ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20070731/index.shtml


e-journal, year V, issue 100, July 17–31, 2007

Activity of Public Institutions

Transdnistrian Problem

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1.1. Appointments. Dismissals

The Parliament has appointed the leadership of the National Commission of Financial Market (NCFM), the so-called "financial mega-regulator":

Chairman: Mihail Cibotaru (member of the Chamber of Auditors, ISS officer);
Deputy Chairwoman: Aurica Doina (controller of the Chamber of Auditors);
Members: Vladimir Morari (CCCEC officer); Alexandra Puscas (employer of an international financial project).

At the same time, the Parliament has dismissed all members of the National Commission for Securities (predecessor of NCFM), Dumitru Ursu (appointed on 20.04.2006), Iurie Tirdea (appointed on 28.07.2005), Vasile Pentelei (appointed on 17.02.2005), Ghenadie Ciobanu (appointed on 06.12.2002), without a plausible and concrete motivation, though their 7-year mandates did not expire yet.

1.2. Legal acts

Law on state-guaranteed legal assistance. The document regulates the conditions, volume and mode of granting of the state-guaranteed legal assistance for protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms, other legitimate interests of people, ensuring of a free and fair access of everybody to qualified legal assistance. The assistance will be primary (granting of information and consulting) and secondary (granting of legal services and representation). The document is part of a package of acts for the judicial reform and its enforcement is a priority action for the implementation of the Moldova-European Union Action Plan (EUMAP) in 2007.

Law on status of information officer. It regulates the legal status of information officer of the Information and Security Service (ISS) of Moldova and the mode of functioning of the special service. The officer is in charge with organising, planning, conducting and controlling the information and counter information activity; collecting, verifying, storing, analysing and using information about national security; executing operative and special activity against terrorism and actions that undermine the national security; protecting the state secret, etc. The law is part of debts related to respect for commitments and tasks of member states of the Council of Europe.

Law on modification and completion of the Law on Superior Council of Magistracy (SCM) (introduction of the Legal Inspection). The document launched by Moldovan president seeks the creation of the Legal Inspection to advise the SCM. This body will be in charge with controlling the organisational activity aimed at making justice; examining petitions from citizens concerning ethics of judges; verifying appeals of the Prosecutor-General regarding the consent of SCM for filing criminal cases; verifying grounds used by Moldovan president or Parliament to turn down candidacies proposed by SCM to posts of judges or promotion of judges. Competent experts feared that the document does not clearly regulate the status of the Inspection and the mode of creation of this body, and this situation may challenge doublings or conflicts of competences.

Law on prevention and combat of money laundering and financing of terrorism. The Council of Europe (CoE) has studied the new law, which is a commitment assumed within the E.U.-Moldova Action Plan. Independent surveys signalled a selective and inefficient takeover of community regulations in the area, as well as other shortcomings of this document, including the awarding of excessive discretionary functions and excessive regulation rights to competent authorities.

Law on modification and completion of the April 26, 2001 Law # 100-XV on civil status acts. The law establishes the legal status of the civil status service and seeks the simplification of the process of transcription of civil status papers issued on names of Moldovan citizens by foreign authorities, empowering territorial civil status offices of Moldova and diplomatic missions or consular offices of Moldova to transcript these documents.

Law on modification and completion of the law on public associations. The Government has promoted the amendments without the necessary preliminary consultation and transparency, following the declared goal "to adjust them to regulations of the Civil Code." Many nongovernmental organisations have raised essential disagreements with some provisions when the Parliament studied this draft. The draft was finalised after the proposals have been discussed with representatives of civil society organisations, with some of their initiatives being accepted.

Law on modification and completion of the law on ombudsmen and decision on modification of the Regulation on the Centre for Human Rights of Moldova (CHRM). The amendments came after the Optional Protocol to the U.N. Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment was enforced on July 24, 2006. According to the protocol, every state appoints or introduces independent mechanisms to prevent the torture at national level. It is worth to notice that intentions of authorities to award these functions to CHRM have raised the criticism of nongovernmental institutions in charge with protection of human rights (Amnesty International, Helsinki-Moldova Committee).

Law on modification and completion of the March 28, 1995 Law # 411-XIII on Healthcare. Under the law, heads of public medical-sanitary institutions created by Health Ministry or local public authorities are selected at contests and the Health Ministry dismisses them. This amendment is motivated by "the lack of necessary competences of local public authorities in the law on administrative decentralisation and the law on local public administration." Independent observers raise concerns with these amendments, fearing that they may allow a selection of heads of these local (district) medical institutions on political-administrative and economic criteria.

Law on modification of the law on 2007 state budget. The Government motivates the changes with the "situation of agriculture" and estimation of additional collections to the budget from VAT, customs duties and reduction of amounts for repayment of excise stamps. The highest rises envisage the growth of the fund for subsidising of farmers and rise (doubling) of the reserve fund of executive. Earlier, the Chamber of Auditors and opposition parliamentarians, mass media and other independent observers have repeatedly signalled serious shortcomings linked to administration of the reserve fund of executive, faulty and abusive use of the money from this fund including for political and conjuncture goals.

Law on modification and completion of the law on republican fund and local social assistance funds for people. It establishes a new modality of raising the tax from mobile telephony operators: 2.5 percent of the earning on sales of these services.

Law on modification and completion of the law on river and water basin protection areas and strips. It introduces amendments on classification of water areas and river protection strips, as well as special regulations on coordination of activities in these areas: with the central authority in charge with administration of natural resources; central health authority; state ecological survey agency; agency in charge with evaluation of the impact on environment. The new provisions are based on experience of neighbouring countries, particularly of the Russian Federation.

Law on completion of Article 24 of the May 31, 1990 Law # 64-XII on Government. It stipulates the creation of the Agency Apele Moldovei as a Government-controlled competent central body. The agency will be created through reorganisation of the Republican Water Management Concern Apele Moldovei. The need is motivated by "idea to bring together all the tasks linked to management of waters and water systems, as well as implementation of the strategy on water and sewerage delivery to Moldovan localities, into a single public institution."

Law on modification and completion of the Customs Code and Tax Code. It regulates aspects of functioning of duty-free markets at ground crossing points of the state border (Moldovan-Romanian border). It is worth to note that the previous legislation which allowed the functioning of such markets was modified at the indication of state leadership, with the purpose to obstruct these activities, which "have facilitated tax avoidance schemes and other customs frauds." The actions of authorities made some economic agents appeal to international courts and the ECHR has recently sentenced Moldova to pay huge damages (520,000 Euros in the case Bimer vs. Moldova).

Laws on extension of some terms for enforcement and execution of legal norms:

Laws on ratification of some international acts:

Decision approving the judiciary strengthening strategy. The Parliament adopts this decision. Art. 1. – the judiciary strengthening strategy is approved accordingly to the annex which is part of this decision. Art.2. – the Government will ensure the implementation of the judiciary strengthening strategy and will work out draft legislative acts needed to implement the strategy and will deliver them to the Parliament.

Decision on granting of additional benefits to members of the Parliament. It increases the fees for sittings (from 30 up to 100 lei) and the compensation for transportation expenditures (from 300 lei up to 500 lei per parliamentarian). Also, it introduces a dismissal indemnity worth 6 monthly remunerations paid when the mandate of the Parliament is over, and annual compensations worth a monthly salary for treatment in sanatoriums. The draft decision is not accompanied by a public arguing note or results of economic, financial and anti-corruption surveys.

1.3. Statements

The parliamentary faction representing the Our Moldova Alliance (AMN) released a statement "on situation of agriculture" on July 19, 2007, seeking urgent measures to improve the situation of agriculture, in particular, "to stop the destruction of small agricultural entrepreneur."

Speaker and all faction leaders have told their opinions about activity of the Parliament and evolution of social-political situation in country, at the end of the summer session:


Government

2.1. Appointments. Reshuffles

2.2. Decisions

Decision approving the regulation on e-mail system of public authorities. The Information and Security Service will ensure the functioning and security of the system. The system will be gradually built by 2009.

Decision on creation of a working group to monitor the strategic foreign direct investment inflows and related transactions. Under this decision, central bodies of public administration will coordinate beforehand with the working group all actions for promotion of strategic investments in national economy and will take actions to attract investments only after the working group makes a decision in this respect.

Decision on monitoring of import operations. The state will regulate the prices of a series of goods imported by individuals and businesses. The Customs Service will monitor the import transactions of economic agents and will notify the State Tax Inspectorate and the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption, if it discovers that the prices of goods are by 40 percent higher than the prices from this decision. This mechanism aims to discover fiscal evasions after undervaluation of imported goods at customs stations and to enhance budget collections on account of customs duties.

Decision on implementation of the action programme on implementation of the new system of evaluation of real estate for taxation. As many as 20,035 commercial real estates and 6,458 industrial real estates have been evaluated and data on 40,329 garages and 24,543 plots of fruit-growing associations have been collected in the period concerned (from October 1, 2006 to May 1, 2007). The list of problems includes: non-presentation of lists of holders of the right to location of non-privatised apartments, insufficient cooperation between territorial cadastral offices and local public administrations, etc.

Decisions approving some programmes, concepts, strategies:

Decisions approving some draft laws:

Decisions on allocation of finances from the reserve fund of the Government:

2.3. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Working group for problems of entrepreneurs

The prime minister has met representatives of the Foreign Investors Associations in Moldova and the talks focussed on attraction of more investments. Investors said that the dialogue between central public administration and business community has advanced much in the past years and new investments in Moldovan economy have essentially helped improving the business community. In particular, it was stressed that the Government is receptive to diverse problems, including those signalled in the White Book. At the same time, investors said that actions aimed at improving the legislative-normative and fiscal framework must continue, in order to create new stimulatory conditions for attraction of foreign capital in Moldova. In the context, they signalled a series of problems that must be solved via a permanent dialogue. In order to maintain a permanent and efficient dialogue, it was decided to create a special working group to operatively work out and propose optimal solutions to problems occurring in entrepreneurial activity.

Proposals of young prime ministers concerning the draft National Development Plan (NDP)

Members of the club of young prime ministers have discussed aspects of the NDP goals and raised proposals worked out after consulting sittings with the participation of youths from areas, diverse nongovernmental organisations. The initiatives seek more support for participation of youths in social and economic processes in country. The prime minister encouraged the youths to continue their active participation in public debates and drafting of diverse documents on youth. In the context, the prime minister asked the club members to study and tell their opinions about the functioning concept of the Republican Youth Centre.


Transdnistrian Problem

President Voronin makes a series of statements on Transnistria

During the period covered here President Vladimir Voronin made a series of statements on the Transnistrian settlement process within a press-conference and an ample interview with NIT TV Station. The main theses that President Voronin put forward in his statements could be summed up as follows:

A recurring theme in President Voronin’s statements on Transnistria has been a series of charges against the opposition parties of having compromised the political consensus on the Transnistrian settlement and of opposing an eventual settlement for fears of losing "their personal, political and patrimonial welfare".

It is worth noting that in an interview with Radio Free Europe the US Ambassador to Moldova, Michael Kirby, noted that although it is necessary for Moldova to talk to Russia about the Transnistrian settlement, Moldova should also talk to other partners in the "5+2" format, which remains the best format for discussing any solutions. Ambassador Kirby invoked the precedent of the so-called Kozak Memorandum, which could have undermined the territorial integrity of Moldova, and said that in the context of the intense Moldovan-Russian talks in the past months US wanted to know what was happening. "There was a huge tempest, but it is not clear if it was a tempest or a tempest in a teapot", the US diplomat said referring to those talks.

Transnistrian exports to the EU on rise

According to a communique released by the Ministry of Reintegration, 70 Transnistrian businesses registered with the Moldovan State Registration Chamber in the first half of 2007. This has brought to 338 the number of Transnistrian businesses registered permanently or temporarily with the Moldovan authorities to date. Of these, 45 economic agents registered after the adoption of Government Decision no. 301 on 17 March 2007, whereby both permanent and provisional registration with the Moldovan authorities gets Transnistrian business access to trade preferences enjoyed by Moldova as part of its GSP+ agreement with the EU. In January – June 2007, Moldovan Customs Service issued 635 preferential certificates of origin to 17 Transnistrian businesses for exports to the EU. Transnistrian exports to the EU have increased by 17.4 % compared to 2005 and the EU has ranked second after the CIS as the final destination of Transnistrian exports (37%).

Overall Transnistrian exports in the first half of 2007 were twice as much as in the same period of 2006. Steel and light industry products accounted for most of the region’s exports. The Moldova Trade and Industry Chamber issued 3,386 certificates of origin for Transnistrian produced export items in the first half of 2007, which is 37% more than in 2006.

Economic analysts have explained this growth in Transnistrian exports to the EU by the fact that Romania, traditionally one of the main destinations of Transnistrian exports, is from 1 January 2007 an EU Member State. The access to European Trade Preferences that Transnistrian businesses gained as a result of their registration with Moldovan de jure authorities is another key factor.

This data shows that despite the official propaganda businesses in the region operate normally, more than that, they expand to new markets. This data also shows the benefits that the registration of Transnistrian businesses with the Moldovan authorities bring to their activity, but also in a broader sense to the reintegration of the economic space of Moldova.

It is worth noting that on 13 July the Inter RAO EES owned Transnistrian Power Plant in Dnestrovsc (Kuciurgan), one of the largest Transnistrian enterprises, resumed exports to Romania. The plant will increase its production capacity twice by operating two more power blocks in addition to the two blocks working at the moment. The company expects to export to Romania over one billion kilowat in the first year of operation at the price of 0.05 USD per kilowat.


Foreign Affairs

European integration

Sitting on implementation of EUMAP

The chief of state held a sitting on implementation of the European Union – Moldova Action Plan (EUMAP) on July 24, 2007. Taking part in the sitting were important decision makers from central public institutions. President Voronin stressed the need of implementing the EUMAP goals in the due terms, in order to bring Moldova closer to the "European standards and values on multiple plans, including the free move of citizens, goods and capital." Also, it was noted that every institution must respect its action plan agreed with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration and it was stressed the need to remedy the shortcomings related to implementation of EUMAP signalled at the June 2007 Luxembourg meeting of the E.U.-Moldova Cooperation Council.

We recall that the E.U. has underlined at that meeting the "need for Moldova to redouble its efforts aimed at implementing democratic reforms in crucial areas such as respect for human rights, freedom of the media and respect for the rule of law, including the independence of the judiciary. It also stressed the importance of a transparent business environment and anti-corruption fight."[1] (Bold – ADEPT)

Bilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Romania

Public talks on two of the existing problems related to the Moldova-Romania relationship have been resumed in the period covered by this issue of the journal. In particular, the citizenship issue and the problem of opening of two Romanian consulates in Moldova have been discussed. President Vladimir Voronin has resumed the talks.

President Voronin has accused Romania during a broadcast aired by TV channel NIT that it profits of the situation when Moldovans cannot travel to the E.U. without visas and proposes them the Romanian citizenship.

The chief of state delivered this statement shortly after Kalman Miszei, E.U. Special Representative for Moldova, would recently invited Romania to restrict the citizenship awarding procedure. According to the Bucharest Ministry of Justice, 2,430 applications for Romanian citizenship have been accepted after the simplified citizenship awarding procedure was suspended in 2002, compared with 98,000 applications accepted before.

Elsewhere, Voronin said that Moldova will not open two Romanian consulates in Balti and Cahul in the near future because of the lack of "a mutual interest". Romanian Foreign Minister Adrian Cioroianu replied that Bucharest is still interested to open two consulates in Balti and Cahul and revealed that his ministry has reiterated a request in this respect to the Moldovan Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration.

Republic of Moldova – Russia

After having demanded samples from five Moldovan wine companies such as Vismos, Calarasi-Divin, Buket Moldavii, DK-Intertrade and Kvint (all with Russian capital), the Russian food security supervisor Rospotrebnadzor allowed the first three wineries to export their production to the Russian market.

According to Valeriu Mironescu, director of Moldova-Vin Agency, the decision to test the wines of five companies only is discrimination and it is unknown so far how the choice was made.

Moldovan President Vladimir Voronin has also raised dissatisfaction with this decision by Rospotrebnadzor and described it as unacceptable for Chisinau. He noted that either all Moldovan enterprises or none of them will be authorised to export, and instructed the Moldova-Vin director not to issue excise stamps as long as Russia does not accept all Moldovan producers.

Multilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe

Respect for CoE recommendations

Speaker Marian Lupu told a summary news conference on activity of the Parliament that all legislative actions stipulated by cooperation programme between Moldovan Parliament and CoE have been implemented during the spring-summer 2007 session with two exceptions. He indicated the failure to adopt in the second reading the draft law on political parties and their financing and the Education Code.

It is worth to note that this programme should be implemented in 2005–2006. Secondly, the Parliament is late to adopt new laws on status of the Chisinau municipality and consolidation of parliamentary immunity; it did not condemn so far the principle of dismissal of Comrat mayor by People’s Assembly of Gagauzia and did not investigate many criminal charges brought against opposition leaders at national and local levels – all these actions are stipulated by the programme concerned.

ECHR judgment

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) passed a judgment on Gorea vs. Moldova on July 17. The Strasbourg-based Court indicated the violation of Article 5�1 of the Convention (legality of jail) , as Grigore Gorea was jailed without a legal warrant after the term of the arrest warrant issued on his name has expired. Moldova was told to pay 9,000 Euros to the applicant in non-pecuniary damages and 2,500 Euros in costs and expenses, as well as any other fees which will be paid from these amounts. The ECHR has sentenced Moldova in 68 cases until now, obliging it to pay damages worth approximately 1.43 million Euros to applicants.


1 EU Council (2007), EU-Moldova Cooperation Council Ninth meeting, Luxembourg, 19 June, EU Press Communique, 11009/07 (Presse 143)


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Death of political partnership
Igor Botan

I. Propagandistic explosions

Propagandistic explosions featuring the chief of state as lead character took place in the mid-July, immediately after it came out that representatives of the ruling party have been elected as chairmen of less than 1/3 of districts. District councillors elected on June 3 on behalf of the ruling party and on behalf of approximately five or six opposition parties have obstructed each other for about one month and a half while electing the chairmen of district executives. This explains the apparent delay of the propagandistic wave launched to libel the opposition and to threat citizens directly or indirectly for making a "wrong" choice on June 3.

Neither the ruling party nor the "aggregated opposition" hold at least 2/3 of mandates of councillors in approximately 3/4 of districts, so that under the law on local public administration the sittings became deliberative through a simple majority only by the third meeting. The aggregated opposition heads approximately 2/3 of districts after negotiating a coalition. The games of mutual blockage exceeded the limit after the third sitting in the district of Rezina was invalidated again, so that the district council will be dissolved and new elections will take place in two months.

The chief of state has acknowledged an absolutely new political situation in Moldova has emerged as a result of the elections of chairmen of districts. In the view of this new situation he has declared the end of the "political partnership" with the "constructive opposition" which plotted with the "intransigent opposition" against the Party of Communists of the Republic of Moldova (PCRM). However, the PCRM leader avoided explanations why these opposition entities made the pact and which purpose the "political partnership" declared defunct was to serve?

Detailed answers to these questions may be found in election monitoring reports by the OSCE Mission, which signalled an unprecedented harassment of opposition candidates by administrations led by PCRM representatives. In this respect, the conclusion made in diplomatic terms in the preliminary report is quintessential: "The electoral legislation of the Republic of Moldova ensures an adequate basis for democratic elections to the degree in which it is applied with good will". Obviously, the "good will" lacked, and this lack became fatal for maintaining the "political partnership" which was declared in 2005 for the purpose of "the European integration of the Republic of Moldova." A credible "European integration" process is impossible when the opposition is harassed and the mass media is manipulated, according to facts stated in the report.

II. Threats resulting from the PCRM defeat

In principle, the PCRM does not have reasons for dissatisfaction. Its representatives have gained leadership offices in 1/3 of districts, and this result perfectly correlates with the number of votes garnered by this party nationwide – 34.2 percent. It gained these votes in conditions of a total control over the administrative resources and a quasi-total control of national audiovisual outlets. Thus, this is not an artificial injustice for the PCRM. However, it is the victory of the Our Moldova Alliance (OMA) that amplifies the feeling of loss by the PCRM in two thirds of districts. OMA leader Serafim Urechean has become the dedicated "political enemy" of President Voronin after being harassed in the past five years. The concern and anger of the chief of state are linked to the disproportion of OMA’s success – 17 percent of the votes of electors versus more than 40 percent of the posts of district chairmen.

From the perspective of the 2009 parliamentary elections, the capacity of attraction of OMA is growing due to the impression of ascension produced by results of election of district chairmen. This happens on background of dramatic decline of the PCRM, which continues to excel in making "political enemies" only. To obtain this result, it was worth for Serafim Urechean to declare after the June 3 elections that "the options of the voters demand that the approaches set by the 4 April 2005 act be left to history".

If the OMA has reconfirmed its capacity of becoming the nucleus of a strong liberal pole, the statement delivered after elections regarding the coalition between the Party of Social Democracy of Moldova (PSDM), the Social Democratic Party of Moldova (SDPM) and the Centrist Union of Moldova (CUM) to create a social-democratic coalition which would merge in a single party before the 2009 parliamentary elections is a clear pretence to building a new social-democratic pole. It would have an unpredictable influence on the process or erosion of the PCRM, which is declining and is very late with reforming and modernising itself.

Given the results of the recent local elections, the new social-democratic party would enjoy a minimum electoral potential of more than 10 percent at the beginning. The existence of some known leaders, including the most experienced one, Dumitru Braghis, former prime minister, is another incontestable advantage. The fact that the leaders of the social-democratic coalition have not been observed to share anti-Russian attitudes and rhetoric would make credible by 2009 their pretence to want to replace the PCRM in the role the latter has assumed lately, that of improving the relations with Russia. While the PCRM leader claims that he wants to repair the deteriorated relations with Russia, leaders of the social-democratic coalition could invoke the privilege of relations unaffected by participation in previous conflicts such as the "Kozak memorandum", economic embargoes, etc. Another important fact is that the social-democratic coalition has the largest potential for creating a social-democratic pole of attraction for those disappointed with the PCRM policies.

The fact that the elements of the social-democratic coalition have been left out of the majoritay coalition in the Chisinau municipality council, the favourite target of the PCRM propaganda, places it outside the epicentre of propagandistic clashes and battles. This circumstance allows the social-democratic coalition to seek the role of the "third force."

III. The reform of PCRM

The defeat of the PCRM in local elections has brought back to the fore the problem of modernisation of this party. The plenary of the Central Committee decided on July 7, 2007 to convoke the 6th congress on March 15, 2008 to amend the statute and political programme of the party. Nothing surprising. Such announcements have been made periodically after the May 2002 plenary sitting. However, plenary sittings, party conferences and even the December 2004 5th congress made cosmetic changes only.

Until the recent local elections the refusal to modernise the PCRM were explained through the fact that the unreformed party enjoys broad popular support anyway. Now that the PCRM has lost the 3 June local elections, this argument is not valid any longer. In fact, the party should have modernised a long time ago. The difference between "before and after elections" is that if the PCRM was reformed before the elections, then its orthodox members would have invoked the reform as the cause of defeat. Now after the actual defeat in elections some PCRM reformists invoke the belated modernisation as its cause.

The latter are right: one thing is to modernise a successful party in order to fuel and develop its success and another thing is to modernise a party with the purpose to rescue it. But this remark is not good for the PCRM because "reformed" or unreformed it would maintain the same essence as long as Vladimir Voronin leads it. He is the main pillar of the PCRM and his behaviour and nature cardinally mark the party and cannot be changed or reformed. It may be said that Voronin’s charisma has ensured the success of the party, but now it has become the main obstacle in changing its essence. Voronin will be some kind of Taras Bulba for the PCRM that he has masterminded, irrespective of whether the communist doctrine will be changed by a socialist one or not.

In this regard, the reformation of PCRM may be reduced to the editing of the status and programme. Indeed, it cannot be postponed any longer after President Voronin proclaimed the "liberal revolution" in April 2007 while the party’s programme stipulates in particular that "the supreme goal of PCRM is to build a communist society." Articles I (6) and II (20) from statute of PCRM explicitly stipulate sanctions, including the expulsion from party "for actions running counter to the programme."

The most significant fact is that although there is a consensus to modify the status and the programme of PCRM, there is no consensus on changing its name. President Voronin has constantly resisted to the change of the party’s name in the past two years, though he promised to the "constructive opposition" doing so when seeking its vote for the second presidential mandate. At the same time, all media outlets affiliated to the PCRM and personally to Voronin did not report the viewpoint expressed at a recent news conference by Speaker Marian Lupu regarding the necessity of changing the name of PCRM and the transformation of this party into a European left-wing party.

The probability of an eventual schism of PCRM as a result of its failure in local elections and disagreements on the need of changing the name of this party is exaggerated, but not negligible. These discussions are supported by the mass media affiliated with the opposition parties interested in the collapse of PCRM. The party led by Vladimir Voronin had faced only one scandalous schism back in 1996, when the "piece" that had cut out from it later disappeared from political scene. An eventual split would render little credibility the groups breaking up with the PCRM at such a late stage. Therefore intestine wrangles are most likely. By all means, during the preparations for the March 2008 a series of out of ordinary developments of large resonance may take place.

IV. Probability of early parliamentary elections

The talks on an eventual rapid settlement of the Transnistrian conflict supported by statements by President Voronin that he is ready to stop his presidential mandate, if this would be a condition for speeding up the resolution, fuelled the allegations about preparation of early parliamentary elections. Another argument in favour of early elections is that the collapse of the PCRM at local elections was so sudden and the trends have become so suggestive that the PCRM is interested to organise early elections as soon as possible, and this secure the support it still has to avoid a total collapse at the 2009 elections.

There are several factors that make early parliamentary elections unlikely. Firstly, it is hard to believe that the PCRM may want early elections before the March 2008 reformation congress. After the congress, early elections may be provoked through artificial ways in the long term, so they are held in the autumn, half a year before they are due. Secondly, the Transnistrian conflict has such a big force of inertia that to believe in a rapid resolution is somewhat naive. However willing Russia could be to support a rapid resolution, it will insist on three principles, which it has invoked constantly and on numerous occasions: recognition of equality between the sides involved; respect for existing agreements between the sides; direct negotiations between the sides and adoption of mutual decisions supported by mediators. In addition, the conflict settlement negotiations cannot be withdrawn from a general context no matter how often Presidents Putin and Voronin meet "in secret" or "separately". For this reason, the schemes of organisation of early parliamentary elections to offer representation to Transnistrians, followed by awarding of high- administrative posts, etc., before adoption of a mutually accepted document of principle describing in details the consecutiveness of every action based on plenary respect for previous regulations and guarantees, are inconsistent.

As the rating of PCRM has declined down to 34 percent, the party will probably seek ordinary parliamentary elections, which must take place in March 2009. The synchronisation of parliamentary and presidential elections is the main trump of the PCRM. In these circumstances the PCRM may set itself the minimal task. The statements by President Voronin have already set the maximal task – that of revenge and regaining of position lost in the local elections. The minimal task is much more realistic – focusing efforts on at least maintaining the rating at the level of the 3 June local elections.

An elementary calculation shows that if political parties gain the same number of votes at the 2009 parliamentary elections as they garnered in districts in 2007, the PCRM would win exactly 41 mandates, the minimum number of deputy votes necessary to block the election of the president. The constitutional norm stipulates the election of the chief of state with three fifths of the votes of parliamentarians. After two failed attempts the Parliament is dissolved by the incumbent President. PCRM has already enjoyed twice this constitutional norm – in 2001 and 2005, when it has won the elections and convinced part of the opposition to re-elect Vladimir Voronin to the office of the president. The synchronisation of parliamentary and presidential elections suggests the "package" resolution of election of the chief of state, chairman of the Parliament and appointment of the Government. This could help PCRM to stay afloat and even to influence the further events.

So, one can conclude that President Voronin is the proponent of maximum task having announced the death of the "political partnership" to revenge. On the other hand, Speaker Marian Lupu is the proponent of the continuation of the "political partnership", indicating that the minimum task is much more realistic. This approach allows at least for the prevention of political destabilisation of large proportion. The autumn barometer of public opinion will show which of the two leaders is right.

V. Findings and expectations


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]