![]() | Association for Participatory Democracy | Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md Original: /en/e-journal/20041103/index.shtml |
Activity of public institutions
During the aforesaid period Parliament's attention was focused on draft budget for 2005 and draft budget of state insurance for 2005. As usual deputies heard Minister of Finance and Minister of Economy and raised a number of questions. Later on, leaders of Parliament factions voiced their own positions on the draft. Opposition pointed the lack of a sustainable strategy of economic development, whereas majority faction criticised insufficient funding of certain fields such as education and agriculture. Further, while opposition considered little funds were allotted to social sphere, majority faction on the contrary stated that funding to these areas rose considerably. Finally, following a tradition already, opposition factions refused voting the draft.
1.2. Legal acts
(For further details on Parliament activity see http://www.e-democracy.md/en/comments/legislative/)
2.1. Decisions
3.1. Decree
Local government was obliged to develop and enforce their own action plans for the year of local communities of the Republic of Moldova. Central and local government were obliged to cooperate "with public association and citizen initiatives". Mass media was invited to "largely cover on the activities carried out as part of the year of local communities of the Republic of Moldova".
3.2. Meetings
On October 28, President Voronin had a meeting with American Ambassador to Moldova, Heather Hodges, and talked Stability and Security Pact for the Republic of Moldova (SSPRM). American Ambassador stated that both US and EU saw the Pact as "a potential mechanism for consolidating regional security" that is why they supported the initiative to sign SSPRM in early December during the OSCE Summit in Sofia. Heather Hodges opted for including OSCE among the signatories of the Declaration, whereas US and EU to act as observers in the process of settling Transdnistrian conflict.
Noteworthy, the idea of SSPRM was launched by President Vladimir Voronin on June 1, 2004 and was to serve as a compromise that "might be reached as a result of a political conference gathering Heads of Foreign Policy Departments from Russia, US, Romania, Ukraine and EU and them signing a Stability and Security Pact for the Republic of Moldova. This document having the status of an international law document, would be an efficient system of long-term guarantees for the entire Moldovan state, would open new unique approaches as regards developing democratic institutions, ensuring civic concord in the country and resolution of Transdnistrian conflict as soon as possible".
That issue was the subject of a telephone conversation the same day between President Voronin and Javier Solana, High Representative of EU for the Common Foreign and Security Policy.
2.1 Elections might slow down economic growth
2005-2006 might be tough years for the National Bank and future Government. There are a number of challenges lying ahead the governors: keeping budget deficit below 1% of the GDP, keeping inflation under control (below 10%), making domestic enterprises more competitive. It seems economic growth has slowed down in Moldova and this despite preparations for 2005 parliamentary elections. Regardless who wins elections, European integration would influence the policy led by the Government.
Predictions. A 6% economic growth is forecasted for 2005-2006 impinged by growing investments and consumer spending. It is estimated that inflation would drop to 8% by the end of 2005 and 6.5% by 2006. According to the same forecasts, current account deficit would drop to 5% of the GDP in 2005-2006 from the 5.5% of the GDP in 2004.
As for budget deficit, Government set a target of 1% of GDP in 2005, however there are many lingering concerns that fiscal reforms1 planed for the next year might have a negative effect on the revenues and would likely thwart attempts to reach the target. Recently resumed economic growth (6.5%) has been driven by better levied taxes and VAT, as well as wage raise.
Risks. Economy-watchers say a 6.5% GDP growth in the first half of the year coupled with surging consumer spending, eventually swell the net exports deficit, which raises the question whether such GDP growth rates may be sustained on mid-term. Trade balance deficit is still a source of concern, many questions arising regarding our economy's competitiveness on long-term. Monetary policy led by the National Banks envisages a gradual decrease of inflation while avoiding an excessive appreciations in real terms of the national currency. Keeping inflation steady might work if coupled with a control of exchange rate.
Moldovan goods and services are loosing grounds on the domestic market, covering only 60% of the domestic consumption. Given the lack of an adequate response from domestic manufacturers, surging consumer spending has further deepened the gap between imports and exports, which had a negative effect on the trade balance deficit. Last year, exports surpassed imports by 622 million USD. Businesses worry that direct foreign investments (58.3 million USD) and portfolio (2.03 million USD) failed to balance current account deficit. This also explains why net average salary per economy in Moldova does not account for the tenth part of the average in Europe.
Comparison
2.2 Swelling National Bank's foreign currency reserves
According to the data released by the National Bank of the Republic of Moldova its foreign currency reserves hit a record high 391.6 million USD at the end of September. It came as a result of massive purchases of foreign currency - 117 million USD in the third quarter alone. As a result, National Bank managed to restore its foreign currency reserves to the levels before the 1998 Russian financial crisis, that reverberated in the entire region, Moldova being no exception.
Since the national currency was put in circulation back in 1993, National Bank managed to double its foreign currency reserves in three years, when they surged from 180 million to 365.7 million USD. However, after the crisis they dropped 2.5 times to a record low of 143 million USD in December 1998. Even if IMF suspended crediting Moldova over 1999-2003, loans that are usually used to fill foreign currency reserves, National Bank managed to add more than 150 million USD to its reserves mainly by purchasing foreign currency on the domestic market.
In 2004 National Bank purchased over 120 million USD mainly from the transfers of Moldovan citizens working abroad. Evolution of foreign reserves has even handily outstripped forecasts made by independent experts who expected National Bank's reserves to reach 350 million USD by the end of the year.
2.3 Tension growing in sugar industry
Great many sugar manufacturers participating in a seminar concluded that sugar industry would not make it unless both Parliament and Government agree to reduce VAT for sugar manufacturers from 20% to 8%. They voiced their lingering concerns about growing prices on energy that at the end of the day incurs additional costs, thus not allowing them to buy additional raw materials.
The major sugar manufacturers, among them "Suedzucker Moldova" and "Marr Sugar Moldova" conducted a market research estimating that the maximum price for 1 tone of sugar might reach the international market level, i.e. 460-480 USD, VAT not included. Such a price might be set for the Moldovan sugar only when exporting the extra above domestic market's needs and only after introducing a record keeping system2, controlling and regulating the market similar to EU system. An 850-900 thousand tones of sugar beat are expected to be harvested this year, out of which an estimated 90 thousand tones of sugar are to be produced. On average 85 thousand tones of sugar are consumed by the domestic market.
Last year Russia and Ukraine excluded sugar imported from Moldova from the free trade scheme. Later on, Ukraine set a customs tax worth 300 Euro per tone, while Russia a tax worth 45% of the imported amount, or no less than 150 Euro per tone. A draft protocol signed by Republic of Moldova and Russia provides that exports of Moldovan sugar to Russia under free trade scheme would be resumed in 2005 at an annualized quota of 5 thousand tones.
Previously, sugar manufacturers estimated that sugar price on the domestic market might surge by 10%. On top of that, they believed that by the end of the year sugar may not be sold for less than 7 Lei per kg, as otherwise factories would be in the loss. Government decided to set an 8% VAT tax on white sugar (see http://www.e-democracy.md/en/e-journal/20041020/#2), given that factories purchase sugar beat at a 5% VAT tax while sell sugar product at a 20% tax, it is only natural that the price on sugar is set to soar. The new tax would apply both to Moldovan sugar and imported one.
2.4 Relations with international financial organisations
Shigeo Katsu and Paul Bermingham had a number of meetings with Moldovan officials, among them President Voronin, Speaker Eugenia Ostapciuc, Prime-Minister Vasile Tarlev. High on the agenda of the meetings was WB's support to Moldova in building a market economy and poverty reduction. WB officials reiterated their interest for the Government to implement Poverty Reduction Strategy. In a related note, World Bank completed its Country Assistance Strategy for Moldova due to be examined on December 14, 2004.
One of the conclusions reached at the meeting was that the country's economic potential was not fully exploited, despite the success registered in the last two years. Moldovan Prime-Minister spoke of the importance IMF to support PRSP and jointly develop an action plan in this respect.
After completing its visit IMF mission would develop a report evaluating economic conditions in the Republic of Moldova and would submit it to the IMF Executive Council.
After the resolution, although incomplete, of the issue of Moldovan Latin script schools from the Transnistrian region, the tensions between the Moldovan and Transnistrian sides re-erupted on 15 October, when the Transnistrian administration installed a permanent check point between Severnii district of Tighina town and Varnita village, and another one between Severnii district and Tighina town. The two check points replaced mobile customs points mobilized in June 2004. The Varnita village, situated on the left bank of Nistru River, but under the jurisdiction of the Moldovan Government, is located in the security area, where, according to the ceasefire agreement of 1992, no paramilitary forces may be deployed and all move should be coordinated with the United Commandment of the Peacekeeping Forces. In protest, dozens of villagers blocked from 17 October with concrete barrages the Chisinau-Tighina highway that passes by the village. Russian peacekeepers removed the barrages on 19 October without authorisation from the United Commandment and without removing the Transnistrian checkpoints. At the Joint Control Commission on 22 October, the Transnistrian side accepted to withdraw its two checkpoints on the condition that the Moldovan side withdraws its fiscal checkpoint set at the entry into Varnita in June 2004. For some time now, the Transnistrian customs officials and border guards have constantly intimidating the inhabitants of Varnita village by subjecting them to various unmotivated checks and duties.
In the meantime, the European Union offered its support for resolving the border problems between the Republic of Moldova and Ukraine, according to a press communique of the Moldovan Foreign Ministry of 18 October. According to the communique, during the trilateral EU- Republic of Moldova - Ukraine consultations on 15 October, the EU offered to support the implementation of agreements between Chisinau and Kiev on setting up joint customs checkpoints on the Transnistrian segment of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border. In addition, the EU will provide financial assistance to the Moldovan customs services, including for training programmes and for equipment, and has shown ready to fund a computerised system of exchanging information between Moldovan and Ukrainian customs.
On the other hand, Moldovan media have reported that the EU and the US intend to sign a Declaration on the Stability and Security of the Republic of Moldova at the OSCE Ministerial Summit to be held in early December in Sofia. According to a presidential press communique, quoted by Moldavskie Vedomosti, the US Ambassador to Moldova, Heather Hodges, stated during a meeting with President Voronin on 28 October that both the US and the EU see the Declaration as a potential mechanism of consolidating security in the region. In June 2004, President Voronin proposed to the US, EU, Russian Federation, Ukraine and Romania to sign a Pact of Stability and Security for the Republic of Moldova, whereby the signatory states would agree to coordinate their actions with regard to the Republic of Moldova, including the Transnistrian conflict. According to observers, if the US and the EU sign the Declaration, Romania is very likely to sign it too, and it is only up to Russia and Ukraine to take an official stand on the document.
In the view of the special representative of the Russian Foreign Ministry, Igor Savolski, though, who visited Moldova on 25 and 26 October together with the Moscow's representative to the Transnistrian conflict resolution talks, Valeri Nesteruskin, the initiative regarding the Pact is still in the phase of consultations and is not even directly related to the Transnistrian problem. The two Russian officials, who came to Chisinau to encourage the Moldovan and Transnistrian sides to resume the talks, said instead that to Russia the strategic partnership with Moldova is "an enduring option" and that "for overcoming possible problems, coordinated actions and a permanent dialogue" are necessary, informs Basa-press. At the end of the visit, the two dignitaries said that the five-sided negotiations format is functional and there is no other format, but have not given a definite answer as to the readiness of the Moldovan Government to resume its participation in the talks in this format.
The position of the official Chisinau regarding the inefficiency of the current negotiations format and the need to change it was reiterated by the Moldovan Foreign Minister, Andrei Stratan, during a press conference on 25 October. The same position was vociferated by the Deputy Speaker of the Moldovan Parliament, Vadim Misin, who suggested at a press conference on 28 October that since the five-sided format has not led to any result, it has to be changed by 1 January 2005, according to the principles of "a single and integrated territory, a single customs, banking, monetary and defence space" and without the participation of the break away leader Igor Smirnov.
While the prospects for the resumption of talks between Chisinau and Tiraspol remain uncertain, the Supreme Soviet in Tiraspol adopted on 27 October, in the final reading, amendments to the privatisation programme of Transnistria for 2001-2004, which was completed with several dozens enterprises, including two of the largest Transnistrian enterprises - the textiles factory "Tirotex" and the Brandy making company "Kvint". The amendments were proposed by the Transnistrian "minister of education" in September, which she motivated by the "difficult political and economic situation caused by the sanctioned imposed by the Moldovan Government on Transnistria". According to the Transnistrian official news agency Olvia-press, already a number of applications for participation in the privatisation of "Tirotex" factory have been submitted to the Transnistrian "economy ministry" by several Russian and one Dutch firms. The two enterprises are to be privatised by the end of 2004, despite the Law on the Privatisation on the left bank of Nistru River and in the Tighina town adopted earlier by the Moldovan Parliament and which provides that all Transnistrian businesses will pass from 1 January 2005 into the ownership of their employees free of charge.
Among the issues under discussion were a) President Vladimir Voronin's initiative on Stability and Security Plan for Moldova; b) ways of settling Transdnistrian conflict; c) enforcing Republic of Moldova - EU Action Plan; d) ways of facilitating visa regime for Moldovan citizens; e) bilateral relations and cooperation in areas of security and frontiers; f) ways to attract investments to the Republic of Moldova by means of British Office for Construction and Consultancy, etc.
The same issues were high on the agenda during Minister Stratan meetings with NATO and EU high officials in Brussels on October 21.
The Two Presidents opted for "joining efforts in view of peaceful resolution of territorial conflicts the two countries are confronted with, in line with generally accepted norms and principles of international law".
During his visit, President Vladimir Voronin made several points: a) Republic of Moldova had no intention to leave CIS, although it regretted its low level of efficiency; b) it was necessary to adjust principles of cooperation within CIS to those within EU; d) scepticism as regards GUUAM, albeit several interesting initiatives were launched recently.
"3D" strategy - from "extremism" to consensus?
Oazu Nantoi
While governors and opposition were jostling for influence, the generous gesture made by Chisinau on February 7, 1996 when it handed over to Tiraspol customs seals of the Republic of Moldova, was left unnoticed. Back then Igor Smirnov decided it was the right time to appoint his son as the Chair of the State Customs Committee. Even the Memorandum of May 8, 1997 being truly unconstitutional was left unnoticed by the Moldovan society as it was struggling with dire social-economic straits. Indeed, politicians and public officials in Chisinau who realized that in political meddling with Tiraspol they might earn a fortune, fully exploited this apathy in society.
Thus Moldovan society was split into two parallel worlds. One - society indifferent to the conflict. The other - the underworld merged with the political elite in Chisinau, Kiev and Moscow that fully benefited of the "frozen" conflict. Sporadic attempts by journalists, publicists to draw the attention of the public to the things happening failed, but those who dared to speak up were immediately labelled as "extremists" .
In the spring of 2000 Institute for Public Policies embarked on studying regional conflicts and Transdniestrian conflict in particular. Step by step a number of studies were produced, all of them pointing to the effect that both the "unique" formula of the peacekeeping forces and "five-sided" negotiated format were imposed so as to allow Russian Federation to keep the situation under its control and prevent the resolution of the conflict.
Things started to change immediately after parliamentary elections of February 2001. Reintegration of the country has taken centre stage. In many of his declaration and actions President Voronin draw public's attention to the Transdnistrian issue, teetering from huge concessions to Tiraspol to dubbing Igor Smirnov "bandit and mafia", move followed by the introduction of new customs seals.
The idea to settle Transdnistrian conflict by turning Republic of Moldova into a federative state was yet another challenge for the Moldovan society. For the first time, West formed a joint front with OSCE and Russia and endorsed the initiative. For the first time the pages of governmental media were open to opposition forces to have their say on the federalisation. Debates that followed highlighted the weaknesses of the federalization idea - holding a referendum and questionable viability of the federative state established by mechanically assembling Transdnistrian regime, dubbed as criminal by Moldovan authorities, and what currently is the Republic of Moldova. None of the proponents of federalization was able to tell what would happen to the Republic of Moldova in case the referendum on federalization was to fail, or how viable the "reunited" state would be if the repressive structures of the Tiraspol regime were not eliminated first.
3D strategy was launched in the summer of 2003 after it became clear that ideas formulated in IPP's studies needed a "packaging" able to compete with the "federalisation" formula. The end-goal was very clear while developing the 3D strategy. The reintegrated state was to become viable, democratic, prosperous, European-oriented and "immune" to any recurrence of secessionism. This is feasible as citizens on both sides of Dniester do not view each other as enemies. This last thing, has led us to the conclusion that Igor Smirnov's clan should not be allowed to the negotiation table, as it represents foreign geopolitical and economic-criminal interests and seeks to hinder conflict resolution.
Respectively, 3D strategy provides for eliminating all the obstacles for the reintegration of the Republic of Moldova, establishing efficient mechanisms and mobilizing resources necessary. At the same time, the strategy also envisages blocking any possibility for Tiraspol regime to pursue the aforesaid interests (geopolitical and international organized crime network) that kept them alive. The gist of the strategy resumes to three major goals - Demilitarization of the Moldovan Dniestrian Republic (withdrawing Russian Federation troops and dismantling its MDR's potential) Decriminalization of the entire region by halting smuggling and Democratization of the Republic of Moldova as a whole.
3D strategy includes a psychological element as well - for 15 years MDR's public opinion is manipulated; it was raised in the fear for the enemy from the right bank of Dniester. It would take time to demolish those stereotypes, time in which some positive expectations should be brought to the people of Transdnistria as regards perspective of country reintegration, democratization of entire society, and European future of the Republic of Moldova.
In the summer of 2004 a group of independent experts from Moldova and abroad decided to draft and present to the public 3D strategy and a Road Map that would clearly outline to be undertaken actions and responsibilities of the actors involved in the process of reintegrating Moldova. This initiative of the civil society has a twofold goal. On the one hand, to provide a document to the political elite and society at large that would pave the way to a national consensus on settling Transdnistrian conflict. Similarly, 3D and Road Map are to show the West that at last Republic of Moldova has realized what it wants as regards Transdnistrian conflict, that it knows how to reintegrate the country and is ready to assume its share of responsibility. So far twenty six NGOs endorsed the document that was presented to the major political parties of Moldova. Latest declarations made by President Voronin as regards Transdnistrian conflict are to a large extend in line with the main principles of 3D strategy. Apparently, all the premises for achieving a national consensus on Moldova reintegration seem to be there, however the time will show to what extent Moldovan society and its so-called political elite are ready to this breakthrough. There is only one alternative to reintegrating the country and a very tough one - continuous degradation of the idea of Republic of Moldova statehood.
What's in their for us in the draft budget for 2005?
Iurie Gotisan
Moreover, considerable funds are to be allotted next year to special state services, public order, national defence - 23% of the total budget spending. Excessive funding of the force structures speaks for itself - incumbent power seeks to improve social-economic conditions in a rather specific manner, rather than by passing and enforcing laws that would spot and prevent various forms of corruption and embezzlement.
On the last 100 metres, budget for this year might be further undercut by some unforeseen spending that the Government had to assume. On top of that, during last week Government session Minister of Finance announced that due to the failure to collect all forecasted taxes, there was a budget "whole" worth 1 billion Lei in the state budget for this year. Having said this, it is very likely the macroeconomic targets set for the next year would not be met.
The fact that Moldova doesn't have a functional market economy would make all the problems even worse in an electoral year and would likely undermine all the social-oriented "moves" envisaged in the draft budget for 2005. The mere mention of "elections" brings the draft budget in the centre of electorate and contestants' attention with both of them seeking to exploit it to their own advantage, i.e. the former to ask the latter to provide or promise.
If we are to look back at the developments since September, the first to claim their rights were teachers who threatened to go on strike. And the timing was perfect, beginning of the school year. Government yielded and raised wages by 20%. On top of that on the last 100 metres before draft budget approval, Government took over even more of a burden: indemnifying pensions; raising allocations, compensations and indemnities; all in all an estimated at 890 million Lei. What the Government didn't do was to take into account fluctuating prices on raw materials and oil on the international market.
All of the aforesaid would wield a heavy pressure on achieving the targets set for the next year, namely: a 6% economic growth and keeping inflation below 9%. It's difficult to asses the impact of the swelling budget spending, as nobody works seriously with economic modelling in Moldova and there is not enough statistics data.
Early this year, a part of the healthcare employees agreed to adjourn negotiations on wages for the next year, however they have changed their mind lately seizing the right moment. As one government official put it, one cannot go to the polling stations when people are rallying nearby. Therefore, Government would have again to dig deep into its pockets and come up with new amendments to the draft budget so as to ease the spirits.
Yet once again, ruling party's generous promises are confronted with economic realities. Previously, ruling party's generosity was tempered by financial isolation brought by worsening relations with international monetary organisations. Recent decisions of the International Monetary Fund, currently with a mission in Moldova, to adjourn discussions on our country spoiled any hopes for an aid from abroad, or at least for an aid in the first half of 2005. Moldova would find it difficult to service foreign debt as well as to finance foreign deficit, i.e. trade balance and current account deficit.
Draft budget for 2005 promises lowering fiscal burden for legal and natural entities alike. In particular it promises to cut by 2% the income tax for legal entities, from 20% in 2004 to 18% in 2005; and income tax quotas for natural entities from 10%, 15% and 22% in 2004 to 9%, 14% and 20% in 2005. Ministry of Finance estimated that the move would roughly cost 1 billion Lei. Potentially, the move would pay back by surging investments from Moldovan business.
Apparently, the state lets the fiscal burden loose. In reality, envisaged moves would not reform taxation system, while their impact remains unclear. Moldovan officials keep promising jobs and wage-raise. However, draft budget paints a less robust picture, social contribution would drop from 28% to 27%, healthcare insurance would go up by 2%, and most importantly the idea of a single taxation quota was abandoned.
Reinvesting profits, amidst lowering income tax from 20% to 18%, would rather be a constraint. An income tax as low as 18% might lure foreign investors. If this was the intention of the Government, then it fades when compared to 15% income tax in the region. On the contrary, ambiguous laws, bureaucracy, not to speak of the rule of law would scare any investor away.
Although it is said to be socially-oriented, the current draft budget follows fiscal and budgetary policies of the previous years. One of the rules of economic policies says that budget is a financial reflection of the state policies, but it seems this rule doesn't work in Moldova. Macroeconomic indicators used in drafting the budget for the next year, which Prime-Minister likes bragging about, have induced ecstasy among legislators. Unfortunately, Moldovan economy is not as healthy as Tarlev's Government wants to see it. Allegorically speaking, there is only one step to go from ecstasy to agony.
The following contributed to this issue:
|
© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT" Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated | e-mail: [email protected] |