![]() | Association for Participatory Democracy | Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md Original: /en/e-journal/20071015/index.shtml |
Activity of Public Institutions
1.1. Appointments. Immunities
The Parliament has taken notice of the resignation demand of parliamentarian Ion Ciontoloi, who was elected on behalf of the Our Moldova Alliance (OMA). Ciontoloi has tendered resignation in connection with his election as chairman of the Causeni district. Earlier, the parliamentary majority has approved the withdrawal of the parliamentary immunity at the request of the Prosecutor-General’s Office and gave green light to the trying of Ciontoloi under penal charges, as he is accused of abusive administration of cooperative property. The fate of the penal case was not told to the public opinion.
Elena Pui was appointed member of the Management Board of the National Commission of Financial Market for a 2-year term.
Judge Nina Cernat was appointed deputy chairwoman of the economic college of the Supreme Court of Justice for a 4-year term, at the initiative of the Superior Council of Magistracy.
Deputy Vladimir Filat was excluded from the Moldovan Democratic Party faction after he has withdrawn from this party. Filat has become an "unaffiliated lawmaker".
1.2. Legal acts
Laws on ratification of some international acts:
Draft law on state registration of legal entities and individual entrepreneurs. The draft law passed in the first reading was worked out to implement the concept on automatic information system called state register of legal entities" and to execute the legislative programme for 2005–09, aiming to replace the Law # l265-XIV from October 5, 2000 concerning state registration of enterprises and organisations. It brings a shorter registration and erasing procedure (shorter registration term, fewer documents, special stipulation of the list of documents needed for registration, ban of the demand of additional documents, online application for state registration, etc.)
Draft law on modification of some legal acts. The document voted in the first reading is linked to the closing of the administrative military department of the Ministry of Defence and takeover of competences regarding administrative military activity (conduct of administrative military activity in the territory, establishing and payment of pensions and indemnities to retirees of the Armed Forces and their families) by the General Staff of the National Army. The draft is also conditioned by optimisation of administrative military leadership and activity in compliance with Chapter VI of the 2nd Stage (2005–08) of the military reform concept approved under the Parliament Decision # 1315-XV from July 26, 2002.
Draft law on modification and completion of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova. The amendments aim to introduce harsher punishments for offences against children (illegal adoption, infantile pornography).
1.3. Parliamentary control. Statements
The chairman of the Parliament has promised to start controlling the execution of laws at plenary sittings of the legislature in late October. Commission chairmen must raise proposals until then regarding ways to conduct the control and the laws which will be verified accordingly to individual priorities.
Hearings
The Parliament has heard and debated on a report regarding the situation of agriculture and Government’s measures against the 2007 drought. Parliamentary opposition representatives described the actions of authorities as insufficient and inefficient, while seeking the aid of the international community is a premature step which deteriorates Moldova’s image.
Questions. Interpellations
OMA Deputy Anatolie Onceanu has asked the Prosecutor-General’s Office, the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption and the electronic media watchdog CCA to report if the airing frequency of the second national TV network (earlier owned by the Romanian Television Society) was legally awarded. In a second interpellation Onceanu asked the Government to report what provisions of the regulation on use of the reserve fund it has followed to distribute finances for the Culture Caravan in 2005–07, and demanded the Chamber of Auditors to control if the public funds used for this project have been legally and efficiently spent.
Christian Democratic Deputy Ion Varta has demanded information regarding the taking of credits from international financiers, when the situation on domestic market is favourable and there is a significant budgetary surplus. He demanded explanations, motivations, arguments regarding these credits; he wants to know the reimbursement conditions, interest rate, distribution mechanism, transparency, auctions, and the beneficiaries of these credits. Also, Varta asked the prosecutor-general and the prime minister to control if the persons in charge with publishing the official gazette Monitorul Oficial act legally, as they did not want for one month to publish the CCA decision on confirmation of Mr. Vlad Turcanu as CCA chairman.
Deputy Vladimir Filat has asked the Government to report the situation of students who visited the United States within the Work and Travel Programme and the situation regarding the resumption of wine exports to the Russian Federation.
Communist parliamentarian Victor Stepaniuc has asked the Government to take a position of principle towards Moldova-Romania relations.
Statements
Deputy Vitalia Pavlcenco has read a declaration by the National Liberal Party "concerning irresponsible statements delivered by President Vladimir Voronin after the local elections," expressing a deep concern with the anti-democratic actions of the chief of state.
2.1. Appointments. Reshuffles
The Government has appointed:
2.2. Decisions
Decision on activity of the Ministry of Economy and Commerce in 2006 and in the first half of 2007. The document certifies the fulfilment of some tasks: the implementation and monitoring of strategic documents; the improvement of business environment; the entrepreneurship regulation reform; the cooperation with international financial organisations; job openings, etc. The shortcomings include among others:
Decision accepting the cession of rights and obligations. The Government allows the Redeco L.T.D. Company to cede all the rights and commitments resulting from the July 6, 1995 cession agreement on research and exploitation of the crude oil and gas deposits of Moldova to the Valiexchimp S.R.L. Company. The rights and commitments of Valiexchimp S.R.L. do not include the prospecting and exploitation of crude oil and gas resources in Moldova. At the same time, a governmental commission in charge with monitoring the takeover of the rights and commitments resulting from the concession agreement is being created.
Decisions approving some draft laws:
Decisions on allocation of funds:
2.3. Sittings. Decisions. Statements
300,000 new jobs and a 300-dollar salary
The executive has heard a report by the Ministry of Economy and Commerce regarding the implementation of the Government decision # 1332 from 22.11.2006 on opening of 300,000 new jobs by 2009 and rise of the medium monthly salary on economy up to the equivalent of 300 U.S. dollars. According to the report, the medium salary in certain branches (air transportation, post, energy, tobacco industry) has already reached the planned level and workers from other sectors will have the planned earnings by the end of 2008. At the same time, budgetary workers could earn a medium salary of 300 dollars by mid-2009. Jobs open in a high pace, as 46,600 jobs opened in the first half of 2007, which is more than 66 percent of the plan for this year. In comparison with 2006, the indicator has grown 3.8-fold, with jobs opening in industry, trade, building, transportation and telecommunication sectors. At present, approximately 30,000 jobseekers are formally registered, while 35,000 jobs are available.
Combating illegal migration, trafficking and smuggling
The prime minister has chaired a working sitting on struggle against illegal migration, human trafficking and smuggling of commodities and currency. He admitted that the measures taken in these fields are insufficient to reach the assumed objectives, in spite of certain positive results. In order to combat these phenomena, Vasile Tarlev instructed the competent authorities to urgently promote the draft legislative and normative acts needed to improve the existing normative framework, and to work out and implement some realistic mechanisms for their further execution. The Interior Ministry will take the measures needed to boost the activity of the national committee against human trafficking and the competent governmental institutions will intensify the cooperation with civil society and mass media, in order to promote information, education and training campaigns. Also, preventive and practical measures will be taken among functionaries whose work is connected to migration and struggle against human trafficking, so that to find and sanction the corrupt persons. The Interior Ministry, the Information and Security Service, the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption, customs and border guard services will have to intensify their activity in order to discover and combat smuggling schemes and ways.
Attention toward CPA Reform
The premier has chaired a sitting of the governmental commission for Central Public Administration Reform, which heard a report on implementation of the reform by the Ministry of Health and studied priority reform-related actions for 2008. Commission members drew the conclusion that the Ministry of Health has taken most of actions stipulated by reform strategy. In order to fortify the activity, subordinated institutions could open to ensure the implementation of policies on technical-material base of medical-sanitary facilities and on sanitary management. Vasile Tarlev noted that the Ministry of Health is now the first central public administration institution which has started elaborating such a plan to optimise its structure. Commission members examined a draft action plan on implementation of the CPA Reform Strategy and supported most of the proposed measures, so that the document will be additionally discussed with all participating institutions and delivered for approval by the end of this year.
Development of transportation infrastructure
A working sitting has studied transportation infrastructure development projects in Moldova and the assessment envisaged the building and repairing of national roads the next years. It decided to focus on modernisation and repairing of the high traffic road sectors Chisinau-Balti, Chisinau-Hincesti-Cimislia-Comrat, Causeni-Stefan-Voda, Orhei-Rezina in 2008. The premier urged competent bodies to finalise the action plan on construction of the highway Giurgiulesti-Criva. At the same time, it was stressed the importance of ensuring the traffic infrastructure, including the renovation of wait pavilions at bus stations, information of roads, planting of nut trees on the brink of routes.
MFAEI collegial council
A sitting of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration collegial council has studied the present situation and perspectives to settle the Transdnistrian conflict. Participants also examined the work of Moldovan diplomatic missions, topics of political dialogue within European institutions on bilateral and multilateral dimensions. The importance of promoting a dynamic commercial-economic cooperation in order to widely ensure the foreign markets for Moldovan goods was particularly stressed. Diplomatic missions are expected to pay a greater attention to implementation of the strategy on attracting investments and promoting exports. In order to implement the basic tasks of the diplomatic missions, diplomats indicated the need of enhancing their responsibilities and improving the communication mechanism between missions and MFAEI.
Enhanced concern with using international assistance
According to a communication of the governmental press service, the executive is taking conjugated actions to efficiently use the foreign assistance worth 1.2 billion dollars declared within the Advisory Group of Donors for Moldova on December 12, 2006. A permanent process of use of the declared assistance and attraction of new sources for social-economic development of Moldova has started after that date. Approximately 800 million dollars are contracted for ongoing projects on sectors of major importance: education, development of private sector, infrastructure development, healthcare, development of agriculture, etc. The fields of assistance have been established for majority of funds identified jointly with all partners. The proper start of the projects is conditioned with standard pre-launching procedures such as finalisation of reference terms and other draft documents, negotiation process, approval of donor’s financing for projects, etc. According to the communication, the National Commission for Foreign Assistance created under the Government Decision # 322 from March 28, 2006, which includes members of Government, local public administration and civil society, is in charge with all decisions on use of foreign assistance and monitoring of ongoing projects.
3.1. Decrees
3.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements
Interest for activity of Apele Moldovei Agency
Moldova’s president has convoked governmental decision makers at a working sitting to discuss the water and sewerage providing services for localities, enlargement of irrigated fields. He was told that the reorganisation of Apele Moldova (Moldova’s Waters) Agency is over; agency director Veaceslav Iordan noted that the newly-created structure is ready to launch projects on renovation and extension of existing systems or construction of new water pipes, in line with the strategy on nationwide water and sewerage providing of localities. Vladimir Voronin stressed the need to accurately respect the quality standards while modernising and exploiting the water providing and sewerage networks. Speaking about irrigation of farm land, Voronin indicated the opportunity of districts to work out own programmes on enlargement of irrigated fields and the necessity to find additional finances for irrigation projects within diverse investment programmes.
New ideas and proposals on settlement of the Transdnistrian conflict[2]
Moldova’s president has launched many proposals on settlement of the Transdnistrian problem in mass media in the past two weeks. In particular, they call for:
Certain national and international observers welcomed the presidential initiatives, but the Tiraspol administration received them with scepticism.
Political-diplomatic meetings
The Moldovan president has had meetings with representatives of other countries and international organisations, including:
1. Prices and inflation
Rises by rises…
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) or the monthly inflation rate was 1.6 percent in September 2007. The cumulated inflation rate for three quarters was 9 percent. Prices of food products grew by 1.6 percent in September, of manufactured goods by 1.5 percent and tariffs of public services increased by 1.6 percent.
Inflation target for 2007 will be failed…
The 10-percent inflation target established by Government and National Bank of Moldova (NBM) will be failed for sure, though the central bank has increased the basic interest rate and the mandatory reserve rates for commercial banks. One anticipates possible price rises of volatile prices (vegetables, fruits or fuels) for the next months and this will probably increase the annual inflation rate in continuation.
…but it could decline due to appreciation of leu…
However, one believes that the inflation rate could decline a little this year due to the strong appreciation of the exchange rate. It was observed that the exchange rate has appreciated by 0.10–0.15 lei immediately after the inflation rate was published. Last changes in the monetary policy of NBM, which may be described as pretty aggressive, could strengthen the appreciation of exchange rate, and this fact would reduce the inflation rate a little.
2. Banking
Bank assets exceed 60 percent of GDP…
All assets of the banking have grown by about 30 percent in eight months of 2007. They were worth nearly 29.5 billion lei (2.56 million dollars) in early September and rose about 1.5-fold compared with the same period of last year. The growth of bank assets was particularly due to the rise of people’s deposits in commercial banks, as well as to the strong advance of foreign investments in capital of domestic banks, up to over 65 percent of the total.
Moldovan banks are being hunt more…
The share of foreign investments in banks’ capital has particularly grown after the share of the French group Societe Generale in the shareholder capital of Mobiasbanca rose up to over 95 percent and after Gruppo Veneto Banca, the only shareholder of EximBank, decided last August to raise by 15 million Euros the capital of the Chisinau-based bank and the Austrian investment fund VSP Capital Partners purchased all shares of the commercial bank Unibank from the Russian commercial bank Petrocomerts in exchange for 14.76 million Euros in September.
…while crediting is on permanent rise
Deposits of commercial banks have increased by more than 25 percent, up to about 21.6 billion lei (1.87 billion dollars). The credit portfolio of commercial banks registered a comparable rise. Credits rose by nearly 29.5 percent in January-August, up to about 17 billion lei (1.47 billion dollars). At the same time, deposits and credits have grown by about 40 percent and 50 percent, compared with the same period of 2007.
3. Foreign trade
Trade deficit reaches about 1.4 billion dollars…
Moldova’s deficit of trade balance reached nearly 1.4 billion dollars (about 38 percent of the 2007 GDP) after eight months of 2007 or rose by over 42 percent compared with the same period of last year. The alarming rise of the trade deficit was linked to the considerable difference between evolution of exports and imports. Moldova had a negative trade balance of 602.6 million dollars (+49.1 percent) with the European Union, 477.5 million dollars (+33.3 percent) with CIS, and 314 million dollars (+45.9 percent) with other countries.
Moldova had the highest deficit of 316.3 million dollars with Ukraine, followed by Russian Federation – 155.3 million dollars, Germany 141.5 million dollars, Romania 132 million dollars), China 109.8 million dollars. It exported goods worth 810.5 million dollars in January-August 2007 and imported goods worth over 2.2 billion dollars, which is by about 37 percent more than in the similar period of 2006. The import-export coverage rate was 36.8 percent, compared with 39.7 percent in January-August 2006.
Chronic deficit and growth of imports…
One thinks that the better economic growth performances in the period concerned (8 percent in Q1), as well as the rise of investments in restructuring and modernisation have probably increased the import demand. On the other hand, an analysis of the structure of trade deficit on main economic destinations reveals the factors which press the trade balance. One may say that the trade deficit is chronic and it will grow in continuation, so that it will be harder to finance it. Indeed, the economic growth structure in Moldova was particularly due to imports in the past years.
In two ample interviews granted in the period concerned, President Vladimir Voronin has raised a series of proposals to Tiraspol aimed at settlement of the Transdnistria problem[1]. According to analysts, the initiatives are part of the "package of Moldovan proposals" which Chisinau has negotiated with Moscow last year. The main proposals raised by president in an interview with Komsomolskaya Pravda call for:
In the second interview the president has proposed the demilitarisation of the Republic of Moldova and Transdnistrian region. He reiterated the unconditional maintenance of the neutrality principle and raised the following proposals: destruction of military hardware, firesystems and all rocket complexes by Chisinau and Tiraspol; creation of Joint Armed Forces to function on basis of territorial completion of military units; replacement of military units with military training centres.
The Ministry of Reintegration transmitted a letter to the Transdnistrian representative at political negotiations, Valeri Litskai, on October 8, 2007, inviting him to start implementing the initiatives raised by President Voronin in the interview with Komsomolskaya Pravda. The ministry proposed the creation of a joint working group to elaborate the schedule and topics of sittings of joint expert groups, which would propose measures to implement the initiatives. Also, Chisinau seeks the ensuring of a free move, including by withdrawing the checkpoints from the security zone, withdrawal of travel restrictions on officials, implementation of joint projects to rebuild and modernise the infrastructure, remedy the consequences of the drought, measures aimed at demilitarisation and disarmament, etc.
The head of the Tiraspol foreign department, Valeri Litskai, has turned down Chisinau’s initiatives, describing them as "uninteresting, impossible and inopportune at present." Transdnistrian leader Igor Smirnov has released a communication, turning down all initiatives of Chisinau and signalling a "discrepancy between statements and actions of Moldovan president," whom he accused of hidden intentions to "annex Transdnistria". On the other hand, Transdnistrian "speaker" Evgeni Shevchyuk was more open-minded towards initiatives of Chisinau, appreciating the positive offer of Chisinau[2]. According to Shevchyuk, "the non-aggressive rhetoric of the speech is welcome and it reveals a change of approaches," while the negotiations will be successful only if "Transdnistria receives positive initiatives and statements." Shevchyuk recommended the Chisinau and Tiraspol legislatures to ratify the agreements signed by Moldova and the Transdnistrian region and proposed the further monitoring of their enforcement. This would "improve the political atmosphere" and would create the framework "for the signing of new documents." In addition, Shevchyuk asked the Moldovan Parliament to annul the law on basic principles of status of Moldova’s eastern districts, which he noted, was a unilateral and inacceptable step for Tiraspol.
Vienna hosted a new round of consultations of mediators and observers of the Transdnistria settlement on October 11. According to a final statement adopted at the end of the consultation round, mediators and observers welcomed the Moldovan presidential initiatives on resolution of a series of social-economic problems between Chisinau and Tiraspol, as well as the decision of Chisinau to extend the registration deadline for Transdnistria-based enterprises until December 31, 2008. Also, they welcomed the decision of Transdnistrian authorities to annul the 100-percent tax on Moldovan goods and the "migration tax". Representatives of OSCE, Russia and Ukraine, as well as observers on behalf of the European Union and United States proposed the organisation of a "Five-Plus-Two" negotiation round before the OSCE Ministerial Meeting set for late November, inviting the sides to restart the negotiations unconditionally and immediately. The consultation round was preceded by a visit of OSCE Chairman-in-Office Miguel Angel Moratinos, Spanish foreign minister, to Chisinau. He reiterated his support for a lasting political solution to the Transdnistrian conflict, with respect for territorial integrity and sovereignty of Moldova. Moratinos called for identification of a common standpoint of OSCE member states regarding the Transdnistrian problem at the Madrid OSCE Ministerial Meeting.
European integration
10th Meeting of the EU-Moldova Parliamentary Cooperation Committee
Chisinau hosted the 10th Meeting of the European Union – Moldova Parliamentary Cooperation Committee (PCC) on October 1–2, 2007. PCC co-chairpersons Marianne Mikko on behalf of the European Parliament (EP) and Victor Stepaniuc on behalf of the Moldovan Parliament directed the PCC works. The meeting approved a final statement and recommendations for the EU-Moldova Cooperation Council.
EU-Moldova PCC welcomed Moldova’s efforts to implement the EU-Moldova Action Plan (EUMAP); reiterated the need for Moldovan authorities to redouble their efforts in order to implement democratic reforms in a series of areas such as respect for human rights, freedom of the media, respect for supremacy of the law; stressed that Moldova’s perspectives to join the EU are open; invited the European Commission to ensure the simultaneous enforcement of EU-Moldova agreements on facilitated visa regime and readmission of illegal migrants by January 1, 2008; called for resumption of the "Five-Plus-Two" Transdnistria settlement negotiations; rejected any parallels between Transdnistria and Kosovo, etc.
Marianne Mikko has stated to journalists at the end of the visit that Moldova still has much work to do in order to implement the EUMAP and this fact keeps the country far away from EU.
Signing of EU-Moldova agreements on facilitated visa regime and readmission
EU and Moldova signed facilitated visa application and readmission agreements in Brussels on October 10. Taking part in the signing ceremony were European Commission Vice President Franco Frattini, and Manuel Lobo Antunes, state secretary for European affairs of Portugal, the country which runs the Council Chairmanship, on behalf of the EU and Deputy Prime Minister Andrei Stratan, minister of foreign affairs and European integration, on behalf of Moldova. These agreements were initialled on April 25, 2007, when the Common Application Centre (CAC) opened in Chisinau.
According to a joint press release by EU institutions, the facilitated visa application agreement maintains the 35-euro price for a Schengen visa for Moldovan citizens instead of 60 Euros and it even excludes the visa costs for certain categories of applicants. Also, the documents needed to apply for a visa will be simplified for certain applicants, for example, businessmen, students, journalists, and others. Certain categories of applicants who often travel to the EU will be issued multi-visas for a long term. Holders of diplomatic passports will not need visas to enter the EU. It is worth to note that the facilitated visa application agreement will not cover the United Kingdom and Ireland, which are not part of the Schengen area.
The readmission agreement regulates the management of illegal migration. It obliges the sides to reciprocally readmit the illegal migrants. Even more, it obliges the EU and Moldova to readmit the citizens of a third side who transited the territory of one or another country when they intended to enter the EU or Moldova.
Now the EP is expected to issue an opinion on these agreements and it is hoped that the documents will be enforced by January 1, 2008. Meantime, European Commission Vice President Franco Frattini handed in the two EU-Moldova agreements to President Vladimir Voronin in Chisinau on October 14.
Beyond the formal dimension of handing in the agreements, which could be sent to Chisinau via diplomatic post, Frattini’s visit was a message of EU political support for Moldova. Moldova was hinted that the EU is also concerned with its problems and the latter is ready to continue supporting Moldova if it honours its commitments.
NCEI
Continuing the tradition introduced on September 13, 2007, the National Commission for European Integration (NCEI) held two sittings on October 4 and 12.
NCEI chairman Vasile Tarlev demanded public institutions at the October 4 sitting to work hard in order to create an ample information space regarding the results of implementation of EUMAP.
The sittings heard reports by the Ministry of Reintegration, Interior Ministry (IM), Ministry of Information Development, Information and Security Service, Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption (CSECC), Border Guard Service (BGS). Tarlev instructed IM, BGS and CSECC to remedy the signalled shortcomings by October 16 and to execute all tasks related to implementation of EUMAP.
CAC
Italian Ambassador to Moldova Daniele Mancini has announced that his country will join the Common Application Centre (CAC) inside the Hungarian Embassy in Chisinau starting January 1, 2008.
Bilateral cooperation
Republic of Moldova – Romania
The relations between Moldova and Romania have been reduced to incidents without plausible explanations in the period concerned. Some delegations of Romanian functionaries invited to attend festivities on the Holiday of Chisinau were denied to enter Moldova on October 12. Moldovan border guards invoked the lack of original invitations in order to justify their refusal.
Romanian Foreign Minister Adrian Cioroianu notified the EU General Affairs and External Relations Council in Luxembourg on October 15 over the incident at the Leuseni border crossing point. The problem was raised to consider a common standpoint of the EU for the October 25-scheduled 8th EU-Moldova Cooperation Committee.
To recall that under existing regulations, EU citizens do not need visas and other documents to justify their staying in Moldova starting January 1, 2007.
Republic of Moldova – Russia
Moldovan President Vladimir Voronin has met his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin at a summit of CIS leaders. They discussed the bilateral economic relations, in particular, the resumption of Moldovan wine exports to the Russian Federation and issues related to the Transdnistrian problem.
Shortly after the Dushanbe CIS Summit, the Moldova-Vin Agency reported that Moldovan producers have "restarted" the wine exports to the Russian Federation. Nicolae Casim, director of the national spirits record centre, stated to BASA-press that companies Vismos and DK-Intertrade have purchased trademarks to export wines to Russia, while Migdal-P, Calarasi-Divin and Lion-Gri have applied for trademarks.
Multilateral cooperation
Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe
PACE session
The autumn session of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) has taken place in the period concerned. Moldovan Speaker Marian Lupu led the Moldovan parliamentary delegation at the session of the Strasbourg forum.
The PACE session approved a report on Moldova’s respect for commitments towards Council of Europe (CoE). Since the last monitoring report in 2005, Moldova has advanced significantly on the path of democratic reforms, reads the report, and Moldova has signed 63 Conventions dealing with the country’s commitments to the CoE. However, further improvements should be made to the legislation on the judiciary, the general prosecutor’s office, political parties and local self-government, as well as electoral legislation and practices.
The Assembly invited the Moldovan authorities to take concrete measures in order to move closer to honouring all country’s commitments, so that the closing of the monitoring procedure may be envisaged in the foreseeable future.
ECHR judgments
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has passed three judgments on Moldova in the period concerned, in particular, in cases Clionov vs. Moldova, Grivneac vs. Moldova and Curararu vs. Moldova. The Strasbourg-based Court indicated the violation of the rights to a fair trial and property protection in all these cases.
It obliged Moldova to pay 300 Euros in pecuniary damages and 2,700 Euros in non-pecuniary damages to the applicant in the first case. In the second case the Moldovan Government was told to pay 1,500 Euros in non-pecuniary damages to the applicant and Moldovan authorities have to pay 4,000 Euros in non-pecuniary damages and 70 Euros in costs and expenses in the third case.
Republic of Moldova – CIS
President Vladimir Voronin has attended a summit of heads of state of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) in Dushanbe, Tajikistan. At the summit, Moldova has signed with certain reservations a decision on CIS development concept and basic action plan on implementation of this concept. The interstate common action programme against crimes for 2008–10, the cooperation programme of CIS members against illicit trafficking in drugs for 2008–10, the cooperation programme of CIS members against terrorism and other violent and extremist manifestations for 2008–10 were also signed with reservations.
Also, Moldova undersigned a declaration on preparations for the 65th anniversary of Victory in the World War II; a declaration of the Council of the International Association of Academies of Sciences and decisions on elaboration of cooperation proposals in the field of coordinated transportation policy of CIS member states.
Also, Moldova accepted the appointment of Sergey Lebedev as chairman of the Executive Committee, CIS executive secretary.
Transdnistrian settlement initiatives by President Voronin
Igor Botan
Two interviews with President Vladimir Voronin published by the Moscow-based newspapers Komsomolskaya Pravda (in Moldova) and Izvestya on October 4 and 10, 2007 mark a new approach of the problems linked to the settlement of the Transdnistrian conflict. The new approach of principle proposes:
Also, the chief of state reiterated a series of principles that Moldova will not give up during the settlement of the Transdnistrian conflict. One will see below that the chief of state has prepared well his arguments this time and at least they eliminate the need of persuading the international community, foreign diplomats that he loves his country as much as presidents of the states represented by diplomatic corps in Chisinau do, the way it happened in late June when President Voronin had to convoke foreign diplomats to explain them the essence of the "package of proposals" raised to the Russian Federation to restore the bilateral relations and settle the Transdnistrian conflict.
In all likelihood, the new presidential initiatives will have an impact but not immediately.
1) Recent evolution of bilateral relations with Russia
President Voronin has placed his initiatives in the context of better relations with the Russian Federation. Before launching the proper initiatives he noted that:
These remarks were aimed to demonstrate the pragmatic approach of existing problems in bilateral relations outside the "eternal friendship" slogans. In order to confirm the ground for optimism, President Voronin stressed that Russia is permanently reiterating the need to settle the Transdnistrian problem on basis of territorial unity of Moldova, transparent approach of existing problems and guaranteed support of all participants in the negotiation process.
2) Recent evolution of Chisinau-Tiraspol relations
The optimism of President Voronin is also based on internal factors related to reciprocal confidence measures taken in humanitarian and economic areas;
On the other hand, the president noted that the Transdnistrian authorities have made some steps forward:
Examples of reciprocal cooperation have also been revealed, in particular, the implementation of projects supported by international institutions such as the programmes against tuberculosis and Acquired Immunity Deficit Syndrome, aimed to demonstrate the unity of joint efforts to resolve humanitarian problems and to assure that "Moldova does not have plans to annex Transdnistria by force."
In order to stress the importance of his initiatives, President Voronin reiterated a series of principles that Moldova will not cede in the Transdnistria settlement process. These principles mark the internal and external political context of settlement of the conflict:
Insisting on these principles, President Voronin was confident that Moldova, Ukraine, EU, Russia "will not reaccept the fishing in the troubled waters of the early 1990s. Transdnistrians are not interested any longer in criminal economic schemes, but they are interested in legalisation of properties from barber’s shops to big enterprises in the recognised legal area."
President Voronin did not mention only one principle of great interest – the attitude towards the July 22, 2005 law on basic principles of the special status of localities from the left bank of the Dniester River (Transdnistria). In fact, the chief of state emphasised at the June 2007 meeting with diplomatic corps that the "package of initiatives" raised to the Russian Federation does not stipulate the renunciation of this law, which remains a cornerstone in the settlement process. It is unclear so far if President Voronin has changed his attitude towards this law in his new initiatives, particularly when the mediators and observers of the negotiation process were empowered to find a solution to Transdnistria’s status.
Substantiating his initiatives, the chief of state noted that "there are problems linked to Transdnistria’s status which we cannot resolve outside the existing negotiation process. The great powers will retry to resolve them, no matter how serious are the obstacles on way of tackling the Transdnistrian problems." The Republic of Moldova must "influence the eventual solutions," focussing on problems "which we can resolve without intermediaries, for the interest of citizens from both banks of the Dniester":
President Voronin substantiates the eventual success of these initiatives on confidence that "everybody expects stability and predictability of the conflict resolution process. This time, the Chisinau-Tiraspol dialogue could justify the expectations of citizens from both banks of the Dniester River. Chisinau is ready to resolve these problems."
1) What the National Army is good for?
The chief of state substantiated his proposals on demilitarisation and disarmament invoking Moldova’s neutrality status. He wondered what role Moldova’s armed forces play and gave the following answers:
President Voronin drew the conclusion that "there are two absolutely useless armies in Moldova, including Transdnistria"
2) How to achieve the disarmament and the demilitarisation?
President Voronin considers that "Moldova and Transdnistria could start the disarmament and demilitarisation process until mediators and observers discuss the format of the peacekeeping operation in the region." Thus, "a demilitarisation agreement would be reached after a complex analysis" as follows:
3) What the united army should deal with?
According to Voronin’s initiatives, the military will be trained in an eventual army to learn the "profession of peacekeeper" at the highest level. They will have to learn both the military art and the art of preventing conflicts, stopping them under agreements. The peacekeeping experience of neutral states such as Sweden, Finland and Ireland was indicated as a very good example to follow.
President Voronin’s initiatives pass Moldova’s framework, proposing international solutions. Thus, arguing that the army of the unified Moldova is useful only as a peacekeeping force trained to intervene at the request of international bodies in order to manifest solidarity with other countries and nations, he proposes international organisations to allow only neutral states to hold peacekeeping missions. This would be the pledge of sincere peacekeeping missions, without following obscure goals.
President Voronin says that a substantial international support including financial is needed to implement his initiatives. So, the following is needed to protect the military from feeling themselves victims of the proposed changes:
The chief of state is sure that "it is the time to take actions, but these projects will be only good intentions without a support of the international community." Even more, he is sure that "the foreign partners of Moldova, in particular, the United States, NATO member states, Ukraine and Russia are interested in such a transformation of the Moldovan army. We will resolve these problems with their support only."
1) Internal reactions
Internal reactions to the new initiatives of President Voronin were positive in general. Both representatives of political parties and commentators stressed the generally satisfactory argumentation aimed to strengthen the confidence of the citizens from the left bank of the Dniester River towards intentions of the official Chisinau to settle the conflict. There is a substantial difference between the new approach and the one launched last spring, when impossible actions such as early elections in a parliament of the common state were proposed while a solution of principle to the legal status of Transdnistria as part of a reunited Moldova was absent.
It was noted that many of the recent presidential initiatives have a tangency or reiterate in fact elements of:
These examples reveal that the recent initiatives of the chief of state generally met some expectations and they deserve all support. At the same time, there were some reservations regarding possibility to implement them. Firstly, it was invoked the pre-electoral nature of the initiatives. Also, it was indicated the desire of the chief of state to attenuate the eventual reactions of Russia towards recognition of Kosovo’s independence by the West. This way, it was tried to explain the policy on approaching Moldova to Russia in the detriment of good relations with Romania and the refusal to take part in events linked to the GUAM membership. Only leftwing parties such as the Patria-Moldova Party and the Ravnopravye Movement, which radically call for approaching Russia and CIS, described President Voronin’s initiatives as impossible because the chief of state is not trusted in Transdnistria.
2) Transdnistria’s reactions
Reactions of the Transdnistrian authorities toward President Voronin’s initiatives were foreseeable. Here and there ironical and even sarcastic, here and there favourably inclined, the attitudes were expressed and they could not be ignored like those towards the "package of proposals" on Russia last summer. Transdnistrian authorities simply affirmed then that they did not hear anything about organisation of early parliamentary elections with Transdnistria’s participation in November 2007 and about appointment of its representatives to high-ranking governmental posts.
Transdnistrian leader Igor Smirnov stressed that the recent initiatives by President Voronin aim at PR and propaganda only. He noted that there are documents that he and President Voronin signed on May 16, 2001 for all humanitarian and economic initiatives:
As regards the demilitarisation and disarmament initiatives, the Transdnistrian leaders gave a very succinct answer: – President Voronin is not credible after he accepted and then turned down in November 2003 the Kozak Memorandum on disarmament and demilitarisation of Moldova and Transdnistria.
Reactions of the chairman of the Supreme Soviet, Evgeny Shevchyuk, were more diplomatic. He welcomed in principle the initiatives as a manifestation of Chisinau’s good-will. However, he demanded guarantees that these are serious intentions, not propagandistic actions. In order to confirm the good intentions, Shevchyuk recommended the Chisinau Parliament to ratify the agreements signed by the sides, including the protocols invoked by Smirnov. Also, he demanded the Chisinau Parliament to annul the law on basic principles of special legal status of localities from the left bank of the Dniester River (Transdnistria)."
The former chairman of the Supreme Soviet, a founding parent of the regime from the left bank of the Dniester, Grigore Maracutsa, special representative of the Supreme Soviet for interparliamentary relations, welcomed President Voronin’s initiatives, but stressed that they will be accepted if Russia’s influence is spread from the small territory of Transdnistria on the whole territory of the Republic of Moldova. Only this way Transdnistria would negotiate with Russia and Moldova to resolve the problems in Russia’s interest.
Transdnistrian foreign minister Valery Litskay has made the shortest comments on President Voronin’s initiatives: "uninteresting, impossible and inopportune." Perhaps Litskay was hurt by tonality of Moldova’s Ministry of Reintegration, which proposed him "to create a joint working group in order to work out a schedule of sittings of joint expert groups and their topics, so that to resolve the problems related to implementation of the initiatives by Moldovan President Vladimir Voronin launched in the interview with the Komsomolskaya Pravda newspaper."
The reactions toward the new initiatives by President Voronin will not stop soon for sure, but on the contrary, they will be a constant decorum of preparations for the March 2009 parliamentary elections. At this stage, at least two initiative groups have posted intentions to create political parties for participation in the 2009 elections, launching sounding proposals on Transdnistria problem.
In the first case, the former presidential advisor Sergiu Mocanu (dismissed in late June 2007) launched a document titled "A strategy for the Republic of Moldova," anticipating this way the presidential initiatives with one week. Thus, on September 26, 2007 Mocanu announced "an ample campaign to promote the initiative – in the European Union with the territory we control," on behalf of the initiative group People’s Action.
It should be noted from the very beginning that the initiative of the former advisor is completely contrary to the presidential proposal. Mass media launched the supposition that the "strategy" of the former presidential advisor is only an invitation at an "intellectual exercise". By accepting this approach it is important to know the premises and how the former presidential advisor argues his initiative:
In consequence, the solution "In the European Union with the territory we control" proposed by the former presidential adviser stipulates:
Thus, the preliminary conditions of the "intellectual exercise" seem to be as clear as the proposed solutions. But one thing is unclear: the solutions are the things that the former presidential advisor apparently wants, not the results of conclusions substantiated in logical and methodological terms. It is unclear why a border with all necessary attributions is needed to make the European integration issue a priority versus the country reintegration problem.
Firstly, if these are "rigours" in setting up a border with all necessary attributions, it seems that the former presidential advisor did not take great pains to study the Moldovan laws on state border and border guard service, in order to find out what the "rigours" he speaks about imply in fact. He is very approximate as regards the marking of the border across the right bank of the Dniester, making abstraction of the security zone and Chisinau-controlled localities on the left bank, as well as of the fact that the Bender municipality is de facto under the jurisdiction of the separatist regime. It is unclear how to enter the security zone to "rigorously" set up the border.
Secondly, it is unclear what the eventual border across the Dniester will be used for. It seems that the quality of governance, rather than the absence of a border on the Dniester affects Moldova’s accession to EU priority at present. The two banks of the Dniester do not hold economic relations in fact. The infrastructure was separated long ago. The Transdnistrian regime does not obstruct the building of authentic democratic institutions in line with European standards on the right bank of the Dniester. Would the border across the Dniester improve the quality of the Moldovan judiciary or would it make the mass media freer? Even more, European institutions clearly signal that justifications related to the influence of the unsettled conflict on the adequate functioning of democratic institutions is not accepted any longer.
Thirdly, it is an illusion that by isolating the right bank from the left bank the first could become attractive for the latter meanwhile. Even the author of the "strategy" says that Transdnistria is a "zone of political, economic and military protectorate of the Russian Federation." Would Russia accept a much worse material condition of its industrialised protectorate than on the right bank? So far, it was clear that Moscow has promptly combated all claims of Chisinau to create a better situation on the right bank, both in political and economic terms, in particular, the conduct of a referendum on independence and joining to Russia, embargoes on Moldova, differentiated gas prices and exigency toward payments on the right and the left banks, etc. Moscow has taken all these actions to equal the conditions of the two conflicting sides in the so-called negotiation process. The claim to isolate Transdnistria in order to make the right bank more attractive for the left bank is illusory at present, given Russia’s political and economic ascension. Russia is like a "thermostat" capable to keep the constant "temperature of Transdnistria" regardless of eventual oscillations of temperature in Chisinau. This is a demonstrated fact. The declared intention to isolate Transdnistria will unquestionably be described as an attempt to antagonise the Moldovan-Russian relations with all predictable consequences. Russia has habituated us to prompt, "asymmetrical" but efficient answers, isn’t it? The threats of the "strategy" developer to break up diplomatic relations with the states which would obstruct it to stand out seem to be simple manifestations of "patriotic courage".
Fourthly, the former presidential adviser launches suppositions regarding the European integration, but he does not know how the EU will understand them. He makes abstraction of the years-long efforts of Moldovan authorities to internationalise the conflict resolution, including by attracting the EU to observe the negotiation process and to monitor the Transdnistrian segment of the Moldova-Ukraine border via EUBAM. The EU-Moldova Action Plan, as an updated document on implementation of CPA, stipulates the settlement of the Transdnistrian conflict via negotiations as one of major goals. Even more, a similar clause outlined in the summary of this document persists in the EU-Ukraine Action Plan. We know the huge inertia of EU decisions, how much time some countries like Moldova need to persuade the EU to make such decisions. Under these circumstances, what would be the impact of the "rigorous delimitation of the border across the Dniester without a beforehand consent of the EU? Would this initiative be interpreted as an occasion to invoke the danger of an eventual "humanitarian catastrophe" in Transdnistria, so that Russia be able to accuse the EU of co-participation in it through EUBAM? Invited by separatist leaders, the 100,000 Russian citizens and 65,000 Ukrainian citizens who reside Transdnistria would invoke this argument for sure, demanding these states to help them. Believing that they will obediently wait Moldova’s accession to the EU and its attractiveness is an illusion. What could stop Russia and Ukraine from helping their citizens who are threatened to be isolated? Perhaps the same fear to break up the diplomatic relations with Moldova, isn’t it?
Fifthly, it seems that the "strategy" does not care about the fate of 300,000 Moldovan citizens who reside Transdnistria when its author argues the need of "rigorously" demarking the border across the Dniester with the fact that the Moldovan authorities cannot control the "clean" criminal records submitted while applying for a passport for travelling abroad. Does this mean that the "strategy" calls for the refusal to issue Moldovan passports for travelling abroad to Moldovan citizens from Transdnistria? It is unclear.
Sixthly, it seems that the author of this "strategy" does not imagine what arguments give to Transdnistrian authorities for "asymmetrical" responses, as for example, when announcing the introduction of a visa regime with Moldova after the "rigorous" marking of the border. Of course, Transdnistria would have to obtain the open support of Russia and Ukraine and the finalisation of Transdnistria’s passport issuance by the two states.
In general, the non-estimation of possible reactions and actions of Russia, Ukraine, EU and separatist regime to the eventual implementation of the "strategy" is the main shortcoming of the document by the former presidential advisor. It is a fact that the influence of foreign factors in Moldova is bigger than of internal factors. Perhaps one believes that those around will be stony, fascinated by this "strategy"? This is impossible because former advisors of Moldovan president know and understand all these facts well for sure.
For this reason, the way the "strategy" claims that the declared goals of Moldova must be formulated and accomplished in the order of priorities – the EU integration and then the country reintegration – the "intellectual exercise" must make clear the priorities of the initiative group. This is the conclusion: the initiative group aims to reintroduce the former presidential advisor in politics by creating the own political party to participate in the 2009 parliamentary elections. The Transdnistrian problem is the ground of the new party, while the proposals seeking the "rigorous" marking of the border across the Dniester is the main point of attraction aimed to create the shock wave. In this regard, the "strategy" perfectly fits the perceptions of citizens revealed by the CBS AXA survey in September. Thus, 44.5 percent vs. 26.3 percent of the citizens would oppose the recognition of Transdnistria’s independence, if this would be the price to continue the European integration process. On the other hand, 53 percent vs. 22.8 percent would oppose the European integration goal, if Transdnistria would want this. The survey shows that keeping the status quo of the European integration and country reintegration priorities is the optimal solution so far.
It is unknown if the author of the "strategy" took into account the findings of the survey, but his offer comes to polarise the attitudes and it does not pass the limit of preferences of the majority of citizens. The "strategy" would not bring any added value to the status quo situation without this contraposition of the European integration and country reintegration goals, but this way it calls minimum for an "intellectual exercise" and maximum for a "people’s action" to build a new political party. Indeed, the desire of the "strategy" developer to succeed first to the Parliament in order to promote his initiatives is normal. Arguments to justify the impossibility of fulfilling the promises will be found later.
The "strategy" by former presidential adviser produces reverberations inside of the initiative group of the future Liberal Democratic Party of Moldova (LDPM), which invoked the need of holding a national referendum on Transdnistrian problem, when he was launched on October 1, 2007, avoiding any details about questions or area of an eventual referendum.
The favourable circumstances invoked by President Voronin for his recent initiatives are incomplete, omitting a series of important factors. The Russian Federation has started the electoral campaign for parliamentary elections followed by presidential campaign. A new configuration of all state power will be built in Russia later. This process will probably last until May 2008. Of course, these events will eclipse any other political events the next half a year, especially outside. For this reason, the Russian authorities will unlikely deal with the Transdnistria settlement by summer 2008. They will be rather interested to maintain the status quo in the region.
If this supposition is true, the new administration (the partially renewed one) of Russia will come back to resolve the problems involving Russia including the Transdnistrian conflict when President Vladimir Voronin will be a real "lame duck" concerned with own succession to the governing, with whom nobody seriously discusses future projects. From this viewpoint, the probability that President Voronin’s initiatives will have an immediate impact on settlement of the Transdnistrian conflict before the 2009 parliamentary elections is minimal.
The negative attitudes of the Tiraspol leaders towards initiatives and credibility of President Voronin dramatically reduce the chances of the presidential initiatives to be implemented. Truly, the personal animosities between leaders from the two banks of the Dniester River have become proverbial and their communication via interviews with the Russian media is one more proof that progresses in settling the conflict are actually impossible during the concomitant governance of trimmings from the two banks of the Dniester River. The way the Chisinau Ministry of Reintegration has proposed Tiraspol to take measures in order to implement President Voronin’s initiatives, inviting the Transdnistrian authorities to read the interview published by Komsomolskaya Pravda, reveals that Chisinau wanted a refusal indeed, so that to accuse Tiraspol of intransigency.
President Voronin had grounds to launch his most "humanistic and pacifying" initiatives on Transdnistria settlement in October 2007. The rapid settlement of the Transdnistrian conflict was one of his main promises when he took over the unlimited power in February 2001. The conflict was not settled so far after more than six years and there are signs that President Voronin will fail the resolution during his second presidential mandate. In fact, the rule of President Voronin meant the complete coverage of the vicious circle, so that he proposes actions coordinated with the Transdnistrian administration which he had given up six years ago. However, the searching of a solution was "internationalised" and the only lever of Chisinau to influence the situation in Transdnistria – cooperation with EU and introduction of EUBAM – was fond in the period concerned. In this situation, President Voronin can only "bequeath" a set of principles to his successor which would establish the reference points of the Transdnistria settlement. Interviews with Vladimir Voronin aimed to formulate these reference points, making the impression of a "political testament". Even more, the chief of state warned that the eventual opposition of his party in2009 does not mean the renunciation to these principles. On the contrary, the Party of Communists will fight to keep them.
The advantages of President Voronin’s initiatives are clear in this situation, and they are capable to attenuate somehow the criticism for failing one of his electoral promises. Firstly, the proposals will be accepted and even commended by mediators and observers of the "5+2" negotiation format, of course except for Transdnistria. But the arguments of Transdnistrian leaders regarding the non-confidence toward President Voronin are weaker than the arguments in favour of an immediate resolution of problems of citizens from the left bank of the Dniester River as long as mediators and observers are looking for solutions to the status of Transdnistria in the "3+2" format, that means without Moldova and Transdnistria. Secondly, President Voronin’s initiatives are more realistic and acceptable for participants in the "3+2" format than the proposals of the Moldovan opposition, which either deprive or envisage impossible actions. Thirdly, the initiatives of President Voronin will be needed to prevent Russia’s threats to recognise Transdnistria’s independence, if the West eventually recognises Kosovo’s independence. Probably, it would be inconvenient to Russia to accomplish its threats. Finally, Russia could accept the argument that the situation in Transdnistria and the solutions proposed by Moldova’s authorities are unlike those in Kosovo.
The Moldovan political class should reconsider very carefully the "inheritance" of President Voronin not only as regards the Transdnistrian conflict. The modality of tackling the problems – from accepting and unexpected signing of some documents of principle to unexpected renunciation to fulfil the promises – should be avoided. For example: a) the signing of protocols with Transdnistria in 2001 and further renunciation; b) the invitation of very important foreign players (EU, USA, OSCE) to participate in a joint effort to draft documents of principle and the parallel calling "behind Europe" on services of one of them – Russia, like in case of the Kozak Memorandum; c) the calling on support of regional organisations in moments of crisis and even the proposal to reanimate them by organising some summits, the way it happened with GUAM before the March 2005 elections (perhaps to regain the ruined credibility in relations with the Russian Federation) ant the unexplained refusal to participate in its summits later on (2007 GUAM’s summits in Baku and Vilnius). All these actions cannot have another effect but reduction of Moldova’s credibility.
Promoting a predictable, transparent and coordinated policy of principle even in details with main strategic partners, particularly with the EU, is the best strategy for condition and potential of Moldova. This is necessary particularly after the entire political class has undersigned the statement on political partnership for implementation of the European integration goal.
Dual citizenship restrictions: concern with public interests or fear over own citizens
Sergiu Grosu
After long and contradictory debates, the parliamentary majority passed on October 4, 2007 in the first reading the draft law on modification and completion of some legislative acts, which aims to "restrict Moldovan citizens from holding the citizenships of other states when they run public posts." The draft law envisages more than 20 organic laws, covering in fact all public offices in the Republic of Moldova. The Government, as developer of this initiative, acknowledges that the withdrawal of the interdiction on holding of a foreign citizenship from Constitution and further from the law on citizenship was an essential step to "democratise the citizenship institution and an important step to respect the human rights and fundamental freedoms." At the same time, initiators consider that "the trend of Moldovan citizens to obtain the citizenship of other states is linked to their desire to enjoy some travel facilities in the European area, social insurance indemnities, family integration, unconditional employment, education," etc., and this situation "produces some political-legal obligations toward these states, an issue capable to challenge a conflict of interests in case of commitments toward both states."
Parliamentary and extra-parliamentary opposition representatives, political and legal experts criticise this initiative, describing it as capable to fuel the social splitting, to encourage staff sorting on political, social and even national criteria[1].
The draft was worked out and registered as a legislative initiative in early 2007, shortly after Romania’s accession to the European Union, and many experts fear that the agitation produced by this event after Romanian authorities had received more than 800,000 citizenship applications of Moldovan citizens[2] produced the "normative reaction" of the Chisinau authorities. The Government had had an inadequate reaction at the beginning, trying awkwardly to obstruct the applications and launching later incomprehensible statements regarding travel possibilities in the EU area[3], but this struggling produced reverse reactions of the population. Although the communication to the draft law does not directly envisage the Moldovan-Romanian relations, the context and the wordings "the trend of Moldovan citizens to obtain the citizenship of other states is linked to their desire to enjoy some travel facilities in the European area, social insurance indemnities, family integration, unconditional employment, education…," "in order to settle the situation in the country" indicate for sure the state envisaged by these interdictions.
The fact that Article II of the Law # 232/05.06.2003 concerning modification and completion of the law on Moldovan citizenship (adopted with the purpose to ensure the conformity with constitutional norms modified under the Law # 1469/2002) obliged the Government to adjust its normative acts and raise proposals on adjustment of legislation to this law to the Parliament within 3 months is a decisive argument that the legislative initiative is spontaneous. Meanwhile, the law on citizenship was modified and completed four times and the Government supported by the same parliamentary majority was not changed. Therefore, if a consistent policy of principle, a true care for public interests existed, the change would have been made long ago and it would have been appreciated adequately, because the situations and legal regulations would have developed concomitantly. If the Government considered at that stage that it was unnecessary to introduce the restrictions, it means that it accepted the situation and allowed anybody to hold a plurality of citizens, and it had no plans to introduce any bans in general.
The proposed amendments and completions aim to oblige the candidate to a public post or a public functionary to hold "the Moldovan citizenship only." The "domicile inside of the country" completes this requirement sometimes[4].
According to lawyers, the draft formally unfits the legislative technique requirements[5], in particular:
The restrictions have not been introduced when the plurality of citizenships was allowed, so that the further implementation of the restrictive norms could affect important legal principles: the consecutiveness, the stability and the predictability.
The conflicts of interests presumed by developers of this draft are not clearly estimated or stressed, so that it is impossible to establish if these are: the compulsory military service or the Homeland defence service; the obligation to pay taxes and fees; the possibilities of attending massive manifestations; the interdictions to be a member of a foreign party, etc. The absence of regulations to settle these conflicts of interests among public functionaries before enforcement of this law is another proof that the reason is subjective.
Although ensuring the compatibility with the community legislation is a mandatory condition for drafting legislative acts, the draft and the communication do not contain references to the necessary regulations of the community legislation and the compatibility of the draft law with the community regulations is not estimated. The Government cites provisions of the November 6, 1997 European Convention on Citizenship, assuring that the national legal framework respects them. However, a deeper analysis reveals that the interdiction on public functionaries to hold multiple citizenships violates the Article 17 of the Convention (rights and obligations resulting from the dual citizenship), which says that: "1) Citizens of the Party State who hold a foreign citizenship have the same rights and obligations in the Party State which they reside as the citizens of this state do." Article 17 (2) of the Convention does not justify the interdictions stipulated by this draft law and limiting the access to a public office is unjustified as well.
The fact that the Government did not ask a preliminary expertise of the Council of Europe on this draft and the parliamentary majority turned down a proposal seeking the expertise fuels certain suspicions and reveals fears of authorities that European forums would not support or would even criticise their intentions.
1. The draft does not correspond to all regulations of the national legislation[6]:
Conditioning the access to public posts with exclusiveness of the Moldovan citizenship could be interpreted as a breach of the Constitution, as Articles 16 and 19 of the Supreme Law stipulate that all Moldovan citizens are equal in front of the law and public authorities, while foreigners and stateless people have the same rights and obligations as Moldovan citizens do, with some exceptions stipulated by law. The Constitution makes a difference between foreign citizens and stateless people, but it does not make a difference between holders of a dual or multiple citizenships and "exclusive" citizens of the Republic of Moldova. The state protects its citizens, but accordingly to the draft, the rights of own citizens will be reduced to the rights of foreigners and stateless people, and holders of multiple citizenships will become an intermediary category between foreigners and citizens, with this norm being interpreted as a repressive measure against own citizens.
Article 39 of the Constitution allows Moldovan citizens to participate in administration of public affairs directly and via their representatives and it stipulates that "under the law, every citizen is ensured access to a public post." The accordance of the restrictions with this constitutional norm is not completely ensured.
The Article 54 of the Constitution bans the Republic of Moldova to adopt laws capable to suppress or reduce the human and citizens’ rights and fundamental freedoms and the exercise of the rights and freedoms "cannot be restricted but accordingly to the law, in line with unanimously recognized norms of the international law and if the restrictions are necessary for the interests of national security, territorial integrity, economic welfare of the country, public order, against massive troubles and crimes, for the protection of rights, freedoms and dignity of other persons, against disclosure of secret information or for guaranteeing the authority and impartiality of the judiciary." The restriction must be "proportional to the situation which produced it and it cannot affect the right or the freedom." Accordingly to the communication and draft, the restrictions are not proportional, justified and they unfit these criteria.
The amendment to the Article 13 of the law on public service aims to extend the restriction on all persons who fall under incidence of this law, and it envisages a very large range of functions: see in this regard the Annex 1 to the law on public service and the single classifier of public posts (GD # 151 from February 23, 2001). At the same time, it does not aim to modify certain laws which establish the status of important public functionaries: the Law # 768-XIV from February 2, 2000 on status of local councilor, the Law # 344-XIII from December 23, 1994 on special legal status of Gagauzia (Gagauz-Yeri); the Law # 333-XVI from November 10, 2006 on status of penal officer; the Law # 162-XVI from July 22, 2005 on status of military; the Law # 93 from April 5, 2007 on Civil Protection and Emergency Service; the Law # 108-XIII from May 17, 1994 on state border of the Republic of Moldova (concerning border guard troops), etc.
2. The absence of provisions on a control mechanism for candidates to public offices is the main omission of the draft. The failure to guarantee the rights of public functionaries who already hold foreign citizenships is even worse. In the virtue of the non-retroactivity principle of the law, these persons should not be controlled or restricted, but there is no special legal guarantee in this respect. However, if a guarantee is introduced, subjects of the law will face an unfair treatment, and even the time criterion is applicable for different treatment (it depends when a foreign citizenship was obtained).
3. The imperfect regulations could harm the public and private interests:
The modality of promoting the interdictions, generality of the formal motivation, the lack of conclusive and convincing arguments regarding the "dangerous" absence of these restrictions impose the conclusion that creating possibilities to sort out the candidates and functionaries (on political, administrative or even national criteria) is the main goal of the modifications, and omitting the inclusion of complete and intrinsically related norms could encourage a biased, selective application of the new regulations.
The faulty promotion of the modifications reveals a certain fear of authorities towards own citizens, a non-confidence towards the effect of the policy promoted at governmental level and over possibility to be shared and supported entirely and constantly by all representatives of the public sector. The Government wants this way to impose a certain fear to people and to put them in a dilemma: would they lose the possibilities to affirm themselves in their country if they had one more guarantee from another state?
The proposed regulations do not have a perfect composition with an intrinsic connection: they do not clearly regulate the situation of the present holders of multiple citizenships; they do not establish mechanisms of control and application of the necessary sanctions in case of disobedience with the restrictions. The implementation of the new provisions on persons who have already gained a foreign citizenship could produce instability, could affect the confidence of these citizens towards Moldova.
The restrictions will not make the citizens love their Homeland more; they will not increase the number of people who want the Moldovan citizenship in order to serve it with a special belief. Finally, these awkward attempts will not reduce the number of those who leave Moldova and look for a better life and Government. On the contrary, the number of those who leave the country will be completed by potential or acting functionaries who will take with them their experience, skills, leaving the "exclusive" citizen love at home.
The contributors to this issue are:
|
© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT" Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated | e-mail: [email protected] |