ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20050926/index.shtml


e-journal, III year, no. 58, September 13-26, 2005

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Conflict

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Government

1.1. Appointments

During its September 14 session Government appointed MP Mihail Camerzan as Republic of Moldova Ambassador to Portugal. The diplomatic mission was opened in early 2005 and the position so far was vacant.

Currently, Mihail Camerzan is a deputy in Parliament on the Communist Party list. Over 2001-2005 he hold the position of Deputy Speaker. Coming to Parliament on the Braghis Alliance list he left the faction once appointed as Deputy Speaker. Over 1998-2001 Camerzan was the Secretary of the Parliament Permanent Bureau being in the "For a Democratic and Prosperous Moldova" faction headed by Dumitru Diacov.

Noteworthy, 9 Communist deputies resigned since March after being promoted to various positions in the central government. Recently Government proposed appointing another former Communist deputy Ion Filimon as Republic of Moldova Ambassador to Belarus. Ion Filimon is the 87 on the Communist candidate list.

In 2001 Parliament passed the Law on Diplomatic Service providing certain conditions for candidates to diplomatic service, such as: previous experience in diplomatic service, serving in the relevant ministry or other institutions specialized in international affairs, fluency in at least one foreign language.

1.2. Sessions. Resolutions

Computers for schools

During a working session convened by Prime-Minister with the participation of education officials it was found that the enforcement of the "Salt" (Leap) plan is delayed. Only 85% of the schools have computers, it is planned that by the end of September each Moldovan school would have at least one computer. There are no figures on the average number of computers in each school, or their access to Internet.

"Salt" program was initiated back in 2004 by the President in view of providing each Moldovan school with computers having access to internet. According to the Ministry of Education, there are no computers in over 250 schools, while only 54% of the schools have computer classrooms (on average 50 children per computer), the great majority of which being opened back in 1997-1998.

In late 2004 Government approved a Resolution (No 1424-22.12.2004) on enforcing "Salt" program obliging Ministry of Transportation and Communications to provide free access to internet to schools by September 1, 2005. The same resolution obliged the Ministry of Education and Ministry of Finance to find the resources necessary for purchasing 6,000 computers for schools.

Government also entrusted local councils to purchase the equipment for networks rayon of the and municipal education departments, as well as allot funds for intern connection and provide Internet services to schools. Experts say it was because of this delegation of responsibilities that the plan's enforcement was delayed as the local budgets were already approved.

Currently there are over 1,600 education institutions in the Republic of Moldova (schools, gymnasiums, lyceums and colleges). A school in rural area would need at least 10-12 computers, with an average 8,000 MDL per computer (636 USD). Albeit the "Salt" program is about to be complete in several months, there are no data on the number of computers purchased from state funds, their price, nor whether the copyright law was observed.

1.3. Resolutions

Exemptions from taxes in agriculture

On its September 14 session Government approved a string of amendments canceling some agricultural taxes. As of 2006, agricultural farms would only pay land tax (worth 1.5 MDL (0.12 USD) for hectare) and social security tax. Legal entities and farms would be exempted from a number of taxes, namely: income tax; real estate tax; territory planning tax, water and road fund. It is estimated that the amendments would deprive local budgets of 35 million MDL(2.8 billion USD) yearly.

Under a special law approved by the Parliament, over 2004-2005 a pilot project was implemented in Taraclia whereby a single agricultural tax was approved, however its results haven't been made public yet. There are evidences that the project failed, while via its new initiative the Government attempts to diminish the negative effects of VAT, which is to be applied commencing 2006.

Noteworthy, this issue might trigger some controversial debates in Parliament, as many deputies claimed the move would give rise to embezzlement, but also protests from local government deprived from its sources of revenues.

Approval of 2006 budget

Government approved draft state budget and draft social security budget for the next year, draft law on obligatory medication insurance for 2006, as well as mid-term expenses forecast (2006-2008).

The Government prepared a few surprises for tax-payers, namely:

  1. Raised VAT: - A 20% VAT shall be applied for fito-technical, zoo-technical and horticular goods; cancelled VAT exemptions on import of pesticides and machinery; 8% VAT shall be applied on import and delivery of medicines;
  2. Introduced new taxes: private tax (1% on privatizing units in state property); 0.8% tax to commercial banks when paying taxes to the state.
  3. Preserved the highest 20% quota on income tax paid by natural entities on amounts exceeding 21,000 MDL (167 USD) yearly/ 1,750 MDL (139 USD) monthly.
  4. Raising to 3% the social security tax paid by the employee.
  5. Raising by 151 MDL (12 USD) the obligatory medical insurance, worth 816 MDL (65 USD).

The draft budget also allots 170 million MDL (13.52 million USD) for the "Moldovan Village" National Program. According to initial estimates the program was to cost over 45 billion MDL (39.8 million USD) in 2005-2015, out of which 7 billion MDL (356.7 million USD) were to be spent over 2005-2006. Annually around 160 million MDL (12.7 million USD) are needed for renovating water supply and sewage networks, for extending gas networks - 200 million MDL (15.9 billion USD), and for environment - about 500 million MDL (39.8 million USD).

When the draft budget was presented, Prime-Minister insisted on "consulting public opinion". All our attempts to send our propositions to Government and Ministry of Finance from their official web page www.moldova.md (where the document was posted for public debates) failed. On top of that, trade unions and employers' union submitted a package of recommendations, while Government again failed to take many of them into consideration (especially as regards salary raise, investments, and support of agriculture, etc).


Presidency


Economic Policies

1. Financial-bank system

2. Foreign trade

3. Moldova in the world


Transdnistrian Conflict

On 22 September the electoral campaign for the elections to the Supreme Soviet (the de facto local legislative body) determined for 11 December 2005 started in the break away region of Transnistria. The 43 deputies will be elected for five years according to the principles of a majoritarian electoral system within single mandate electoral constituencies, half of which will be organised in Tiraspol and Tighina (Bender) towns. 418,468 voters are expected to participate in the poll; the number of voters has been calculated according to the results of the population census conducted by the Transnistrian authorities in October 2004, and which have showed that at present the region is populated by approximately 555,000 inhabitants (see http://www.olvia.idknet.com/ol37-09-05.htm for more results). For the holding of elections, 1.2 million Transnistrian rubles or around 150,000 USD have been allocated from the local budget.

The elections will take place on the basis of the Transnistrian "constitution" and electoral laws - the latter have been recently reviewed by a panel of the Russian State Duma, which found them in full compliance with existing international standards in the field. In the near future, the Central Electoral Commission of Transnistria will send letters of invitation to several states and international organisations to observe the elections, including to the central electoral bodies of the CIS states and the states of the so-called "CIS-2", the organisation of non-recognised states from the CIS.

Both the Moldovan authorities and the OSCE said they will not recognise the results of the 11 December elections.

The organisation of free and fair elections in Transnistria was one of the key subjects discussed by President Vladimir Voronin during his meeting with his Ukrainian counterpart Victor Yushcenko on 21 September in Kiev. As a result of the meeting, the two Presidents signed a joint letter to the OSCE in which they have called upon the OSCE to take the necessary steps to set up an International Electoral Commission to organise the elections to the Transnistrian legislative in compliance with the OSCE standards. During a press conference organised on 22 September in Chisinau, the Head of the OSCE Mission to Moldova, William Hill, said that a first step towards meeting the two presidents' request would be to conduct an objective assessment of the situation in the region, and that the OSCE is already looking into this. According to a technical document drafted at the Mission, the OSCE would need around eight months to organise democratic elections in Transnistria. The OSCE however will start dealing with this only after a political decision on the matter is reached.

During the same press conference, Hill outlined the key points on the agenda of the meeting of the participants in the Transnistrian negotiations process that is to take place on 26-27 September in Odessa. Thus, in Odessa, representatives of the Republic of Moldova, Transnistria and the mediators on behalf of the OSCE, the Russian Federation and Ukraine will discuss about the resumption of the negotiations process, the holding of democratic elections in Transnistria, problems related to the democratisation of the region, the monitoring of enterprises from the Transnistrian industrial-military complex and of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border. Also, the meeting will examine the proposal to extend the negotiations format by inviting the EU and US to join it as observers. According to Hill, the agenda of the meeting was accepted both by Chisinau and Tiraspol, but "judging from consultations, the parties view each of these problems in their own way".

We would like to remind our readers that the negotiations process has been stopped since Moldova suspended its participation in it in August 2004 in sigh of protest against the policy of the Transnistrian authorities on the Moldovan Latin script schools from the region. The Moldovan side has also stopped for several months now its participation in the work of the Joint Control Commission, the body created through the 1992 ceasefire agreement to monitor the situation in the security zone, in response to the illegal instalment of Transnistrian customs and check points in the security zone.

In a different development, the EU decided to deploy by 1 December at the latest a border mission on the Moldovan-Ukrainian border, which will consist of 50 representatives of border and customs services. The mission will be led by the EU Special Representative for Moldova, Adriaan Jacobovits de Szeged, and will last for two years. At the beginning of October, Moldova and Ukraine will sign a Memorandum on the Activity of the European Commission Facilitation Mission at the Moldovan-Ukrainian border, following which the EU Council will adopt the plan of activity of the mission and its funding arrangements, the cost of the mission being evaluated at 3 million US USD.


Foreign Affairs

Enforcement of the EU-Republic of Moldova Action Plan

Moldova presented in Brussels the first quarterly report on the enforcement of the Action Plan EU-Republic of Moldova. According to Deputy Prime-Minister of Foreign Affairs, Valeriu Ostalep, European officials praised the report. It features the plan enforcement, measures undertaken by the Republic of Moldova in reforming the judiciary and electoral systems, adjusting national legislation to the European one, as well as in energy, transportation, and trade. From the part of EU the following steps might be mentioned, opening a permanent EU Mission to Chisinau scheduled for October, allocating funds for enforcement of the Action Plan in 2006. Ostalep indicated that there Moldova stands good chances to obtain a more advanced status in relations with EU and become associated member by 2007.

To make some progress as regards free circulation of citizens and simplify visa regime, European officials asked their Moldovan counterparts to perfect the laws and procedures on migration and border control. Noteworthy, the Report on the enforcement of the EU-Republic of Moldova Action Plan wasn't made public, nor were inter-ministerial and departmental programs on enforcement of individual plans.

GUAM perspectives

President Voronin declared that the future of GUAM depends on whether some concrete problems would be solved, namely transportation of oil and gas from Caspian sea to Europe. Voronin believes that only if oil and gas bypassed Russia, GUAM wouldn't morph into an apathy structure, like CIS.

Noteworthy, initially Moldova was quite reserved towards the international structure established on the post-soviet arena, joining Russia in criticizing GUUAM for serving US interests in the region. However, when relations with Russia cooled down, Moldova changed the vector of its foreign policy, fully endorsing GUUAM, especially in the hope to reap some economic benefits.

Wine export to Russia unclear

On the eve of Odessa negotiations on Transnistria, Russian media reports on restrictions to be set on the imports of alcohol from Moldova - thus reviving the talks on trade war between Russia and Moldova. Reportedly, Russian federal customs service stopped issuing excises to the importers of alcohol from Moldova, thereby blocking the imports, which might affect wineries of Moldova.

On September 16, "Moldova-Vin" State Agency, Union of Wine Exporters of Moldova and National Association of Participants to Russia Alcohol Market signed a Cooperative Agreement on promoting Moldovan alcohol on the Russian market. The agreement provides for some favourable conditions for the sale of Moldovan wines and cognac on the Russian market, provided they are of high qualify and certified accordingly.

Republic of Moldova exports up to 85% of its wine to Russia, holding a 60% share market. Noteworthy, Russian businesses are the main investors in Moldovan wine industry owning the biggest companies.

In February 2005, Russian Federation State Duma asked Russian Government to examine the possibility of limiting or stopping the import of Moldovan wine, citing among others the poor quality of the wine.

Recently Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry announced that it would be possible to resume the export of fruits and vegetables to Russia in October, after an almost six months ban. Exports would resume only after Russian experts inspect in Chisinau all goods that are to be shipped to Russia.


Studies, Analyses, Comments

New municipal elections
Igor Botan

1. Timeliness of new elections

The Central Election Commission (CEC) unanimously decided on September 23 to convoke new local elections in 10 settlements, including the Chisinau municipality, on November 27. CEC passed this decision on an as democratic as possible way, taking into account paragraphs (m) and (n) of Article 22 of the Election Code regarding "consultation of parties and public organizations" for "plenary participation in the electoral process." The CEC sitting was really public, with participation of journalists, representatives of political parties and public organizations, as well as of the OSCE Mission to Moldova.

Although the CEC decision perfectly fits the international standards, norms of Moldova's electoral legislation, rulings of the Constitutional Court regarding election of local public administration bodies, there is an impression, however, that this decision is inopportune, especially as regards the Chisinau municipality.

International standards particularly envisage the strict need of periodical organization of elections. Under Article 1 of the Election Code, the periodicity of elections is ensured within mandatory "general elections" of any kind. There are detailed norms on terms for organization of "general elections", either parliamentary, or local polls. The same detailed norms envisage the establishing of eventual early parliamentary elections, which end an old phase and begin a new phase of periodicity of elections for the new Parliament elected for a 4-year period. This is a provision of Article 63 of Constitution.

As for local elections, the periodicity of elections is ensured by the 4-year mandate of local public administration bodies, which begins on the day of "general elections", being in effect for the entire community of local councils and mayors in Moldova. The Constitutional Court has passed a number of rulings aimed to clarify the way of election of local public administration bodies and to establish the strict duration of their mandates, after adoption of Moldovan Constitution in 1994 and after the first local elections conducted on its basis in 1995. Thus, two rulings of the Constitutional Court say that the 4-year mandate of local public administration bodies established through Article 119 (1) of the Election Code cannot be shortened or prolonged. Another two decisions based on Article 112 of Constitution say that the central administration authorities cannot name the local authorities if a mayoral office becomes vacant. Even more, the July 30, 2002 notice # 2 of the Constitutional Court opposed the intention of a group of 52 lawmakers to modify the Constitution, so that to allow local councils to elect mayors indirectly, an intention which perfectly complied with the European Chart Autonomous Exercise of Local Power, an international document which has priority over internal legislation after the Moldovan Parliament ratified it in 1998.

All the documents envisaged above indicate the need to elect local councils and mayors within local "general elections". Article 139 of the Election Code stipulates the organization of new election of councils and mayors in case of such a need. As for new elections of local councils, there were no major problems the past 10 years. There were very few cases of this kind. As regards new mayoral elections, such elections take place in 10-25 settlements a year throughout a 4-year mandate. The experience of new elections of mayors was satisfactory till the office of Chisinau mayor became vacant last spring, and new followed by repeated local elections failed.

Thus, if we speak about legal side of local elections in the Chisinau municipality, we observe that it was completely respected throughout current mandate: 1) citizens directly elected a mayor of Chisinau for a 4-year period on May 23, 2003; 2) early and, respectively, repeated elections took place on July 10 and 24 after the mayor elected in 2003 had stepped down, but they remained invalid because of the low turnout. Following questions appear under these conditions - how necessary the repeated new elections are, can the non-stop organization of new elections be avoided?

The answer may be based on the fact that the vacancy of mayoral office, regardless of its cause, always has an element of hazard and therefore the problem to elect the mayor must be treated through the opportunity to organize new elections or a deputy mayor must be ad-interim mayor. In this regard, before setting the new elections for November 27, CEC should call on the Parliament in order to try to persuade lawmakers to modify Article 139 of the Election Code, so that no election validation threshold of 1/3 participation rate be in effect for new elections or at least to eliminate it in case of repeated elections; to ask the legislature to interpret Article 139 of the Election Code on basis of Article 66 (c) of Constitution in a move to clarify how many times a settlement can organize new local elections throughout a 4 years mandate.

  1. If the legislature insists on the need to maintain at all costs the 1/3 participation rate threshold for validation of results of new local elections, this way giving them more legitimacy, it would be logical to apply Article 39 of the law on local public administration, which says that "a deputy mayor becomes mayor if the mayor steps down before term," after an eventual failure of new mayoral elections because of the low turnout, till expiration of mandate and convocation of local general elections. This approach would be in perfect compliance with provisions of Constitutional and electoral legislation of Moldova, as well as with Article 3.2 of the European Chart Autonomous Exercise of Local Power, which says that self -government "shall be exercised by councils or assemblies composed of members freely elected by secret ballot on the basis of direct, equal, universal suffrage, and which may possess executive organs responsible to them. This provision shall in no way affect recourse to assemblies of citizens, referendums or any other form of direct citizen participation where it is permitted by statute."

  2. If as many as needed new mayoral elections are to be organized, the barrier related to the mandatory participation rate threshold of minimum 1/3 out of the number of eligible citizens must be eliminated, at least for repeated elections after the failed new elections. This factor obstructed the validation of the July 10 early elections and July 24 repeated elections in Chisinau.

Both approaches would allow us to get rid of "electoral fibrillations" caused by eventual failed elections, which have nothing in common with the obligation of periodical elections and interest of citizens to have a local administration to protect their legitimate interests.

2. Interests of political parties

Leaders and representatives of political parties the Liberal Party (PL), Democratic Party (PD), Christian Democratic People's Party (PPCD), Party of Communists (PC), Social Liberal Party (PSL) have favored the establishing of data of new local elections in their speeches before CEC passed this decision.

However, attitudes and expectations of political parties regarding the scheduled elections, especially in Chisinau, are different. Although the summer period halted the participation last summer, the results of the July 10 new elections and July 24 repeated elections highlighted the rating of candidates of parties in Chisinau. This rating also indicates the interests of parties for new elections:

  1. The ruling PC can be sure that the rating of its candidate will remain at the highest level the next two months till election day, being credited with real chances to become winner in the 1st round or runoff vote. This would happen in spite of major economic difficulties which follow the rise of fuels prices and commercial sanctions introduced by the Russian Federation;

  2. The parties which are members of the so-called "constructive opposition" (PPCD, PC, PSL) gave green light to establishing of election day without much enthusiasm. It is more important for them to pressure the ruling party to fulfill its obligations within "national consensus" in order to register concrete accomplishments by the May 2007 local "general elections" than to spend financial and organizational resources in order to understand one more time that their rating is lower than usually. In this regard, the solution proposed by PPCD chairman Iurie Rosca at a televised program on PRO TV channel to let the municipal council confirm the ad-interim mayor can be understood. It is true that he did not specify that such a solution is proposed only for cases registered after the failure of new elections;

  3. The active opposition represented by Our Moldova Alliance seems to be interested the most in organization of new elections in Chisinau. AMN leader Serafim Urechean said after the failure of new and repeated elections last summer that he will bid for the mayor post. He has recently stated that "the idea of the PPCD leader to deprive the electorate of the right to elect mayors is a continuation of the communist anti-reform and a deviation from principles of European democracy." The interventions of Serafim Urechean against PCRM seem to be inspired. Permanent blaming of Moldova by the European Court of Human Rights continues on the western front. Russia's commercial sanctions against Moldova are on the eastern front. However, the participation of Serafim Urechean in the municipal elections in Chisinau is very risky. He must only win for eventuality to participate in the municipal elections in Chisinau. However, Urechean's resignation from the mayoral office last April with the declared goal "to promote the interests of citizens in the Parliament at national level," followed by change of this intention with only half a year later, in order to come back to the Chisinau City Hall may lay serious obstacles on his way. He will have to give financial explanations as well - why millions of lei should be wasted because of him, public money, for these maneuvers of resignation-comeback to the Chisinau City Hall? Citizens may wonder whether an eventual victory of Serafim Urechean would mean the start of a new phase of the "cold war" between him and President Voronin.

  4. Parties with low rating are interested to participate in a new political show in order to keep the attention of voters.

These interests of political parties also highlight the problem of timeliness to hold new elections in the Chisinau municipality. Also, there are other problems regarding timeliness to organize elections:

  1. under amendments to the Election Code approved last July, preparations for the November 27 elections will take place during reformation of electoral bodies and CEC, and this contravenes the good practices recommended by the Venice Commission to avoid an essential change of rules during the electoral process;

  2. the Chisinau electorate may demonstrate tiredness and reticence over new elections after being convoked four times for voting in only 9 months (parliamentary elections on March 6; early local elections on July 10; repeated local election on July 24; new local elections on November 27). An eventual electoral activism of people who did not attend the elections last summer because of vacation could be combated by passivity of persons who voted in vain.

  3. some potential strong candidates may decide not to participate in the new elections because an eventual victory may rather harm their political career. Truly, does it make any sense for a strong opposition candidate to win the municipal elections with one year and half before general elections, on the eve of winter, which seems to be very difficult from energy point of view, without any certainty to enjoy the support and understanding of the municipal council?

All these causes taken together may have a negative impact on motivation of citizens to participate in elections.

3. What should voters do?

It may be supposed that electors in the Chisinau municipality are tired of invitations to cast their votes four times in only 9 months. However, they have nothing to do but to accept this situation and to use their constitutional right and obligation of citizen to cast their ballots. The best solution to the electoral tiredness is to make the Chisinau residents read or read again the extraordinary literary works of known writers Mihail Saltikov-Scedrin and Iaroslaw Gasec - "The Story of a City" and, respectively, "Municipal Elections" in the new electoral period. Thus, the special pleasure is to persuade that "all is old and all is new", that means the present problems of the Chisinau municipality and their approach by politicians during electoral campaign are very similar to the ones faced by other cities from other meridians almost 100 years ago (and even more).


GDP is on the rise despite unfavorable circumstances
Iurie Gotisan

Last week official statistics released data on the economic growth, i.e. an 8.6% surge in the first half of the year. Giving the industrial growth, good harvest and growing exports, the economic growth for the year might equal or even exceed 2004 one.

This time again, consumption fueled the economic growth - which is not exactly a bad thing. Only in this case, the pace of credit growth, especially the consumption one, runs counter to economy's ability to promptly react to surging demand, and therefore massive imports shake the trade balance. Areas which should be boosted by credits, namely manufacturing, are very slow.

At the same time, evolution of oil price on the international markets, which hit a record high level skyrocketed the oil prices on the Moldovan market. As it is included in production costs of many consumer goods, surging oil prices pose a threat for the economic growth that consequently might cause a downturn in the economic growth. Furthermore, trade deficit that reached 600 million USD over January - July 2005, record high since 1001, might also influence the economic growth.

Flagging profit margins of the exporters - due to rising production costs, fuel price and appreciation of the national currency - coupled with dropping investments in exporting industry, might set the budget deficit to soar exceeding 30% of the GDP by the end of the year, i.e. go over 1 billion USD. Under those circumstances, one may well expect an outflow of foreign capital and Leu depreciation. This is only a scenario, however it should not be ruled out.

Nevertheless, statistically speaking this year might as well report high economic growth; but let's better wait until the end of the year.

As for inflation, it registered 3.7% over January - August, perfectly falling within the Government 8-10% forecast. However, one should not forget about the deflation registered over the summer, traditional for that period of the year. The prices on food have dropped thanks to the good harvest this year and great supply as Russia banned the import of fruits, vegetables and meat from Moldova.

Still, this year is different, especially because of skyrocketed oil prices. It is also expected that prices on natural gas will rise, especially after so many declarations made by the Russian officials in this respect. Accordingly, inflation is set to soar. If this happens, it would be largely due to skyrocketed prices on fuel, electricity and high production costs.

Firstly, heating price would be likely adjusted (raised) to the rising oil prices once it is supplied to the consumers. This adjustment would be definitely recorded by the statistics. Rising oil prices are also likely to set the electricity price to soar. Moldelectrica already announced that it would raise the price for transporting energy.

Oil price fluctuations on the international market is yet another cause of concern when it comes to inflation rate. And this largely due to the fact that oil price is reflected in all the prices considered when estimating inflation rate. It is known-for-a-fact that domestic prices adjust faster to the international prices, than the domestic salaries do.

Furthermore, rising production costs, fueled by growing salaries, might also shape inflation. For the National Bank seeking to ensure the price stability the situation is not exactly favorable.

Having said that, the economy would slow down, especially if there would be other unfavorable circumstances to come.


The following contributed to this issue:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]