ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20071031/index.shtml


e-journal, year V, issue 105, October 16–31, 2007

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Problem

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1.1. Appointments

The Parliament has given green light to a proposal by the chief of state to appoint Artur Resetnicov as director of the Information and Security Service for a 5-year term. Previously, Resetnicov was presidential advisor for legal affairs.

1.2. Legal acts

Law on state registration of legal entities and individual entrepreneurs. It regulates the procedure of state registration of legal entities and individual entrepreneurs, the keeping of state registers of legal entities and individual entrepreneurs, and establishes the legal status of the state registration body and registrar.

Draft law on draft state budget law for 2008. The document backed by the major parliamentary faction alone establishes a series of macroeconomic indicators for next year, in particular, a 9.3 percent inflation rate; a 12.2 lei/1 dollar exchange rate; estimated revenues worth 14,658,000,000 lei, expenses worth 4,881,000,000, a 0.5 percent GDP deficit. It forecasts a 6 percent rise of the Gross Domestic Product, up to 56.8 billion lei. The medium salary on economy shall grow by approximately 23 percent. Approximately 1.2 billion lei is foreseen for the implementation of the budgetary pay law; salaries of teachers and doctors, allocations for social programmes shall grow. Opposition parliamentary factions have sought higher revenues, allocations for local public administration and a larger reserve fund for agriculture[1].

Draft law on vegetal regnum. The document approved in the first reading aims to contribute to healthcare, protection and well-being of animals, obliging individuals and legal entities holding animals to respect legal requirements and sanitary-veterinary norms. The document also stipulates the creation of a central supervision authority called the Sanitary Veterinary and Food Security Agency on basis of the State Veterinary Inspectorate and district/municipal sanitary-veterinary services.

Draft law on modification and completion of certain legal acts (status of foreigners).

The document adopted in the first reading regulates the documentation of beneficiaries of humanitarian aid in Moldova (who hold identity and travel cards).

1.3. Parliamentary control. Statements

Hearings

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration (MFAEI) reported a considerable rise of the number of Moldovan youths participating in the international Work and Travel programme (approximately 44,000 visas for 2007) and leave for the United States. MFAEI, the Moldovan Embassy in Washington and the U.S. Department of State have established a mechanism to operatively study the complaints of Moldovan students participating in this programme, as they signal violation of their rights by employers or intermediary companies.

Answering a question regarding the legality of a clause from an agreement signed between Soroca representatives of two political parties, in which members of the Party of Communists of the Republic of Moldova pledge to contribute to issuance of a licence for the Granite and Stone Quarry in Soroca, the Ministry of Justice said that a conclusion regarding an eventual legal responsibility of the persons who signed this agreement is impossible. At the same time, the deputy minister of justice did not gainsay the supposition that this issue will be treated as a "political corruption" element.

Questions. Interpellations

Parliamentarian Valentina Cusnir has asked the Government to report on completion of the special fund from the change of destination of farm land in 2006–07, used to work the new fields (amounts, fields, legal acts, sources).

Democratic parliamentarian Valentina Buliga has asked the Government to report on sentencing of Moldova by ECHR, causes and future measures to stop such losses.

Lawmakers Valentina Stratan and Igor Klipii have demanded explanations why investigations on a traffic accident involving the presidential car are delayed and demanded competent authorities to file criminal charges against persons who cleaned up the traces of this accident and violated the effective legislation.

Deputy Vladimir Filat has asked the Government Apparatus to present a complete list of special number plates issued until now and of users of these transports.

Christian Democratic Deputy Vlad Cubreacov has asked the prime minister to report on fulfilment of Moldova’s commitments towards the Council of Europe, in particular concerning the religious freedom (Cubreacov invoked the blocking of the process of registration of religious denominations and their components).

Our Moldova Deputy Alexandru Lipcan has asked the Government to report on legal status of fields located between the barbed wire and the state border on the Proute River and perspectives to change the boundaries of administrative territorial units in order to transmit them these fields.

Our Moldova Deputy Gheorghe Susarenco has asked the Government to report on non-execution of executory titles worth over one million lei by the Ministry of Education and Youth. He also blamed Minister Victor Tvircun for the illegal dismissal of more than ten headmasters to whom law courts have awarded victory but the judgments are unexecuted so far.

Communist Deputy Vladimir Panfilov has asked the Prosecutor-General’s Office to ensure the security of parliamentarian Ion Neagu and former legislator Sergiu Burca, as their lives are threatened in connection with some statements regarding the disappearance of Christian Democratic parliamentarian Vlad Cubreacov in 2002.

Statements

Our Moldova Deputy Gheorghe Susarenco has protested in connection with breaches committed by Parliament’s leadership during plenary sittings, since it obstructs the opposition and gives priority to representatives of the Communist majority to address.

Deputy Vitalia Pavlicenco has read a statement concerning the anti-Romania hysteria of the communist regime, raising a deep concern of the National Liberal Party with actions of Moldovan authorities.

The Our Moldova Alliance (OMA) faction has said that the debates on the draft state budget law for 2008 should be preceded by several conditions, in particular, a preliminary in-depth study and discussion; live broadcasting on public radio and TV channels; the presence of all district and municipality heads in the Parliament in order to take an attitude.

Three unaffiliated lawmakers, members of the Social Liberal Party, joined the parliamentary faction of the Democratic Party of Moldova. At the same time, it was reiterated the idea to build a political centre in future through the merger of these parties and joining of other parties with similar doctrines.


Government

2.1. Decisions

Decision awarding facilities to young doctors and pharmacists. Young doctors and pharmacists who will accept to work in rural areas of Moldova will enjoy facilities the first three years after graduation, in particular, a monthly rent compensation (up to 0.5 percent of the minimum official salary on country) or free housing from local public administration; doctors and pharmacists who graduate from higher education will get a single indemnity worth 30,000 lei (nurses will be paid 24,000 lei), paid proportionally after each year of work; a monthly compensation of the cost of 30 KW of electricity, one cubic metre of wood and one ton of coal.

Decision approving the action plan on execution of the Parliament Decision approving the report on execution of the 2006 state budget and public funds. These parliamentary decisions oblige the executive to take organisational, legal, methodological and disciplinary measures in order to improve the quality of financial management and to target the budgetary-fiscal policy at implementing the state social-economic policies; to consolidate efforts of all budget executors in order to ensure a good management of budgetary funds; to ensure the institutionalisation of control on volumes and quality of budget-funded works; to regulate relations between budgets of administrative territorial units of first and second levels and to extend the participation of public authorities in implementing budgetary policies. Also, the Government must ensure the execution of recommendations by the Chamber of Auditors; optimise the expenses and ensure the integrity of public patrimony; efficiently manage the public debt and orient the budgetary-fiscal policy to the economic development objective.

Decisions approving certain draft laws:

Decisions on allocation of funds. Following amounts will be allocated from the reserve fund of the Government:

2.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Support for mortgage building

The Government has plans to continue assisting the National Housing Service in order to give an impulse to the mortgage social housing building. The prime minister appreciated the work of this service and of the Construction and Territorial Development Agency, at a broadened sitting with the participation of representatives of enterprises and managers acting on the mortgage market, but noted that the two institutions have to use reserves in order to develop this sector. The executive will take measures to give social residences to socially vulnerable people who lack purchase power and the National Housing Service was told to table an efficient action plan within one month, so that to give an impulse to the mortgage social housing building. At the same time, the Ministry of Economy and Commerce was instructed to elaborate a price formation mechanism for building materials, as "there are big problems in this area and prices of many building materials are artificially increased."

A new social protection strategy

The Collegial Council of the Ministry of Social Protection, Family and Child has approved a draft national strategy on building an integrated social service system and the Government is due to study it. The document implies a complex concept of state policy on social protection of people in need, which will include the neediest population in social assistance programmes. The system is based on priority targeting of social services at the poorest people who will be chosen on basis of individual needs.

Elaboration of National Development Plan

The prime minister has chaired a sitting which heard a report on actions taken to work out the draft National Development Plan (NDP) strategy, as well as actions needed to finalise the NDP Action Plan. Officials in charge with this plan reported that 25 public debates with the participation of approximately 1,500 representatives of NGOs, civil society, academia, national and international experts, etc., have been organised to work out the draft NDP strategy. The draft strategy is being finished and published at www.pnd.md for the public and the NDP action plan is being finalised.

Meeting with Gagauz lawmakers

Vasile Tarlev has met a group of members of the People’s Assembly of the Administrative Territorial Unit Gagauzia and discussed future actions aimed to impel the social-economic development of the region. Representatives of the Administrative Territorial Unit Gagauzia sought financial assistance to implement new infrastructure projects, help children learn the Moldovan language, hold cultural actions. The prime minister promised that the Government will give green light to the call of lawmakers and will provide methodical and financial assistance, including for learning of Moldovan, Gagauz languages, and others. Observers note that the Gagauzia governor could easier and more operatively notify the prime minister regarding the problems of the region, as he is a member of the Government, but this functionary represents the opposition and central authorities prefer to marginalise him, discussing mainly with Gagauz supporters of the ruling party.


Presidency

3.1. Decrees

The chief of state has signed a decree on creation of the State Commission for Strategic Analysis of the Defence in the Republic of Moldova to accomplish the objectives of the National Programme on Implementation of the Moldova-NATO Individual Partnership Action Plan (IPAP).

Under a presidential decree, the National Council for Awarding of the State Prize was created and presidential adviser Mihail Platon was appointed chief state advisor, secretary of the Council for Awarding of the State Prize.

The president has also awarded high state medals, in particular:

3.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Interest for territorial development

Vladimir Voronin has visited the districts of Ungheni and Rezina (Rezina will hold new elections in November to elect a district council, as it was earlier impossible to create one).

The chief of state has convoked a special sitting and ordered an action plan on social-economic development of the Basarabeasca district, in particular to stipulate the supply of the district centre with drinkable water; the capital renovation of the residual water cleaning station; the renovation of social-cultural and medical-sanitary institutions, the modernisation of infrastructure of localities, the intensification of economic activities.

The president has convoked a sitting on the Transnistrian settlement and signalled the need of building mechanisms to protect the property rights of farmers from the Transnistrian region on farm land, in compliance with national legislation and international norms.

Shortcomings of control activity

Vladimir Voronin has convoked a sitting on abusive, groundless and inefficient controls by inspection bodies on economic agents. Following indications by the chief of state, the Government has immediately decided the same day to cut by 10 percent the personnel of the Prosecutor-General’s Office, the Centre for the Struggle Against Economic Crimes and Corruption, the Interior Ministry, the State Tax Inspectorate, the Construction and Territorial Development Agency, the Standardisation and Metrology Service, the State Ecological Inspectorate.

Voronin has told a new sitting on activity of control bodies that many abuses and violations committed by inspectors demonstrate the inefficiency of the existing system including 61 inspection structures, and noted that the number of subdivisions and employees is exaggerated and produces doublings of posts and corruption. The Government was told to work out and implement a legislative and institutional action plan in order to urgently reorganise the inspection system. In addition, it was proposed to introduce a permanent monitoring on activity of control and supervision bodies.

Concern with patrimony

Moldova’s president has convoked a sitting on protection of state patrimony in enterprises of strategic importance, which focussed on situation of the Crop Product Enterprise Chisinau that stopped working in 2006. At present, many economic agents claim huge debts from this society, trying to seize the patrimony of this enterprise via law courts. It was decided that the invoked debts will be studied very seriously and the state will pay them if the law court confirms them, so that to definitively resolve this problem and to protect and keep the state patrimony in Crop Product Enterprise Chisinau.

Sitting of the Ministry of Social Protection Collegial Council

Addressing the sitting, the chief of state said that the decision to create the ministry was correct and it is part of the state leadership’s efforts to build a social state. Voronin emphasised that though the ministry has achieved certain progress in improving the social services for diverse categories of people, its area of concern was not reduced and the fulfilment of its objectives will be very important for society in continuation. He underlined the significance of finalising the draft national strategy on building an integrated social service system, and the need of a more active participation of beneficiaries in the social protection process, including decision-making.


1 ADEPT has plans to release soon an in-depth analysis on the draft state budget law for 2008 in order to comment this document.


Economic Policies

1. Prices and inflation

2. Labour market

3. Banking

4. Foreign trade


Transdnistrian Problem

Transnistrian settlement initiatives by President Voronin

President Voronin launched some additional proposals regarding the presidential initiatives on Transnistrian settlement in a new interview with the Komsomolskaya Pravda newspaper on October 24. In particular, he referred to property rights in Transnistria, which is one of the most sensitive issues related to the conflict settlement. According to the president, Moldova will guarantee the property rights in Transnistria on basis of a simple property declaration, without investigating much the way one property or another was acquired. Moldova has already worked out a draft law in this respect. The draft was tabled to the Transnistria settlement mediators and observers and, the President assured, they have appreciated the approach of Chisinau regarding this issue. At the same time, the chief of state insisted that this draft law could be adopted only concomitantly with regulation of the status of the Transnistrian region, as the adoption of such a law before the final resolution of the conflict could encourage criminal structures to take arbitrary actions.

The OSCE, the United States, the European Union and Ukraine have backed the package of initiatives by President Voronin. According to the president, Russia, which "plays a decisive role" in this conflict[1], did not express so far a clear attitude towards these initiatives, though it has earlier signed a statement welcoming Moldova’s initiatives together with other mediators and observers. It seems that these initiatives have been the topic of talks between President Voronin and visiting Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Gregory Karasin.

On the other hand, Tiraspol leaders deny in continuation that they have received formal Transnistria settlement initiatives from Chisinau. They claim that the new initiatives by Chisinau have been launched only in the form of media interviews so far and there is no positive change in relations with Chisinau[2].

Meanwhile, the Chisinau Government has made a decision on implementation of President Voronin’s initiatives aimed at strengthening the confidence and security in the Transnistria settlement context. Under the new decision, seven sectoral working groups will be created to work out action plans on implementation of the presidential initiatives and to work out and implement joint projects inclusively with the participation of representatives of the Transnistrian region within one month. The working groups will focus on elaboration and implementation of infrastructure projects; resumption of normal activity of railroads; better functioning of educational institutions; conditions for economic and commercial activity; consolidation of stability and ensuring free movement in the security zone, disarmament and demilitarisation; granting of humanitarian aid.

Europa.md has quoted Reintegration Minister Vasile Sova as saying that Tiraspol had a positive reaction towards the initiatives of Chisinau and the first draft proposals will be available within two weeks.

A more active role for European Union

While on a visit to Chisinau, European Parliament Deputy Chairman, Miguel Angel Martinez, has called for the strengthening of the EU role in the Transnistria settlement process. Moldpress news agency has quoted the European MP as saying that the present observer status of the EU in the Transnistria settlement process is ineffective and unfit for the role the EU must assume on the European continent. He expressed optimism that the future legal and political framework of EU-Moldova relations will envisage a more active role for the EU in the Transnistrian settlement process, an idea which the Chisinau authorities have supported.

It is worth noting that the proposals seeking a more active EU role in the Transnistria settlement process launched by Miguel Angel Martinez in Chisinau are also part of a recent Resolution by the European Parliament concerning violation of human rights in the Transnistrian region.

The initiatives by the European parliamentarian also resonate to some degree with the EU readiness to provide direct humanitarian aid to the Transnistrian region in order to remedy the consequences of the summer 2007 drought. EU Special Representative for Moldova, Kalman Mizsei, has expressed the EU readiness during a meeting with the Tiraspol speaker. Mizsei recommended the Transnistrian authorities to work out concrete assistance proposals and reports on consequences of the drought, on which basis the EU will consider the possibility to grant assistance to the region.

Also, Mizsei and Transnistrian parliamentarians discussed possible measures to allow people from the two banks of the Nistru River to engage in commercial activity, to enter and leave the region without problems, and to create a positive climate for the negotiation process[3].


1 Moldpress, October 29, 2007

2 Novy Region, October 17, 2007

3 Novy Region, October 15, 2007


Foreign Affairs

European integration

8th Meeting of E.U.- Moldova Cooperation Committee

Chisinau hosted the 8th Meeting of the European Union – Moldova Cooperation Committee on October 25. Hilde Hardeman, head of unit within the DG RELEX of the European Commission, chaired the meeting on behalf of the European Commission and Valeriu Ostalep, deputy minister of foreign affairs and European integration, on behalf of Moldova.

The meeting focussed on the process of implementation of the E.U.-Moldova Action Plan (EUMAP). According to a communication by the Moldovan Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration (MFAEI), European officials noted that Moldova has achieved important legislative progresses and reiterated the importance of ensuring the enforcement of the adopted legal and normative acts. Thus, E.U. representatives have restated one of the conclusions of the Progress Report on Moldova released by the European Commission on December 4, 2006, and of the June 19 Luxembourg 9th Meeting of the E.U.-Moldova Cooperation Council. It means that the E.U. did not improve much so far its perception on Moldova’s capacity to effectively implement the legislative achievements.

Following progresses have been noted among others: the active political dialogue between E.U. and Moldova, Moldova’s accession to the Bologna Process; the participation in the ERASMUS-MUNDUS "External Cooperation Window" and TEMPUS III programmes, etc.

Hilde Hardeman has told a news conference after the formal meeting that the European Commission will release its second report assessing the progress in implementing the EUMAP in April 2008 and the E.U. will thus decide on its further relationship with Moldova. In turn, Valeriu Ostalep was confident regarding the progress of relations between the Parties and noted that the name of the new agreement with the E.U. is less important for Moldova, then is if this document will help Moldova to benefit from the EU four fundamental freedoms. This is greater brain wave and option than the former obsessive desire of Chisinau to sign an Association Agreement with the E.U. This demand has started irritating Brussels.

NCEI

The National Commission for European Integration (NCEI) held an ordinary weekly sitting on October 25. The Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry, the Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources and the Ministry of Industry and Infrastructure reported their achievements aimed at implementing the EUMAP. The few shortcomings signalled at the NCEI sitting are related to the implementation of technical regulations and functioning of food quality testing laboratories.

Like at the precedent sittings, Prime Minister Vasile Tarlev signalled the need of amply reporting the EUMAP implementation process to European institutions.

Visit of EP vice-president to Moldova

European Parliament (EP) Vice-President Miguel Angel Martinez Martinez was on an official visit to Moldova in late October. In Chisinau he has met Moldovan dignitaries including President Vladimir Voronin and Speaker Marian Lupu. The talks focussed on many topics, from the move of Moldovan citizens in the E.U. to the Transdnistrian settlement.

The EP vice-president declared readiness to help extending the interparliamentary dialogue, so that to enhance Moldova’s visibility in Europe and to ease the inclusion of its priorities on the European agenda of talks. In this respect, the Moldovan side was interested to organise working visits of Moldovan parliamentarians to the EP.

Bilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Romania

The Moldovan-Romanian bilateral relations have shown signs of a little relieve in the period concerned. Moldovan Speaker Marian Lupu and Romanian Ambassador to Moldova Filip Teodorescu have agreed during a meeting that the common European values and standards must be the binder of the two countries. Starting from this linking bridge, the Moldovan-Romanian relations could be further developed in a wide range of areas: economic, commercial, transborder cooperation, people-to-people contacts, etc.

However, President Voronin has a bit different opinion on these matters. He hinted during a broadcast aired by TV channel NIT that Moldova is ready to cede and negotiate with Romania only with the purpose to fructify its European aspirations.

Regional cooperation

Republic of Moldova – BSEC

The Turkish capital of Ankara hosted the 17th Meeting of the Black See Economic Cooperation (BSEC) Foreign Ministers on October 25. Eugenia Kistruga, deputy minister of foreign affairs and European integration, represented Moldova at the meeting. According to the MFAEI press service, representatives of the states participating in the meeting studied the mechanisms needed to enforce the declaration of the June 2007 Istanbul BSEC Summit and approved a BSEC statement. Turkey handed over the BSEC chairmanship to Ukraine at the end of the meeting, after running it for half a year.

Multilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe

ECHR judgments

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has passed a record number of judgments – 15 – vs. Moldova in the period concerned, in particular, Tara and Poiata vs. Moldova; Tiberneac Vasile vs. Moldova; Nadulisneac Ion vs. Moldova; Buianovschi vs. Moldova; Deordiev and Deordiev vs. Moldova; Vitan vs. Moldova; Tiberneac vs. Moldova; Marcu vs. Moldova; Cazacu vs. Moldova; Colibaba vs. Moldova; Flux and Samson vs. Moldova; Stici vs. Moldova; Turcan and Turcan vs. Moldova; Deliuchin vs. Moldova, and Lipatnikova and Rudic vs. Moldova. Moldova was sentenced for violation of freedom of expression, rights to protection of property, effective appeal, for torture, illegal detention and non-execution or late execution of judgments[1].

The ECHR has sentenced Moldova in 91 cases until now. It passed 46 judgments (50.5 percent) vs. Moldova only in 2007(!), the year that authorities declared to be the "last 100 metres" in the EUMAP implementation process[2].


1 Moldova will have to pay 78,710 Euros (approximately 1.3 million lei) as damages in the 15 cases.

2 The ECHR has obliged Moldova to pay approximately 1.53 million Euros (about 25.3 million lei) in damages to applicants until now.


Studies, Analyses, Comments

What does sociological profile of new local power suggest? (Part II)
Igor Botan, 31 October 2007


III. Sociological profile of district and municipal councillors

There are essential differences between sociological profiles of district and municipal councillors (2nd level of local administration) and mayors of localities elected at the June 3 and 17, 2007 local elections. These differences will be highlighted below, being the expression of particularities of the Law # 436-XVI from 28.12.06 concerning the local public administration and the Law # 768-XIV from 02.02.2000 concerning the status of local councillor, which regulate the competences, responsibilities, incompatibilities and temporary framework of councillors and mayors. Thus, councillors enjoy an extended authority in making decisions and controlling their execution by administration, but their responsibilities are very vague inclusively because of an unstable remuneration (except for daily allowances), having a normal work programme of one sitting in three months. Instead, mayors have managerial responsibilities and their function is incompatible with any other remunerated post, except for teaching or scientific jobs.

Distribution on political membership criterion

Table 19 reveals that the councillor position is politicised more than the mayoral office. Thus, only 1.9 percent of the elected district and municipal councillors attended the elections as independent candidates, compared with 15 percent of mayors. Also, the mayoral office was wanted more than the councillor position – more than 9 persons bided for the post of mayor and more than 5 persons for the office of councillor. The distribution of the 1,122 district and municipal councillors on political membership criterion generally repeats the distribution of mayors.

Table 19. Political membership of district and municipal councilors, 2007
Political membership of district and municipal councilors, 2007
Distribution on age criterion

The medium age of district councillors is 51.7 years old, by four years more than of mayors. Table 20 reveals that the PCRM and the LP are at the poles of the age average of councillors among parties with a certain weight.

Table 20. Medium age of district and municipal councilors, 2007
Medium age of district and municipal councilors, 2007

Table 21 shows that proportions of age categories of the main political parties are comparable. In contrast with the distribution of mayors, the distribution of councillors on age criterion is more balanced. There is an explanation in this respect: the councillors are elected on party lists, being represented those inserted in top of candidates lists, while as regards mayors the representation of different categories rests at a bigger extend with sympathies of citizens for skills of candidates and less with representation norms accepted by parties. Table 21 reveals that the LP and the CDPP are the parties with the most balanced representation on age criterion, while the PCRM, the OMA and the DPM promote the most experienced persons.

Table 21. Distribution of district and municipal councilors on age criterion
Distribution of district and municipal councilors on age criterion
Distribution on gender criterion

As many as 16.5 percent of the district and municipal councillors are female, which is by 1.5 percent less than female mayors. The percent of independent female councillors – 0.2 percent – confirms that Moldovan parties have an important role in promoting equal genders in politics. Table 22 highlights the numeric representation of female councillors in political parties.

Table 22. Political membership of female district and municipal councilors
Political membership of female district and municipal councilors

In general, the representation of women in Parliament – 20 percent, mayoralties 18 percent and district and municipal councils 16.5 percent accordingly to the European average is the merit of parties. Although there are clear progresses in promoting women, one cannot speak so far about well-done policies in this respect. The representation of female councillors in the two municipalities with status of administrative territorial units of second level, Balti and Chisinau, is cardinally different. The representation of female councillors in Balti is 14.3 percent, which means below the average on country, while the representation of female councillors in the Chisinau municipality is the highest – 1/3. The performance in Chisinau is due to the second faction in the Chisinau Municipal Council, the Liberal Party, which is represented more than 50 percent by women. Table 23 shows that the LP has the highest representation of women in district and municipal councils on country.

Table 23. Percent of female municipal and district councillors of every party
Percent of female municipal and district councillors of every party
Distribution on education criterion

As approximately 90 percent of councillors had studied in the soviet period like mayors, their distribution on education criterion indicates a certain reality linked to the economic profile and staff training policies from the period concerned. Table 24 compared with Table 9 indicates certain differences in distribution of councillors and mayors on education criterion, and this fact can be intuited rather than established on basis of clear data. A comparison of data on education and occupation may give a more credible explanation and this will be done in the column regarding distribution on occupation criterion (Table 26).

Table 24. Distribution of municipal and district councillors on education criterion
Distribution of municipal and district councillors on education criterion

Table 25 confirms that the representation of councillors on education criteria like of mayors is uniform for the main political parties represented in Parliament.

Table 25. Distribution of municipal and district councillors of parliamentary parties on education criterion
Distribution of municipal and district councillors of parliamentary parties on education criterion
Distribution on occupation criterion

Table 26 reveals the categories of politically and administratively active citizens in the light of basic occupation. The fact that entrepreneurs are represented most in local public administration bodies is not new, and this thing was also observed after the May 2003 local elections. If acknowledging that the "statistic" norm accordingly to which 5–7 percent of citizens are entrepreneurs is applicable in Moldova as well, their 24 percent representation in local councils, which means a four-fold rise, is a phenomenon worthy of attention and analysis.

Table 26. Distribution of municipal and district councillors on profession
Distribution of municipal and district councillors on profession

This phenomenon is one of most remarkable effects of the transition period. In all likelihood, the most active and skilful citizens had started up business in the period concerned, but the most significant segment of entrepreneurs was made of engineers because of deindustrialisation of Moldova. An explanation in this respect would be that health and educational institutions had subsisted somehow in the most difficult times, that is why doctors and teaches kept their jobs while engineers lost them very quickly, being forced by circumstances to adapt themselves to the new conditions.

So, the conclusion is that the overrepresentation of entrepreneurs and engineers in local administration councils is justified somehow. However, there are more prosaic reasons for overrepresentation of entrepreneurs in local administration councils. Entrepreneurs finance their electoral campaigns alone and they probably offer larger support to their parties. It is not an occurrence that businessmen choose to be elected in representative bodies when the financing of parties and electoral campaigns is not regulated adequately and financial control bodies manifest an excessive zeal towards the business willing to fund opposition parties.

Businessmen are also overrepresented among mayors. Table 12 hides the true number of businessmen elected mayors, as the relative majority of nearly 50 percent of mayors who have recently been re-elected came from business sector before their first election in 2003.

Table 27 reveals the distribution of councillors representing parliamentary parties on occupation criterion. Curiously, the share of entrepreneurs in the PCRM exceeds the average for this category, as well as for the OMA and the DPM. In general, it is very curious that approximately 42 percent of all business councillors are elected on behalf of the PCRM. In this respect, the reciprocal post-election accusations of the ruling party and opposition parties regarding attempts "to bribe" certain independent councillors or representatives of small parties or even to convert political "enemies" in order to create majority coalitions in districts, are grounded. Councillors who are businessmen could have used such artifices for "efficiency" reasons, without consulting the party leaders. Anyway, the scandals related to the "purchase of votes" of councillors should fuel thoughts.

Table 27. Distribution of municipal and district councillors of parliamentary parties on occupation criterion
Distribution of municipal and district councillors of parliamentary parties on occupation criterion

Table 27 shows that the PCRM is the main beneficiary of skills of specialists and public functionaries from de-concentrated services of central public administration (CPA) and probably of administrative resources. Anyway, decisions by the July 7 PCRM plenary session, obliging PCRM members elected in the public administration bodies, also confirms the danger of politicising the public administration.

Another fact worth to be mentioned is that teachers and doctors, particularly headmasters and directors of hospitals have a significant representation quota in district and municipal councils. The fact that the representation of teachers and doctors is proportional in terms of political affiliation indicates similar attitudes of influent political parties towards education and healthcare. However, if teachers are represented more or less uniformly among mayors and councillors, doctors are mainly represented among councillors, as this profession does not admit long interruptions imposed by the position of mayor.

Table 28 reveals the number of re-elected councillors of every political party.

Table 28. Number of re-elected municipal and district councilors
Number of re-elected municipal and district councilors

Table 29 reveals that the re-elected councillors count for approximately 35 percent and accordingly to previous data, this is typical both to local councils and to the Moldovan Parliament. Like in case of mayors, the PCRM has the highest percentage of re-elected councillors, but district democratic coalitions of other parties may compete with the PCRM regarding the previous experience of councillors.

Table 29. Percentage of re-elected municipal and district councillors
Percentage of re-elected municipal and district councillors
Political migration of councillors

The political migration of re-elected councillors allows a general estimation of the political migration phenomenon. Thus, 395 (35.2 percent) out of 1,122 councillors are re-elected councillors. The political migration among councillors was 14 percent, which is two-fold lower than of mayors. Mayors probably feel more the influence of competitive parties, particularly of the ruling party. As expected for councillors as well, the PCRM was the most active party to convert councillors of political opponents and independents. However, opposition parties, particularly the main rival of the Party of Communists, the OMA, cannot complain because they acted the same way.

If the mayors’ conversion proportion is 5:1 in favour of PCRM and in the detriment of OMA, in the case of councillors’ conversion the proportion is only 2:1 (see Table 30), and this corresponds exactly to the electoral rating of the PCRM and the OMA.

Table 30. Converted re-elected municipal and district councillors
Converted re-elected municipal and district councillors

However, the OMA has a justification, as most of the converted councillors came from former members of the Democratic Moldova Bloc (DMB) – the SLP and the DP. Secondly, as observed in Table 31, the OMA has suffered the most from political conversions of councillors.

Nevertheless, proportions of political migration among councillors must not surprise. The political migration of district/municipal councillors is nothing but an echo of manoeuvres of coalition, merger and splitting of central party elites and that’s why central elites "reap what they seed."

Table 31. Municipal and district councillors who migrated from indicated parties
Municipal and district councillors who migrated from indicated parties

Table 32 provides complete information regarding the political migration of councillors. The number of re-elected councillors of every party is indicated on the diagonal at the intersection of the horizontal and vertical for each party. The number of councillors converted from every opponent party is indicated on the horizontal. The number of councillors lost by each party to opponents is indicated on the vertical.

Table 32. Converted district councillors
 PCRMOMADPMCDPPPSDMSDPMRPPCUMLPPLJNLPEBPRRICSLPPMSNMAPMTotal
PCRM22784----1----4-1624
OMA2773---------24--11
DPM--33---------1-1-2
CDPP-2-20------------2
PSDM-1--6-----------1
SDPM--1--5----------1
RPP-1----1---------1
CUM11-----6--------2
LP---1----2---1---2
PLJ---1-----1------1
NLP----------1-1---1
EBPRR-----------1----0
IC2211--------81-18
SLP-------------7--0
PMSNM--------------0-0
APM---------------00
Total5159300010000952756

IV. Political profile of district/municipal administrations

The results of the June 3 and 17, 2007 local elections had an immediate impact on conduct of the main political parties. In this regard, the PCRM was the first party to comment the results of local elections at the July 7, 2007 plenary session, establishing its immediate priorities to prepare itself for the 2009 parliamentary elections. An unhidden objective voiced by President Voronin was formulated as a threat against districts ruled by opposition parties (district chairmen and deputy chairmen).

Table 32 highlights the political membership of district chairmen and Chisinau and Balti administrations. The PCRM exercises two kinds of pressures on opposition majority coalitions from districts and Chisinau municipality: financial pressures, which are clearly observed in the draft budget law for 2008, a document especially contested by the OMA, which rules a relative majority of districts; information pressures aimed to libel leaders of opposition parties, especially the LP leaders who rule the Chisinau municipality. It is true that leaders of opposition parties have provided lots of pretexts to be ridiculed by the PCRM propagandistic machine. If the opposition knew to learn from own mistakes and draw conclusions from what happened so that not to expose itself to the confusing propaganda of the PCRM (at least till the 2009 elections), it would be thankful to this propagandistic machine for starting its assaults now.

Table 33. Political membership of district chairmen and administrations of municipalities (Chisinau and Balti)
Political membership of district chairmen and administrations of municipalities (Chisinau and Balti)

Table 33 reveals the distribution of offices of deputy district chairmen and deputy mayors of the Chisinau and Balti municipalities.

Table 34. Political membership of deputy district chairmen
Political membership of deputy district chairmen

V. Conclusions

  1. The sociological profile of mayors and district/municipal councillors reveals that the representation of all important political parties in public administration bodies is generally more or less uniform in terms of education and occupation of local councillors. In this regard, one could say that the profile of the largest and most active segment of political parties represented in public administration bodies is irrelevant for the Moldovan political cleavage. The social status determined by education and occupation of representatives of political parties does not substantiate the pretensions to represent some social levels with certain specifics.

  2. The essential differences in representation of parties in local public administration bodies envisage the age and the gender. However, comparisons reveal the positive role of parties in reducing the disequilibrium. The distribution of independent mayors and councillors on diverse criteria is a reference point for these comparisons. Given the fact that approximately 52 percent of the voters are women and approximately 40 percent are citizens between 20 and 39 years old, these categories are represented 8 and 4 percent in case of independent councillors, compared with the average of 16.5 percent and 8 percent. The situation is different as regards mayors. The representation of women and persons between 20 and 39 years old is as follows: 15 percent and 18 percent for independents, compared with the average of 18 percent and 15 percent. Youths promotes themselves easier to the mayoral position than via parties.

  3. Entrepreneurs in Moldova represent the most active political segment, being represented by approximately ¼ of district/municipal councils. Of course, these are representatives of small and medium businesses made of managers of limited societies, joint stock societies and individual enterprises. This would be a very encouraging conclusion if the Moldovan political culture allowed a clear delimitation of the private and public interest. However, there are clear signals that the business joins the politics to protect itself against pressures rather than because it is aware of its role in society. As the activeness and capacities of businessmen exceed the statistic average, the Moldovan political scene may change much very soon.

  4. The example of small and medium business representatives may encourage the big business, which could get involved with social projects after the 2009 parliamentary elections. The approach of political problems is typical to businessmen, given the risk distribution criterion. It is logical to distribute the "political eggs" to other baskets as well, not only to the one of the ruling party. That’s why investments in new social democratic, liberal, etc., projects are expected. This is expected including because the politics has become the most profitable business at the current development stage of the Republic of Moldova. This conclusion is effective both for Moldova and for all states in transition.

  5. Mergers, coalitions and political migration will further persist until the 2009 parliamentary elections, as the uniformity of parties’ representation on occupation of their members allows slight jumps over doctrinaire and ideological barriers. In spite of uniformity of representatives of main political parties, doctrines and ideologies of Moldovan parties remain important to strengthen the leadership of parties and to assimilate the experience and elaborations of "internationals" built on basis of doctrines.

  6. The uniformity of parties’ representation on education and occupation of their members suggests that once they are elected to rule the country or municipalities, parties will be lured to promote policies dictated by circumstances rather than by supported doctrines and ideologies. A confirmation in this respect is the fact that the PCRM does not scruple to state that it promotes "liberal reforms in economy" in spite of its communist doctrine based on the "Marxist-Leninist theory," while the LP says after having gained the power in the Chisinau municipality that it has to reconsider the social policies in order to protect the socially vulnerable levels. For this reason, arguments that an eventual coalition or merger of social democratic parties with social liberal parties, etc. would be unnatural do not resist. The invoked "uniformity" is also clear because electoral offers of majority of political parties are amazingly similar in spite of doctrinaire differences. Under these circumstances, in order to raise electoral profit, the main political parties polarise the public opinion on more sensitive criteria than the doctrinaire ones, such as: linguistic, ethnic identity, interpretation of history, with the purpose to suggest visions for an eventual future. Political scandals that have already started from perspective of the 2009 parliamentary elections are another source to polarise opinions in a relatively uniform space.

  7. Besides multiple organisational and media advantages, the PCRM is very advantaged by experience of its representatives in public administration. In contrast, the opposition could face soon a very unpleasant fact with a huge propagandistic potential. Knowing how hard opposition political parties have negotiated major coalitions in districts, including to influence the election of district chairmen and deputy chairmen, it is strange that they did not work to confederate or at least to inform the public opinion over preparation of new elections for the Rezina district council, elected on June 3, 2007 but dissolved because democratic parties could not ensure at three consecutive sittings the necessary quorum to demonstrate the functionality. The opposition would need very much a victory at the November 11 elections in order to influence the public opinion, so that to provide an incontestable confirmation of the trend of unrecoverable decline of the PCRM. The way the opposition has prepared itself for the Rezina elections does not inspire confidence that it realised the importance of the victory. The PCRM has truly avoided talks on election of the Rezina district council, with the probable purpose not to remind the public opinion that the boycott of the PCRM was one of indispensable elements to dissolve the district council and waste public funds. However, the goal of the PCRM is understandable – to undermine the opposition and to win the November 11 new district elections. The recent visit of President Voronin to the Rezina district and the suggestion to electors that those they vote on June 3 do not understand what value they promote are not occurrences. If the PCRM wins the Rezina elections, the media-holding affiliated to PCRM will have an amazing propagandistic topic to suggest citizens what may happen at the 2009 parliamentary elections. Even more, an eventual victory of the PCRM in Rezina will answer what would have happened at the early parliamentary elections, if the opposition had blocked the April 4, 2005 election of the president.


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]