ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20060328/index.shtml


e-journal, IV year, no. 70, 15-28 March 2006

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Conflict

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1.1. Reshuffles

The Parliament has declared two vacant mandates of lawmaker, one of the faction representing the Communist Party of Moldova (PCRM) faction, while the second of the electoral bloc Democratic Moldova (BMD). Accordingly to the order, Efim Agachi, representative of the Democratic Party of Moldova, will be validated from the list of BMD for the vacancy.

1.2. Legislative acts

Law for the modification and completion of the Law # 1569-XV from December 20, 2002 concerning the introduction and withdrawal of goods from the Republic of Moldova by individuals. The adopted law introduces a series of amendments aimed to liberalise the border crossing regime for individuals and goods that they introduce or withdraw from the country. In particular, it allows individuals to introduce unlimited currency and to withdraw up to 10,000 euros from Moldova without showing bank certifications.

Draft law for the modification of Article 5 of the Law # 633-XV from November 15, 2001 regarding the prevention and combat of money laundering and financing of terrorism. The document adopted in the first reading stipulates that data on any limited or suspect financial deals are delivered to the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption1. Also, the minimal limit of these operations carried out by individuals was reduced down to 200,000 lei (15,000 dollars).

Draft law for the completion of some legislative acts concerning the customs activity. The draft adopted in the first reading stipulates the transfer of origin certification competences from the Chamber of Commerce and Industry to the Customs Service. It empowers customs bodies to demand any necessary documents from economic agent for certification of exports, which would justify and demonstrate the origin of goods and would make an expertise of origin of commodities if needed be.

1.3. Parliamentary control. Declarations

Hearings

The special commission for monitoring of the process of restitution of deposits to depositors of the Guineia bank and Intercapital concern has held a sitting and heard reports and information of the Justice Ministry, Prosecutor-General's Office and ex-officio administrators. According to unveiled information, prosecutors have examined pretensions of former depositors of the Guinea Bank, while execution bodies organised auctions to sale of a real estate that belonged to Intercapital and taken over by state. Under the Law# 197 from July 28, 2005, the Execution Department of the Justice Ministry will emergently sell the building from the town of Vatra of the Chisinau municipality and will ensure the enforcement of execution documents of Intercapital depositors, while the Government will have to take measures needed for its implementation within two months after enforcement of this law (by October 12, 2005) should take the necessary measures needed for its implementation. According to information tabled at the sitting of the special commission, the auctions for sale of real estate have failed and, therefore, the restitution of deposits is impossible.

Questions and interpellations

The Justice Ministry has replied to an interpellation regarding the activity of pioneer organisations, mentioning the principles that served as basis for creation and activity of these public youth organisations in Moldova. At the same time, a representative of the ministry affirmed that the number of these organisations and number of their members are unknown because the legislation does not stipulate the mandatory information over such an obligation.

PPCD parliamentarian Gheorghe Susarenco has asked the Prosecutor-General's Office to study the possibility to file penal cases against heads of the Centru and Buiucani district courts of the Chisinau municipality. The Superior Council of Magistracy said that these courts violate the principle of aleatory distribution (under Art. 344 of the Code of Penal Procedure: in the mode established at the beginning of the year, in alphabetic order) of penal cases, with chairmen of courts making decisions either on basis "of complexity or resonance of the case," or "of the task of judges." Deputy Susarenco considers that these actions are elements of the offence "Excess of authority or exceeded service competences." It should be noted in this context that the chairman of the Centru district court has examined the case of former defence minister Valeriu Pasat, whom he sentenced for an offence stipulated by Art. 185 of the 1961 Penal Code - "Excess of authority or exceeded service competences." The examination of cases by the Buiucani court district often captures the attention of public opinion because central institutions of the state administration (Parliament, Presidency, Government) are based in its area, as well as headquarters of CCCEC, SIS, and cases filed against these institutions have a special resonance.

Susarenco also reiterated his previous interpellation in which he demanded the Municipal Council to sack the deputy mayors of Chisinau because they illegally run these posts. Lawmaker Dumitru Braghis has asked the Government to report on indexation of social insurance pensions, which will be indexed starting April 1, 2006. According to the lawmaker, the uniform indexation of pensions is unfair because persons who earn small pensions will receive a minor indexation, while those who earn high pensions will receive high rises comparable to the size of social pensions of first level2. The need to reform the pension system is being discussed for quite a long time and the Government has earlier planned to take some measures for differentiated rises and indexation, but no final result was obtained so far."

Declarations

The AMN faction launched a declaration on March 23 regarding the failure to respect the commitments towards the Council of Europe, saying that the Republic of Moldova "does not comply with commitments assumed while joining the Council of Europe" and the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) monitors the functioning of democratic institutions in Moldova for such a long time from this reason. AMN accused the ruling party of "not fulfilling its commitments on reformation of political system, public sector, local administration and autonomy, audiovisual, justice and prosecutor's office." It accused the parliamentary majority of delaying the implementation of the schedule for adjustment of legislation to the Resolutions and Recommendations of PACE, violation of the moratorium recommended by PACE on sensitive problems such as history and language, "mimicking the implementation of democratic reforms." The declaration calls for organisation of a special sitting of the Parliament to discuss the progress of reforms and respect for commitments toward CoE.

In parallel with the AMN declaration, a statement of the Communist Party faction was read, and it envisaged the cited statements and replied to accusations taken by AMN in a previous declaration regarding the situation of agriculture. It said that PCRM "aims first of all to ensure the welfare of population" and to promote the legislative reforms aimed to remedy the situation in agriculture. PCRM mentioned the annual rise of state subsidies for agriculture, creation of a network of technological machine stations, agricultural land consolidation, etc.


Government

2.1. Reshuffles

The Government has appointed Ion Mihailuta as chief state adviser for local public administration. Mihailuta had earlier worked in subdivisions of the Government's Apparatus (State Chancellery).

2.2. Decisions

2.3. Sittings. Decisions. Declarations

Report on implementation of EGPRSP

The Government unveiled the annual report on implementation of the Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (EGPRSP) at a national forum on March 23. According to estimates, the poverty rates have declined by 14.5 percentage points in 2002-2004 and 26.5 percent of Moldova's population was poor in 2004 (compared with 40 percent in 2002). The social-economic evolution is characterised through progress, while the rise of GDP in 2005 (7.1 percent) exceeded the estimates from EGPRSP (5 percent). These collections of budgetary resources, fiscal administration have progressed, the healthcare factors have improved (maternal death rate, infantile death and morality rate of children under 5 have declined).

However, the economic growth is due to the rise of consumption fuelled mostly by imports and financed by remittances. According to the report, "the high flow of remittances (39 percent of GDP), growth of import (77.5 percent of GDP), trade deficit (39 percent of GDP) and current account deficit (7.3 percent of GDP) are elements of the rise of dependence of economic growth and economic situation in general on foreign factors. Under these conditions and due to the insufficient restructuring of economy and low investments, external vulnerability of the country is growing, while the perspective of a sustained economic growth and poverty reduction may become uncertain, if no immediate actions are take to remedy the situation."

The category of problems also includes:

Support to agricultural producers

Prime Minister Vasile Tarlevhas told the General Assembly of the republican union of associations of agricultural producers Uniagroprotect that the authorities are expected in 2006 and in perspective to revise all national and structural programmes on agri-food sector; to promote model projects on development of capacities of ecological agri-food production; utility of two district laboratories for testing of animal food products; to open local offices to provide livestock services and technological stations of machines; to subsidise indirectly by allocating some credits for special purposes for development of some key branches of the country's economy, etc.

The prime minister assured that the proce of Diesel oil acquired by farmers will not grow by July 2006, and the moratorium was agreed ar a sitting with the participation of biggest importers of oil products on market. The executive hopes that oil products could be imported for lower prices after the opening of the Giurgiulesti oil terminal.

Annulment of entrepreneur's patent

The Government will propose the gradual withdrawal of retail trade, passenger transportation by cars, taxi and cargo carriage practiced on basis of entrepreneur's patent. These amendments to legislation will be enforced by late 2008. The executive motivates its intentions through the need "to legalise the commercial activity and to protect the rights of consumers," by starting from the fact that the volume of retail sale on basis of entrepreneur's patent is valued at over 8 billion lei (more than 600 million dollars). The Ministry of Economy and Trade proposes to admit the free registration of holders of patent as individual enterprises or other legal form of activity. We note that the law on entrepreneur's patent was adopted in 1998 and it allows now about 50 types of activities with payment of some fix monthly or annual taxes, which include: income tax, taxes for natural resources; tax for location of commercial facilities, tax for territorial arrangement, tax for the right to provide passenger carriage services, as well as taxes to the state social insurance budget. Other fees, taxes and duties are paid by patent holder after general principles.

Declaration on property in Transnistria

The Moldovan Government has adopted a declaration saying that "the entire patrimony of residents of the Transnistrian region, production potential of economic agents based in the region, are not and cannot be an object of pretension of Moldova's official authorities." The executive declared that it "guarantees the right to property of individuals and businesses from the Trasnsnistrian region registered with relevant bodies of Moldova, rules for conduct of foreign trade operations, as well as rules for registration of economic agents in the Transnistrian region approved through the Government decision # 815 from August 2, 2005, # 1001 from September 19, 2001 and # 299 from March 22, 2006, will action until elaboration of a mechanism to regulate these relations within the definitive political settlement of the Transnistrian conflict."

The declaration was adopted at a large sitting of the Government dedicated on developments in the eastern region of the country, with the participation of Moldova's President.


3. Presidency

3.1. Decrees

The Moldovan President has awarded the Civil Merit medal to Iurie Bucinschi, adviser for social development issues for the Moldovan Prime Minister.

The chief of state has signed two decrees on appointment of two ambassadors through plurality of offices:

3.2. Meetings. Sittings. Declarations

Sitting on relations with the Russian Federation

Vladimir Voronin has convoked a sitting with decision makers of the Parliament, Government, Foreign and European Integration Ministry and Presidency and discussed ways to settle the Moldovan-Russian relations. Taking part in the meeting was also Moldova's Ambassador in Moscow Vasile Surza, who has said meanwhile that the sitting discussed the development of situation in the Transnistrian region, misunderstandings that appeared in this context between Moldova and the Russian Federation and preparations for a visit of Moldova's President to Moscow.

Meeting with the U.S. ambassador

Vladimir Voronin has highly appreciated the contribution of the United States to internationalisation of the Transnistrian conflict, rise of interest of European and international structures for the conflict resolution, at a meeting with Mrs. Heather Hodges, U.S. Ambassador to Moldova. Mrs. Hodges said that developments registered in Moldova last year have been increasingly gaining space in agenda of the U.S., which is supporting the latest actions of the Chisinau authorities aimed at a final political settlement of the Transnistrian conflict, combat of corruption and fulfilment of high standards of democratic, economic and social development.

Collaboration with Estonia

At a Moldovan-Estonian economic forum that Chisinau hosted during a visit of the Estonian president, Vladimir Voronin has called for a plenary development of the bilateral commercial-economic relations, intensification of activity of Moldovan economic agents on the Estonian market. Arnold Ruutel said that Estonia supports the reformation process in the Republic of Moldova and its bids for European integration, while Estonian businessmen and investors are open for cooperation with Moldovan partners.

Meeting with Russian businessmen

The Moldovan President has received the chairman of the Russian holding Vinny Mir and the chairman of the Union of Participants in the Spirits Market of the Russian Federation. The presidential press service said that the meeting examined problems regarding simplification of the procedure of certification of alcohol production from Moldova and its preparation for exportation to the Russian Federation. The sides noted that the export of Moldovan wines and cognacs did not suffer in the first two months of this year despite some difficulties.

Participation in conference of the United Left Group of the European Parliament

Vladimir Voronin has attended the conference themed "The European Union and New Neighbours" that Chisinau hosted at the initiative of the United Left Group of the European Parliament. The chief of state told the forum that the pro-European integration policy of Moldova is not characterised to leftwing forces in the former Soviet area, but there are some moments that determined the Moldovan Communists to make an aware choice - the path to Europe. The main causes are the lack of viable alternatives, as only "the development of the corrupt capitalism, with a nominal democracy, aggressive xenophobe nationalism" and maintenance of country's division, persistence of the Transnistrian conflict and tries to settle this conflict by imposing a military or other presence to Moldova," are proposed instead of the European integration.

Improvement of sick leave granting mechanism

A sitting hosted by Presidency has discussed the granting of sick leaves and payment of indemnities for temporary incapacity of work. According to unveiled date, the budgetary expenses for his sector rose by more than 230 million lei in 2005 and by 40 percent compared with 2004. It was mentioned that the situation is due to imperfection of legislation in the field and fact that these regulations do not encourage employers and employees to reduce the sick-related costs. Vladimir Voronin has asked the Ministry of Health and Social Protection to establish a strict control on the process of granting of sick leaves, while decision makers of the Government and Parliament we told to draft amendments to legislation in the area.

Concerns over privatisation and management of public patrimony

The Moldovan president has chaired a sitting on privatisation and management of the state patrimony, analysing the situation in the area, perspective to privatise the objects included in the state privatisation programme for 1997-1998, which was extended until late April 20063. Speaking about privatisation programme for the next stage, Voronin highlighted the need to diversify methods and principles of sale of patrimony, creation of conditions for an efficient use of public economic assets.

Agricultural cooperatives - optimum forms of organisation of activity in agriculture

The Moldovan President has reiterated the state's interest for support to agricultural producers at a meeting with heads of Moldovan agricultural cooperatives organised by the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry, noting that production cooperatives are an optimum form of organisation of activity in agriculture. Cooperatives will be developed on a new basis, in line with principles of the market economy and economic realities, but they shall contribute to consolidation of agricultural land, which allows the implementation of modern technologies and growing of highly productive sorts.

Declaration on participation in the Millennium Challenge Account

According to the declaration, the Moldovan authorities have asked that the potential resources that the country will benefit within this programme be directed to prevention and combat of corruption, a phenomenon that undermines the sustained development and democratic values, discourages the process of attraction of foreign investments, increases costs of transactions, distorts the mechanisms of market economy, etc. A working group made up by representatives of public authorities, business environment, civil society has drafted an action plan including both concrete measures aimed to enhance the institutional capacity of public bodies participating in prevention and combat of corruption, and a wide set of actions requiring the active participation of civil society, business environment, journalists in this process, a plan that the American side has described as very ambitious and its successful implementation is a joint notorious responsibility of bodies of the power and entire community. The chief of state calls on the entire society, representatives of public administration bodies, opposition, and business environment to participate actively in fulfilment of anti-corruption commitments assumed within the Millennium Challenge Account.


1 Art.5 (3) of the Law # 633 from November 15, 2001 concerning prevention and combat of money laundering and financing of terrorism stipulates that CCCEC is not unconditionally told the operations undertaken by non-residents in financial institutions from the Republic of Moldova or in branches and offices of foreign banks authorised in the Republic of Moldova.

2 As for example, the law on state social insurance pensions, the pension of lawmakers and Government members must be calculated in the amount of 75 percent of the sum of all monthly payments established in the new law on salary system for budgetary sector and it would exceed 5,000 lei. The indexation of 15.7 percent of this amount will exceed 750 lei, while the average pensions for retirement does not exceed 500 lei (the minimal indexed pension for retirement will be only 336 lei starting April 1, 2006).

3 State property worth 65 million lei was sold in 2005, though 127 million lei was foreseen in the budget. The budget raised only 61 million lei from privatisation in 2004. Only 28 million lei is expected to be raised to the budget in 2006, though the privatisation programme for the entire year includes enterprises such as S.A. Tutun - CTC (nominal of shares (n.s.) worth 101,539,640 lei), S.A.Franzeluta (n.s. - 19,655,120 lei), S.A. Viorica-Cosmetic (n.s. - 17,013,620 lei), S.A.RED Nord (n.s. - 90,794,620 lei), etc.


Economic Policies

1. Prices and inflation

2. Labour market

3. Real sector

4. Financial-banking sector

5. Business climate


Transdnistrian Conflict

The US, OSCE, EU support Moldovan-Ukrainian border regime

The Republic of Moldova and Ukraine have continued to apply the unified customs regime instituted on 3 March at the Moldovan-Ukrainian border, including the Transnistrian segment, according to which only goods accompanied by Moldovan official customs documents are allowed through the border. The US, OSCE and EU have supported the implementation of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border and have deplored the attempts of the Transnistrian authorities to simulate an economic blockade by obstructing the region's foreign trade activities. In particular the new customs regime has been supported by a series of UE Member States (Great Britain, Portugal, Latvia etc.), as well as by the most important EU institutions, which have issued a series of statements of support. Earlier, Javier Solana, EU Common Foreign and Security Policy High Representative, qualified the measures taken by Ukraine as "very important for the establishment of an orderly regime at the Ukrainian-Moldovan border, which for the EU is very important".

The Russian Federation asks for the suspension of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border regime

The Transnistrian and Russian authorities have continued to call the actions of Moldova and Ukraine "economic blockade". The range of statements made by Russian Foreign Ministry and State Duma condemning Moldovan-Ukrainian customs measures has been continued by the Russian Ambassador to Moldova, Nicolai Reabov, who held a press conference on 20 March in Chisinau. Reabov qualified the Moldovan-Ukrainian regime as "political action", aimed at changing the political power in Tiraspol with one that would be more "receptive". According to Reabov, to accomplish this, Chisinau first wants to establish the control over the entire foreign economic activity of Transnistria, undermine its budget and induce a social crisis. "The increase in the tension around Transnistria, caused by Ukraine's joining Moldova's attempts to include the region in its economic space outside of the negotiations format raises serious concerns in Russia", said Reabov. He has warned of the destructive political and economic consequences and the possible destabilisation of the situation both in Transnistria and beyond and has called for suspending the recently implemented regime and organise talks between the parties.

These and other statements by Ambassador Reabov have triggered a tough reaction on behalf both of Moldovan officialdom and in particular the public opinion. The Moldovan Ministry of Foreign Affairs called "unacceptable" the behaviour of the Russian Ambassador and sent a message to the Russian Foreign Ministry stating that Reabov's statements have "an overtly biased character and do not fit into the diplomatic dialogue between two sovereign states". The Moldovan Ambassador in Moscow, Vasile Sturza, was convoked to Chisinau for consultations.

Asked to comment the statements of the Russian Ambassador, Ukraine's Ambassador, Piotr Cialii, told a press conference in Chisinau that Reabov's proposal to include the issues related to the registration of Transnistrian economic agents in Chisinau on the agenda of negotiations in the "5+2" format is unfounded because the problems related to the order at the border concern the domestic laws of a given country, but also the responsibility of each state. Within the same press conference, Cialii refuted the roomers whereby after the parliamentary elections Ukraine will revise its decision on the customs regime at its border with Moldova. "The guarantor of our position, as well as the guarantor of Ukraine's Constitution is the President of the country", the Ukrainian Ambassador said.

The "humanitarian crisis" in Transnistria - propaganda action

The Transnistrian authorities have continued to self-isolate the region to create the impression of an "economic blockade" on behalf of Ukraine and Moldova and to show its negative "humanitarian" effects on the region. Thus, the Transnistrian authorities allow intermittently the entry of Ukrainian good into Transnistria, intimidate the Transnistrian businessmen registered or intending to register in Moldova, increase artificially the prices on consumption goods etc. The late payments of wages of "state" employees and of pensions, as well as other social problems that the region has encountered for some time now, are now blamed on the so-called blockade. According to newspaper Novaia Gazeta (New Newspaper), it is suspicious that even the enterprises that are registered in Moldova, such as the cement factory in Ribnita, are stationing, while the workers and the pensioners are ordered to participate in the street protests against the "blockade" in exchange of financial rewards. The speculations of the Tiraspol authorities regarding the so-called "humanitarian crisis" in the region are supported by the Russian Federation, which sent to Transnistria 23 lorries with humanitarian aid in form of medicines and food stuff. The transit of the Russian "humanitarian" caravan through the Ukrainian territory has sparked a real diplomatic quarrel between Ukraine and Russia, after Ukraine asked that the caravan drives only at night time and all inscriptions are removed from the lorries.

At the same time, on 23 March, the Moldovan Foreign Ministry published a statement in which it condemns the attempts of the Transnistrian authorities to self-isolate the region and deny the existence of a "humanitarian crisis" in the region, calling the actions of Tiraspol as "propagandistic" and aimed to mislead the local population and tension artificially the situation. "It is all the more regrettable that these pseudo arguments of Tiraspol are accepted by some influential Russian circles. The interpretations by these circles regarding the Transnistrian region of Moldova are biased and to the detriment of the population on the left side of Nistru," the Moldovan Foreign Ministry statement said.

The EU Border Assistance Mission supports Ukraine

General Ferenc Bamfi, Head of the EU Border Assistance Mission at the Moldovan-Ukrainian border, has denied the existence of a humanitarian crisis in Transnistria within the 4th coordination meeting what took place on 23 March in Chisinau. General Bamfi declared that the situation in Transnistria is peaceful and that the region has enough food supplies for all inhabitants. One can import to Transnistria food stuffs, the passenger traffic is fluent, only transports intended for transit are blocked. The companies registered in Moldova do not have the possibility to export goods because of the situation in the region, however, the employees of these enterprises continue to receive their wages, General Bamfi said. According to him, Ukraine's decision to implement the new customs regime is a correct one, and the new regime corresponds to international standards and ensures the legality at the border. Dropping this regime would be a step backwards and would be in breach of legal order.

Summing up the results of the four months of activity of the EU Border Assistance Mission, General Bamfi stated that the cases of smuggling registered at the Moldovan-Ukrainian border to date have been insignificant and that the situation is under control. Bamfi also said that in the near future the Moldovan and Ukrainian customs services will receive equipment and technical assistance to monitor the Transnistrian segment of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border.


Foreign Affairs

Republic of Moldova - Council of Europe

PACE rapporteurs for Moldova Josette Durrieu and Egidijus Vareikis had a summarising meeting with the Moldovan president on March 16, mentioning the maintenance of political stability in the Republic of Moldova, a factor that essentially increases the chances of a successful implementation of the Moldova - E.U. Action Plan. The CoE representatives highlighted the need to speed up and intensify the activities of promotion and implementation of democratic reforms, which would allow Moldova to get rid of the CoE monitoring and to hold a higher level of cooperation within CoE's structures. President Voronin has expressed gratitude to the PACE rapporteurs for their interest towards Moldova and assured them of the clear interest of authorities to meet the exigencies of the Council of Europe. The PACE rapporteurs told a conference held to summarise their monitoring visit that the drafting and implementation of a series of reforms by late July 2006 would allow Moldova to fulfil its commitments towards CoE.

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has urged the Moldovan Government to present its observations over the case of the chairman of the Victoriabank Commercial Bank Board within maximum two months. The sides will be invited to comment their statements after the Government presents its arguments and the Court will decide on admissibility of this application.

The ECHR sentenced Moldova1 in two more cases on March 21:

Representatives of the Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia have sued the Moldovan Government at ECHR for non-execution of a final judgment of the Moldovan Supreme Court of Justice which ruled that the Church Acoperamintul Maicii Domnului in Floresti is subordinated to the Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia. According to the secretary of the Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia, the Floresti public administration authorities ignore the ruling of the Supreme Court of Justice and try to pass the church concerned under subordination of the Metropolitan Church of Moldova. Representatives of the Floresti district administration say that they do not participate in this conflict, while the police interventions aim to ensure the public order and security of parishioners regardless of their religion.

Republic of Moldova - European Union

The European Parliament (EP) adopted a declaration on human rights in Moldova and, in particular in Transnistria, on March 16. The document says that the European Neighbourhood Policy recognises the European aspirations of Moldova and the E.U. has made important steps forward intensification of commitment towards the Republic of Moldova and identification of solutions to the Transnistrian conflict. The EP Resolution2:

The Foreign and European Integration Ministry released a declaration on March 20, appreciating the stance of the E.U., U.S. and OSCE concerning the implementation of the December 30 Joint Declaration of the Moldovan and Ukrainian premiers, welcoming the adopted standpoint and expressing deep gratitude for their support for Moldova's efforts to settle the Transnistrian conflict on a peaceful way. The Moldovan Foreign and European Integration Ministry highlights the role of the Border Assistance Mission in the process of monitoring of the implementation of the Joint Declaration and development of an efficient and transparent border regime. The ministry reiterates that the joint actions of Moldova and Ukraine are part of the wish of both states to use the European standards in all fields, outlining their common aspirations for entry in the European community.

The fourth meeting of coordination of the E.U. Border Assistance Mission to Moldova and Ukraine took place on March 23. The Mission head said that many attempts to smuggle cigarettes, drugs, frozen meat were disclosed in February, but these cases were insignificant and the situation is under control. It was announced that the customs services of Moldova and Ukraine will receive equipment and technical assistance for monitoring of the Trasnistrian section of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border.

Republic of Moldova - Romania

Radu de Hohenzollern-Veringen, special representative of the Romanian Government for Integration, Cooperation and Sustained Development, was on an official visit to Chisinau on March 14-17. Meetings of the envoy of the Romanian Government and a forum of businessmen that took place within the visit focussed, in particular, on bilateral commercial-economic cooperation, with Romanian businessmen expressing a special interest to collaborate with Moldovan partners, especially after the integration of the neighbouring states in the E.U. and appearance of new opportunities for development of economic relations. Prince Radu de Hohenzollern-Veringen has met with chairman and deputy chairman of the Parliament, prime minister, minister of economy and trade, defence minister while visiting Chisinau.

Vasile Blaga, Romanian minister of administration and interior, said that Moldovan citizens will be able to enter Romania with visas starting November 1, 2006. He delivered this statement at the ceremony of signing of the Protocol on Agreement of Readmission in the Republic of Moldova and Romania, with the Romanian minister saying that Romania has to introduce these measures "without any joy, on basis of commitments that it has assumed for entry in the E.U." Blaga reiterated that the Romanian authorities put efforts to offer a preferential treatment for Moldovan citizens regarding visa issuing problem, so that not to restrict the freedom of move, noting that holders of diplomatic and service passports will not need visas. Representatives of the Moldovan Foreign and European Integration Ministry said meanwhile that the visa regime for Moldovans willing to travel to Romania will not be introduced earlier than on January 1, 2007. The head of the Directorate for Consular Affairs in the Foreign and European Integration Ministry said that a draft agreement on visa regime tabled by the Romanian side is being examined and approved.

The Protocol on implementation of the Readmission Agreement between Romania and the Republic of Moldova, which the interior ministers of the two countries signed on March 23, 2006, obliges Moldova to accept the readmission of its citizens and clandestine migrants if they were identified in Romania. The procedures may have a special significance after Romania's integration in the E.U., this country becoming a destination for potential illegal migrants.

The Interior Minister of Moldova has asked his Romanian counterpart "to set up an efficient mechanism capable to prevent the awarding of Romanian citizenship on basis of fake acts." Gheorghe Papuc envisaged applications of Moldovan-born crime leaders who aim to get rid of penal responsibility in Moldova. The two ministers agreed to work out an information exchange mechanism with the purpose to establish the truth of acts of Moldovan citizens.

Romanian Foreign Minister Mihai Razvan Ungureanu said that the apparent crisis in the Transnistrian region is a consequence of a false policy of the separatist regime. Ungureanu noted that the agreement between Ukraine and Moldova regarding control on commodity transit in the Transnistrian section of the state border brings light to a very difficult issue. He reiterated Romania's dissatisfaction with the pace of the five-plus-two negotiations and noted that the E.U. shares this dissatisfaction.

Romanian President Traian Basescu said in Brussels, where he attended a meeting of the European People's Party, that the integration of the Western Balkan countries and Moldova in the Central European Free Trade Agreement (CEFTA) "is a solution that the European People's Party regards as a means to speed up the preparation of these countries for integration in the E.U."

Republic of Moldova - Russian Federation

Statements of the Russian Ambassador to Moldova

The Russian Ambassador to Moldova delivered some statements at a March 20 news conference which raised serious reactions from the Moldovan authorities and political forces. Nicolay Ryabov said among others that:

Reacting to statements of the Russian ambassador, the PPCD parliamentary faction has proposed the Parliament to draft a declaration on attitude of Russia and its representative over relations with Moldova. Representatives of AMN and PCRM consider that the executive and the Foreign Ministry shall react to Ryabov's statements. The Liberal Party has proposed to declare Ryabov as "persona non-grata" in the Republic of Moldovan and to change the Russian Federation's status in the negotiation process into "side of the conflict".

The Foreign and European Integration Ministry of Moldova has sent a letter to the Russian Foreign Ministry saying what it thinks about the statements of the Russian ambassador in Chisinau and asking its Russian counterpart if what Ryabov said is his personal vision or the stance of the Russian authorities. At the same time, Moldova's Ambassador to Moscow Vasile Sturza was invited in Chisinau for consultations, discussing the Moldovan-Russian relations, including the statements of the Russian ambassador in Chisinau.

Blocking actions of the Russian Federation

The Russian State Duma has asked the committee for CIS affairs to ask information from the Russian Government and Foreign Ministry regarding the "possibility to introduce restrictions for migrants from Moldova and west of Ukraine."

The chief state sanitary doctor of the Russian Federation has announced that Russia will take drastic measures against Moldovan and Georgian wine imports because "of some questions regarding the food security indexes." Officials in charge with wine making sector and control on spirits, as well as Moldovan wine makers say that the statements of the Russian veterinary doctor are irresponsible because Moldova respects the standards, exigencies and norms for heavy metals, pesticides and other substances contained in spirits and Moldovan wines can claim the category of ecologically clean drinks, in compliance with European standards.

According to the Russian mass media, the Russian Union of Wine Makers and Vine Growers has asked the Russian Government to launch an anti-dumping investigation against Moldovan wines, while a request in this regard was delivered to the Russian premier and minister of economic development and trade. This NGO claims that the wines made in Moldova are unfairly competing on the Russian market and Moscow should increase the customs duties for these imports. According to officials of the Moldova-Vin Agency, the anti-dumping investigation would be "welcome because it would confirm the higher quality of Moldovan wines."

Starting March 27, 2006, the Russian Federation restricted the importation of wines from Moldova and Georgia. The Moldovan authorities said that the interdiction has a political nature and noted that Moldova will not accept Russia's entry in WTO as long as the restriction on importation of some products made in Moldova is in effect. A delegation from Moldova-Vin will negotiate the unblocking of Moldovan exports with the Russian authorities.

A delegation of the Moldovan Government including the chairmen of the joint stock society Moldova-Gaz is negotiating in Moscow the price for the natural gas that will be delivered to our country starting April 1.

Moldova in the world

The chairman of the Moldovan Socialist Party, former parliamentarian Victor Morev has been declared internationally wanted, being suspected of some corruption-related actions. According to a March 27 a communication of the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption (CCCEC), Morev has brought a pecuniary damage of over 2 million lei to the state. CCCEC invokes the illicit sale of state property (land fields) by Morev through excess of authority while running the Balti City Hall. CCCEC noted that Morev has left the municipality immediately after the anti-corruption officers discovered his illegal actions and he was declared as internationally wanted.

Victor Morev was elected lawmaker in 1990-1995 (electoral bloc Socialist Party and Unitate-Yedinstvo Movement) and in 2001-2005 (electoral bloc Braghis Alliance), when he has left the parliamentary faction and became independent lawmaker, supporting however all initiatives and decisions of the parliamentary majority of PCRM.


1 The overall amount of pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages established by ECHR for cases vs Moldovan Government exceeds 360,000 euros plus more than 30,000 euros in costs and expenses (see the Summary of ECHR judgments)

2 Published by the March 21 issue of the newspaper Moldova Suverana and the EP's website


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Summary of ECHR judgments and decisions on appeals vs Moldova
Vladislav Gribincea

The summary of judgments and decisions of the European Court of Human Rights on appeals vs Moldova was worked out by Vladislav GRIBINCEA, jurist in the public organisation Lawyers for Human Rights on March 23, 2006.

I. Judgments

ECHR states the case for an appeal through judgments, as a rule, after the cause is declared admissible.

  1. December 13, 2001 - MITROPOLITAN CHURCH OF BESSARABIA and others v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 45701/99) - judgment from June 7, 2001 - violation of Article 9 of the Convention (freedom of religion) - refusal to register a religious domination.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 20,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 7,025

  2. April 20, 2004 - AMIHALACHIOAIE v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 60115/00) - judgment from April 23, 2002 - violation of Article 10 of the Convention (freedom of expression) - proportionality of a pecuniary sanction for criticising a decision of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Moldova.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 0
    costs and expenses - EUR 0

  3. May 18, 2004 - PRODAN v. MOLDOVA (Application no.49806/99) - judgment from January 7, 2003 - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a court) - non-execution of judicial decisions on payment of some amounts of money and restitution of a real estate by the Chisinau City Hall; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usage of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 11,000
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 3,000

    The Court did not state the case for the cost of an apartment which should be restored. This issue will be settled through a distinct judgment.

  4. June 15, 2004 - LUNTRE and others 14 v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 2916/02) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of various judgments on payment of some amounts of money by the Ministry of Finance; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usages of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 795
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 14,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 0

  5. June 15, 2004 - PASTELI and others 3 v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 9898/02) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-execution of judgments on payment of some amounts of money by the Ministry of Finance; violation of Art. 1 of the additional protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usages of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 386
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 3,300
    costs and expenses - EUR 0

  6. June 15, 2004 - SIRBU and others 5 v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 73562/01) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of judgments on payment of some amounts of money by the Ministry of Finance; violation of Art. 1 of the additional protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usages of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 487
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 6,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,200

  7. July 6, 2004 - BOCANCEA and others 8 v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 18872/02) - violation of Art. 6(1) the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of judgments on payment of some amounts of money by the Ministry of Finance; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usages of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 833
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 7,300

  8. July 8, 2004 - ILASCU and others 3 v. MOLDOVA and RUSSIA (Application no. 48787/99) - judgment from July 7, 2001 - violation of Art. 3 of the Convention (prohibition of torture) - treatment and conditions of detention in prisons of the Moldovan Republic of Transnistria; violation of Art. 5 of the Convention (right to liberty and security) - detention of applicants runs "counter the law"; violation of Art. 34 of the Convention (right of petition to the ECHR) by Moldova - declaration of Mr. Voronin that Mr. Ilascu is the person who is keeping his comrades detained in Tiraspol because he did not withdraw his application to the ECHR; violation of Art. 34 (right of petition to the ECHR) of the Convention by Russia - exercising pressure on Moldova through diplomatic means in order to retract Moldova's stance in the case in favour of Russia.

    non-pecuniary and pecuniary damage: Russian Federation

    Mr. Ilascu - EUR 180,000;
    other applicants - EUR 120,000 to each of the applicants;
    Art. 34 - EUR 7,000 to each applicant;

    non-pecuniary and pecuniary damage: Republic of Moldova

    Andrei Ivantoc, Tudor Popa and Alexandru Lesco - EUR 60,000 to each of the applicants;
    Art. 34 - EUR 3,000 to each applicant;

    costs and expenses:
    Russian Federation - EUR 14,000
    Moldova - EUR 7,000

  9. July 20, 2004 - CROITORU v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 18882/02) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of judgments on payment of some amounts by the Ministry of Finance; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usages of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 98.36
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 800
    costs and expenses - EUR 69.14

  10. September 14, 2004 - TIMBAL v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 22970/02) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of judgments on payment of some amounts of money by the Interior Ministry; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usages of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 370
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 800

  11. December 21, 2004 - BUSUIOC v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 61513/00) - judgment from April 27, 2004 - violation of Art. 10 of the Convention (freedom of expression) - obligation of a journalist, on a case of protection of honour and dignity, to demonstrate that his conclusions are true. Obligation to non-pecuniary damage when the journalist had acted in good faith and it has been shown that there existed reasonable factual basis for the opinion expressed and he covered matters of public interest.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 125
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 4,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,500

  12. January 18, 2005 - POPOV (1) v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 74153/01) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of a judgment on restitution of a residence confiscated by the Chisinau City Hall; violation of Art. 1 of the additional protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usages of possession.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 5,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,000

    The Court did not state the case for pecuniary claims, this issue being reserved for a repaired judgment (see judgment # 26)

  13. February 1, 2005 - ZILIBERBERG v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 61821/00) - judgment from May 4, 2004 - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) - failure of a court to summon the applicant for the hearing of his appeal regarding an administrative sanction.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 0
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,000

  14. March 1, 2005 - MERIAKRI v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 53487/99) - judgment from January 16, 2001 - the Government of the Republic of Moldova has acknowledged that the censorship of correspondence of detainees with ECHR contravenes to Art. 8 (right to respect for correspondence) of the Convention.

    non-pecuniary damage - MDL 14,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 2,000

  15. March 22, 2005 - ROSCA v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 6267/02) - judgment from November 30, 2004 - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) - annulment of a final judicial decision on payment of an amount of money by accepting a request for annulment; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to deprive of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 3,500
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 2,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 690

  16. May 24, 2005 - DUMBRAVEANU v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 20940/03) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of judgments on payment of some amounts of money by the Chisinau Municipal Council; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usage of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 3,400
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 1,360
    costs and expenses - EUR 390

  17. July 26, 2005 - SCUTARI v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 20864/03) violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of judgments on payment of some amounts by the Orhei Local Council; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usage of possession.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 1,250

  18. September 13, 2005 - OSTROVAR v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 36475/02) - judgment from March 22, 2005 - violation of Art. 3 of the Convention (prohibition of torture) - conditions of detention in the Prison # 3 based in the Chisinau municipality; violation of Art. 8 of the Convention (right to respect of private and family life) - right to have meetings with his family and censorship of correspondence; violation of Art. 13 of the Convention (right to an effective remedy) taken together with Art. 3 of the Convention - impossibility to resist effectively to the treatment he had faced; no violation of Art. 13 taken together with Art. 8 of the Convention - respect of the denial to the applicant of contact with his family and daughter.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 3,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,500

  19. October 4, 2005 - BECCIEV v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 9190/03) - judgment from March 5, 2005 - violation of Article 3 from Convention (prohibition of inhuman or degrading treatment) - condition of detention in the Temporary Detention Facility of the General Police Inspectorate of the Chisinau municipality; violation of Article 5 of the Convention (right to liberty and security) - reasons concerning detention of applicant were not relevant and sufficient.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 1,000
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 4,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,200

  20. October 4, 2005 - SARBAN v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 3456/05) - violation of Article 3 of the Convention (prohibition of torture) - absence of medical care for detained person; violation of Art. 5 of the Convention (right to liberty and security) - reasons concerning detention of applicant were not relevant and sufficient.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 4,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 3,000

  21. October 11, 2005 - SAVITCHI v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 11039/02) - judgment from February 1, 2005 - violation of Art. 10 (freedom of expression) - obligation of a journalist to demonstrate that her conclusions correspond to reality in a case of protection of honour and dignity. Deprivation of applicant of an effective opportunity to adduce evidence to support her statements.

    pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage - EUR 3,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,500

  22. October 18, 2005 - DANILIUC v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 46581/99) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of judgments on payment of some amounts of money by the Costesti local council; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usage of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 100
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 1,000

  23. November 8, 2005 - ASITO v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 40663/98) - judgments from March 16, 1999 and July 10, 2001 - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - annulment of a final judicial decision by accepting a request for annulment; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification of deprivation of property.

    The ECHR will communicate the damage, costs and expenses in a distinct judgment.

  24. November 15, 2005 - BAIBARAC v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 31530/03) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of a judgment on payment of some amounts by the Edinet local council; violation of Art. 1 of the additional protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usage of possession.

    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 1,000

  25. December 6, 2005 - POPOV (2) v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 19960/04) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) - revision of an unexecuted final judicial decision without indicating the reasons, after the non-enforcement of judgment was deplored to the ECHR and the application was communicated to the Government.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 3, 365
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 3,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 715

  26. January 17, 2006 - POPOV (1) v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 74153/01) - ARTICLE 41 - pecuniary damage (which was not awarded through the January 18, 2005 judgment)

    pecuniary damage - EUR 14,840

  27. February 14, 2006 - CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PEOPLE'S PARTY v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 28793/02) judgment from March 22, 2005 - violation of Art.11 of the Convention (freedom of association) - suspension of the CDDP between January 18 and February 8, 2002 for organising meetings with involvement of minors that the Chisinau City Hall did not authorise. The reasons invoked by national authorities were not relevant and sufficient.

    costs and expenses - EUR 4,000

  28. March 21, 2006 - LUPACESCU and others 7 v. MOLDOVA (Applications no. 3417/02, 5994/02, 28365/02, 5742/03, 8693/03, 31976/03, 13681/03 and 32759/03) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - non-enforcement of a judgment on payment of some amounts of money by state authorities; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification to prevent the usage of possession.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 2,188.64
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 9,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,500

  29. March 21, 2006 - JOSAN v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 37431/02) - violation of Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (access to a court) - annulment of a final judicial decision by accepting a request for annulment; violation of Art. 1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) - lack of justification of deprivation of property.

    pecuniary damage - EUR 16,000
    non-pecuniary damage - EUR 2,000
    costs and expenses - EUR 1,250

II. Admissible applications

Admissible applications when the application was not declared inadmissible.

  1. June 15, 2004 - MANOLE and others v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 13936/02) - the application was brought by 9 former employees of the state-owned company TeleRadio-Moldova, who complained under Article 10 (right to freedom of expression) of the Convention about the censorship imposed on Moldovan national radio and television. The June 15, 2004 judgment is partial. Public hearings took place on March 7, 2006.

  2. April 5, 2005 - IORDACHI and others 4 v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 25198/02) - the application was brought by five persons who complained that they had been victims of interception of their communications, while the domestic legislation does not contain sufficient guarantees to prevent interference with respect for private right concerning Art. 8 of the Convention (right to respect for private life). The application was declared admissible.

  3. September 13, 2005 - CORSACOV v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 18944/02) - the application was brought by a young man who complained that he had been ill-treated by police while the prosecutor's office did not investigate his appeals, so that Art. 3 of the Convention (prohibition of torture) was violated. The application was entirely admitted.

  4. October 11, 2005 - CIORAP v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 12066/02) - the application was brought by a person sentenced to detention and it envisages 17 counts. They are related to violation of Articles 3 (prohibition of torture), 6 (right to a fair hearing), 8 (respect for correspondence) and 10 (freedom of expression) of the Convention. The application was declared admissible on the date mentioned above and it envisages conditions of detention, forced nutrition, equity of procedure of evacuation of his family from apartment, censorship of correspondence and right to contact his family.

III. Inadmissible applications

Under Art. 35 of the Convention, the Court may only deal with the matter after all domestic remedies have been exhausted, accordingly to the generally recognised rules of international law, and within a period of six months from the date on which the final decision was taken. The Court shall not deal with any application submitted under Art. 34 that: a) is anonymous; or b) is substantially the same as a matter that has already been examined by the Court or has already been submitted to another procedure of international investigation or settlement and contains no relevant new information. The Court shall declare inadmissible any individual application submitted under Art. 34 which it considers incompatible with the provisions of the Convention and protocols thereto, manifestly ill-founded, or an abuse of the right of application.

  1. July 2, 2002 - GORIZDRA v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 53180/99). The applicant claimed that the introduction of the 4-percent threshold for succession to the Parliament of the Republic of Moldova at the 1998 parliamentary elections was contrary to Art. 3 of the Additional Protocol to the Convention (right to free elections). The Court found that the introduction of a threshold for succession to the Parliament does not run counter the Convention. Art. 3 of the Additional Protocol to the Convention does not require the institution of a certain electoral system.

    The applicant also claimed that the examination of his complaints by courts regarding contestation of results of the 1995 and 1997 elections was unfair and contravened to Art. 6 of the Convention (right to a fair hearing). The Court noted that Art. 6 of the Convention is not applicable for electoral contestations.

  2. September 14, 2004 - FRUNZE v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 42308/02) - the applicant claimed that Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) was violated through cassation of a request for annulment of s decision in his favour. The application was declared inadmissible because it was submitted with 6 months after admission of the request for annulment.

  3. September 14, 2004 - RAHOTCHI v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 31927/03) - the applicant claimed that Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) was violated through cassation of a request for annulment of s decision in his favour. The application was declared inadmissible because it was submitted with 6 months after admission of the request for annulment.

  4. November 30, 2004 - CHURCH ST. HRALAMPIE and others v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 19967/02) - Applicants claimed that Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) was violated through a settlement on striking out their application, maintained through a decision of the court of appeal. The application was declared inadmissible because Art. 6 is not applicable for intermediary procedures that do not have a decisive effect on "the civil right or obligation", or applicants are not hampered to submit a new appeal at national level.

  5. December 14, 2004 - LUPASCU v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 36475/02). The applicant claimed that Art. 6 (1) of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) was violated through cassation of a request for annulment of a decision in his favour. The application was declared inadmissible because the claim regarding violation of Art. 6 (1) was submitted with 6 months after admission of the request for annulment.

  6. January 4, 2005 - PENTIACOVA and others 48 v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 14462/03). The applicants who suffer from chronic renal failure claimed that they had been forced to undergo a treatment with unbearable pain and suffering because the Haemodialysis Centre of the Republican Clinic Hospital did not provide them the strictly necessary medical care, contrary to Art. 3 of the Convention (prohibition of torture), and this has put their lives a risk contrary to Art. 2 of the Convention (right to life). They also alleged that they could oppose the treatments they were subdued to contrary to Art. 13 of the Convention (right to an effective remedy). At the same time, the applicants received a poorer treatment than people suffering from chronic renal failure from the Emergency Hospital. The application was declared inadmissible. The Court examined the application under Art. 8 of the Convention (right to respect of private life) and declared it groundless because the Convention does not indicate a general obligation of governments to provide the entire range of medical assistance on public money.

  7. June 15, 2005 - SPIRITUAL DIRECTION OF MUSLIMS FROM REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 12282/02) - the applicant claimed that the denial of registration of this religious denomination with the Justice Ministry was a violation of Art. 9 of the Convention (freedom of religion). The application was declared inadmissible because the registration was denied due to the failure to submit all the documents necessary for registration of a religious denomination. The Court found out that the request to submit all the demanded documents was not arbitrary or impossible.

  8. November 26, 2005 - GRITCO v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 15840/02) - the applicant claimed that Art. 6 of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) was violated through non-execution of a judicial decision against a closing private bank. The application was declared as inadmissible because the Convention does not oblige the state to be responsible for debts of private banks.

IV. Striking out under Article 37 of the Convention

Under Art. 37 of the Convention, the Court may at any stage of the proceedings decide to strike an application out of its list of cases where circumstances lead to the conclusion that: a) the applicant does not intend to pursue his application; or b) the matter has been resolved; or c) for any other reason established by the Court, it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the application. However, the Court shall continue the examination of the application if respect for human rights defined in the Convention and the protocols thereto so requires.

  1. January 10, 2006 - DONIC v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 1805/02). The application was stricken out because the applicant did not respond to the correspondence of the Court. The Court made the conclusion that the applicant does not want his application be examined any longer and no special circumstance justifies the continued examination of this application.

  2. January 10, 2006 - HARCENCO v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 23606/02). The application was crossed off because the applicant did not respond to the correspondence of the Court. The Court made the conclusion that the applicant does not want to pursue his application any longer and no special circumstance justifies the continued examination of this application.

  3. January 10, 2006 - MARIN v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 31281/02). The application was stricken out because the applicant did not respond to the correspondence of the Court. The Court made the conclusion that the applicant does not want to pursue his application any longer and no special circumstance justifies the continued examination of this application.

V. Friendly settlements

If the Court declares the application admissible, it shall place itself at the disposal of the parties concerned with a view to securing a friendly settlement of the matter on the basis of respect for human rights. If a friendly settlement is effected, the Court shall strike the case out of its list by means of a decision which shall be confined to a brief statement of the facts and of the solution reached. It has a legal force of a judgment and it shall be transmitted to the Committee of Ministers, which shall supervise its execution.

  1. March 11, 2003 - GUTAN v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 57507/00) - the plaintiff claimed violation of Art. 6 of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) and Art.1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) through non-execution of a judgment on restitution of his house. The applicant notified the ECHR on June 14, 2002 that the decision was executed and he did not want the Court to continue the examination of his application any longer. The Court has stopped the procedure initiated by applicant on this ground.

  2. May 6, 2003 - SVETENCO and JELIMALAI v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 52528/99) - the applicants claimed violation of Art. 6 of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) and Art.1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) through non-execution of a judgment on restitution of a house. The applicant notified the ECHR on February 17, 2003 that he had accepted 52,000 lei from the Government instead of the house, that the amount was paid and that he did not want to pursue his application any longer. The Court has stopped the procedure initiated by applicant on this ground.

  3. November 30, 2004 - FURTUNA v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 2418/02) - the applicant complained of violation of Art. 6 of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) and Art.1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) through non-enforcement of two judgments on payment of some amounts of money. Both judgments were executed on May 20, 2003. The applicant sent two letters to the ECHR saying that he did not want to pursue his application any longer. The Court has stopped the procedure initiated by applicant on this ground.

  4. March 1, 2005 - PARITCHI v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 54396/00) - the applicant complained of violation of Art. 6 of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) and Art.1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) through non-execution of a judgment on restitution of his house. The applicant notified the ECHR on November 3, 2003 and May 5, 2004 that he had signed an agreement with the Government confirming that he received 205,362 lei instead of the house awarded through a judicial decision. The applicant pledged to withdraw his application from ECHR through that agreement. The Court has stopped the procedure initiated by applicant on this ground.

  5. October 25, 2005 - S.A.COMBUSTIBIL SOLID v. MOLDOVA (Application no. 5542/03) - the applicant complained of violation of Art. 6 of the Convention (right to a fair hearing) and Art.1 of the Additional Protocol (protection of property) through non-execution of a judgment on payment of an amount of money. The applicant notified the ECHR on January 26, 2004 that the unexecuted decision that he had complained to the Court was enforced meanwhile and he did not want to pursue his application any longer. The Court has stopped the procedure initiated by applicant on this ground.


The following contributed to this issue:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]