ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20061115/index.shtml


e-journal, year IV, issue 84, 1-15 November 2006

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Conflict

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1.1. Rules. Immunities

The Parliament has approved Carmelia Albu as member of the electronic media watchdog CCA for a 4-year term. Albu was proposed by the council of unions of radio and television employees.

Examining a proposal by the Superior Council of Magistracy, the Parliament has appointed three judges of the Supreme Court of Justice: Valeriu Arhip; Valentina Clevadi and Valeriu Doaga. Communist lawmakers did not vote for appointment of Gheorghe Ulianovschi, though the legal commission for rules and immunities has approved this candidacy and did not find any breaches related to the promotion procedure.

The Parliament took notice of the resignation of Communist Deputy Sergiu Stati. The 69th candidate from the list of the Communist Party of Moldova will receive the vacant mandate.

1.2. Legislative acts

1.3. Parliamentary control. Statements

Questions and interpellations

Replying to a request by lawmakers, Minister of Transportation and Road Management Miron Gagauz said that Moldova will not redirect passenger trains through Transnistria because security of travellers will not be ensured.

Replying an interpellation by Democratic Deputy Vladimir Filat, the Ministry of Economy and Commerce said that Moldovan Government has started negotiations on Moldova's debt for natural gas ceded by Gazprom to a Russian enterprise. Concrete information on results of negotiations was not presented. As of September 1, 2006, debts of Moldova Gaz accounted for 1,382,000,000 dollars, of them 1.85 billion dollars in debts of the Transnistrian region.

Gheorghe Susarenco has asked the Prosecutor's Office to verify information regarding disappearance of topographic map of territorial delimitations in the Moldovan-Ukrainian border area[1] from the state archives of Moldova in 1998. According to another interpellation, Susarenco has asked Moldovan Government to explain the participation of executive members in a November 7 meeting organised by Communist Party of Moldova (PCRM) and if the participation of ministers who are not PCRM members is a violation of Article 5 (2) of Constitution, which says that "no ideology can be instituted as an official ideology of the state."

Citing a media report[2], AMN Deputy Anatol Onceanu has asked the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption (CCCEC) to verify if actions by local authorities in the district of Orhei seeking sponsoring of propagandistic actions by governance are not a hidden extortion and if the demand for cash is not corruption.

Democratic Deputy Valentina Buliga has asked the Government to report on granting of indemnities to young teachers, noting that there are cases of groundless refusal through wrong interpretation of law.

Veaceslav Untila, deputy chairman of the Our Moldova Alliance (AMN) faction, has asked the domestic security service SIS and the SIS-controlled special communication centre to report on checking of messages from emails, legal base and grounds of eventual controls.

Statements

Parliamentarian Anatol Taranu has sought the dismissal of Corneliu Mihalache from the post of member of the electronic media watchdog CCA because he has published a political article in Puls in his quality of chief editor and this is a violation of the oath of CCA members. A communist deputy replied that Mihalache has tendered his resignation from the newspaper of communist youth on the day when he was appointed a CCA member. Employees of the newspaper assured that the signing of an article by Mihalache was a technical mistake.

Deputy Vlad Cubreacov has read a statement on stance of the Christian Democratic faction toward an initiative by communist lawmakers seeking the stop of live broadcasting of the Parliament's plenary sittings. The Christian Democratic People's Party (PPCD) regrets the resumption of talks on this old and closed topic, recalling that this decision was one of the ten conditions of the PPCD for election of Moldovan president, a condition of the parliamentary political consensus. Giving up the live broadcasting would be a step backward, a negative signal for society and European partners of Moldova, while arguments taken to support this idea are not based on fair criteria. According to the PPCD: - the problem of broadcasting must be resolved by rightly administrating the allocated budgetary funds; - the problem of too long interventions of lawmakers must find a solution in the law on modification of the Parliament's Regulation, while the promotion of populist initiatives of some lawmakers must be dammed by modifying the Constitution and awarding the right to legislative initiative to parliamentary factions only, not to separated groups of lawmakers. The PPCD appeals to the Moldovan president, who leads the PCRM, to keep the live broadcasting of plenary sittings of the Parliament in order to maintain political stability and continue the consistent implementation of democratic reforms.

Social Liberal deputies have asked the Moldovan president to explain in the Parliament the eventual pretensions of Chisinau against neighbouring states. Social Liberal Deputy Igor Clipii said that the relations of Moldova with all states in the region are unsatisfactory, including because actions and statements of President Vladimir Voronin. Elsewhere, Clipii sought the release of a report by UNDP/Moldova experts, which inserts findings and recommendations on efficient activity of the Parliament and its working groups. The speaker assured that this report will be made public when it is finalised.

PPCD Deputy Ion Varta has demanded the Parliament to revise members of a commission created by the Moldovan Academy of Sciences at the initiative of the chief of state to survey the integrated history textbooks from pre-university education system. Varta said that the commission was created on alarming principles and authors of the criticised textbooks are also members, this being an inadmissible action. The decision on inclusion of some persons who are not experts of history in this commission is also contested after a series of inaccuracies have been discovered in integrated history textbooks for schools.


Government

2.1. Rules. Reshuffles

The Government has appointed Ion Stavila as deputy minister of reintegration, Victor Cuhal as deputy director of the Standardisation and Metrology Service and Vadim Smintina as deputy director of the Sports Agency.

Deputy Premier Valerian Cristea was appointed Moldovan ambassador to the Czech Republic.

2.2. Decisions

Decision on measures of implementation of objectives on creation of 300,000 new jobs and rise of medium monthly salary on economy up to the equivalent of 300 dollars. The decision establishes annual tasks of ministries and other central administrative authorities for creation of new jobs in subordinated branches and recommends the regional administration authorities (of the Autonomous Territorial Unit Gagauzia), district councils and the Chisinau and Balti City Halls to work out and implement actions plans on creation of the indicated jobs.

Decision approving the framework regulation on organisation and functioning of centres of assistance and protection of victims of trafficking in human beings. Centres may be created at community level and they will protect and temporarily host victims of trafficking in persons, helping them join their families and community later.

Decision on adjustment of Moldovan legislation to community legislation. The governmental decision obliges the Justice Ministry to propose the creation of a centre for the adjustment of Moldovan legislation to the European Union's legislation. The new structure will have to work out a plan on gradual adjustment of national legislation to the community legislation. The Government has also approved a regulation on mechanism of adjustment of Moldovan legislation to community laws, which explains modalities of surveying and editing draft acts by respecting the terminology of European legislation.

Decision approving the action plan on facilitation of visa regime with the E.U. The plan establishes actions that will be undertaken in 2007-2008 to start negotiations on readmission and repatriation, consolidation of border and migration management.

Decision on analysis of findings of controls held by the Chamber of Auditors on management of public financial resources in the 2005 budgetary exercise. The Government indicates a better financial management and a series of essential drawbacks in management of public patrimony and finances. It establishes a series of measures to improve the situation: warning heads of central authorities; enhancing responsibility of budget executors; consolidating strategic planning capacities; optimising tax management; assessing and recording public patrimony; optimising the control on legality of actions, etc.

The Government has approved a draft law on regional development and a draft law on modification of the law on tobacco and tobacco products (stricter conditions for sale of products near pre-university institutions).

2.3. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Gradual modernisation of roads

A working sitting chaired by prime minister has focussed on modernisation of roads in Moldova, which will be a priority task of the Government in 2007. Some important sources in the field will be allocated from foreign donors and state budget. Priority will be granted to building works at the Chisinau-Leuseni road, reconstruction of the Chisinau-Comrat snd Orhei-Rezina routes, with an action plan on modernisation of motorways in Moldova being worked in parallel. Vasile Tarlev has told the Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure to work out an action plan on gradual modernisation of roads coordinated with leadership of all districts and to open contests by end of 2006 to select entrepreneurs.

Construction of strategic gas pipe

The prime minister has convoked a sitting on construction of the main gas pipe Tocuz-Cainari-Mereni, which will be built about 16.5 kilometres at the first stage and assembling of a gas distribution station by the end of 2006. Vasile Tarlev revealed the importance of the project that ensures the energy security of Moldova.

Combating illicit passenger transportation

Decision-making officials in the field of transportation, licensing and interior affairs have reported on execution of the programme combating the illicit passenger carriage at a sitting convoked by Premier Vasile Tarlev. Although the situation has improved (this fact is confirmed by higher incomes, fewer administrative contraventions and traffic accidents with grave consequences), there are big reserves in the process of combat of this phenomenon. The programme combating the illicit passenger carriage was approved through the Governmental Decision # 1054 from 05.08.2002 and contains a series of actions that should be taken in 2002, with a further permanent monitoring.

Strategy on employment policies

The Ministry of Economy and Commerce has tabled a draft national strategy on employment policies for 2007-2020. The document aims to be a basis for elaboration and implementation of annual action plans on employment, branch and territorial employment programmes for various categories of population. The implementation of this strategy must contribute to elimination of the deficit of jobs, growth of employment rate in economy, better motivation of employers to increase the number of jobs and to raise salaries.

Opening of university and lyceum of Academy of Sciences

The Government has approved a draft law on opening of the University of the Moldovan Academy of Sciences, which will annually admit about 1,000 students selected at a contest. At the same time, the executive has decided to create the Lyceum of the Moldovan Academy of Sciences (ASM), an ASM-controlled institution of exact and humanist sciences for talented children from Moldova. The new institution will be located in the building of a former research institute of ASM, which will include classrooms, libraries, sport and festivity halls, a canteen and hostel after reconstruction. The high school will admit about 200 students, by 15 persons in every class.

Establishing price of education

The cabinet of ministers has approved the nomenclature of works and services executed and granted for pay by educational institutions subordinated to the Ministry of Education and Youth (in vocational schools, colleges and institutions of higher learning).

Export interdictions introduced and annulled

By sending a letter to the Customs Service and wineries, director-general of the Agro-Industrial Agency MoldovaVin has restricted the exports in bulk of wines made from 2006 crop. He invoked the need of improving the image of Moldovan wines on world market, reducing possibilities of counterfeiting wines. Representatives of companies and experts in the field have criticised this decision and described it as inopportune and abusive.

The MoldovaVin administration has withdrawn the interdictions a week later, saying that they could gravely affect vine growing and winemaking companies.


3. Presidency

3.1. Decrees

Moldovan president has signed decrees awarding medals to state dignitaries:

The chief of state has revoked Valerian Cristea from the post of deputy prime minister, while Minister of Local Public Administration Vitalie Vrabie was appointed deputy premier in charge with coordinating relations between central and local public administrations, resolution of problems linked to social-economic development of territories.

3.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Development of capital

President Vladimir Voronin has chaired a sitting on social-economic development of the Chisinau municipality in 2007, with the participation of Prime Minister Vasile Tarlev, ministers and leadership of the Chisinau City Hall. According to the chief of state, the social-economic condition of the city has improved in 2006 and some measures have been taken to improve the living standards of Chisinau residents. The further development of the municipality must refer to complete gasification, elaboration of a project on reconstruction of the household water station, continuation of works for arrangement and lighting of streets, capital renovation of social institutions. The chief of state has called for an accelerated elaboration of projects on rearrangement of the Valea Morilor Park and reconstruction of the Summer Theatre in that area. Speaking about urban transportation, Vladimir Voronin called for more trolleys.

Functioning of pharmacies

The chief of state has told a sitting on functioning of pharmaceutical system in Moldova that the Drug Agency has demonstrated its utility and it held some efficient activities: the condition of the drug producer Farmaco has improved; many finances have been saved due to the implementation of a new public procurement system for medications; the volume of production sold by domestic enterprises has grown; the acquisition process is more transparent now. Speaking about tasks, the president highlighted the need of resolving the problem of pharmacies from hospitals; improving the mechanism of formation of prices of pharmaceutical products; establishing a permanent control on drug prescription procedure. The Drug Agency is due to intensify its activity in order to optimise the process of regulation and control of pharmaceutical system in Moldova, with the state authorities monitoring its activity in continuation.

Resolving problems of water basins

The president has convoked a sitting on management and exploitation of water basins. According to the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry (MAFI), 3,915 water objectives are identified and registered with territorial cadastral bodies at present and they are used to breed fish, irrigate agricultural fields, technical needs and entertainment. The existing problems in the field are linked to imperfect legislative base, violation of the law on renting in agriculture by local public authorities and chaotic renting or use of ponds, dispersed and uncoordinated activity of state bodies, other institutions in the field of fish breeding or exploitation of ponds. MAFI has plans to implement a complex legislative and organisational action plan, including to draft a law on waters (instead of the Code of Waters) and of a draft governmental decision on some measures for improvement of activity of fish breeding sector and regulation of the mode of use of ponds, founding a state enterprise to produce water biological resources and coordinate the fish breeding sector of Moldova. The chief of state backed the idea to elaborate a single methodology of calculation of the rent tax and a new model of rent contract, need of strict respect for ecological parameters during exploitation of lakes, ensuring possibility of use of water from ponds for irrigation and free access of citizens to water objectives for entertainment goals.

Concerns with situation in viticulture and winemaking sector

President Vladimir Voronin has emphasised at a sitting on winemaking and wine exports that present difficulties faced by Moldovan viticulture and winemaking sector must not affect ongoing processes of restoration and development of this industry. The needed priority actions include intensification of activity to maintain the existing pace of planting vines, need of a strict respect for norms of the Law on Vine and Wine concerning making of wines with origin names, farmers' wine and secondary wine products. In the context of exportation of Moldovan wines, the chief of state indicated the importance of an essential reduction of the share of wines exported in bulk, growth of brand cognacs. The Agro-Industrial Agency MoldovaVin and bodies of local public administration were empowered to sustain economic agents to plant at least 7,000 hectares of vine in 2007. The need of modifying the legislation on licensing of spirits exports was also indicated.

Sitting of the Supreme Security Council

A sitting of the Supreme Security Council has focussed on illicit trafficking in drugs. The chief of state said after hearing a report that bodies of central public administration and local authorities in charge with prevention and combat of trafficking in drugs do not work enough. Vladimir Voronin instructed responsible persons to fortify the prevention of drug addiction, recommending them to hold media campaigns about danger of consuming drugs, especially for risk groups. The chief of state asked the Government to study the situation regarding execution of decisions and orders on prevention and combat of illicite trafficking in drugs and to sanction administrations of irresponsible public institutions.


1 Article "Cheile de la Gurile Dunarii" published in the November 2, 2006 issue # 104 of Ziarul de Garda.

2 Article "Raket Orheian" published in the November 1, 2006 issue of newspaper Moldavskye Vedomosti.


Economic Policies

1. Inflation and prices: potential forecasts

2. Labour market

3. Foreign trade


Transdnistrian Conflict

Thawing postponed
Igor Botan

I. The OSCE cannot ensure restart of negotiations

The group of 30 OSCE ambassadors who have recently paid a working visit to Moldova has concluded that the OSCE cannot persuade the conflicting sides, Chisinau and Tiraspol, to resume the five-plus-two negotiations. Thus, it seems that the Belgian OSCE Chairmanship faces serious difficulties in achieving its goals. It pledged when it took over the mandate last January to implement the "3R" strategy on reformation of the organisation: Reform; Rebalancing (political, military, economic and humanitarian dimensions); Revitalisation of the OSCE, declaring the settlement of frozen conflicts among priorities. The achievement of the last goal seems to be a real failure. More, the head of the Belgian Permanent Mission to the OSCE, Ambassador Bertrand de Crombrugge says that his country did not prepare a new project on settlement of the Transnistrian conflict, though the newspaper Flux has published details from the so-called Belgian project which had been vehement criticised. All these facts strengthen our conviction that the OSCE ministerial summit this year will fail again to adopt a final statement through a consensus. The fact that OSCE officials acknowledge the impossibility of persuading the conflicting sides to resume the negotiations must not surprise. It is known for a long time that the Russian Federation must be persuaded to restart the negotiations, not Transnistria as a conflicting side, since the Tiraspol regime entirely depends on benevolence of the first. Russia is a very important feature within the OSCE and it has recently worked out its own strategy on frozen conflicts, but the OSCE does not have and cannot have it. This explains the above mentioned situation.

II. Strategy of the Russian Federation

1. Origins of strategy: BZhZskin vs. Bzhezinsky?

It is not difficult at all to understand the strategy of the Russian Federation. It is enough to recall the statement by President Vladimir Putin that "the collapse of the USSR was a big geopolitical catastrophe." By saying this, he has refrained himself from telling that former Soviet republics will feel again soon the effects of the Russian Federation's efforts to remedy the consequences of this catastrophe. Truly, the echo precedes the event in politics. Thus, what President Putin has refrained himself to tell was said long ago very clearly by the incumbent deputy chairmen of the State Duma, Sergey Baburin, Vladimir Zhirinovsky and a leader of the ruling party Yedinnaya Rossia, Konstantin Zatulin, and Vladimir Putin has recently awarded high state medals to them for this fact, appreciating their special merits.

It is clear from what was said above that Baburin, Zhirinovsky and Zatulin (BZhZ), some of them being ideologists and animators of the famous "Russian march", are a kind of collective BZhZ-skin of President Vladimir Putin. After prices of hydrocarbons have reached astronomic levels and the "energy weapon" has become effective, "judoka Putin" has also sat down at "The Great Chessboard" described by known Zbignev Bzhezinsky. Exactly as in the mentioned book the fate wanted Ukraine to be a big stake at this "chessboard" while the irony of destiny wanted that the collective BZhZskin be declared in corpore persona non grata in this country this year. It is true that if Premier Yanukovich manages to get rid of the foreign and defence ministers from quota of President Yushchenko, Tarasyuk and Gritsenko, there will be no room for irony any longer.

However, we must note that despite origin and essence of the new strategy of Russia, the implementation of this document by President Putin is intelligent and mocking, including toward the West. Even more, Russia is imprudent to claim moral superiority. The only but minor problem for President Putin is that strategist Zhirinovsky is permanently and publicly claiming his copyright for all ideas laid at basis of strategic initiatives of the Russian administration.

2. Main elements of reference

We are interested in strategic behaviour of the Russian Federation at the extent it affects the interests of CIS members that face frozen conflicts, especially of the Republic of Moldova. It is based on three known things that we should reiterate:

  1. Once Belgium has taken over the OSCE Chairmanship and made public its priorities, President Putin replied on January 31, 2006 - the Russian Federation will interpret the eventual "Kosovo precedent" as universal and applicable for all frozen conflicts in CIS.
  2. The Republic of Moldova, its partners from the West and GUAM were recalled by Russia on various occasions the fundamental need of maintaining the "equal status of the sides" participating in frozen conflicts.
  3. Complete ignorance by Russia of calls by the West and GUAM members to honour the commitments assumed at the Istanbul OSCE summit, ignorance of multiple resolutions by the Council of Europe and the European Parliament on ECHR judgments on Ilascu case, as well as of arguments that the eventual "Kosovo precedent" cannot be applied on frozen conflicts in CIS, given the different origin of these conflicts.

It is a fact that Russia can afford all these things, hinting that it imitates only the West's conduct as a measure of response, in order to protect own interests, being sure that it does not risk anything.

3. "Adequate and asymmetrical" reactions to maintain "equality of sides"

We have ascertained that the maintenance of "equality of the sides" involved in frozen conflicts is a basic element of efforts aimed to remedy consequences "of the biggest geopolitical catastrophe." It is interesting how Russia ensures this "equality of sides" in the virtue of its power. In this respect, Russia holds some arguments that it may use how it wants:

  1. The 1997 Primakov Memorandum signed by President Lucinschi inclusively stipulates express the "equality of sides", while an author of the excellent study "Thawing a frozen conflict. Legal aspects of the separatist crisis in Moldova", professor Christopher Borgen of The Association of the Bar of the City of New York (ABCNY) has explained that under international law a "memorandum" has the value given by signatory parties. Thus, Moldovan authorities do not want to give any price to the Primakov Memorandum any longer, but Russian authorities regard it as the main document of reference in settling the conflict between Chisinau and Tiraspol. Russia is very strong, Moldova is very weak and therefore commentaries on consequences of divergent attitudes toward the invoked memorandum are useless;
  2. Russian authorities invoke on any occasion the rejection in 2003 of the Kozak Memorandum, a document worked out at the request of Moldovan authorities, in a move to outline the "dependent nature of Moldovan policy on negative influences of the West," which "has torpedoed an almost ready solution to the Transnistrian conflict." This way, Russia posts an alleged moral advantage and the right to treat the Republic of Moldova like a serious partner, which has cut the branch under its legs for sure;
  3. Moldova's energy dependence and the dependence of Moldovan products on the Russian market are the main factors of influence in ensuring the "equality of sides" involved in the conflict.

Altogether these factors create a visible arsenal of tools of application and justification of "adequate and asymmetrical" answers toward actions taken by Moldovan authorities to settle the Transnistrian conflict. How this is done? The new regional political conjuncture formed after the presidential elections in Ukraine has produced a new approach of measures of settling the Transnistrian conflict. All actions of Moldovan authorities in this regard have been coordinated with the United States, the European Union and Ukraine at a bigger or smaller extent. They are: the Yushchenko plan on conflict resolution through democratisation of the Transnistrian region; introduction of the new customs system in the Transnistrian section of the Moldova-Ukraine border and setup of the European Union's Border Assistance Mission (EUBAM); adoption by Moldovan Parliament of the law on basic principles of Transnistria's status aimed to award more autonomy, etc.

Russia has negatively reacted to all these actions and initiatives and it argued that any initiative uncoordinated with Transnistrian authorities will fail and will be combated "adequately and asymmetrically." It is true that:

  1. Putin's adviser Modest Kolerov has arrived in Tiraspol to become founder parent of the Transnistrian civil society representative, the Proriv International Corporation, reacting to the Yushchenko Plan on democratisation of Transnistria. The refusal of the OSCE to monitor the December 2005 Transnistrian parliamentary elections was parried through an observance mission from the State Duma. Reproaches that there is no democracy in Transnsitria because of the lack of political parties have been combated through immediate constitution of five (!) political parties on summer 2006 and all of them support the separatism and Russia. Thus, Russian political technologists established the "equality of the sides" regarding democratic institutions;
  2. The "adequate measures" of the Russian Federation toward the new customs regime in the Transnistrian section of the Moldova-Ukraine border consisted of a quasi-total blocking of Moldovan export to the Russian market. The "asymmetrical" side of reaction is that while blocking the Republic of Moldova, Russia has granted humanitarian aid to Transnistria and hundreds of millions of dollars in cash in account of properties from the region. Now Transnistrian authorities do not hide their satisfaction to see who will succumb first - the separatist regime under the new customs regime but supported by Russia or the Republic of Moldova blocked economically by its main strategic partner? Even more, natural gas prices for Moldova are raised two-fold compared with 2005 and they could be increased three-fold in 2006. Transnistria pays the old price or it will be lowered, being allowed not to pay for the current consumption. This "asymmetrical" treatment aims to undermine any pretension to make the Republic of Moldova economically attractive for Transnistrians.
  3. The law on basic principles of Transnistria's legal status adopted by Moldovan Parliament in July 2005 has produced a reply with the longest period of manifestation. Truly, how could Russia reply adequately to adoption of a law by Parliament of a recognised state? The adoption of a law with contrary provisions by Transnistria's Supreme Soviet would not be regarded as an "adequate" and "asymmetrical" response. For this reason, Russia has inspired, supported and financed an alleged referendum on joining to itself; it means "a direct people's vote" which it did not recognise. This is part of the notion of "adequate and asymmetrical" answer.
  4. Finally, Moldova's tries to reply in its turn "adequately" to confiscation of its property from Transnistria, especially of infrastructure by bypassing Transnistria in passenger railway communication with Russia was combated with an "adequate" answer - the Russian Federation has stopped the railway communication with Moldova. This case is interesting especially through co-participation of Ukraine in railway blocking of Moldova. In this regard, it should be mentioned that a Ukrainian minister from "quota of President Yushchenko" supports Moldova within GUAM, OSCE, U.N., etc., while ministers of the majority party of Premier Yanukovich co-participate in organisation of "adequate and asymmetrical measures" of the Russian Federation against the Republic of Moldova. It seems that this is only the beginning.

III. Conclusions

  1. The thawing and settlement of the Transnistrian conflict is postponed for an indefinite term. Russia's strategy cannot be left aside in settlement of this conflict.

  2. Russia's policy on frozen conflicts is resumed to ensure de facto the "equality of the sides" participating in so-called frozen conflicts. It is not prepared to incorporate the separatist enclaves in itself, as these actions are capable to create big external problems. Also, the recognition of independence of Transnistria and other separatist regimes in spite of results of so-called referendums and recognition of their legitimacy by State Duma is not very probable. If so, it would mean that the entire space of remedying consequences of the "geopolitical catastrophe" is reduced to these separatist regions only. It is too little for the new Russian elite, which has stirred up the nationalist spirit and revengeful expectations in Russia for the entire post-Soviet area. The risk is that the "Russian march" inspired by present elite could turn against itself, if the inspired expectations are impossible.

  3. Russia will probably act on long term to destabilise the socio-economic condition and, as a result, the political situation through its economic-financial and commercial policies. The most devoted partner of the Russian Federation, Belarus, is also tested its awareness over gravity of the "geopolitical catastrophe" that took place 15 years ago. There will be tries to change political elites in CIS. Organisations such as "Patria-Moldova" based in Moscow will be involved to speak on behalf of CIS nations and nationals from all meridians. Eventual changes of ruling elites should ensure the achievement of older claims for settlement of frozen conflicts on basis of principles "equality of sides"; it means through creation of contractual federations with equal subjects or confederations anchored by Russia through present separatist regimes.

  4. Eventual yielding by Moldovan authorities must be regarded in the light of the Russian strategy described above. Nobody should nourish illusions that accepting ceding in certain fields could restore the status quo antes. For example, if Moldova cedes in the "transit protocol" problem, which Russia is negotiating to ensure the economic and commercial freedom of Transnistria, this will be the consent to be an "equal side" with Transnistria in Russia's strategic calculations. What would Transnistria have to negotiate later with Moldova but a confederation with a certain orientation of foreign policy? We could admit such a version, if Russia has a behaviour and image similar to the one of the European Union. But so nobody should be surprised that "Russian marches" will take place in all Moldova for implementation of such a scenario.

  5. One more argument has appeared for the ruling party of Moldova besides the one that there is more socialism in Moldova than in CIS to promote a firm pro-European policy. It will be really hard to find arguments in favour of a relation of partnership and perspectives of cooperation after the Russian Communist Party decided at the October plenary session to give up the principle of internationalism and to choose instead the "Russian issue".

  6. In spite of changes in Ukrainian policy, the hope to settle the Transnistrian conflict may be linked further to this country. It was observed that Ukrainian oligarchs are very interested in an eventual free exchange agreement with the E.U. They are ready to give up other agreements such as synchronisation of Ukraine's access to the World Trade Organisation together with Russia but to obtain a free trade agreement with the E.U. after the joining to the WTO. Like formerly, the Republic of Moldova should persuade the E.U. that the attitude toward the Transnistrian conflict remains the good faith test of Ukraine. Indeed, this fact was recently confirmed by Javier Solana, high representative for foreign policy and common security. Moldova's request should be found in documents signed by E.U. with Ukraine, of course in the right place. The impact would be significant through fact that such an introduced practice would undermine the hopes of citizens from Transnistria that a new independence referendum or joining to Russia is possible. Citizens would finally realise that they are in a trap and they are used to satisfy self-pride of some revengeful elites.

  7. The Republic of Moldova must make place of manoeuvre to advance to the European direction only, so that not to become the "pawn of sacrifice" from "big backgammon" of big players. An authentic democratisation is the only way to do this.


Foreign Affairs

Republic of Moldova - Council of Europe

According to a conclusion of corapporteurs of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), Moldova cannot get rid of the monitoring, though our country has achieved some progresses in democratisation of society after the latest report on monitoring. Drawbacks and shortcomings are related to "partial" freedom of mass media, quality of justice, of adopted laws and the way they are applied.

The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe resumed debates on execution of the European Court of Human Rights' judgment on "Ilascu and others versus Moldova and the Russian Federation" at the November 8 session. The Moldovan delegation has thanked the states which constantly manifested interest and support for a rapid solution to this case. The Finnish delegation has reiterated on behalf of the European Union Presidency the concerns of the E.U. over non-settlement of this case and urged Moldova and the Russian Federation to take all measures for an immediate release of Andrei Ivantoc and Tudor Petrov-Popa. Finland noted again that the non-execution of this ruling by the Russian Federation deteriorates the image of this country within the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe and the credibility of the whole human rights protection system.

The ECHR has sentenced Moldova in another four cases:

Republic of Moldova - European Union

The European Union intends to modify the procedure of granting financial assistance to Moldova in 2007, so that Moldova will receive more assistance within the Neighbourhood Policy. According to minister of foreign affairs and European integration, the TACIS programme will be replaced with a new tool, which will not be limited to technical assistance only. More than 50 percent of the sources granted from European funds will be directed to support the state budget for implementation of economic and infrastructure development projects.

A recent report by the European Commission insists on priority of European values, geographic limits and warns over enlargement. The commission stipulates stricter conditions for admission of candidates, especially for political reforms in these states, without excluding the accession of new candidates in future. The enlargement agenda includes now the Western Balkans and Turkey, but it is premature to schedule the accession of these candidates.

Republic of Moldova - Romania

The Mediafax news agency has quoted Romanian President Traian Basescu as saying that he "is disappointed with the integrated history textbook" promoted in Moldovan educational institutions. Speaking about relationship between Romania and Moldova, the Romanian president reiterated that Romania supports the integration of Moldova in the E.U. enlargement wave that covers the Western Balkans area, in order to avoid the inclusion of the neighbouring country in the wave comprising Ukraine. Basescu noted that the growth of confidence between political factors from Bucharest and Chisinau is the only goal of Romanian authorities at present.

On November 3, the Romanian Traffic Police and the Moldovan Border Guards Service signed a plan on cooperation between border institutions for 2007, which stipulates intensified efforts against crimes at the Moldova-Romania state border, a series of measures to strengthen the border management.

The Romanian Consulate in Chisinau accepts applications for collective visas from Moldovan citizens. The diplomatic mission will introduce an online appointment system for persons seeking individual visas. The embassy assures that Moldovans will not pay for Romanian visas.

Republic of Moldova - Russian Federation

The Yedinaya Rossia Party has delegated a group of lawmakers from the State Duma to monitor the presidential elections in the unrecognised Transnistrian Moldovan Republic (Deputies Olga Selivestrova, Konstantin Zatulin and Sergey Kolesnikov are delegated).

Vladimir Yakunin, director of the Russian railway company, has described the decision to suspend the train # 47 with Chisinau-Moscow destination as political, noting that Russian railway authorities coordinate their international relations accordingly to political conjuncture and evolutions.

Moldova's chief sanitary doctor has commented on accusations brought by his Russian counterpart Gennady Onishchenko, saying that "the community of experts and doctors from Moldova estimates with deep compassion and pity the size of alcohol poisoning in the Russian Federation, with Moldovan authorities taking additional measures to verify all spirits from the Russian Federation, though such social epidemics have not been registered in Moldova.

Rospotrebndazor has stopped negotiations with Moldovan authorities regarding the access of wines to Russian market. Rospotrebndazor head Gennady Onishchenko said that the contacts have been suspended because the "Moldovan side failed the agreed measures." At the same time, Onishchenko said that there is a better perspective for negotiations on resumption of spirits exports from Transnistria [a Rospotrebnadzor delegation has already visited the region] and Abkhazia.

According to data of the National Bureau for Statisitcs, the Russian Federation remains the main importer of Moldovan products in January-September. Goods worth 142.3 million dollars were delivered to the Russian Federation in nine months of this year, which is by 15.2 percent less than in the same period of 2005.

Moldova in the world

According to data of the National Bureau for Statistics, 494 foreign citizens obtained residence permits in Moldova in January-September 2006. At the same time, 1,256 immigrants have arrived in Moldova in the period concerned, of them 762 persons obtained fixed-term permits. Most foreign citizens (250) have arrived from Ukraine and Turkey (237). More than 1,300 persons have repatriated themselves from Moldova in the same period.

Moldova was declared eligible for full financial assistance of the Millennium Challenge Corporation in 2007. The Board of Directors of the U.S. Millennium Challenge Corporation said that Moldova has joined another 22 countries eligible for development assistance. Eligibility for the Complete Program is a direct result of reformation policies promoted by Moldovan Government, being "a prize for implementation of some good policies."


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Gagauzia: The Region of Development
Galina Selari

At the beginning of September the Government examined and established the "tasks" concerning one of the most discussed issues of its Programme - "the two magical threes": 300 thou new labour places and the country average wage of 300 USD. Common interest to both problem per se and the variants of its solution is understandable and explicable since it concerns each of us who live in Moldova. The question of all questions though is the same as it was almost two years ago - is this possible? The Government answered through its corresponding decision followed, further on, by comments of experts, journalists and the electorate.

In the meantime, the Government answered once again to the above mentioned question through approval of the draft law on regional development perhaps without even knowing it. After all, it is the country's regions combining its natural, demographic and production resources, settlements, infrastructure, that form the natural basis of sustainable development, which means that the actions to support regional development undertaken in the "legal basis - structures - processes" system should ensure higher effectiveness of the country's economy as a whole through expansion of economic growth and, more important, of its results away from the centre (Chisinau first of all) towards the regions.

NB: regions of development superimpose on the existing administrative-territorial structure, while keeping the historically established division into sub-regions: North, Centre, Chisinau, South-East in the prospect, South and ATU Gagauzia.

Among all future regions of development only two exist today in reality: Chisinau, where economic life is concentrated and accrues, and Gagauzia, of which is much less known. The "rest" of Moldova is rarely discussed at all.

Moreover, at the first place Gagauzia is taken as political category, and just this feature is usually discussed and such debates go even more active now spread from the autonomy to the centre.

At the same time, economic peculiarity of the region is obvious. Unlike other administrative-territorial units whose number and border are flexible and are set starting from the specific tasks of state management, Gagauzia - as an autonomous territorial formation - enjoys the special treatment and differs through a considerable advantage: its territorial "stability" initially rests upon the results of the referendum of 1995, which means that, considering the expanded powers and increased responsibility, real (in its European meaning) regional development is possible here.

Given the "scarceness" of information let us try to answer the question put at the beginning - is it possible in Gagauzia, for instance?

Let us remember, that the first Programme of socio-economic development of Gagauzia (Gagauz-Eri) approved by the People's Assembly of Gagauzia in April of 1997, established priorities and indicators of development for 1996-2000. But it appears that the initial lack of coordination of goals and their financial backing, aggravated by the force majeur of 1998, affected the implementation so much that its outcome still waits to be given publicity.

Later, in 2001 an attempt was undertaken (the first in the history of the independent Moldova!) to elaborate the Regional programme of development of Gagauz-Eri. It was planned that that programme would set priorities and mechanisms of ensuring sustainable human development in Gagauzia, as the region of the Republic of Moldova, till 2003, with its further development till 2005 and even 2020. At that, most importantly, the emphasis during setting goals and priorities was done on local conditions and resources, taking into account the capacities of the state as a whole. Unfortunately, the work "ended" just with the assessment of the initial basis, advantages, potential and factors of the region's development, as well as eventual risks[1] were analyzed, but elaboration of the concept of sustainable development of the region and the programme per se never started.

So, Gagauzia today. First, about the most important - the people. Noteworthy is that the natural habitat of concentration of the Gagauz population has been almost the same during the modern history - and mainly coincides with the data of the censuses of Bessarabian population of 1897 and 1907, but compared to that data the region's population grew three times as much.

Truth to tell, comparison with the census of 1989 is not so optimistic: the population reduced, but nevertheless twice as little as in Moldova as a whole. The share of the capable population has abruptly increased (64%), while traditionally, due to high "children's quote" it was 45-50%. Here, at least two problems are beginning to emerge. First, employment today is not a comforting answer; the number of those employed dropped by 17% during the last 5 years (in Moldova, on average - by 5%). At that, average wage is 25% lower the average in Moldova and less by half (!) as compared to the capital. Apparently, this is the reason cca 20 thou persons (according to official estimates) have left their homes in search of better life abroad. Second, who will be able to work tomorrow, but it is today when we have to start thinking about it (which is also the task of the regional policy).

The direction of the search: structural shifts in the real sector of economy, encouragement of entrepreneurship, attraction of internal and external investments.

By the way, as for the investment legislation, Gagauzia has some positive experience of its own. Under the Law on Investments and Investment Activity of ATU Gagauzia, starting from 2001 all agents of the investment activity enjoy benefits provided by the legislation of Moldova and extra benefits - under the local law. In the Republic of Moldova, it was only 2004 when foreign and domestic investors were afforded equal treatment. It seems that transport and geographical closeness to the countries of the Danube-Balkans region and the Black Sea basin, traditional close cultural and economic ties with them, together with traditional enterprise of the population and acceptable legislation have attracted investors to the region, both domestic and foreign. Noteworthy is that the structure of Gagauz investments from the point of view of property differs from the country average - about 50% investments are of foreign or "mixed" origin (in Moldova as a whole - about 30%).

In 2001, Turkish holding "Asena-Textil" has commenced its operation. Having started in Ciadir-Lunga, it currently operates in two more settlements, which means real jobs and wages.

It was more than 10 years ago when the American company "Redeco" started extracting petroleum in Valeni village, and this summer petroleum will began to be processed by the first Moldovan refinery (owner "AS Petrol Moldova"): 70 work places have been already created, and 100 more are in the offing.

Still exists and tries to develop FEZ "Production Park "Valacanes". As of the end of 2005, 15 residents are registered there (there were 16 in 2004), but unfortunately more than a half of them does not operate in reality (reserve!), and work places are still obviously little - slightly more than 400. Production of elite wines is the main activity. As regards equipment, laboratory instrument of control and analysis the enterprise (DK Intertrade SRL, Russia) is one of the leading in Moldova. It is assumed that FEZ production range will become more varied: there were registered new residents planning to produce dried fruits and wool. The present companies will also broaden their activity - "Metalgazcon SRL" is going to produce walnut oil (plus no less than 60 work places).

But there are enough problems in Gagauzia as well. And the relations with the centre is the most evident. There is a lot to think about in the context of the state regional policy currently formed by the Government, especially as regards financial, economic and organizational mechanisms of its implementation. And today, mutual reproaches can be periodically heard concerning inter-budget relations. The centre is displeased with discrepancies in legislation, Gagauzia - with the amount of transfers. Despite the changes undertaken at the legislative, including the constitutional, level, the compromise is still to be found. Unfortunately, the reality of Moldova is that these legally established rights are not fully backed by own resources yet. One may surmise that once regions of development are created these problems can acquire a new characteristic - the necessity to reach judicious compromise between the intraregional community, including local administrations.

Regional policy has to stop being associated mainly with distribution of resources granted by the centre. Only in this case growth driven by regions is possible in Moldova - activization of the economy in the regions, improvement of living standards, and the social stability as the result.


1 Regional programme Gagauz-Eri: Analysis of the Initial Basis, www.cisr-md.org


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]