ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20050912/index.shtml


e-journal, III year, no. 57, August 31 - September 12, 2005

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Conflict

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Government

1.1. Appointments

On September 7, Government appointed Vasile Sturza as Republic of Moldova Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Ambassador to Russian Federation, and recalled him from his previously hold position as Moldova's Ambassador to Bulgarian Republic as well as other positions. The office of Moldovan Ambassador to Russia became vacant when Vladimir Turcan was elected to Moldovan Parliament and Chair of the Parliamentary Juridical Commission for Appointments and Immunities. The office was vacant for over six months, which might be explained by the deadlock in the Russian-Moldovan relations. Accordingly a figure able to address it and be seen by good eyes by the Russian side was sought. Vasile Sturza has a rich political background: he served four years as the Minister of Justice, later for several years he represented Moldovan side at the negotiation table with Transdnistria. The latter brought him in contact with numerous Russian diplomats and made him acceptable to the Russian side. Noteworthy, there are a number of vacant offices, namely Moldovan Ambassador to Poland, Portugal, Bulgaria, Azerbaijan, etc.

1.2. Sessions. Resolutions


Economic Policies

1. Prices and inflation

2. Public finances

3. Financial-banking system

4. Foreign trade

5. Labour market

6. Moldova in the world


Transdnistrian Conflict

Between 31 August and 2 September, the Transnistrian authorities organised a series of events to celebrate the 15th anniversary of the "Transnistrian state". The tone of manifestations was set by the Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov who held a press conference on 31 August. "The statehood of Transnistria alone is the guarantee of life and security of the inhabitants of the region", told Smirnov the press conference, qualifying Moldova's policy towards the Transnistrian region as a "political theft under the cover of democracy and respect for human rights". Smirnov reiterated his readiness to restart the political negotiations with Moldova, but only on terms of equality, and showed ready to offer all borders and enterprise to international monitors, saying that in Transnistria there exist "all the premises for fighting border smuggling". Smirnov also declared that the peacekeeping operation should be carried out under Russian leadership, because the "people trust the Russian peacekeepers" and Russia has always been present in the region. Speaking about the legislative elections scheduled for the end of 2005, Smirnov said they will take place to schedule "according to the laws of Transnistria". "We have invited foreign observers to monitor the elections and we have done everything to ensure they are open ones. The international community can recognise them or not," Smirnov also said.

The key celebrations included a festive meeting on 1 September attended by a group of Russian deputies, a show about the history of Transnistria and a military parade on 2 September. In addition, three commemorative coins of gold and silver were put into circulation on the occasion. According to a communique of Smirnov's press service, over 30 foreign media institutions accredited journalists at the manifestations, including BBC, Reuters and France-press. Delegations from Abkhazia, Northern Karabakh and South Ossethia attended, as well as a delegation from Russia, led by the Deputy Speaker of the Russian Duma, Serghei Baburin.

In an interview with Transnistria's official news agency Olvia-press, the latter defined Transnistria as a "geopolitical reality" and stated that Moldova and Transnistria are at present "two different states that have emerged from the ruins of the former MSSR". Pointing to a change of "the ideology of power" in Moscow, Baburin expressed hope that already during President Putin's current mandate Russia will recognise Transnistria as an independent and sovereign state.

It is worth noting that during the same period Russia's special representative to the talks on the Transnistrian conflict resolution, Ambassador with Special Missions of the Russian MFA, Valeri Nesteruskin, told the press in Moscow that for the time being the necessary conditions for the evacuation of the Russian troops from Transnistria are not in place. Among the "necessary conditions" for the evacuation Nesteruskin mentioned an active political dialogue between the conflicting parties that would allow for a well organised and constructive cooperation with the local authorities in the process. At the same time, Nesteruskin said that Russia will only withdraw its army from Transnistria when it will be sure that "some unacceptable conditions will not be forced upon Tiraspol".

Among other important events related to the Transnistrian conflict resolution one may also mention the two initiatives launched in Bucharest, one on the state of negotiations and another one proposing on possible evolutions in the field.

Romanian Academic Society (SAR Policy Brief no.16) launched the project "How could we help Moldova to help itself". According to the report, intensively promoting Transnistrian issue under the current political context might be counterproductive both to Romania's security and Republic of Moldova' consolidation.

It is believed that Moldova should progress in European accession as Cyprus did, while the conflict resolution might go high on Romania's agenda once it becomes an EU member. Until then, Republic of Moldova should steer its foreign policy towards West rather than East and get seriously prepared for joining EU. In essence, the project envisages Moldova becoming autonomous from Transnistria, while the latter be isolated via an international embargo.

Meantime, MP Adrian Severin released in Bucharest the policy research developed by "Ovidiu Shincai" Institute entitled "Transnistria - evolution of the frozen conflict and prospects of resolution". The document recommends decision-makers in Bucharest to take steps in view of "setting loose Transnistria as a territory of the Republic of Moldova and placing it under a regime similar to that applied to Kosovo province". Later, after being placed under international protectorate, the 3D (demilitarization, democratization and decriminalization) strategy should be applied. Simultaneously, a process similar to the one launched in Cyprus aimed at Republic of Moldova accession to EU should start, provided that EU "would replace its good neighborhood policy for Moldova into an integration, enlargement one".

The report claims that "after Romania and Bulgaria join EU, the next two countries to follow should be Croatia and Republic of Moldova. Republic of Moldova's accession to EU should represent a security guarantee for EU's eastern border. EU's borders lying on Dniester river would be stable on the long-term, while Ukraine stands slim chances of accession to EU".

For now, none of Moldovan officials commented on the two initiatives. The official press reported that on September 11, Moldovan and Romanian Foreign Ministers met in Iasi.


Foreign Affairs


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of the Parliament within the first session
Sergiu Grosu

Lawmakers are expected in late September to return from their two months vacation and start the examination of draft laws included in the agenda of the legislature. The priorities of the second session (which is the shortest and lasts less than three months) have not been established until now, though the executive had drafted a four-year activity program and action plans. Also, the Parliament passed a decision last June, obliging the executive to submit on September 1, 2005 a list of legislative documents which will be drafted in order to implement the governing program and national strategies on key sectors, aiming at brining in accordance the national legislation to community acquis. It is not clear yet whether the executive has fulfilled the task, nor whether envisaged list of legislative documents has been developed and lawmakers agenda.

One may only engage in suppositions on the agenda of the next session, however what really is feasible is to review the previous session of the legislators elected on March 6, 2005 elections when they adopted more than 200 legislative documents.

Political and organizational problems

The great majority of spring-summer session focused on political issues and settlement of organizational aspects of Parliament activity. Thus, several sessions in a row focused on election of the Parliament's administration, members of the permanent bureau, parliamentary factions and commissions. Also, the lawmakers debated more than once the membership of parliamentary delegations, with representatives of different factions expressing contradictory preferences on cooperation at international and inter-parliamentary levels. Two sessions of the Parliament focused on election and, respectively, investiture of the President, another session was dedicated to introduction of the candidate to the Prime-Minister seat and confidence vote to the Government. Almost an entire session focused on appointment of the Supreme Court of Justice head, while another session was used to name judges and deputy chairmen of the Supreme Court of Justice (and only one of them was finally appointed). Another session was used to hear the annual report of the Human Rights Center, a hearing when Parliamentary opposition voiced harsh criticism. Statements and appeals on different topics of interior and foreign policies represented a separate issue. Also, the Parliament examined separately the Law on Basic Provisions of the Status of the Left Bank of Dniester river.

Parliamentarians paid a special attention to several key sectors, as follows:

Economy, budget and finances

The Parliament adopted a set of amendments shaping the fiscal policy for 2006, establishing a small reduction of the income tax, with introduction or simultaneous rise of the value-added tax for agriculture. On the one hand, tax-payers salute the reduction of income tax as it may increase the taxable base, reduce the shadow economy, but on the other hand it may pose some problems in filling the state coffers. Respectively, the rise of VAT in agriculture sector will result in higher prices on agricultural products, price-hike also propelled further upwards by the briskly raising oil prices.

Representatives of the Government appreciate the amendments made to the state budget for 2005 as the first success of this kind in the past ten years, but a closer look at the expenditures envisaged by the amendments shows sings of increased spending, investments in expensive repairs and reconstructions of administrative, social-cultural, entertainment units. Also, budgetary financial investments are almost absent in important economic and social sectors [creation of new enterprises, construction of housing, crediting youth, building educational and sport institutions, etc].

The amendments to laws which regulate the activity of investment funds aim at bringing more transparency and new guarantees for shareholders. On the other hand the parliamentary opposition viewed them as an attempt to redistribute property and to close up societies which are not of interest to the governors, without ensuring a full protection to investors and shareholders.

The new law on leasing was described as an outstanding success, but it gathered a rich harvest of criticism and the President did not promulgate it at the very beginning. It is very hard to estimate the effects of the new regulation since they are almost absent.

Reformation of some institutions

Under agreements on political partnership, lawmakers dedicated a great deal of time to the elaboration and adoption of a set of laws on reforming some institutions and their accountability to opposition. (For further details please see the commentary on this package of legislative documents published in the July 4-29, 2005 e-journal # 55, 3rd year)

Education and science

Lawmakers modified the education law in an attempt to bring it in accordance with the process of integration in the community area (Bologna Process). Also, the deadline set for private educational institutions to comply with legal requirements [increase of statutory fund, own premises, adequate technical and didactic endowment, etc.] was extended for one year.

The list of professions and specialties taught by higher education institutions was adopted through a distinct law. Representatives of the parliamentary opposition criticized some of the provisions [but without any result], proposing to grant the right to education in medicine sector to private educational institutions as well, since this is an internationally recognized practice.

As for science, the Parliament outlined the strategic directions of activity in the area of science and innovation till 2010 and adopted a Law on Botanical Gardens, whose adoption was preceded by a scandal related to inadequate management of the Chisinau municipality Botanical Garden.

Agriculture and related sectors

Lawmakers adopted after repeated debates a Law on Organic Agricultural Products, whose initial provisions were harshly criticized by the academic and scientific environment. Later, the draft proposed by executive was modified, however large financial resources will be needed for implementation of the law and the budget did not provide for them yet.

Transmission and use of land fields and real estate

The Parliament adopted several legislative documents on statute of state-controlled land fields and real estate:

  1. Transmission of a building in the town of Vatra to the Justice Ministry for urgent sale, in an attempt to recover the losses of depositors of the Intercapital concern (Law # 197/XVI).
  2. Inclusion of a block and adjacent plot located in the territory of the governmental pension in the village of Holercani, the Dubasari district, in the privatization program (Law # 198-XVI).
  3. Withdrawal of 15 hectares of higher quality land from the agricultural circuit and the further sale of 12 hectares and building of some objectives which will be part of the Wine City enterprise on about 3 hectares (Law # 184-XVI).
  4. Exemption of incomes raised by individuals from sale of agricultural fields from taxes with the purpose to transmit them to the railway company of Moldova, in order to restore the Revaca-Cainari segment (Law # 73-XVI), and others.

Whenever those initiatives were on the Government's agenda, they triggered a storm of criticism from the parliamentary opposition, who accused the authorities of inefficient management of public resources and attempts to surreptitiously sell the state patrimony.

Finally, one may conclude that the key component of the activity of legislature - lawmaking - had to suffer; great many of the laws examined were mainly political, organisational and formal documents. The conclusion is also based on the fact that out of a total of 100 adopted laws:

Decisions on settlement of political and organizational problems related to activity of the governmental branches represented more than half of the total number of adopted documents.

Supposedly, the autumn-winter session will be more productive, the following laws will be high on legislators' agenda:

Also, lawmakers did not start yet the examination of the new Law on the Status of Chisinau Municipality, new Law on the Status of Public Officials and evaluation of their performances, Law on Central Public Administration, new Law on Cults and Law on Political Parties, etc. The public debate (promised by the President) on draft Education Code must start soon (only the draft law on higher education was published by press). The way those document would be developed and put forward for public debates would enable us to judge on the governors' openness and commitment to reform.


Real estate market in a deadlock
Iurie Gotisan

Since 2001 the prices on real estate surged 3.5 times. For instance one bedroom apartment was worth an average $5,500 USD back in 2001, while now it goes for no less than 17,000 USD. Even if the real estate market has registered stagnation after a boom in the recent years, experts reckon a 15-20% price hike on real estate is inevitable by the end of the year.

It's hard to trace the trends on real estate market in Moldova. In Chisinau, for instance, prices on different types of estate in different districts should be available in the statistics released by the notaries. Albeit they levy huge fees on real estate transactions, notaries declare meager fees and no law has so far made them release clear data on the real estate price. The only reliable indicator in use is the "call" price, that is, the price the real estate agency or a seller asks for.

Sluggish period was registered on real estate transactions, and this largely due to skyrocketed prices. Albeit the current supply meets the demand by over 50%, the prices remain high. On top of that, the demand is low due to lack of funding. The prices shot up enormously, while great many of those who would opt for mortgage, cannot apply for it in banks as their income does not qualify. Moreover, there are some psychological factors that shape the market, namely speculators.

At the same time the last three years saw a boom in construction, which partly explains the surged demand for apartments. On the other hand, the high interest rates set by banks for mortgage stymie even further the stagnating market. What slows down the market is the high prices called by the sellers, encouraged by real-estate agencies earning heavy money on those transactions, prices that are far beyond what the potential buyers could afford.

A solution to revive the market is to boost construction of new apartment blocs. However, the move raises some problems as well, as the land prices are surging. Therefore, it is no longer profitable to build houses, as the costs exceed by far the prices dictated by the markets. On the other hand, the high prices on land make the construction of apartment blocks profitable.

Still, the real estate boom hit hard the poor and young families that cannot afford a house. Mortgage might be a solution, promoted by efficient housing policies, however this market is not yet fully-fledged in Moldova. For now, the only problem with the mortgages is the limited offer of new apartments, which are rather expensive.

On top of that, people are wary when in comes to blocks under construction. There are offers for apartments worth 25,000 Euro. You first sign a pre-contract for that amount, mind you the price is only a tentative one, when the construction is over you'll have to take more money out of your pockets than initially planned.

Local banks may want to be more active in providing mortgage credits at an interest rate no higher than 10% for at least 25 years. As the banks have huge amounts in their coffers, such a move might boost construction of new housing. Yet another solution is for the state to subsidize a part of the interest rate, quite luring for those wishing to buy housing. Such schemes are very popular in Europe. Furthermore, European Bank for Reconstruction and Development opened quiet cheap credit lines for several local commercial banks, funds that they might want to use for financing construction of new housing.


The following contributed to this issue:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]