-09-04.htm

3 http://www.olvia.idknet.com/ol11-09-04.htm

4 "Начало трагедии" (Beginning of a tragedy), Ведомости, 12.05.04

5 "Судороги рождения нации" (Nation labor pains), Русский журнал, 4.09.04

6 "СНГ - страна советов" (CIS - country of the soviets), GazetaSNG.ru, 17.09.04

7 "Лавров пытался разобраться с англичанами на нейтральной территории" (Lavrov tried to deal with the Brits on neutral grounds), Независимая газета,�206, 24.09.04


The following contributed to this issue:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]