ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20080615/index.shtml


e-journal, year VI, issue 119, June 1–15, 2008

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Problem

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1.1. Appointments. Dismissals

Nina Cernat was nominated Deputy Chairwoman of the Supreme Court of Justice.

1.2. Legal acts

Law on social aid. The law regulates the legal framework and guarantees the right of disadvantaged families to decent living standards and equal possibilities by granting them social aid. Disadvantaged families in which all adult members correspond to one of the following criteria: have the retirement age; are disabled; are registered as job seekers; look after a child who is younger than six years old; look after a disabled person, will be provided social aid. The family will not have the right to social assistance should a member own worthy estate (measured accordingly to some indicators approved by Government). The social assistance is established as a difference between guaranteed minimum monthly earning of a family and its overall revenue (revenues raised under the shape of currency and in kind from remunerated work, all types of entrepreneurial activities, social insurance and assistance, use of farm land and plots, as well as other kinds of revenues, including property, securities and real estate owned by family).

Law on State Guard and Protection Service. The law sets the legal framework, principles of activity, duties, rights, competence and status of employees of the State Guard and Protection Service, control on their activity. It lays a special emphasis on social protection of SGPS staff.

Law on modification of Article 3 of the law on ombudsmen. Requirements for nomination of ombudsmen have been completed with the condition to enjoy an outstanding reputation.

Note by ADEPT: This amendment was adopted at the initiative of Moldovan president, but it does not specify the way the reputation may be assessed as outstanding, and this may encourage abusive interpretations. Nor it stipulates possibilities to contest untrue information or information collected via quasi-legal means which may be used to libel the candidate unaccepted by parliamentary majority.

Law on abrogation of the law concerning interpretation of provisions of some legal acts. The October 20, 2005 Law no. 245-XVI on interpretation of provisions of some legal acts was declared unconstitutional under the Constitutional Court Decision no. 20 from November 30, 2006.

Note by ADEPT: The unconstitutional law has introduced interpretations that harmed the interests of some economic agents which appealed to international law courts (International Arbitrage Court and ECHR), and the latter decided in their turn that the Parliament has abusively adopted the interpretations in order to further legislate a legal protection for abusive actions taken by the Customs Service of Moldova.

Decision concerning the Report by the Human Rights Centre on respect for human rights in the Republic of Moldova in 2007. The document reveals some shortcomings in the work of ombudsmen and signals the need to strictly respect the law on ombudsmen; examining appeals by citizens promptly and knowledgeably; exercising more efficiently the right to appeal on law courts in order to protect interests of petitioners; impelling the legal education of population; taking actions to ensure the functioning of the national anti-torture mechanism; participating more actively in actions stipulated by the National Action Plan on Human Rights. The Government is instructed to take actions in order to improve the normative and legislative framework in accordance with recommendations by the Centre Report and prevent violations of human rights.

Draft law on labour migration. The draft adopted in the first reading explains the labour migration as voluntary departure of Moldovan citizens to other countries and voluntary arrival of foreigners or stateless people to Moldova for temporary work purpose. The law will regulate the temporary work of immigrant workers, conditions of granting, renewal and revocation of the right to work and the right to temporarily stay for labour purpose, as well as requirements for temporary employment of Moldovan citizens abroad. The law will cover foreigners and stateless people who arrived in Moldova for temporary labour purpose, all individuals and legal entities, public administration authorities, Moldovans who temporarily immigrate to other countries for labour purpose.

Draft law on modification of some legal acts (concerning competence of CCECC). It limits the right of the Center for Combating Economic Crimes and Corruption (CCECC) to perform fiscal controls, except for penal charges. Under amendments, the CCECC shall be deprived of the right to order the forced execution of fiscal obligations.

Draft law on legal statute of adoption. It aims to regulate legal relations on protection of rights of the child, establish the legal statute of adoption, and ensure cooperation between public administration authorities and nongovernmental organisations and international cooperation in this area.

Draft law on modification and completion of some legislative acts (Law on security of personal data). Amendments aim to minutely regulate aspects of nomination and dismissal of administration of the National Centre for the Security of Personal Data, establish the status and functioning of the Centre.

Note by ADEPT: Experts note that in spite of the declared goal to ensure a real independence from any public authority, the proposed mechanisms and provisions do not contribute enough to ensuring the independence and inviolability of the centre head[1].

1.3. Parliamentary control. Statements

Hearings. Motions

The Centre for Human Rights released a report on respect for human rights in the Republic of Moldova in 2007. It generally signals the violation of the same rights: private security; quality of life; access to information; private property; access to justice, etc.

Director of Moldova-Vin Agency informed parliamentarians about situation in viticulture and winemaking industry, enterprises expected to be privatised and negotiations on spirits export held with the Russian Rospotrebnadzor Service.

By responding to a draft motion on situation in energy sector, the Ministry of Economy and Trade has reported:

The communist parliamentary majority has turned down the motion and only 19 parliamentarians have voted it.

Questions. Interpellations

Deputy Gheorghe Susarenco has asked law enforcement bodies to provide information regarding paintings stolen from Russian museums which Moldovan president has promised to deliver to Russian authorities soon. Susarenco indicated the necessity of finishing penal investigations and limiting the abusive involvement of the chief of state in managing and keeping this evidence.

Statements. Appeals

Our Moldova Alliance (OMA) Deputy Leonid Bujor has asked the Prosecutor-General’s Office to report grounds of criminal cases filed against some Moldovan youths and reality of the danger that they allegedly pose to statehood, and demanded it if calls by those youths are riskier for statehood than plans of the PCRM, which openly proposed in 2001 to include Moldova into the Russia-Belarus Union.

Deputy Gheorghe Susarenco has released a statement on situation of the Leova District Council, in which the PCRM faction and its supporters deliberately obstruct the settlement of the vacancy of a district councillor who died in early 2008.

National Liberal Party Deputy Vitalia Pavlicenco has invited legislators to find ways to study the legality of interferences by President Vladimir Voronin into prohibited areas, with the last one being the topic of press freedom, which des not have adequate conditions in Moldovan society.

The OMA faction has released a statement on respect for human rights in Moldova, which describes the situation in this area as regressive and permanently worsening.


Government

2.1. Appointments. Dismissals

Natalia Solcan, head of the European Integration Directorate of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration, was proposed Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Ambassador of Moldova to the United Kingdom.

Nicolae Taran was nominated Deputy Director-general of the Industrial Agency Moldova-Vin.

Anatolie Turcan was relieved from the office of deputy director of the Building and Territorial Development Agency, as the institution was reorganised.

Victor Cuhal was relieved from the office of deputy Director of the Standardisation and Metrology Service on reorganisation reason.

2.2. Decisions

Decision on completion of the decision concerning state coordination and regulation of prices (tariffs). The list of goods for which the state regulates the commercial addition (approved under GD no. 547 from 04.08.1995) was completed with the following commodities: pastries, cruppers and rice. This decision is a reaction to the speculative rise of prices of some foodstuffs in retailing network. The Government has established a working group to consider possibilities of combating illegal price rises.

Decision on rise of salaries for employees of the sanitary-epidemiologic service. The salary will be increased by 15 percent per year of work under major risk for health, with the maximum rise reaching 100 percent of the salary for office. The personnel in charge with preventing and combating HIV/AIDS will be paid a 10-percent rise per year, but not more than 60 percent of the salary for office. About 2.7 million lei will be needed for this purpose in 2008.

Decision introducing the professional day of journalist. The Day of Journalist will be celebrated on June 12, on the birthday of late journalist Constantin Chirosco. This initiative came from a group of 28 Moldovan journalists who have sent a request in this regard to Moldovan president.

Decisions approving draft legislative acts:

2.3. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Strategy on social inclusion of disabled people

The draft strategy calls for the harmonisation of the social protection system for disabled people in order to ensure their social inclusion and respect for their rights and fundamental freedoms. The number of disabled people is on the continuous rise in Moldova, counting for over 170,000 persons (by 28,000 people more than in 2007). Representatives of associations of invalids from Moldova have demanded the council to discuss at next sittings possibilities of removing obstacles to social integration of invalids, help them get employed, etc.

Meeting of donors

Prime Minister Zinaida Greceanii has attended a meeting of donors which focussed on emergency assistance to remedy the drought-related crisis in Moldova. Greceanii said in an address that extreme weather effects from 2007 have demonstrated one more time that the agriculture is the weakest and riskiest sector of national economy. According to the premier, the negative weather last year has imposed more efficient and unordinary long-term actions aimed to permanently develop the agro-food sector and ensure the food security of the country.

Permanent cooperation with Foreign Investors Association (FIA)

A meeting between the prime minister and FIA members has discussed prospects of cooperation between business community and Government aimed to improve investment climate in Moldova. Investors said that the dialogue between central public administration and business community has advanced much in the past years and thus many problems have been resolved. Investors raised a set of recommendations aimed to reduce the inflation rate and maintain the macroeconomic stability. FIA representatives discussed the opportunity of developing the legal framework in order to boost Moldova’s attractiveness in implementing public-private partnership projects. The premier noted that the Ministry of Economy and Trade has conducted an in-depth assessment of recommendations and objectives from the "White Book" of investors and it will shortly propose its visions aimed at ensuring a new quality growth in the area. Foreign investors were encouraged to work out a new issue of the "White Book" in order to assess the economic condition and establish visions regarding cooperation opportunities.


Presidency

3.1. Decrees

Under a presidential decree, Ilie Telescu was nominated presidential advisor for humanitarian programmes. Telescu ran the TeleRadio-Moldova Company until 2007.

The Honour Order was awarded to:

Mihail Rusu, chairman of the Floresti district, was awarded the Order of the Republic.

3.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Reorganisation of the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry

The Moldovan president has chaired a sitting on reorganisation of the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry (MAFI) and subordinated institutions. The chief of state considers that the necessity of reorganising the ministry is part of efforts to meet EU standards and this will entrust the MAFI to draft policies and normative-legislative framework on agro-industrial complex, to negotiate, coordinate, supervise and administrate adjacent sectors by following the example of similar EU ministries. According to initiatives raised at the sitting, the following institutions shall be established: the General Agricultural Inspectorate with 140 employees; the Phytosanitary Agency with 300 employees; the Sanitary-Veterinary Agency for Safe Animal Products with 2,263 employees. Following the reorganisation of agricultural institutions, their number of employees will be reduced by 588 persons. The sitting studied the problem of holding tenders to purchase goods for agriculture, stressing the necessity of optimising the organisation of acquisitions with the view to boost their transparency and efficiency, ensuring an equal access and conditions to all participants in tenders.

Note by ADEPT: The sitting did not mention why the reorganisation did not begin when the new cabinet of ministers was formed and why it was launched ad-hoc without being stipulated express by plans on implementation of the central public administration reform strategy.

Problems of journalists

Vladimir Voronin has met leaders of media outlets and discussed problems faced by newsmen in Moldova. The president promised to remove financial sanctions applied on journalists for non-pecuniary damage produced through libel and noted that any reciprocal criticism against governance and opposition is an element of democratic rules of the game, but the opposition media shall not press journalists who sincerely choose the governance. Journalists approached many issues, including journalistic deontology; access to information about state institutions, including promptness of released data and functionality of their media services, economic problems faced by printed media. They launched initiatives to establish a national professional organisation of journalists and introduce the Journalist’s Professional Day in Moldova.

The Moldovan president launched a legislative initiative after meeting journalists, proposing to limit the responsibility of media outlets in the event that final judicial decisions indicate libel, violated dignity or professional reputation. Media outlets shall dismiss the information in order to compensate the non-pecuniary damage suffered by plaintiff.

Informal CIS Summit

The agenda of the summit of CIS heads of state has included issues of common interest, of which the elaboration of the draft Economic Development Strategy of CIS till 2020; perspectives of cooperation in the area of energy, transportation and communications; social and humanitarian problem; key development directions of the Commonwealth including better CIS activity and functioning of its structures.

During the informal CIS Summit the president of Moldova has met his Russian counterpart Dmitri Medvedev in Sankt Petersburg. They shared opinions about current stage and development prospects of Moldovan-Russian cooperation in diverse areas. Mr. Voronin promised that Moldova will return soon to Russia two paintings stolen from the "Hermitage" Museum in Sankt Petersburg and discovered by Moldovan law enforcement bodies after operative actions. Representatives of "Hermitage" and other Russian museums have stated later that no paintings had been stolen from these museums and assured that no masterpieces by Russians are preserved at "Hermitage".


1 See expertise report on corruptibility of the draft law no.1594 of 15.05.2008, www.capc.md.


Economic Policies

1. Prices and inflation

2. Banking

3. Public finances

4. External sector


Transdnistrian Problem

Efforts to resume the negotiation process

Helsinki hosted on June 10, 2008 a working meeting of mediators and observers participating in the Transnistria settlement negotiations. The meeting held at the initiative of OSCE chairman-in-office took place in the "3+2" format, without the participation of Moldova and Transnistria. It focussed on the necessity to consolidate actions aimed at building confidence between the conflicting parties, support working groups established after the April 11, 2008 Voronin-Smirnov meeting. These actions should finally prepare a favourable climate to resume the "5+2" conflict resolution negotiations. In spite of the invoked efforts the situation is stagnating. The meeting of Presidents Voronin and Medvedyev held during the Sankt-Petersburg CIS Summit has failed to approach the resumption of the "5+2" negotiations (see the commentary). On the other hand, the Russian president has awarded the "Friendship" Order to a founder of the Transnistrian separatist regime, Grigori Maracutsa. Maracutsa was curiously awarded three days after the CIS summit for his contribution to developing friendship and interparliamentary relations within the Union for Democracy and Rights of People. This union is nothing but CIS-2 or "separatist international" made of Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Transnsitria.

Actions to undermine confidence

In spite of efforts to strengthen confidence between the two banks of the Dniester River, the situation has rather regressed in the period concerned. Transnistrian authorities have invoked a series of problems and took actions to undermine the Chisinau-Tiraspol relations. Thus, Transnistrian leader has categorically urged Moldovan authorities to recognise Transnistria’s ownership on the railway from the left bank of the Dniester River, threatening with new conflicts and speculating that Moldova is blocking again the transit of commodities on the Transnistrian railroad. Such speculations aim to justify the step by the Tiraspol regime to declare the segment of railway from the left bank of the Dniester as property of the eastern breakaway enclave.

In this context, Transnistrian leaders accused Moldovan authorities of taking deliberate actions to block the use of a spectre of TV and radio waves by Transnistrian broadcasters. The facts invoked by Transnistrian authorities have been registered half or a year ago and Tiraspol stresses them now to discredit the so-called confidence-building actions which are being discussed starting April. By invoking norms of the international law, the Transnistrian side wanted to threaten Chisinau with replying actions.

The demarcation of the Transnistrian section of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border has become a very sensible issue between Chisinau and Tiraspol. Knowing the trilateral interest (EU-Moldova-Ukraine) to delimit the Moldovan-Ukrainian border, Transnistria is ostentatiously resisting to Moldova’s participation in the delimitation process. Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov said that should Ukraine refuse to delimit the border with the Moldovan Transnistrian Republic, Transnistrian authorities will do this unilaterally. Transnistrian observers note that Tiraspol would act this way to pose more problems to Ukraine, as the latter is supposed to be accepted in the NATO pre-accession round. Perhaps this is an exaggeration, as Transnistria’s resistance to Ukraine’s plans would be too expensive. It is much easier to explain this by desire of Transnistrian authorities to assure that the invoked segment of the border is Transnistrian-Ukrainian, not Moldovan-Ukrainian.


Foreign Affairs

European Integration

Launching of Mobility Partnership between Republic of Moldova and European Union

Moldovan Interior Minister Valentin Mejinschi, European Commission Vice-President Jacques Barrot, commissioner for justice and home affairs, Mrs. Benita Ferrero-Waldner, Commissioner for External Relations and European Neighbourhood Policy, Slovenian Interior Minister Dragutin Mate, Chairman-in-office of the EU Justice and Home Affairs Council, along with representatives of 14 EU member states signed the Moldova-EU Joint Declaration on the Mobility Partnership, at the meeting of the EU Justice and Home Affairs Council in Luxembourg on June 5, 2008.

Although it is a pilot project for the time being, the mobility partnership aims to consolidate the EU-Moldova cooperation on management of illegal migration, combat and prevention of illegal migration and trafficking in human beings. Several initiatives will be implemented in this respect to consolidate Moldova’s institutional capacities in managing the labour market and migration, implementing migration policies more efficiently; facilitating the "circular migration"[1]; intensifying bilateral cooperation on social protection and reintegration of illegal migrants; encouraging the participation of diaspora in developing Moldova by using their remittances, etc.

Mrs. Benita Ferrero-Waldner has assured the Moldovan delegation that the European Commission will provide full support to this partnership, including financial assistance.

The EU has launched mobility partnerships with two states until now – the Republic of Moldova and Cape Verde.

Bilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Romania

Moldovan Deputy Prime Minister Andrei Stratan, minister of foreign affairs and European integration, had a telephone conversation with Romanian Foreign Minister Lazar Comanescu on June 10, 2008. According to a press release by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration, the ministers have tackled "issues of principle" linked to relations between the two countries. The conversation ended with an invitation by Moldovan foreign minister to his Romanian counterpart to pay an official visit to the Republic of Moldova on July 7, 2008.

Note by ADEPT: Although the brief and dry press release did not reveal key topics discussed by the foreign ministers, one may suppose that they included the much disputed draft small border traffic convention between Moldova and Romania and the state border treaty between Moldova and Romania.

Republic of Moldova – Turkey

Moldova-Turkey relations have intensified in the period concerned, as Chisinau hosted on June 12–13, 2008 the 5th sitting of the Moldovan-Turkish intergovernmental commission for commercial-economic cooperation and a Moldovan-Turkish business forum, as well as bilateral meetings between officials of the two countries.

The intergovernmental commission was chaired by Moldovan First Deputy Prime Minister Igor Dodon, Minister of Economy and Trade, and Turkish State Minister Kursad Tuzmen. The Commission discussed issues related to attraction of Turkish investments in Moldova and development of bilateral cooperation in the area of industry and energy, food industry, transportation, information development, culture and tourism.

While on his visit to Moldova, Mr. Tuzmen has met Moldovan president, prime minister, minister of Foreign Affairs and European integration and Gagauz governor. The talks preceded a meeting between Moldovan Speaker Marian Lupu and his Turkish counterpart Koksal Toptan, Head of the Great National Assembly of Turkey, which took place in Athens during the summit of speakers from member states of the Black Sea Economic Cooperation Organisation Parliamentary Assembly (BSEC/PA).

Republic of Moldova – Switzerland

Moldova’s Deputy Prime Minister Andrei Stratan, Minister of Foreign Affairs and European integration, was on an official visit to Switzerland on June 5–6, 2008. During his visit Mr. Stratan has met Swiss officials, in particular, Swiss Foreign Minister Micheline Calmy Rey, Andre Bugnon, Head of the National Council, Laurent Moutinot, Head of the Canton of Geneva, etc., as well as Sergei Ordzhonikidze, Director-General of the United Nations Office at Geneva.

The talks focussed on the current stage and prospects of political and economic cooperation between Moldova and Switzerland and cooperation within international organisations (UN, OSCE and CoE).

Multilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – BSEC/PA

Athens hosted the summit of speakers from member states of the Black Sea Economic Cooperation Organisation Parliamentary Assembly (BSEC/PA) on June 9, 2008. Taking part in the summit was also Moldovan Speaker Marian Lupu who addressed participants and appreciated BSEC efforts to intensify bilateral and regional cooperation, and noted the insufficiently explored potential of the organisation in tackling transnational matters such as fighting against terrorism and organised crime.

According to a press release by Moldovan Parliament, participants in BSEC/PA works have called for intensified relations between BSEC/PA and EU and consideration of the opportunity to build a Parliamentary Assembly made of BSEC and EU member states. The summit adopted a declaration on the 15th anniversary of the BSEC/PA.

Moldova took over the BSEC/PA Chairmanship for a six-month term, at the 31st BSEC/PA meeting in Athens on June 11, 2008.


1 The circular migration concept allows nationals of a third country to temporarily migrate to the EU for labour, education or professional formation purpose or for altogether, with the condition to return to their origin country when the stay period is over and go back to the EU after 2–3 years on basis of a simplified admission/comeback procedure. According to the Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on circular migration and mobility partnerships between the European Union and third countries/ COM(2007) 248 final of16.05.2007.


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Sankt-Petersburg CIS Summit
Igor Botan

Significance of the Sankt-Petersburg Summit

The informal CIS Summit held in Sankt-Petersburg on June 6–7, 2008 had a distinct significance. All CIS leaders have shown interest to attend the summit and this is a rarity. Grave problems between a number of CIS states and Russia could not halt the participation in the first collective meeting with the newly-elected Russian president, Dmitri Medvedyev. There were reasons before and after the summit to speculate that CIS leaders have made the first "bowing" to the new president of a rising and increasingly powerful Russia.

Two events have especially fuelled such speculations. First, the summit took place in Sankt-Petersburg, the native city of the newly-elected Russian president and his predecessor, as well as the city where King Peter the Great was declared Imperator of Russia by the Senate in 1721. The second event was a gesture by Moldovan President Vladimir Voronin, who has almost managed to turn his "bowing" into a sensational action when he made public the disinterested intention to give back to Russia two paintings stolen from the "Hermitage" Museum in Sankt-Petersburg and found on the eve by Moldovan police in Moldova. Although President Voronin’s announcement produced confusion, Russian authorities and specialists in the field of arts claim that Russia has definitively restored its status of superpower since it is voluntarily recovered losses which it did not have any idea about.

Republic of Moldova meets Russia’s wishes

The Sankt-Petersburg summit like precedent informal summits aimed to discuss key issues between CIS leaders, though truly important problems shall be resolved within bilateral relations. Russia’s major interest in CIS is to confirm its status of "centre of differentiated integration" into the post-Soviet area. These claims have been raised in the past years, in particular, by former president Vladimir Putin and Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, who insist that the modernisation of CIS is a priority on Russia’s foreign policy agenda.

It is worth to note that the almost secret 2007 Dushanbe CIS Summit has proclaimed the reformation of the Commonwealth of Independent States. However, the CIS maintained the priorities established in 2005, in particular regarding migration policy; transportation; education; humanitarian matters especially related to ensuring the status of Russian language in CIS, etc., that means other issues than those indicated by Russia. At the November 2006 Minsk summit, which should start modernising the CIS, former president Vladimir Putin has recommended his counterparts to promote a coordinated foreign policy and a stronger military integration within CIS.

Putin’s wishes have been tactically turned down then, particularly by Kazakhstan and Ukraine and the modernisation of CIS was postponed for 2007. There are grounds to believe that Moldovan authorities have been receptive to Moscow’s messages since Russia embargoed the Moldovan agro-food production in 2006 and the Moldovan wines in 2006. In 2006, Moscow supported a referendum on independence and joining of Transnistria to Russia. Given those circumstances, President Voronin has delivered the famous note explaining the six basic principles to settle the Transnistrian conflict to his Russian counterpart Vladimir Voronin at the August 2006 informal CIS summit. That is why informal CIS summits are needed for! Otherwise, it would be hard to imagine how former president Putin would have got the note by his Moldovan counterpart. That’s true, as Mr. Putin has promised three months later at the Minsk summit to lift the commercial embargo on Moldova and showed interest for initiatives written on the note by President Voronin regarding recognition of Russia’s estates in Transnistria, strengthening of the economic presence on the right side of the Dniester, etc.

Moldova has taken its first test for adjusting its foreign policy to Russia’s wishes in 2007, when it ostentatiously demonstrated its detachment from GUAM, a regional organisation led by Ukraine. Russia’s very negative attitude towards GUAM provides occasions and opportunities to demonstrate loyalty over Russia, a step made by President Voronin by not attending two GUAM summits. In this context, Moldovan authorities revised this year the draft National Security Concept and removed all references to issues capable to irritate Russia, including GUAM. Instead, the ostentatious insistence on setting Moldova’s neutrality in a document that is less important that the Constitution, which stipulates express the neutrality of Moldova, has served as an additional proof that security policies are adjusted to Russia’s wishes. Altogether, these acts fit initiatives released by Vladimir Putin at the 2006 Minsk CIS Summit to promote a coordinated foreign and security policy. For these reasons, President Voronin was justified to expect Russia’s support in settling the Transnistrian conflict.

Russia "freezes" Moldova’s expectations

In Sankt-Petersburg, after President Voronin has shown his "disinterested benevolence" to give back to Russia what the latter did not know that it had lost, the Moldovan chief of state and President Medvedyev had a private meeting on bilateral problems, particularly on the Transnistrian issue. The Tiraspol media could not abstain from sarcasm, stressing that President Voronin has failed "a gentle bowing". The stake that new Russian President Dmitrii Medvedyev could be softened up to give green light to the Transnistrian settlement plan was not materialised. Given the fact that the parliamentary election campaign will officially begin in Moldova within half a year, the Sankt-Petersburg summit has actually provided the last opportunity to make President Medvedyev impel the Transnistrian settlement, so that to have a decisive impact before the end of President Voronin’s mandate. In consequence, the governance-affiliated Moldovan media had to be optimistic that experts will hold consultations after the Voronin-Medvedyev to approach the Transnistrian settlement.

It seems that Russia is not ready yet to quickly resolve a series of problems from convenient positions for it. Now it may fuel expectations which could be postponed until an opportune moment for Russia appears. As regards the Transnistrian conflict, key clauses of President Voronin’s plan are generally known. According to President Voronin, Chisinau has worked out a package of documents which are being studied by mediators and observers. The initiatives concern the status of Transnistria and necessary guarantees; provides a wide autonomy to Transnistria accordingly to the July 22, 2005 law on basic principles of Transnistria’s status, but includes elements of the "Kozak Memorandum"; withdrawal of weapons from the region and Russian military presence; introduction of a civil peacekeeping mission, etc.

In this context, expectations shared by President Voronin in March were linked to the possibility to convoke a non-stop session with Russia’s support in order to identify problems of principle to back the "package" proposals and to be discussed at "5+2" negotiations. Of course, Russia should also persuade the Transnistrian side to restart negotiations. President Voronin was probably expecting his Russian counterpart at the Sankt-Petersburg summit to let him know if Russia is ready to support the package of proposals by Chisinau.

Recent visits by Russian high-ranking dignitaries to Chisinau that anticipated somehow the talks at the Sankt-Petersburg CIS summit aimed to send a message which was pretty clear since March – Russia will not recognise Transnistria’s independence for the time being, so that not to undermine the CIS, but it will not exercise special pressures on Tiraspol, letting the latter find an acceptable solution with Chisinau. Indeed, this is already a rule since the "Primakov Memorandum" was signed in May 1997. Under such circumstances, the conflict will unlikely "thaw" before the spring 2009 parliamentary elections. Another purpose of visits by Russian dignitaries to Chisinau was to test how far President Voronin can yield under the shortage of time. Statements by the chairman of the State Duma Committee for CIS Relations, Alexei Ostrovsky, who said that Mr. Voronin would accept to negotiate a resolution which would allow Transnistria to veto the foreign and security policy of Moldova, provisions that would maintain the essential element of the "Kozak Memorandum", cannot be neglected or exaggerated. Such a resolution would mean to keep Transnistria under Russia’s control and Chisinau under Tiraspol’s control, dispensing Chisinau of the necessity to promote a foreign and security policy coordinated with Russia.

Anyway, given the acute desire of Moldovan authorities to make progress in the Transnistrian settlement process, one may expect spectacular and especially propagandistic surprises before the 2009 parliamentary elections.


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]