ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20070216/index.shtml


e-journal, year V, issue 89, February 1–16, 2007

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Problem

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1.1. Appointments

The majority of parliamentarians have appointed Valeriu Gurbulea as Prosecutor-General. Opposition lawmakers have indicated certain biased actions taken by the candidate when he ran his former offices (prosecutor, secretary of the Supreme Security Council, first deputy prosecutor-general). Gurbulea denied that certain cases have been filed for political reasons and he assured that he did not participate in persecution of some opponents of the governance. As regards the reformation of the Prosecutor’s Office, Gurbulea said that this institution is generally reformed and only its place in magistracy must be established. The new prosecutor-general said about cases of resonance, in which the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has sentenced Moldova, that the ECHR did not find out abuses in filing cases and it sanctioned Moldova for violation of human rights (detention conditions, degrading treatment), without examination of the essence of the case.

The Parliament has appointed the first members of the Administrative Board of the National Agency for the Protection of Competition[1]:

Although it was included in the agenda and debated for a long period, the draft decision on appointment of some judges of the Supreme Court of Justice (N.Budai, S.Caitaz, E.Zinenco) was not adopted so far. Objections raised by chairman of the legal commission for rules and immunities against skills of some candidates and existence of some ECHR judgments that condemn Moldova inclusively for decisions by one of the candidates challenged controversial discussions. Opposition lawmakers noticed that the parliamentary majority appreciate candidates under political aspect, too, with chairman of the Christian Democratic faction warning that these attempts and attitudes of the majority affect the parliamentary political consensus.

1.2. Legal acts

Law on protection of personal data. An independent national centre for the protection of personal data will be created under this law (the executive has initially recommended that ombudsmen exert these functions), and it will take care that the personal information be processed accordingly to the law. The new law regulates the conditions of collection of information, storage, processing and use of personal data and it aims to guarantee the protection of the right of individuals to private life.

Law on prevention of HIV/AIDS infection. The law establishes the legal base of actions taken to prevent the spreading of HIV/AIDS infection by reducing new cases of infection, stopping the exponential growth of epidemic and reducing its impact, ensuring medical and socio-psychological assistance for persons suffering from HIV/AIDS, members of their families, guaranteeing respect for their rights. Some objections have been raised when the draft was debated in the first reading and later, including by civil society, religious groups. Opportune recommendations have been taken into consideration to finalise the law.

Law on modification of the law on civil status acts. By modifying this law, the range of candidates to the post of chief of the civil status service was extended (a long work length in this office (civil status bodies) was earlier needed, but now the law says that the work length in the "public service" is enough.

The draft was tabled by Communist lawmakers, but opposition representatives feared during debates that the amendments follow lobbyist interests in favour of some persons in territorial administration who claim these offices.

Draft law on audit activity. It proposes provisions on organisation of audit activity, rights, obligations and responsibility of the sides involved, required by adjustment of audit activity to international practice and regulations (control on quality of audit works, insurance of activity, keeping registers of bidders, creation of the council for the supervision of audit activity, etc.).

Draft law on limited societies. The document approved in the first reading aims to regulate the mode of constitution, functioning, reorganisation particularities and mode of closing limited societies. Essential provisions envisage the number of founders and minimum registered capital needed to found a limited society (30,000 lei compared with 5,400 lei at present).

Draft law on aeronautic security. It aims to regulate social ties linked to security and protection of passengers, crews, aeronautic personnel, population, airships, installations and services of airports that serve the civil aviation against illicit interventions, in order to ensure aeronautic security by introducing an ensemble of measures aimed at protection of civil aviation against illicit interventions. Opposition lawmakers criticised the activity of the State Administration of Civil Aviation (staff policy, training, deficient financial management, conflicts with operators and foreign administrations). Communist lawmakers also accused SACA of trying to extend the control on areas that do not rest with its competences (security, control, combat of violent acts).

Draft law on national ecological network. The document proposes a legal framework for creation and development of the national ecological network as part of the pan-European ecological network, establishing of a regime of protection and use of functional elements of the national ecological network, competences and obligations of public administration authorities in this field.

Draft law on modification of some legal acts on pharmaceutical activity. Following provisions could be included in the law on pharmaceutical activity and Code of Administrative Contraventions:

1.3. Parliamentary control. Statements

Questions and interpellations

Deputy minister of economy and commerce has reported the implementation of the law on salary system in budgetary sector to the Parliament. The executive will propose a gradual salary rise in 2007 and about 338 million lei is needed for this purpose. Salaries of various categories will grow by 25–50 percent in late 2007.

Our Moldova Alliance (OMA) Deputy Anatol Onceanu has appealed to the Prosecutor-General’s Office and the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption to control the legality of privatisation of the channels Antena C and Euro TV, "financial capacities of new owners to respect the contractual conditions, origin of finances, legal and financial condition of these persons, their financial guarantors."

Communist Deputy Elena Bodnarenco has asked the Prosecutor-General’s Office to consider the legality of a meeting held by Dumitru Braghis in the city of Soroca.

OMA Deputy Valeriu Cosarciuc has asked the prime minister to elucidate the aspects related to prices for gasification of households and the price formation methodology.

Social Liberal Deputy Igor Klipii has asked the prime minister to report methodological criteria of calculation of estimates for works financed from public funds, to explain how planners are selected and what control mechanisms the Government is applying. Klipii invoked in this respect statements by Igor Semenovker, chairman of the Building and Territorial Development Agency, regarding violations and embezzlements admitted by functionaries and entrepreneurs.

Deputy Valentia Cusnir has asked the Government to explain concrete measures taken to improve the situation in vine growing and winemaking sector and relieve the crisis. Deputy Cusnir has also asked the Prosecutor-General’s Office to report on investigation of disappearance of Vlad Cubreacov in 2002.

Deputy Zoia Jalba has asked the Government to present legal grounds why the faculty of veterinary medicine was deprived of a block of studies, as the National Institute of Justice was placed in these headquarters.

Christian Democratic Deputy Stefan Secareanu has asked the Government to report on implementation of amendments to the law on rehabilitation of victims of political repressions. According to information invoked by Secareanu, central and local authorities continue to delay the process of restitution of property and compensation of its value.

Statements

Moldova’s speaker has outlined the tasks of parliamentarians in a speech delivered at the beginning of the spring-summer session:

The OMA faction has delivered several statements at plenary sittings, notably concerning:

Social Liberal Deputy Igor Klipii has read some statements on corruption in Moldova and demanded parliamentary hearings and creation of a parliamentary investigative commission to verify embezzlement of public money and stealing of money from population invoked by Igor Semenovker, director of the Building and Territorial Development Agency.


Government

2.1. Appointments. Reshuffles

The Government has reconfirmed Grigore Belostecinic as rector of the Moldovan Academy of Economics.

2.2. Decisions

Decision on creation of the centre for the adjustment of legislation in accordance with criteria of the European Union. The centre subordinated to the Ministry of Justice will examine draft legal and normative acts, will monitor the compliance of national legislation with criteria established by acquis communautaire. The executive will allocate 1.2 million lei from its reserve fund to finance the activity of the centre in 2007.

Decision that approves the national programme ensuring the ecological security for 2007–2015. Under the document, starting 2007 the national system for monitoring of air quality will be modernised, a regulation on quality of surface waters and norms for used waters will be elaborated, draft laws on sanitation of Moldovan localities, on dangerous waste, on management of chemical substances will be worked out. Central and local authorities will approve departmental and local plans ensuring ecological security and will periodically report on implementation of the national programme to the Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources.

Decision on additional measures regulating the circulation of firearms and munitions. It allows the police bodies to authorise the possession, sale, keeping, holding and carriage of firearms and munitions from illegal possession of citizens who delivered them voluntarily to interior bodies. The Interior Ministry will establish the procedure of reception, examination and authorisation of illegal weapons and munitions delivered voluntarily.

Decision on commission for the selection of candidates for the post of judge to the ECHR. The 14-strong commission is headed by minister of justice and will select candidates by March 9, 2007, accordingly to a special recommendation by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. Three selected candidacies will be presented to the Government for a final internal decision and the candidate selected by Government will need the consent of PACE. The mandate of the acting Moldovan judge to the ECHR expires in October 2007.

Decision approving the programme on distribution of means from the traffic fund in 2007. Maximum profitableness limits of 10 percent for maintenance works and 7 percent for repairs are established for entrepreneurial organisations participating in implementation of this programme.

Decision approving the strategy on reformation of state framework regulating the entrepreneurial activity[2]. The strategy is approved and it contains several sections (description of current situation; necessities of approach; improvement of direction system; ensuring quality of new regulations and improving the existing regulations; principles of regulatory reform; goals and objectives of the reform; expected results; eventual risks; monitoring of implementation). Also, the Government approved an action plan for implementation of the strategy. Central authorities will include in their action plans the actions needed to implement the strategy and will present periodical reports on execution of established measures.

Decisions approving some draft laws:

2.3. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Permanent concerns with domestic trade

Reports on situation of domestic trade, measures taken by responsible officials were presented at a working sitting chaired by prime minister. Premier raised dissatisfaction with situation in the field, noting that an efficient trade system is not created on domestic market so far, not all rights of consumers are respected, adequate conditions of work for vendors are not created, transparent circulation of money is not ensured. In this regard, prime minister welcomed actions taken by Ministry of Economy to implement the reform in trade system, the regulatory reform and to simplify the accounting record modality. The Ministry of Health was asked to work out an action plan on protection of rights of consumers and implementation of a new methodology of monitoring of activities in domestic trade sector. Vasile Tarlev outlined the need of minimising the number of controls on economic agents and embittering punishments for violation of legislation. The draft law on internal trade will be consulted with factors participating in this process, including civil society.

Meeting with representatives of Moldovan Foreign Investors Association

A meeting between prime minister and representatives of the association focussed on a better investment climate, measures needed to attract more investments in national economy. Investors consider that the dialogue between central public administration and business community has developed very much in the past years and, therefore, many problems of businessmen have been solved. In particular, the taxation system was simplified after the fiscal burden was reduced, the legislation has improved, tax and monetary policies have become stable and predictable, the regulatory reform has developed. In this context, the prime minister opted for the elaboration of a joint action plan, which would include a package of coordinated actions and announced the elaboration of a programme aimed to combat corruption in public bodies.


Presidency

3.1. Decrees

Dumitru Diacov, chairman of the Democratic Party of Moldova and leader of the parliamentary faction of the same party, was awarded the Honour Order for long and prodigious work in supreme state bodies, substantial contribution to a better legislation, intense organisational and public activity.

The chief of state has awarded the higher qualification ranking of judge to judges of the Supreme Court of Justice Sergiu Furdui and Sveatoslav Moldovan.

3.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Elaboration of the National Development Plan

President Vladimir Voronin has chaired a sitting on elaboration of the National Development Plan (NDP) for 2008–2011, at which the draft concept and structure of the document were presented. According to the draft, the NDP will be worked out on basis of five strategic priorities:

The future structure of the plan will cover the proper development strategy and the action plan, which will be worked out in compliance with the medium-term expense framework and updated every year in line with the budget law for the year concerned. The period of elaboration will cover three stages: the concept of the document will be established by March 2007; a detailed action plan will be worked out in April-August; public debates will be held in August-October and the Government and Parliament will approve the plan later.

The chief of state stressed the important role of civil society in elaborating the plan, outlining the need of developing this process in a maximum transparency and invited the governmental structured participating in elaboration of this plan to be very receptive in communication with civil society and to ensure a well-structured participative process. According to Vladimir Voronin, the document must have a very good quality so that to be supported by entire society, it must not be a plan of the power only, but one belonging to the entire society, which will actively participle in its implementation, regardless of political visions.

Participation in annual conference of judges

Moldova’s president has stressed in an address to participants in the conference that the reform implemented in the past years has demonstrated both willingness and capacity of judicial institutions to improve the mode of organisation, financing and functioning of law courts. Vladimir Voronin expressed a series of attitudes toward the judicial system:

Permanent concerns with situation in pharmaceutical sector

Vladimir Voronin has convoked a sitting on situation in Moldovan pharmaceutical system and outlined existing problems and established objectives for 2007. According to reports unveiled at the sitting, reforms promoted in pharmaceutical sector have some positive results: normalised situation on domestic drug market, stricter control on importation of medications and their quality, including due to the automatic information system introduced in this sector. The chief of state called on competent governmental officials to continue the ongoing actions, insisting particularly on need of intensifying the efforts aimed at implementing the automatic information system, improving the mechanisms of organisation of drug procurements, reorganising the existing system of pharmacies and creating a network of pharmacies independent of public medical-sanitary institutions. The priority tasks include among others the improvement of the mechanism of formation of drug prices, optimisation of the range of drugs on domestic market and ensuring of an adequate quality of medications. Also, operative measures were demanded to develop the domestic drug industry, develop the stock society Farmaco, and implement an investment project on organisation of first-need drugs in Moldova. The chief of state stressed the need of improving the legislation on pharmaceutical sector, process of accreditation and certification of domestic pharmaceutical institutions.

Facilitating connection to gas pipes

The state will finance the connection of residences of disabled people, participants in war, armed conflicts, and cleanup of consequences of the Chernobil disaster, doctors, teachers and specialists of various branches of activities from rural areas of the country to natural gas pipes. Moldova’s president has made this promise at a meeting with district chairmen, which studied the implementation of the national programme Moldovan Village in the last two years. Vladimir Voronin has asked the Government to work out within five days the methodology of regulation of prices for elaboration of projects and building of gas pipes in Moldovan localities because entrepreneurs are using exaggerated prices for these works and the state leadership should regulate them.

Permanent attention toward development of the Chisinau municipality

A sitting on social-economic development of the Chisinau municipality has made the totals of activities held in 2006 to develop the capital and studied projects that will be implemented in 2007. The chief of state appreciated the works aimed at modernising the Chisinau municipality and underlined the need of continuing the process of upgrading the municipality in a sustained pace, paying a special attention to quality of reconstruction works. Speaking about tasks of the 2007 development programme of the Chisinau municipality, Vladimir Voronin called for the soon elaboration of an action plan for the implementation of this document. He named among priorities:

Assembly of Academy of Sciences

Vladimir Voronin has addressed an annual meeting of the scientific forum and the main ideas are:


1 The National Agency for the Protection of Competition is in charge with promoting the state policy on development of competition, protecting the competition, preventing, limiting and repressing monopolist activity and unfair competition of economic agents, public administration authorities in national economy. The law on protection of competition, which stipulated the creation of this agency, was adopted in 2000, but the creation of this structure was delayed, with experts saying that the protection of interests of monopolists who will be controlled by this agency and of some special rules aimed to limit the dominant position were the main cause.

2 It is worth to note that the strategy has appeared after the Parliament and Government took some measures in this regard (the laws on guillotine, methodologies of evaluation of regulatory impact, and others). The approval of the strategy in early 2007 leads to the conclusion that the previous approaches have not been "strategic" and evaluated well beforehand, they have been spontaneous and the need of establishing some criteria of principle, of system was observed when they were implemented.


Economic Policies

1. Inflation and prices

2. Financial-bank system

3. Public finances

4. Foreign trade


Transdnistrian Problem

"Five-Plus-Two" negotiations

A try to restart the "Five-Plus-Two" negotiations in the mid-February failed. We recall that mediators and observers of the Transnistrian settlement process sent letters to Chisinau and Tiraspol, inviting them at a new round of negotiation on February 15–16, after the Madrid consultations in late January. The Chisinau authorities gave green light to this invitation and confirmed their intention to attend the February round. On the other hand, the Transnistrian side did not give a clear response to the Madrid invitation, refusing the participation with only a couple of days before the round of negotiations. By releasing a press statement on February 15, 2007, the OSCE Mission to Moldova was disappointed with failed negotiations, but fell short of revealing the guilty. The Ministry of Reintegration has also released a communication, expressing disappointment and puzzle with failure of the round of negotiations because of absence of some participants, without invoking any grounded reasons.

Earlier, the head of the Tiraspol "supreme soviet", Evgeny Shevchyuk, has earlier told a meeting with the E.U. special representative for Moldova, Adriaan Jakobovits de Szeged, that a fair solution to the Transnistrian conflict will not be found as long as the Transnistrian region is facing economic and political blockades. According to Shevchyuk, the Transnistrian side will kick off its participation in negotiations only after the methods of force will be given up, because thus Transnistria will face unfair conditions and will be unable to protect itself.

It is worth to mention that the Tiraspol legislature annulled on January 31, 2007 a January 6, 1993 decision by the "supreme soviet" on creation of a confederation with Moldova, as well as decisions by the "supreme council" concerning creation of a federation and creation of a Moldovan-Transnistrian commission in 2003 to work out the constitution of the federal state. Transnistrian "speaker" Evgeny Shevchyuk motivated these decisions with adjustment of the stance of the Transnistrian region on Moldova to the foreign policy concept of Transnistria, results of the September 17 referendum and "constitution" of the region. At the same time, Shevchyuk noted that the annulment of these acts does not mean the refusal of the Transnistrian side to participate in political negotiations with Moldovan authorities.

Munich Conference on Security Policy

Moldovan Minister of Foreign Affairs and European Integration Andrei Stratan referred among others to efforts of Moldovan authorities to settle the Transnistrian conflict, at the February 9–11 Munich Conference on Security Policy. The Moldovan minister reiterated the decision of Moldovan authorities to find a lasting political solution to the Transnistrian conflict on basis of sovereignty and territorial integrity of Moldova. Minister Stratan raised concern with inefficiency of the present peacekeeping mechanism in the Transnistrian region and called for replacement with joint peacekeeping forces with an international mandate. Stratan asked Russia to honour the decisions of the 1999 Istanbul OSCE Summit and to withdraw its military forces and munitions from the Transnistrian region. At the same time, Minister Stratan expressed hope that the E.U. will strengthen its role of guarantor of European security with a bigger contribution to the Transnistrian settlement process. The latter desideratum was also invoked by Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko, who has asked the E.U. to support the territorial integrity of Moldova. According to Yushchenko, the Transnistrian conflict is not a secondary European problem. Yushchenko noted that the signing of a multilateral document to confirm the territorial integrity of Moldova would be opportune. "We must do our best to ensure the optimal settlement of this conflict," Yushchenko said in a speech in Munich.

At the same time, Russian President Vladimir Putin, who has vehemently criticised the foreign policy of the United States and the eastern expansion of NATO, was unsatisfied that NATO member states refuse to ratify the Adapted Treaty of Conventional Forces in Europe as long as Russia keeps its military bases in Georgia and Moldova. According to Putin, the 1,500 Russian soldiers in the Transnistrian region are part of the peacekeeping operation in the region and guard the depots of munitions that remained in the breakaway enclave since the Soviet times.

The 43rd Munich Conference on Security Policy is an important forum of decision makers and security experts dedicated to transatlantic relations and European and international security matters. The current edition brought together first-ranking officials and personalities from the whole world, including German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko, E.U. Council Secretary-General Javier Solana, high representative for CFSP, NATO Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, etc.


Foreign Affairs

Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has sentenced Moldova in two cases for violation of the right to a fair trial and protection of property.

The Strasbourg-based Court has obliged Moldova in the first case to pay 600 euros to Valeriu Avramenko in costs and expenses and the ECHR will establish later the pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages. The applicant bought shares worth 34,000 euros in a state-owned enterprise at an auction held in May 1998. The Ministry of Finance was told to repay approximately 13,000 euros after the auction was annulled. Avramenko demanded an amount equivalent to the one paid for shares, but his application was turned down. This way, the right of the applicant to a fair trial and the right to protection of property were violated, according to the ECHR.

The ECHR has obliged Moldova in the second case to pay a pecuniary damage in the amount of 28,333 euros and another 2,000 euros in non-pecuniary damage to the society Venera-Nord-Vest Borta AG. Venera-Nord-Vest Borta AG has lodged an application with the ECHR as the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova had violated its rights by quashing a judgment in its favour, at the appeal of prosecutor-general, and passed a decision to reject the claims of the plaintiff.

The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe held on February 13–14 the first meeting planned for 2007 for the supervision of the execution of ECHR judgments. The meeting also examined the non-execution of the judgment on Ilascu case and the answer of Moldova and Russia to the 4th Interim Resolution on this case.

Republic of Moldova – European Union

The European commissioner for External Relations and European Neighbourhood Policy, Benita Ferrero-Waldner, was set to visit Chisinau in early February. However, her visit was cancelled, with the European Commission Delegation saying that the European official was feeling bad. The visit of Ferrero-Waldner to Chisinau should follow a meeting that she has recently had with Moldovan Foreign Minister Andrei Stratan in Brussels. It is worth to note that Mr. Stratan has told the meeting that the gaining of the Autonomous Trade Preferences (ATP) and the negotiation of the visa facilitation and readmission agreements are the priorities of Moldova in the dialogue with the E.U.

According to Octavian Calmic, chief of the directorate general for trade policies of the Ministry of Economy and Commerce (MEC), Moldova is expecting a draft decision by the European Commission on awarding of ATP by late February 2007. Further, the draft shall be coordinated with all E.U. member states in 6–7 months. So, Moldova hopes to obtain the ATP in the second half of 2007. Meantime, Chisinau will have to work more in order to enhance the credibility of the goods origin certification system, to improve the customs management and the auditing process at exporting enterprises. These are the main recommendations by a group of experts of the European Commission who have recently visited Chisinau to attend a meeting of the Moldova-E.U. Cooperation Subcommittee for Economy, Finance and Statistics.

As regards the signing of visa facilitation and readmission agreements, Brussels hosted the first round of negotiations in this respect on February 9, 2006. According to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration, the sides did not identify differences of principle on the draft readmission agreement, while the details that must be specified have rather a technical nature. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration has said in connection with the draft visa facilitation agreement that the Moldovan side argued its demand for E.U. visa issuance facilities and European officials will "consult this issue accordingly to internal E.U. procedures." The Foreign Ministry assured that there are no reasons to describe the first round of negotiations as a failure, the way some media outlets have reported.

Hungarian Kalman Mizsei was appointed as E.U. special representative to Moldova, as the mandate of his predecessor Adriaan Jacobovits de Szeged is over.

Kalman Mizsei has served as chief investment officer for Central and Eastern Europe with American International Group; chairman of the Hungarian Export Import Bank and of the Hungarian Export Credit Insurance Ltd.; vice president for Economic Programmes of the Institute for EastWest Studies; deputy director of the Institute for World Economics of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences. Mizsei has also acted as a senior advisor to governments of the region on their economic transition and reform, as well as on such issues as privatisation, debit relief governance, banking and bankruptcy reform. Before being appointed as E.U. special representative to Moldova, Mizsei acted between 2001 and 2006 as assistant secretary-general of the U.N. and director of the UNDP Regional Bureau for Europe and the Commonwealth of Independent States.

Republic of Moldova – Romania

Romanian President Traian Basescu stated to Pro TV Romania on February 4 that 800,000 Moldovan citizens seek Romanian citizenship and an assessment by Romanian authorities show that this figure could reach 1.5 million persons by the end of 2007. In the context, Basescu said that Romania would make a big problem to Europeans, if it awarded the Romanian citizenship to all applicants. For this reason, the Romanian president continued, Moldova should receive a European perspective like the Western Balkans. We recall that the Romanian president expressed this desire in the E.U. Parliament on January 31, 2007. Assuring the European parliamentarians that Moldovans subscribe to European values and, therefore, a European perspective must be considered for them, Basescu added that his country agrees that "the constitutional treaty and the institutional reform are the No.1 priorities of the E.U."

Romanian Minister of Administration and Interior Affairs Vasile Blaga recommended to the E.U. Justice and Home Affairs Council at a February 15 meeting that Romania coordinate the joint centre of E.U. member states, which will open in Chisinau to issue E.U. visas. The Moldovan Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration replied that "it is strange that Romanian authorities did not condescend to consult Moldova’s authorities, all the more the answer was negative, given the fact that Moldovan authorities are efficiently cooperating with Hungarian authorities starting August 2006 to open the visa issuance centre in Chisinau. The logic of launching such proposals with only one month before the inauguration of the centre is unclear."

According to the February 15 issue 79 of the Newsletter of the Romanian Ministry of Administration and Interior Affairs (MAIA), European Commission Deputy President Franco Frattini has welcomed Romania’s desire to participate in the opening of this centre and, following an agreement of principle, Romania will be able to start the preliminary procedures needed to create this centre either in direct coordination of Romania or in a formula of cooperation with other interested member states . According to the February 16 issue 80 of the Newsletter of the Romanian Ministry of Administration and Interior Affairs, the Strategic Committee on Immigration, Borders and Asylum will open talks on February 26 regarding concrete actions that will be taken to open the common European visa issuance centre in Chisinau .

Republic of Moldova – Ukraine

The former foreign minister of Ukraine, Boris Tarasyuk, has stated that the Ukrainian Ministry of Transportation and Communication is cooperating with Moscow to press Moldova in the carriage problem. Tarasyuk was quoted by Kommersant as saying that Ukrainian Minister of Transportation Nicolai Rudikovsky "has started deteriorating the relations with our partner from GUAM, Moldova, in Russia’s favour. The so-called capital renovation of the only railway bridge that links Moldova with the whole world via Ukraine has started this way." According to Tarasyuk, the construction of the railway communication junction Moldova-Ismail-Reni is blocked for the same reason and there were tries to block the flights operated by Air Moldova in Ukraine’s air space. The Ukrainian Ministry of Transportation and Communication described Tarasyuk’s accusations as groundless.

Republic of Moldova – Russian Federation

Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Grigory Karasin has met with Moldova’s ambassador in Moscow, Vasile Sturza, and raised concern with non-accreditation of some Russian diplomats in Chisinau.

Moldpres news agency has quoted "knowledgeable sources" as saying that Karasin referred to the non-accreditation of Oleg Astakhov, charge d’affairs in the Russian Embassy to Moldova, for approximately half a year. The Russian diplomat, former co-chairman of the Joint Control Commission on behalf of Russia, should exert his second mandate in Chisinau.

As regards the resumption of Moldovan wine exports to the Russian Federation, Gennady Onishchenko, head of the Russian service Rospotrebndzor, said in Moscow on February 6 that they will return "soon" to the Russian market, but they will be "discriminated" at a first stage compared with wines from other states. The official noted that "all Moldovan wines will be separately controlled at the border at a first stage beside the internal control system and they will be able to enter the market later."

In this context, it should be noted that the Russian Federation did not unblock the Moldovan wine exports though the relief of Moldovan wine deliveries was announced at a meeting between Moldovan and Russian presidents two months ago. Moldpres has quoted Gheorghe Cozub, chairman of the Moldovan Union of Wine Exporters as saying that this state of things is explained by an informal indication to delay the restart of exports as much as possible.

Republic of Moldova – United States

After the E.U. has accepted to negotiate the liberalisation of the visa regime, the United States has also posted desire to begin a dialogue in this respect with Chisinau. The U.S. ambassador to Moldova, Michael Kirby, has proposed the consideration of possibilities to liberalise the visa regime, at a meeting with Moldovan Deputy Premier Andrei Stratan, minister of foreign affairs and European integration.

According to the press service of the Moldovan Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration, representatives of U.S. and Moldovan consular services will meet soon to discuss the text of the future visa liberalisation agreement.


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Evolution of perceptions of social-economic and political situation (Part I)
Igor Botan

I. Trends revealed by surveys

At present, the evolution of perceptions of social-economic and political situation in Moldova must be estimated for two reasons: a) the absolute victory of the Party of Communists of the Republic of Moldova (PCRM) in the Parliament (3/4 of seats during two mandates) will turn 6 on February 25, 2007; b) the general local elections scheduled for late May-early June, elections which will suggest if the PCRM will be really able to bid for the third mandate of dominant party in 2009, too, are being prepared.

Such estimation is also required because, starting November 2001, the Institute of Public Policy (IPP) has measured the perceptions of social-economic and political situation with a stable periodicity within "barometers of opinion", on basis of a constant set of questions. The last factor is essential to understand the trends revealed by 11 measurements conducted in 5 years. In addition, the conduct of surveys commissioned by the same institution (IPP), in line with the same methodological requirements, with the same error margin enhances the confidence that the revealed trends reflect adequate perceptions of the real social-economic and political processes, in spite of different executors of surveys. Given the fact that people in Moldova still do not believe in surveys and they are suspicious that the public opinion is manipulated via surveys, it is necessary to note that focussing on both findings of surveys and deviations from "norm" may be useful. Truly, what findings of surveys, which show that the absolute majority of Moldovan citizens have constantly considered in the last 6 years that the things in our country went in a wrong direction, could tell us if the same citizens credited the ruling party with the highest rating, confirmed periodically at three elections?

How do you think, do things in Moldova go in a right or wrong direction?
For these reasons, the next barometer and other surveys conducted before elections, likely in March-May, will present interest for observing oscillations of evolution of trends outlined in the past 6 years.

The trends revealed by surveys should reflect somehow the political context, reactions of public opinion to sounding events in internal and external political lives, perceptible things which sometimes are not strongly observed: round o’clock protests held under the aegis of the Christian Democratic People’s Party (CDPP) in January-May 2002; the November 2003 protests against the "Kozak memorandum"; the strategic partnership that followed the "April 4, 2005" voting; the Russian Federation’s embargo on Moldovan agro-food products and wines; multiple sounding political scandals related to violation of rights of opposition, freedom of expression and freedom of mass media, etc.

Following may be the explanations of feeble reactions of citizens to the sounding events mentioned above: a) perception of citizens is basically influenced by the way the mass media covers the events and this is a very sensitive issue for political class; b) effects of important events are manifested much later in the virtue of inertia, when the capacity of establishing the cause-effect relation reduces significantly; c) difficult cumulative effects of many sounding events amplify or reduce the reactions of citizens. However, it was observed that Moldovans react very clearly and distinctly when their welfare is directly threatened. For this reason, both researchers and political class are very interested how the electoral conduct of people may influence the perception of social-economic and political situation of citizens.

II. Stability – premise of predictability of electoral conduct

The electoral behaviour of Moldovan citizens has its specifics for sure. A series of researches based on findings of surveys conducted in 1993–2000 demonstrated that under very bad conditions though in relative stability, the change of the electoral conduct was mainly due to the behaviour of political leaders, especially of high-ranking public functionaries. The results of the 1995 local elections, the 1996 presidential scrutiny, the 1998 parliamentary elections and the 1999 local elections demonstrate that social-economic and political shocks in that period inserted with interests of ruling groups and of those willing the governance produced the "migration" of leaders from one party to another and appearance of new parties or alliances. After the 1994 parliamentary elections, which were a reference point to establish the rating of parties and political leaders, "migration" of the latter after numerous splitting and coalitions attracted the sympathies of electors who have loyally followed the winding trajectories of leaders. Beside the "migration" of leaders, the only remarkable phenomenon with a major impact was the gradual elimination by PCRM of its temporary substitutes – the Agrarian Democratic Party of Moldova (ADPM) and the Unitatea-Yedinsto Union.

The February 25, 2001 parliamentary elections eliminated or started eliminating some "migrant" leaders from domestic political circuit and opened a new phase – the absolute governance of PCRM, this thing being valid at least in the past years. It must be clear that there were serious premises "to undermine the fidelity of electors" in the precedent phase and to start the new period of "electoral devotion": a) the August 1998 financial collapse in Russia had negative repercussions on Moldovan economy, and this influence was wholly manifested in 1999–2000; b) the 2000 constitutional crisis discredited completely the parties and political leaders, associates of the governance at that stage (former members of the Alliance for Democracy and Reforms (ADR) and supporters of former president Petru Lucinschi); c) very favourable conditions, which did not exist in other CIS member states in that period, for oppositional at the time PCRM to criticise governors for consequences of the financial collapse and constitutional crisis, including conditions for open electoral propaganda. The last factor is found in a report by the OSCE Mission on monitoring of the 2001 parliamentary elections. The correctness of public television in Moldova had never been highly appreciated before and after those elections, without any accusation regarding the coverage of the electoral campaign.

Thus, the absolute victory of PCRM at the 2001 elections is not the result of an unusual attitude of Moldovan citizens toward the communist ideology, while the re-election of PCRM in March 2005 confirms the merit of PCRM in stabilising the social-economic situation, which it knew to maintain despite of a very specific manner for a communist party, enjoying a relatively favourable conjuncture: a) the previous governments of Ion Sturza (ADR) and Dumitru Braghis in the period 1999–2000 have remedied many consequences of the financial collapse and its collateral effects; b) the strong growth of remittances from Moldovans working abroad coincided with the PCRM ruling; c) the strong regional economic growth, of which Moldova profited, too, has started. As a result, we may observe how satisfied Moldovan citizens have been of the economic condition in the past 6 years.

How satisfied you are with present economic condition of Moldova?
One may observe that only the number of those "not very satisfied" with the economic condition has decreased by approximately 20 percent since the PCRM gained the power, and this fact confirms the significant reduction of poverty rate. The other groups have accommodated to the "situation of stability". It is interesting that expectations of citizens did not foretoken anything special in the past years, confirming the accommodation to the existing situation.
How do you think, how will be the economic situation in Moldova after one year, in comparison with the present economic condition?
Another factor that attests the stability is linked to a relatively constant perception of citizens toward their main goods, primordial services offered by public institutions, as well as political condition in the country. Some governmental projects and programmes are slowly becoming effective, but sources of dissatisfaction are also outlined very clearly.
How satisfied you are with... (Enough/very satisfied)
But stability under predomination of dissatisfactions cannot be called but stagnation. Thus, development of economy, strengthening of order in country and combat of corruption continue to be regarded as the most important tasks of Moldova, but the interest for them is declining, though people remain still dissatisfied with situation in their country. A possible conclusion is that citizens believe less that these tasks may be achieved. Of course, media campaigns only, like those against corruption, may produce oscillations of citizens’ perceptions. In this situation,
How do you think, what tasks are most important for Moldova at present? (Choose three answers in order of priorities)
citizens propose interesting remedies. In this regard, two contrary options compete distinctively – "growth of state’s role" and "awarding of more facilities to private sector."
What should be done to improve the social-economic situation in Moldova? (Choose 3 answers)
The fact that the option "changing the state leadership" remains more or less constant is also significant because only approximately 15 percent of respondents regard it as an urgent measure to improve the social-economic situation.

III. What threatens the stability?

There are very clear indicators that both authorities and leaders of the ruling party and opposition understand that the current stability in Moldova is related to stagnation. Governors are interested to get rid of stagnation but don’t want to lose control on situation; that means on stability. The opposition claims change, knowing from precedent experiences that the electorate sanctions the political forces which are to blame for destabilisations that have negative consequences on welfare. This fact explains many recent political developments in Moldova.

So far, the rapid price rise is the highest danger for stability. The recent rise of gas prices confirms the concerns that citizens raised in surveys. There are many factors that influence the dynamic rise of prices, but the most important rests with the chain effect challenged by higher prices of natural gas. Other factors that threaten the stability have a political nature and are linked to Moldova’s relations with the Russian Federation. Of course, consequences of the Russian embargo on Moldovan agro-food products and wines will manifest in continuation, though the interdictions are considered to be verbally withdrawn. Intentions of speculation of destabilising factors were very clear in the first half of 2005, when the Moscow-based organisation Patria-Moldova, which claims to represent the interests of all Moldovans working abroad, supported by Transnistrian circles, tried to provoke an acute crisis in Moldova, speculating in mass media the imminence of a financial collapse and calling upon citizens to urgently withdraw their savings from banks.

What worries you most now? (Choose 3 answers)
Given these circumstances and the forthcoming general local elections, Moldovan authorities have taken a series of actions to maintain the social-economic and political equilibrium in country:

  1. The Moldovan Government and Moldova-Gaz Company on one side and the Russian giant Gazprom on the other side signed natural gas delivery agreements for the next five years in late December 2006. On this occasion, the chairman of the parliamentary commission for state security, Iurie Stoicov, PCRM deputy, had a special intervention at a plenary sitting of the Parliament to proudly announce the Government’s performance in ensuring the energy security and stability;
  2. The public mass media has described a discussion between Presidents Vladimir Voronin and Vladimir Putin that took place in Minsk after the CIS summit as a normalisation of Moldova-Russia relations, which will withdraw the embargo on Moldovan products. Indeed, the discussion between the two presidents had only soothing effects on Moldovan public opinion;
  3. Moldova has obtained the promise of international donors to give a substantial financial assistance estimated at approximately 1.2 billion dollars for the next three years, which should reduce the effects of Russia’s economic pressures on Moldova. This is an important thing for maintaining the European orientation of Moldova;
  4. Authorities have managed, with the support of the U.S., E.U. and main international institutions, at least to maintain attitudes toward the Transnistrian conflict, border control and a minimum record of exports of Transnistria, under conditions of an open and provocative support of the Russian Federation for the separatist regime. This thing aims to fortify the European option of Moldova, which is essential to maintain the "strategic partnership for the European integration and settlement of the Transnistrian conflict," declared by ruling party and Opposition;
  5. Leaders of the "constructive opposition" have publicly reconfirmed the "strategic partnership" between the ruling party, CDPP and DP, as the winter parliamentary session has finished.

The "active" opposition has criticised the accomplishment of the governance and its "allies", attributing the few performances to the favourable internal and external conjuncture. However, the latest most sounding event was not challenged by criticism of the "active" opposition, but by recommendations launched in the mid-January 2007 via Radio Free Europe by U.S. analyst Vladimir Socor, who recommended the maintenance of the "strategic partnership between the PCRM and the CDPP as a guarantee of the political stability, with a determinant impact on political alliances before the 2009 parliamentary elections.

(To be continued)


Heating, the dearest electoral agent
Iurie Gotisan

Government lures population with subsidies and throws heating system on city hall�s shoulders...

The introduction of reference prices for the heating supplied to population in the centralised system increased approximately 2.4-fold the price of a gigacalory starting January 1, 2007. Of course, a rise of heating tariffs was expectable after the natural gas prices have grown. Indeed, there were many tries of this kind in the past years. The tariff of 233 lei per gigacalory was established in 1999. Authorities tried to increase the tariff up to 267 lei in late 2000, but the country was on the brink of parliamentary elections and this measure was given up. Other tries to increase the heating tariff followed later, but they finally failed. However, the Chisinau Municipal Council (CMC) gave green light on January 25 to a rise of the heating tariff up to 540 lei per gigacalory. It was also decided that about 220 million lei will be allocated from the municipal budget to cover the difference of price before the new heating season.

The state is subsidising the centralised heating system in almost all European countries because the heating providing service is the most expensive one. For example, these countries practice two forms of indemnities: compensations for vulnerable people and subsidies for heating enterprises. Of course, if these enterprises are efficient and are productive at maximum. Or, our heating system is facing another situation. It is interesting that city hall functionaries said when the new tariff was approved that the municipal budget does not include resources for subsidies and indemnities. It was known for sure that the tariffs will be finally increased and so the city hall administration should think about consequences on summer.

The passing of Termocom from administration of Government to management of local authorities was often followed by turnoffs and huge losses in system. Consumers are not told anything but the fact that the price of a gigacalory is increased in bearable limits. However, all of us pay the subsidy, including those who do not have any connection with the centralised heating system any longer. Local authorities are trying to make an "electoral agent" from heating in terms that the rise of tariffs allowed by reference price will be "controlled" so that not to affect the sympathy capital of population. The negative result of the political equation also affects the system, which may "crack" the next years if not now. And the price of this disaster would be tens of millions of lei thrown in subsidies, not normally invested.

At the same time, the Termocom administration is sure that the higher tariffs will cover all expenses of the enterprise. However, in spite of massive subsidies paid to heating operators in the past years and of those promised for the next 2-3 years, the plants produce energy by suffering losses. The helpless situation of the centralised heating system is firstly linked to the bad management. Local reference prices do not cover at least half (about 40 percent after the rise of natural gas prices) of the production costs of heating because some heating is lost somewhere on the route and nobody knows or wants to stop these losses. If heating producers and providers do not invest in renovation and modernisation of distribution networks, so that to reduce the system losses, no rise of tariffs or granting of state subsidies will resolve their problem. Otherwise, the real cost of a gigacalory will exceed the medium European level after several years because of high gas prices and our energy-consuming and inefficient system.


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]