![]() | Association for Participatory Democracy | Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md Original: /en/e-journal/20080415/index.shtml |
Activity of Public Institutions
1.1. Appointments. Dismissals
Under parliamentary decisions:
1.2. Legal acts
Law on completion of the law concerning declaration and control of incomes and estate of dignitaries. Under completions, within ten days after the deadline for presentation of declarations, the central control commission shall deliver copies of declarations by judges to the Superior Council of Magistracy in order to publish them on its website.
Note by ADEPT: by completing this law, the Parliament has partly approached the transparency issue, avoiding a compulsory publication of all declarations by first-ranking dignitaries on website, though such an initiative was raised long ago and experts said that transparency in this area is an efficient method to prevent and combat corruption at a high level.
Law banning the dual citizenship. A certain circle of holders of dual citizenship will be restricted from running public offices, in particular, members of the Parliament, the chief of state, members of the Government, judges, security officers, local elected officials, functionaries provided access to state secrets, other public functionaries. Persons willing to run these offices will have to confirm their renunciation or an ongoing procedure needed to renounce the citizenship of another country, or withdraw their applications for a foreign citizenship. Note by ADEPT: It was earlier signalled the discriminatory power of this document and the possibility to use it with the purpose to exclude some electoral contestants, as well as to comb out public administration functionaries. The lack of clear provisions on renunciation or declaration to renounce the citizenship of another country will harden the enforcement and could allow an abusive, discretionary application of these regulations.
Law on modification and completion of the Election Code. The document brings new regulations, in particular, it raised the electoral threshold from 4 up to 6 percent; bans electoral blocs; specifies restrictions to elect and to be elected (for persons sentenced to jail terms, those with effective criminal records); explains provisions on suspension of dignitaries from their offices; inclusion into ballots by drawing, etc. Only the PCRM and CDPP factions have backed these modifications.
Law on modification of the law on migration. Under the law, the Government will establish the immigration quota in future after consultations with the Interior Ministry but only for labour purposes. This way, authorities hope to attract foreign investments and open new jobs in Moldova.
Draft law on protection of witnesses and other participants in criminal proceedings. The document regulates the ensuring of security of participants in criminal cases whose lives, body integrity, freedom or property are threatened, as they hold data that they accepted to provide or cogent evidence of grave or very crimes. The document is part of the EU-Moldova Action Plan and priorities of intensifying the fight against organised crime.
Draft law declaring the construction of the Cahul-Giurgiulesti railway as a public utility of national interest. Private assets (fields and constructions) near villages and communes of Manta, Colibasi, Brinza, Valeni, Slobozia Mare and Cislita-Prut, the district of Cahul, will be objects of expropriation for public utility cause. The Government will take all necessary measures on behalf of the state to expropriate assets located in the area of public utility works. Note by ADEPT: Opposition lawmakers did not warm this law, fearing that the planned expropriations are not "fairly compensated" in compliance with relevant constitutional norms (Article 46 (2) of Constitution), while the Government proposes derisory prices to landowners (maximum 56,000 lei per hectare). Also, they accused that the construction concerned affects the environment in the region.
1.3. Parliamentary control. Statements
The parliamentary majority has turned down initiatives by opposition factions and lawmakers:
Questions, Interpellations
The first deputy prosecutor-general has notified the Parliament that:
A representative of the Centre for the Struggle against Economic Crimes and Corruption has answered an interpellation regarding the legality of delivery of calculation equipment by Moldovan president to the Theoretical High School in the village of Magdacesti, the district of Criuleni. Accordingly to the report, the equipment was delivered in compliance with the regulation concerned, under an order by the Directorate-General of the Moldovan President Apparatus.
The Information and Security Service has assured Deputy Gheorghe Susarenco that it does not intercept telephones of parliamentarians.
Several lawmakers have recommended changing the hour of Ora Guvernului (Government’s Hour), so that to be held before plenary sittings and those invited for hearings to be able to fulfil their tasks at workplace later.
Democratic Party Deputy Valeriu Guma has asked the director of the railway company of Moldova CFM to explain the 200-percent rise of the internal cargo carriage transportation tariff for trains starting April 1.
Statements
On April 4, 2008, members of the Parliament commented on the election of the chief of state three years ago. Valentina Cusnir, Vladimir Filat and Iurie Rosca read statements in this respect.
The faction representing the Democratic Party of Moldova has released a statement signalling urgent necessary measures to improve living standards in Moldova, otherwise the country runs the risk to lose all residents and disappear from the map.
The faction of the Our Moldova Alliance accuses the parliamentary majority of having turned plenary sittings of the Parliament into working sittings of the Party of Communists, ignoring all proposals and objections of the opposition; it noted that the vote of Communist lawmakers is dictated by party discipline not by interest of citizens and country.
The faction representing the Party of Communists of the Republic of Moldova accuses the opposition of attempting on freedom of the media by seeking the closure of the "Rezonans" programme aired by Moldova 1 and "Povesti cu Masti" programme aired by TV channel NIT.
The faction representing the Christian Democratic People’s Party has brought new accusations against the leader of the Liberal Democratic Party of Moldova, Vladimir Filat, former director of the Privatisation and State Property Management Department, former minister of state.
In his turn, LDPM chairman Vladimir Filat has accused the CDPP and its leader Iurie Rosca of taking actions to destroy the democratic opposition.
2.1. Appointments. Dismissals
2.2. Decisions
Decision approving the Government’s action plan for the 2nd quarter of 2008. The document includes chapters on elaboration of draft normative and legal regulations, analysis of work of central public administration.
Decision on day-off in May 2008. The 2nd of May will be a day-off and the 17th of May will be a working day. Under this decision, ministries, central administration authorities, managers of state enterprises and organisations will ensure the efficient working of subordinated units on May 17.
Decisions approving some draft laws:
Decisions on allocation of funds:
2.3. Sittings. Decisions. Statements
Immediate priorities
Prime Minister Zinaida Greceanii has asked ministers, at the first sitting of the new Cabinet, to revise own action plans accordingly to the governing programme Progress and Integration. She noted that the governing programme fully complies with the National Development Programme (NDP) and it would be fair to update the action plan on implementation of NDS by following the ruling programme, in order to ensure the necessary monitoring.
Improving actions of Interior Ministry
New Interior Minister Valentin Mejinschi has presented a concept on improvement of the Interior Ministry’s activity, with the purpose to affirm the principle "police serving the society and not vice versa." The following actions are recommended for this purpose:
Diplomatic meetings
Premier Zinaida Greceanii has had a meeting with representatives and delegations from other countries, including:
3.1. Decrees
Mrs. Fatma Firat Topcuoglu, Turkish ambassador to Moldova, was awarded the Civil Merit medal, as her diplomatic mission is over.
3.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements
Law concerning state secret
Moldova’s president has chaired a working sitting with the participation of officials in charge with drafting a new law on state secret, and noted that the legal framework is being updated as the existing law on state secret is out-of-date, runs counter realities in Moldova and European norms in the area. The new draft law on state secret worked out accordingly to recommendations and objections by all central public administration authorities is being finalised and it will be delivered soon to the Government in order to study it. The chief of state outlined the opportunity of studying the experience of European countries in the area of legal regulation of state secrets, so that the final draft law to take into account modern practices from European countries. He also stressed the necessity of optimising the normative framework on protection of state secret and of reducing much the number of secret documents. Also, Vladimir Voronin indicated the opportunity of reducing the number of laws and normative acts regulating the work with secret documents and information.
Youth Year Programme
The chief of state has chaired a sitting on implementation of the action programme concerning the Youth Year, which studied actions of the programme divided into five chapters: legal, normative framework, interventions at policy level; access to services and information; participation of youths; job opportunities for youths; researches and studies on youth policies, 55 actions overall. The sitting also tackled issues such as economic abilities and social support for youths; development of infrastructure of student hostels; employment of youths; rise of the number of budget-funded seats in institutions of higher education and professional institutions (by 30 percent in the first round).
Improving textbook printing system
A sitting convoked by the chief of state has discussed aspects regarding existing textbook printing system, revealing shortcomings in the process of elaboration, editing, assessment, and reassessment and reediting of textbooks. Vladimir Voronin called for a new textbook generation which would meet European norms on didactic material. He recommended the updating of the existing system by setting up a well-structured, functional mechanism based on quality of didactic instructions, fair selection of offers of textbooks. It was stressed the opportunity of improving the mechanism of assessment of manuscripts and selection of reviewers, as well as the need of a methodological framework on assessment of manuscripts and presentation of reviews by assessors.
Activity of "confidence consolidating" groups
Following his meeting with Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov in Bender, Moldovan president has convoked a sitting on activity of working groups in charge with strengthening the confidence between Chisinau and Tiraspol. It discussed diverse aspects of the mode of organisation and conduct of work of the groups, their interaction with similar structures of the Transnistrian side. The groups shall work out proposals on implementation of commercial-economic projects; infrastructure development; restoration of Moldova’s railroads; projects on healthcare and social protection of residents of the Transnistrian region; education and youth; disarmament and demilitarisation; humanitarian assistance; agriculture.
1. Prices and inflation
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose by 1.1 percent in March compared with February 2008. In particular, prices of food products have grown by 1.7 percent, prices of manufactured goods by 0.7 percent, and tariffs for public services have increased by 1.1 percent. Prices of meat, fresh fruits and vegetal oil have grown the most in the period concerned, by more than 5 percent on average. Tariffs for providing services to population have increased by about 4 percent. Even more, prices of real estate transactions have grown by about 15 percent this year. The cumulated inflation rate for 2008 is 4.1 percent (March 2008, compared with December 2007). For comparison, the inflation rate in March 2007 was 2.1 percent, compared with December 2006.
Central banks should monitor real estate prices more carefully…
A recent report by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) says that central banks should monitor real estate prices more carefully. In addition, central banks should take into account prices on real estate market while making decisions on monetary policy interest. The non-performing loan crisis in the United States, which has made important banks go bankrupt, tens of thousands of people lose their jobs and thousands of persons lose their homes because they could not reimburse their credits, brought back the crediting problem on the forefront.
In Moldova for example, the central bank has raised the basic interest rate up to 16.5 percent and thus many important banks had to consider the interest rates on their credits. But a high reference interest practised by the central bank means higher interests on credits by commercial banks and this lowers the crediting level and finally reduces the demand on real estate market. The share of real estate market is different in every country, particularly depending on development level of the mortgage loan market. IMF notes that there are big crediting differences between countries, indicating in this regard the United States, which had a low interest rate which facilitated the access to mortgage credits, and France, which has a stricter credit policy.
The fall of the real estate market does not mean the decline of prices only. It may direct to bankruptcy of banks which granted property-guaranteed credits and now the estate is less worthy, cut jobs of tens of thousands of people, from real estate agents to bankers, and not the last, may affect the economic growth of a country.
2. Banking sector
Interests on deposits following inflation …
Promotions by local banks and new offers make savings more attractive, with the medium interest rate on deposits in lei reaching roughly 16 percent. The medium annual interest on savings in lei rose by more than 0.5 percent last month. After interest rates on deposits were below inflation in late 2007, now they recover the difference compared with price rises. Banks were summoned to raise afferent interests on savings after the basic interest rate has grown, the National Bank of Moldova recently increased the minimum mandatory reserves and a high inflation rate was forecasted.
Banks’ interests on deposits were on the rise in the past weeks. Some banks offer a medium annual interest rate of over 18 percent for deposits in lei from 6 months up to one year. However, higher interests on deposits did not exceed price rises so far. Many depositors realise that they do not gain anything after deducing the interest tax and inflation rate. Thus, banks’ interest rates on deposits in lei are really negative yet.
3. Foreign sector
Moldova’s overall foreign debt counts for about 77 percent of GDP…
Moldova’s overall foreign debt rose by more than 30 percent or 776.5 million dollars in 2007, up to over 3.3 billion dollars, which is approximately 77 percent of the GDP.
According to NBM accounts, the public and public guaranteed debt has grown from 876.4 million dollars in late 2006 up to 938.7 million dollars in late 2007. At the same time, the private non-guaranteed foreign debt has increased by 43.4 percent, up to over 2.36 billion dollars. NBM statistics also reveal that loans count for 48.7 percent of Moldova’s overall foreign debt in late 2007.
In 2007 the National Bank of Moldova was credited about 33.3 million dollars by IMF and reimbursed old loans worth 22.1 million dollars. At the same time, the governmental sector received 47.4 million dollars and paid loans and securities worth about 36 million dollars. According to the central bank, foreign commitments under the shape of loans and securities including related arrears rose up to over 2.25 billion dollars last year. This rise is linked to net inflows (465.14 million dollars), net interest arrears (7.15 million dollars), influence of the exchange rate of U.S. dollar compared with other currencies (65.02 million dollars), and other adjustments (10.75 million dollars).
4. Labour market
Existence minimum in Moldova is over 100 dollars …
The existence minimum in Moldova increased by 17.6 percent in 2007 compared with 2006 and was about 1,100 lei a month. According to NBS accounts, employees of all sectors of national economy except for agriculture afforded the existence minimum for people able to work. Employees in finance sector earned about four fold more than needed for the existence minimum, while salaries in transportation, communication, constructions exceeded the minimum level 2.6 fold. This difference on households is especially linked to different consumer expenditures and high self-consumption share in rural areas. The non-food basket was 44.2 percent of the existence minimum in urban areas and 34.4 percent in rural areas (this indicator is 39.3 percent on country).
People able to work get the highest value of existence minimum, notably 1,159.5 lei, in particular men – 1,227.0 lei. The existence minimum for retirees was 943.4 lei and it covered 85.5 percent of the average per population. As of January 1, 2008, the medium monthly pension accounted for 548.3 lei and covered 58.1 percent of the existence minimum for this category of people.
The maintenance of a child costs 1,002.7 lei on average a month, and this indicator depends on the age of the child, from 394.3 lei per child under 1 year old and up to 1,118.8 lei per child between 7 and 15 years old. Given the monthly indemnities of 230.7 lei paid to insured persons looking after a child below 1.5 years old and 100 lei paid to uninsured persons, these social allocations cover 58.5 and 25.4 percent of the needs of a baby under 1.
Rapid "thaw" may open up "flooding"
Igor Botan
I. Voronin – Smirnov meeting
President Vladimir Voronin and Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov met in Bender on April 11, 2008, after a pause of six years and half. That was a sensational event. Judging after conduct, Smirnov would have liked to avoid that meeting, with the recognition of Transnistria’s independence by Russia being a priority for him. The Russian Federation, which fully controls the Smirnov regime, has constantly insisted that the Transnistrian conflict may be settled through negotiations only, with the participation of Transnistrian representatives as an equal party. As Moldova is preparing the March 2009 parliamentary elections, President Voronin had to breach his famous August 2004 statement that he would never meet "marionettes" again but "puppeteers" only in the conflict resolution process. The resumption of the negotiation process should be a direct result of the Voronin-Smirnov meeting.
Should Voronin continued refusing meetings with Smirnov, the latter would have speculated this refusal on background of Russia’s recent call for the "territorial integrity" of Moldova based on the statement that the "potential of the negotiation process is not yet used up." That means that the further blocking of the negotiations would have fuelled speculations of the Transnistrian regime that Russia should recognise its independence in the "Kosovo precedent" context. In this regard, Smirnov has looked for excuses to avoid the meeting with Voronin, refusing to meet in the territory controlled by constitutional authorities. Instead, Voronin had to humiliate himself in front of who he called "bandit", "criminal", etc., in the past years and accept to go to Bender which is controlled by separatist forces. This detail reveals the side who was interested in this meeting the most.
However, Smirnov has also found a goal of the meeting with Voronin. He made this step after deriding what he described as fanciful statements released by Voronin in a March interview with the Moscow-based newspaper "Kommersant" regarding actions he was ready to take forward settling the Transnistrian conflict. Voronin said in that interview that he was ready to meet Smirnov in order to make a progress in resuming the negotiation process.
Smirnov has severely and clearly explained why he accepted to meet Voronin – to discuss the recognition of Transnistria’s independence. Indeed, Smirnov was obliged to meet instructions by Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, who told him "nado" (must) and to accept a telephone conversation with President Voronin and then the proper meeting. As he has stated after the April 7 telephone conversation, Smirnov accepted to meet Voronin in order to hand in "the friendship agreement between Transnsitria and the Republic of Moldova"; that means an agreement between two sovereign states.
More than that, the Transnistrian propaganda-making machine has held a mad campaign on background of the Voronin-Smirnov meeting in order to stress negative attitudes toward Moldova, noting that Voronin is not credible in eyes of the Tiraspol administration. The public opinion was recalled the March 2005 case of former defence minister; Voronin’s refusal to sign the Kozak Memorandum in 2003; the "economic blockade" introduced in 2006 on the background of recent unprecedented cases of trafficking in drugs in Moldova; other evidence that makes Transnistria unwilling anything in common with Moldova, so that it will regulate its relations through a "friendship agreement" only.
Following the meeting that lasted an hour and half, Voronin and Smirnov have shown themselves up in front of cameras to comment their talks. The two screwed faces were a very eloquent proof of reciprocal feelings of the two persons, as well as of the fact that the circumstances alone have pushed them to a private meeting. Smirnov seized the occasion to stress that Voronin was his guest in Bender and, given this quality, he generously allowed him to address journalists the first. Also, Smirnov noted that he has handed in the "friendship agreement" to Voronin and the "two equal parties" should sign and ratify this document as sovereign and independent states. Finally, Smirnov emphasised that he is expecting constitutional authorities of Moldova to ensure an equal-footing treatment; to withdraw all economic and commercial obstacles faced by Transnsitria. In spite of the manner in which Smirnov tried to lay the emphasis, President Voronin has ostentatiously avoided comments on Smirnov’s provocative initiatives, focussing on matters he was particularly interested in – actions to build confidence between the two banks of the Dniester River; that means measures directly recommended by his October 2007 initiatives.
The only yielding Voronin has reportedly accepted while meeting Smirnov was the promise to ask the European Union (EU) and the United States to withdraw the travel interdiction on 17 Transnistrian dignitaries, but in turn the Transnistrian side shall withdraw the travel ban against a number of Moldovan officials. Instead, Voronin has assured himself a significant support of participants in the "5+2" negotiation process. Thus, the EU special representative to Moldova, Kalman Mizei, has appreciated Voronin’s efforts and his meeting with Smirnov. Voronin’s meeting with Smirnov was synchronised with a meeting between U.S. and UK ambassador Michael Kirby and John Meyer and Transnistrian speaker Evgeni Shevchyuk, who discussed the possibility of implementing infrastructural projects recommended by Voronin’s October 2007 initiatives. Even more, the projects concerned are part of the National Development Strategy (NDS) for 2008–2011 and the programme of the new Greceanii Cabinet of Ministers.
All the facts above have been arranged so that to give the impression that Voronin’s meeting with Smirnov was necessary to restart a wide conflict settlement plan which is not ready yet, though this event was unpleasant for the president of Moldova.
II. Reiterated attitude of President Voronin towards Transnistrian problem
On April 3, 2008, just one week before the meeting with Smirnov, President Voronin reiterated Moldova’s stance on Transnistrian conflict at the Bucharest NATO Summit:
By handing in the so-called "friendship agreement" to Voronin at the April 11 meeting, Smirnov wanted to stress his diametrically opposite point of view regarding the Transnistria settlement. Indeed, Smirnov’s "friendship agreement" is also a response to Voronin’s "October initiatives". Voronin stressed after meeting Smirnov that no groundless yielding to the "separatist regime" is envisaged in the Transnistria settlement process and the process of searching a valid solution to the Transnistrian conflict in the "5+2" format does not stipulate the federalisation of Moldova.
III. Reactions to Voronin-Smirnov meeting
The Chisinau media has controversially commented the Voronin-Smirnov meeting. As a rule, the media affiliated to the ruling party has praised the courage of the chief of state. On the other hand, the independent media and that supporting the opposition said that:
The viewpoints above underline the opposition’s logic that President Voronin is wrongly approaching the Transnistrian problem in terms of principle. A number of opposition parties and local experts consider that the right solution for Moldova is to make a common front with Georgia and Ukraine in favour of a pro-NATO application, rather than to insist on Moldova’s neutrality. According to a part of opposition focussing on neutrality idea is a condition imposed by Russia and it reflects the Russian interests. It is supposed that ceding to Russia with regard to the neutrality problem just opens up the "Pandora’s box". In this respect, President Voronin is accused of promoting obscure interests and non-transparent negotiations.
It is worth to mention that the viewpoints above make abstraction of the new context, which is absolutely unlike the one in which the Voronin-Smirnov meeting took place:
IV. Transnistria – Russia’s handle-free suitcase?
Separatist elites in Tiraspol were also very unsatisfied with Russia’s behaviour. But being fully dependent on Moscow’s benevolence, they had to accept the new conjuncture. The Transnistrian leaders are demoralised because they have been encouraged in the past three years to hold propagandistic campaigns round o’clock to assure citizens that Russia will use the "universality of the Kosovo precedent" in order to recognise Transnistria’s independence, while now they have to look for a compromise solution with the Republic of Moldova.
The March hearings and Declaration by the Russian State Duma concerning the unrecognised republics of Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Transnistria revealed that Russia’s threats to treat the "Kosovo case" as a universal precedent was a banal bluffness. In this regard, a number of Transnistrian lawmakers had to accuse Russia of unwillingness to honour its promises and to blame it for sufferings of Transnistrians, who have to live in an extremely bad material condition and face shortages because of the pro-Russia orientation which proves to be sterile.
These attitudes emerged into a first political scandal between members of the separatist "old guard" in Tiraspol, who started searching those to blame for Moscow’s new attitude towards the separatist enclave. The Supreme Soviet has even accused foreign minister Valeri Litskai of professional incapacity. Trying to defend himself, Litskai had to recall everybody Russia’s inflexible stance to settle the Transnistrian conflict on the basis of Moldova’s territorial integrity and by granting a guaranteed status to Transnistria. He indicated confederative relations between Moldova and Transnistria, hinting that a federative solution would be the best one. The "solution" recommended by Litskai seems to be intermediary between those publicly promoted by Voronin and Smirnov.
However, Russia’s conduct has profound explanations. Russian experts tried to argue why Russia had to act contrarily to own threats to regard the "Kosovo case" as a universal precedent:
V. Conclusions
In the context of the new regional conjuncture President Vladimir Voronin got a positive rather than negative score after the April 11, 2008 meeting. It is hard to underrate the weight of the propagandistic victory of the ruling party a year before the 2009 parliamentary elections. Voronin has actually received a green light to his October 2007 initiative on building confidence between the two banks of the Dniester. The creation of working groups and high probability to resume the "5+2" negotiation process is a proof in this respect. The support of U.S., EU and OSCE representatives for Voronin’s initiatives and financial assistance promises additionally confirm a positive trend;
As regards Moldova’s long-term interests, those raising prudence over President Voronin’s recent performance are true. The ostentatious differentiation that Russia is making between the separatist enclave of Moldova and those of Georgia has a price that Moldova has started paying in advance. In particular, Moldovan authorities kept silence when Russia held elections for the State Duma in Transnistria like at home on March 2. Now it is to see whether Moldovan authorities will tacitly allow Russia to open representations in separatist enclaves, accordingly to the recent Declaration by the State Duma. This process is underway in Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Georgia has immediately and vehemently reacted like at the March 2 elections, seeking international support;
Moldova’s dissociation with GUAM states – Ukraine and Georgia – regarding relations with NATO advantages it somehow in Russia’s attitudes towards the Transnistrian conflict, though this is not the most genuine step by Moldovan authorities. But undermining Ukraine’s positions as regional leader and key pivot of GUAM through Moldova’s eventual withdrawal from this organisation, the way President Voronin has recently announced, is hardly a correct step. Ukraine’s role in settling the Transnistrian conflict is as important as the one of Russia. Ukraine’s advancement forward EU and NATO is the only and most real guarantee for Moldova to recover Transnistria. In this respect, President Voronin’s insistence on internationally "recognised neutrality status" of Moldova raises confusion. By recognising the sovereignty of Moldova, states of the world recognise automatically the constitutional norm on its neutrality. In all likelihood, President Voronin wants the own country to be unable to modify the article concerned from Constitution in future, without the consent of countries which would "recognise its neutrality status." This gives arguments to the opposition to fear that President Voronin wants indeed to limit the sovereignty of the country and turn it into a kind of international protectorate.
Moldovan authorities should not cherish illusions regarding possibility to quickly settle the Transnistrian conflict. Russian influent circles have made public scenarios of likeliest evolutions of Russia’s relations with separatist enclaves. Two scenarios that complete each other could be implemented in parallel, making reference to the U.S. relations with Taiwan and Puerto Rico. It means that relations would be constantly developed on the basis of the "Taiwan example" and Russia would treat the separatist enclaves as de facto independent states. Referenda on association of separatist enclaves with Russia would be periodically recommended in parallel, on the basis of the association of Puerto-Rico with the U.S. Thus, conditions for the slowly "digestion" of the separatist enclaves by Russia would be created by adjusting all aspects of their internal life to Russian norms. Both approaches exclude the need of recognising the independence of the separatist enclaves, allowing Russia to set itself up for being a "firm protector of the international law," as well as to maintain states suffering from separatism in its area of influence. This suits Russia very well, being able to treat the separatist enclaves the way it wants – either as de facto but unrecognised states, "contributing to the resolution of conflicts with constitutional authorities of Moldova and Georgia" or as associated entities populated by "fellow countrymen", citizens of the Russian Federation. In fact, Russia has built relations with the separatist enclaves on basis of the "Taiwan model" since 1992, while the strategy on association with Russia after the Puerto-Rico model was elaborated by Constantin Zatulin in 2000 and it stipulated the massive awarding of the Russian citizenship to residents of separatist enclaves and referenda on association with Russia held in 2006 in all three separatist enclaves. The "Kosovo case" had no connection with those strategies. Now it is simply used for reasons of easiness to argue Russia’s policies on separatist regimes and emphasise the respect for the "international law."
Given the circumstances above, resuming the "5+2" negotiation process is welcome before the 2009 elections but further actions are not recommended, as solutions to Transnistria’s status should be found after elections, when the pressure of rapid and negative solutions will be remedied. In metaphorical terms, the rapid "thaw" of the Transnistrian "frozen conflict" may open up "flooding" of all Moldova. In this regard, preventing risks of an eventual "transnistrisation" of Moldova is a priority.
European integration
Implementation of ENP in 2007. Progress report on implementation of the EU-Moldova Action Plan
On April 3, the European Commission released the Communication to the Council and European Parliament "Implementation of the European Neighbourhood Policy in 2007". The communication is accompanied by other documents of the Commission such as Overall Assessment, Progress and Country Reports. The Communication on the implementation of ENP in 2007 emphasises that the ENP is becoming a reciprocally advantageous partnership for reformation and development, drawing neighbouring countries into an increasingly close relationship with the EU, but promoting a regional integration outside the EU borders. Another important conclusion of the Communication is that future operational instruments which will replace the former Action Plans (especially on Moldova, Ukraine and Israel, which expire in 2008) will be adjusted to ambitions and capacities of partner states, covering differentiated relations between the EU and its partners. However, the new instruments will keep the old format of Action Plans, but will clearly specify the objectives/actions to be taken in the same key areas (7).
But the Progress Report Moldova on implementation of the EU-Moldova Action Plan from November 2006 to December 2007 was the most expected document. According to the Report, Moldova has made progress in all areas covered by EUMAP, in particular, improvement of the institutional framework, signing of the Agreement on Autonomous Trade Preferences and Visa Facilitation and Readmission Agreements, close cooperation with the EU in the Transnistria settlement process and foreign policy questions, Moldova-Ukraine border management, introduction of origin certificates for exported commodities, creation of the National Agency for the Protection of Competition, etc.
According to the representative of the European Commission (EC) Delegation to Moldova, Paolo Berizzi, who has presented the Progress Report at a news conference, Moldova along with Ukraine, Morocco and Israel composes the group of states which made the greatest progress within the ENP.
However, Moldova is still behind in the areas of judicial reform, media freedom, fight against corruption, business and investment climate. According to the European official, the expiration of the Action Plan does not annul its further effective implementation, particularly regarding defaults, as long as another legal framework on EU-Moldova cooperation is unavailable. So far, in spite of insistence of Moldovan authorities to negotiate a new agreement with the EU, which would clearly stipulate Moldova’s European perspective, the EU did not propose a date but noted via its officials that the future agreement will be a continuation of the old Action Plan and it will not envisage the association.
The EC assessment satisfied Moldovan authorities and surprised independent observers who expected a bitter evaluation, given the regressed freedom of human rights and judicial system in Moldova in 2007.
First sitting of the Joint Committee on management of the Visa Facilitation Agreement
Chisinau hosted on April 11, 2008 the first sitting of the Joint Committee on management of the Visa Facilitation Agreement between Moldova and European Community. According to the Agreement, the Joint Committee is in charge with monitoring the endorsement of the document, recommending modification and completions to the Agreement and settling litigations occurring from interpretation or endorsement of the Agreement. The sitting approved procedure regulations of the Committee and discussed directory lines of implementation of the Agreement. The next sitting of the Joint Committee will take place in Brussels.
Bilateral cooperation
Republic of Moldova – Romania
The Moldova-Romania relations were mostly circumscribed to the small border traffic agreement between Moldova and Romania, which if signed, will allow residents in a 50-kilometre area from both sides of the common border to circulate in this area between the two countries without visas or passports, on the basis of special permits. Moldovan Minister of Foreign Affairs and European Integration Andrei Stratan has told a news conference that Moldova received the agreement proposed by Bucharest, but noted that it will be negotiated and signed only after the negotiation and signing of the border agreement between the two countries and basic political treaty. The Romanian side has immediately reacted to this conditioning, with Romanian President Traian Basescu stating during a debate organised by Konrad Adenauer Foundation on April 15 in Bucharest that "a [border] treaty with Moldova is not a priority for Romania."
Note by ADEPT. The basic political treaty and the border treaty have been the subject of disputes between Moldova and Romania for a long time. The name of the language and different visions on national identity were the apple of discord in case of the basic political treaty. In order to remedy this impasse, Romania proposed an alternative in 2006 – the signing of the European Partnership and Cooperation Agreement. As regards the border treaty, divergences are linked to the desire of the Moldovan side to include in the agreement a reference to the 1947 Paris Treaty concerning the border set between Romania and the Union in 1940 (the June 28, 1940 Romanian-Soviet agreement), a document which the Romanian side regards as out-of-date and illegal. According to official sources, both documents are being finalised at level of expert commissions. Although the MFAEI said in 2007 that the agreements could be signed by the end of 2007, the two countries did not sign them so far and no change is expected in this regard in the near future.
Elsewhere, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration has asked Romanian authorities via Romanian Charge d’Affaires to Moldova Ionut Dicu to ensure a wider cooperation with the Moldovan Embassy in Bucharest, as it was tardily notified over cases involving Moldovan citizens. Also, the ministry notified the Romanian diplomat over inadequate conduct of Romanian border officers towards Moldovan citizens, inviting Romanian authorities to organise better the border crossing procedure for citizens of Moldova.
Republic of Moldova – Russia
Moldovan Speaker Marian Lupu met on April 3 the chairman of the State Duma of the Russian Federal Assembly, Boris Grizlov. According to the parliamentary press service, the two dignitaries have tackled issues related to commercial-economic relations between Moldova and Russia and Transnistria settlement process. Also, they discussed the possibility to organise a new meeting of the Moldovan-Russian interparliamentary commission in the Moldovan capital in 2008, with an eventual visit by Boris Grizlov to Chisinau.
Note by ADEPT. Last time, high-ranking parliamentary officials from Russia visited Moldova in 2002.
At the same time, Moldova’s President Vladimir Voronin and Prime Minister Zinaida Grecianii have received Russian Ambassador to Moldova Valeri Kuzmin. They approached issues related to the perspective of resuming the Transnistria settlement negotiation process (which restarted shortly after the meeting concerned) and strengthening of partnership between the two countries in several areas. Prime Minister Grecianii stressed the importance of Russia as a strategic partner of Moldova, assuring the Russian ambassador that the new Cabinet of Ministers will take concrete actions to enlarge and deepen cooperation in all areas of mutual interest. The commission for economic cooperation between Moldova and Russia will play an important role in this process. A first action in this regard took place on April 10, when the director of the federal migration service of the Russian Federation, Konstantin Romodanovsky, invited the Moldovan Government, at a meeting with Prime Minister Zinaida Grecianii, to build a joint database on migrants, which would facilitate the legalisation of migrants in both countries and include them into social assistance programmes.
Republic of Moldova – Ukraine
The Moldovan-Ukrainian relations have been freshened up, as Ukrainian Foreign Minister Volodimir Ogrizko visited Chisinau. According to the Ukrainian diplomacy, the visit aimed to study existing problems in Moldovan-Ukrainian relations (in particular, the recognition of Moldova’s patrimony in Ukraine, electricity prices, demarcation of the border between the two countries, etc.), in order to prepare a future official visit of Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko to Moldova. Ogrizko noted that a schedule of meetings aimed to remedy existing problems was set after talks with Moldova officials, with the first round being set for April 21–22, 2008.
In order to ensure a fair and quick resolution to the demarcation of the Moldova-Ukraine border, the foreign ministers of the two states have signed a letter to European Union Council Secretary-General Javier Solana and European Commissioner for External Relations Benita Ferrero-Waldner, seeking technical (delegation of experts) and financial assistance from the European Union to demark the border, including the Transnistrian section. According to Moldovan Foreign Minister Andrei Stratan, the EU is due to establish the amount of money for both countries, with the overall amount foreseen for the border demarcation accounting for 18 million Euros, of which half will be allocated in the first round.
Also during the visit, the sides have signed the Moldova-Ukraine agreement on cooperation in ensuring rights of national minorities.
Republic of Moldova – Slovakia
A visit by Slovakian Foreign Minister Jan Kubis to Moldova synchronised with a Moldovan-Slovakian economic forum was the key event in relations between the two countries in the period concerned.
The Slovakian foreign minister has met Moldovan officials. The talks focussed on development of commercial-economic relations, Moldova’s European aspirations and Slovakia’s eventual joining to the Common Visa Application Centre. In particular, Mr. Kubis stressed the interest of Slovakian businessmen to invest in Moldova, especially in energy, infrastructure, agriculture. In their turn, Moldovan officials sought Slovakia’s support to get the EU mandate for negotiation of a new Moldova-EU legal agreement, which would clearly stipulate a certain European perspective of Moldova and a gradual approaching of Moldova towards European freedoms.
The sides have signed an intergovernmental agreement between Moldova and Slovakia concerning mutual investment promotion and protection. Negotiations on another important agreement for Slovakian and Moldovan investors, the agreement on avoidance of double taxation, will shortly begin.
Multilateral cooperation
Official website dedicated to Moldovan Chairmanships in five regional commitments
On April 3, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration launched the official website dedicated to the Moldovan Chairmanships in the South East European Cooperation Process (SEECP), Central European Initiative (CEI), Multinational Advisory Group of the Centre for Security Cooperation – RACVIAC (MAG RACVIAC), South Eastern Europe Health Network (SEEHN) and CEFTA in 2008 – 2009.
Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe
ECHR decisions
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) passed two decisions versus Moldova on April 8 in the cases Megadat.com SRL vs. Moldova and Gradinar vs. Moldova. It sentenced Moldova for violation of property and right to a fair trial. The Court did not order any pecuniary damages in the case Gradinar vs. Moldova, as the applicant, Galina Gradinar, did not raise any claims in this regard. As regards the Megadat.com SRL vs. Moldova case, the ECHR did not indicate any pecuniary damages and asked the applicants to claim damages and costs and expenses within three months. According to E.Musuc, manager of Megadat.com SRL, the Megadat.com SRL Company was worth between 8.4 and 14.15 million dollars when it was lifted from its licence.
Republic of Moldova – NATO
Bucharest hosted the 20th NATO Summit on April 2–4. The Moldovan delegation was led by President Vladimir Voronin. Although the Moldovan delegation was almost imperceptible at the summit, Moldova is mentioned in the final declaration of the summit, with NATO supporting the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence of Moldova and calling for a peaceful resolution of the Transnistrian conflict.
Republic of Moldova – CIS
The Council of the Interparliamentary Assembly of the Commonwealth of Independent States, the 30th plenary meeting of the CIS Interparliamentary Assembly and the 37th sitting of the CIS Economic Council have been held in the period concerned. Moldova was represented by Speaker Marian Lupu and First Deputy Prime Minister Igor Dodon, minister of economy and commerce.
Republic of Moldova – SEECP
Moldova will take over the Chairmanship in the South East European Cooperation Process (SEECP) in May. According to Parliament chairman Marian Lupu, Moldova’s priorities as SEECP Chair will be the following: developing the dialogue between SEECP and EU member states, promoting the European perspective of South East European states, supporting European integration aspirations of South East European countries and granting a status of strong and consolidated regional European forum to the SEECP.
Republic of Moldova – RACVIAC
Chisinau hosted the 19th Meeting of the Multinational Advisory Group (MAG) of the Centre for Security Cooperation (RACVIAC) on April 9–11. RACVIAC is a nongovernmental structure in charge with providing specialised assistance to member states of the Stability Pact for South East Europe in the area of regional arms control verification and implementation. Moldova chairs the MAG RACVIAC in 2008.
The Action Plan is dead. Long live the Plan!
Elena Prohnitchi
On April 3, the European Commission made public the second document analyzing the implementation of the European Neighbourhood Policy by the partner countries during the period November 2006 – December 2007 (Communication to the Council and the Parliament on the ENP implementation in 2007) As the first policy document released in December 2006, the current report is accompanied by the Individual Progress Reports and sectoral report.
Main Communication’s conclusions
One of the conclusions of the second ENP evaluation report is the belief of the European Commission that the European Neighbourhood Policy is a successful initiative. Thus, from a project with immature financial tools and without a clear finality at the launching moment, after three years of practical implementation, the ENP arrived at being a viable tool of EU in its relations with neighbour states. This satisfaction of the EU regarding ENP did not emerge in first Communication launched in November 2006 mostly speaking about the ENP consolidation and the enhancement of its impact.
Secondly, the current Communication, as the previous one, highlights that ENP is a tool that promotes "the regional integration beyond the European Union" and should not be perceived as a toll of pre-adhesion to the EU. Moreover, the report underlines the existence of a higher development potential of ENP in the EU relations with its neighbours that still remain to be exploited, inclusively by expansion of the economical benefits offered to the partner countries.
Thirdly, the European Union plans to deepen its relations with Ukraine, Moldova, Morocco and Israel. In Moldova and Ukraine cases, the "deepening of the relations" supposes to sign a new contractual agreement with the EU. However, until the new agreements would be signed, the current operational instruments – Action Plans – remain in place. These would have been adjusted to the "ambitions and capacities of the partner countries, reflecting the differentiated relations of the EU with its partners". Namely, the new instruments will be directly conditioned by the progress made by the partner countries in implementation of Action Plans. It is significant that the new Action Plans structurally will not differ too much from the old ones – the 7 activity domains will be maintained. Depending on the case, only objectives and actions will change. The progress scored by partner countries on the governmence field, will represent, also, the main indicator in offering the EU financial assistance in 2008.
Moldova Progress Report
Nevertheless, the Moldova Progress report was the most waited in Chisinau. This report assesses the progress scored by Moldova in implementation of the EU-Moldova Action Plan and presents the main achievements and problems of this process. Generally, the European Commission appreciated the Moldova’s progress as a "good" one, Moldova together with Ukraine, Morocco and Israel forming the group of states that registered the main progress within the ENP framework. However, analyzing the progress reports of all above-named countries, one can notice that only Morocco and Israel received from the European Commission the qualifying term of "active partner", while appreciations for Moldova and Ukraine were more reticent.
According the country progress report, Moldova has made progress in all domains included in EU-Moldova Action Plan, in particular: the improvement of the institutional framework, the introduction of the procedures on control and certification of origin for exported goods, signing the agreements on the autonomous preferential agreement and on visa facilitation and readmission, cooperation with the EU in the Transnistrian conflict settlement process and the foreign policy issues, the cooperation within the EU Border Assistance Mission (EUBAM), progress in reforming the health system, in the competition policy by creating the National Agency for Competition Protection (qualified as a "good progress) and the protection of the intellectual property rights.
On the other hand, as it was expected, Moldova continue to be overdue in many domains: 1) the inadequate implementation of the legislation on the local self-government; 2) weak quality of the judicial system; 3) extended prerogatives of General Prosecutor’s Office; 4) political influence of the Centre for Combating Corruption and Economic Crime’s activity; 5) insufficient protection of the human rights and fundamental freedoms, in particular, the freedom of expression, freedom of religion and freedom from torture; 6) poor freedom of mass media, especially related to the public audiovisual media; 7) deficient implementation of the legislation on labour standards; 8) less transparent and unsafe business and investment climate. Nonetheless, by the frequency of appearances in the report, the main problem of Moldova remains the deficient and inconsequent application of the already EU-harmonized legislation and the reforming strategies.
It is indubitable that Moldova a made progresses in implementation of the EU-Moldova Action Plan, but reviewing the Moldova’s domains with moderate progress or no progress at all, the question regarding the reason of such a positive evaluation of the European Commission raises involuntarily. One explanation for the European Commission granting such a good mark in advance is to maintain Moldova on the way of reforms and to impel the process of its domestic "Europeanization". In this regard, the European Commission is inclined to raise the financial allocation offered to Moldova through the European Neighbourhood and Partnership Instrument (ENPI) by 250 million euro, in addition to 210 million euro initially earmarked for the period 2007–2010. Thus, the assistance per capita will increase to 15 euro per year, the biggest in the region. It is noteworthy, that the assistance will be oriented to the concrete sectors, including the "overdue" ones, for stimulating their reforming process.
What follows?
During the last year, the Moldovan diplomacy has intensified its efforts in attracting as many supporters as possible, especially among the new EU states, for receiving the European Commission’s mandate to launch the negotiations on signing the new legal agreement with Moldova. The new agreement should follow the current Partnership and Cooperation Agreement. The Moldovan authorities want much the new agreement to specify clear-cut the European perspective of Moldova and the gradual implementation of the European freedoms. Nevertheless, the European officials repeatedly stressed that the content of the new agreement will depend to a large extent by the conclusions of the country progress report on realization of the EU-Moldova Action Plan[1]. Since the European Commission evaluation is positive, it seems that Moldova could follow Ukraine in negotiating a new agreement with the EU. But, still there is along way until the negotiations start and the new agreement is signed. The final result – a new qualitative agreement with the EU or the extension of the EU- Moldova Action Plan for an indeterminate time- will depends, to a large extend, by the capacity of Moldova to continue the political and economical reforms in compliance to the EU-Moldova Action Plan. Not less important will be the exam of the electoral campaign for the parliamentary elections in 2009. It is clear, that only after the parliamentary elections will be held (according to the democracy standards) we can realistically speak about a new legal framework with the EU. By that time, Moldova should excel in implementation of the current or adjusted Action Plan.
The contributors to this issue are:
|
© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT" Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated | e-mail: [email protected] |