ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20090301/index.shtml


e-journal, year VII, issue 133, 15 February – 1 March 2009

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Problem

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Government

1.1. Decisions

Decision concerning the distribution of state budget allocations for salary rise. An amount of 467 million lei is allocated for rises operable starting January 1, 2009.

Decision concerning the freshening of food wheat reserves and acquisition of 5th-class fodder wheat. In order to redress the situation in agriculture and sustain domestic agricultural producers, the Agency for Material Reserves, Public Procurements and Humanitarian Aid is empowered to release from the state material reserves 22,000 tons of food wheat for freshening (replacement) purpose and sell it at open auctions via the Universal Commodity Exchange of Moldova for an initial price of 1,600–1,800 lei per ton of food wheat. The agency jointly with the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry will ensure the recovery of food wheat stocks from the new crop by purchasing it from domestic agricultural producers, and will organise auctions to procure 5th-class fodder wheat from domestic agricultural producers for a maximum price of 1,100 lei a ton.

Decisions concerning allocation of funds:

1.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Contentment with healthcare reform

Prime Minister Zinaida Greceanii has attended a meeting on reporting activity of the Republican Clinical Hospital (SCR) and said that the healthcare reform started in 2004 by introducing mandatory health insurance is being implemented well. Mrs. Greceanii indicated among persistent problems the effect of the disaster faced by the country when the reform was launched and effects of the global economic crisis. The prime minister informed about a project estimated at over 90 million Euros on capital renovation of SCR set to open this year.

CNAS College

The prime minister has attended a sitting of the college of National Social Insurance House (CNAS) and appreciated the work of CNAS in 2008, which ensured a good functioning of the entire social insurance system, payment of all social allowances to beneficiaries on time. At the same time, the prime minister stressed the importance of permanently improving the quality of CNAS services and its territorial subdivisions and demanded more cooperation with other competent state institutions and partners of social dialogue. According to a report by CNAS chair, the institution aims to build a flexible and modern system to meet all demands of beneficiaries of social rights.

Ceaseless fall in population

According to data by the National Bureau for Statistics, the preliminary number of stable population of Moldova was 3,567,500 people on January 1, 2009, compared with 3,570,100 people in 2008.


Presidency

2.1. Decrees

The Honour Order was awarded to Vasili Sakovici, Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Ambassador of Belarus to Moldova.

Under a presidential decree, Deputy Interior Minister Valentin Zubic was awarded the police major-general ranking.

2.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Increased attention to healthcare

Moldova’s president has attended a summing-up meeting with doctors and assured them of his support to modernise the medical system, as the medicine plays a very important role in "building the social state". On the other hand, Vladimir Voronin signalled some shortcomings in healthcare sector: the high percentage of domestic deaths; the imperfect information system of pharmaceutical sector; the necessity to modernise the social insurance system for disabled people.

The chief of state has participated in a cermony on opening of an automatic line to manufacture injection solutions in ampoules within the drug plant Farmaco SA; it is endowed with modern equipment capable to manufacture more than 3.15 million ampoules of 1–10 millilitres a month. The line will manufacture 36 kind of drugs demanded on domestic market, extend the sale market, enhance the output etc.

While on a visit to the Administrative-Territorial Unit Gagauzia, Moldova’s president has participated in the inauguration of a modern surgery block within the Ciadir-Lunga district hospital built accordingly to a pilot project elaborated in 2006.


Economic Policies

1. Banking system

2. International rankings

3. Labour market


Transdnistrian Problem

Efforts to resume negotiations

On February 25, 2009, Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs and European Integration Valeriu Ostalep had a meeting with Ambassador Charalampos Christopoulos, special envoy of the OSCE Chairman-in-Office, who was on a working visit to Moldova. The two officials discussed the present stage of the Transnistria resolution process, stressing the necessity of sustained efforts to resume the "5+2" negotiations. The special envoy of the Greek OSCE Chairmanship confirmed the OSCE support for Moldovan initiatives aimed to settle the Transnistrian conflict. The Greek official reiterated the importance of further promoting confidence-building actions between the two banks of the Dniester, stressing that the final resolution of the conflict may be agreed in the "5+2" format on the basis of respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Republic of Moldova.

On February 26, 2009, Ambassador Charalampos Christopoulos met representatives of Transnistrian authorities in Tiraspol who said as follows:

Deputy Minister of Reintegration Ion Stavila and Ukrainian Ambassador to Moldova Sergei Pirozhkov have discussed Transnistria settlement aspects. The discussion had an informative purpose, with the sides informing each other about recent consultations on resolution process and actions to be taken soon. They stressed the importance of all consultations aimed at resuming the "5+2" negotiation process, within which to work out the special legal status of Transnistria by respecting the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Republic of Moldova. In this context, they considered initiatives on development of Moldovan-Ukrainian cooperation within Euroregions aimed to help strengthening confidence and make appropriate conditions for the definitive settlement of the conflict. (According to MOLDPRES agency)

Impact of Russian foreign minister’s visit to Moldova

While on a visit to Moldova on February 23–24, 2009, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov stated:

Interview between President Vladimir Voronin and Moscow-based newspaper Kommersant

The Moscow-based newspaper Kommersant has published an interview with Moldova’s president after the visit by Russian foreign minister to Chisinau. Vladimir Voronin confirmed that a trilateral meeting Medvedev-Voronin-Smirnov could take place in March to discuss the Transnistrian settlement. Voronin stressed that "5+2" is the only format for negotiations and the "2+1" meeting will be for consultation and communications could be consequently released to inform the public. Voronin was sceptical that Smirnov would accept to sign any declaration on necessity to respect the territorial integrity of Moldova. At the same time, President Voronin noted that, during the eventual meeting with his counterpart Medvedev, he would like to learn the opinion of the Russian leadership regarding the "package approach" accepted by OSCE, Ukraine, EU and U.S. Speaking about the forthcoming parliamentary elections in Moldova, President Voronin was confident that his Party of Communists (PCRM) will win an absolute or perhaps a constitutional majority. According to Voronin, PCRM would need a constitutional majority to modify the Constitution, so that to allow a definitive settlement of the Transnistrian conflict. Voronin stressed that he agreed with Minister Lavrov that, in the event of problems related to preparations for the meeting with President Medvedev, it would be better to organise it after the April 5 parliamentary elections.

Impact of economic crisis

The international economic crisis has a negative impact on Transnistria. In particular, just about 40 out of approximately 100 export enterprises in Transnistria keep working. The geography of exports has changed much. Earlier, 56 percent of supplies went to CIS and only 44 percent to the European Union. Now, 64 percent of exports go to EU and only 25 percent to CIS. The sudden fall of exports to CIS is linked to the serious depreciation of Russian rouble, by 30 percent, and Ukrainian hryvna, by about 60 percent. Hence, Transnistrian-made products worth 100 dollars exported to Russia and Ukraine compete with similar products made by local companies which cost 60–70 dollars. A number of enterprises have ceased their activity, in particular, the Ribnita-based cement plant and the Tiraspol-based household appliance manufacturer. Enterprises Litmas, Electromas and Tirotex have restarted working but very slowly. The Ribnita-based metallurgical plant uses 40 percent of manufacturing capacities. The highest unemployment rate is expected in the region in March. Under these conditions, Transnistrian speaker Evgheny Shevciuk has met the E.U. special representative to Moldova, Kalman Mizsei, to discuss possibilities to facilitate Transnistrian exports to EU.

Reactions to extended travel restrictions for Transnistrian leaders

The Transnistrian diplomacy has raised concern with the extended EU and U.S. travel restrictions on a number of Transnistrian officials. Transnistrian authorities claim that these practices are unjustified, while the EU and U.S. consider that Transnistrian leaders do not prove a sincere interest to settle the Transnistrian conflict, this being the main reason of travel restrictions. On the other hand, the Transnistrian side assures that it is interested in settling the conflict, accusing the Republic of Moldova of having adopted the July 2005 law with the purpose to obstruct the Transnistrian settlement. Therefore, it fears that EU and U.S. actions do not encourage confidence-building measures between the sides. Even more, Transnistrian authorities recall the U.S. and EU the way they have recognised the independence of Kosovo. They regard the travel restrictions on Transnistrian leaders as a pressure which has a contrary effect, as they cannot make their viewpoints loud. Definitively, Transnistrian authorities threatened the U.S. and EU that they will reply. The list of Transnistrian leaders restricted from entering the U.S. and EU, which Transnistria media compares with the "Schindler List" (?!), includes 19 officials headed by Igor Smirnov. Russian special envoy Valeriy Nesteruskin says that prohibitive actions cannot encourage the Chisinau-Tiraspol dialogue.

Humanitarian aid problems

Deputy Minister of Reintegration Ion Stavila was baffled with recent public statements delivered by the head of the International Organisation Doctors without Borders Mission, Mark Walsh, who said that people from the Transnistrian region get just a low percent of the humanitarian aid provided to Moldova. While meeting Mark Walsh, the Moldovan official described these accusations as biased and untrue. According to Stavila, the Government and foreign donors have provided humanitarian aid worth over 40 million dollars to residents of the Transnistrian region in the past two years. The aid included eyeglasses, prostheses, hearing devices, and wheelchairs for retirees and disabled people, material goods to remedy consequences of natural disasters, donations of equipment and drugs for health institutions from the left bank of the Dniester, etc. Stavila regretted artificial obstacles laid by Tiraspol structures, which harden the dissemination of Moldova’s humanitarian aid in the region for political reasons. He reiterated willingness of Chisinau authorities to keep promoting confidence-building and sustain people in the Transnistria settlement process. (According to MOLDPRES agency)

ECHR likely to award victory to Interdnestrcom

The Transnistrian media has reported that the ECHR could award victory to the Transnistrian telecommunication operator Interdnestrcom versus Moldovan Government, as the case is being studied. Some years ago, Interdnestrcom had bought a mobile telephony licence from Moldovan Government and paid one million dollars. Meanwhile, Moldovan authorities annulled the licence and refused to repay the money.


Foreign Affairs

European Integration

European Union will allocate 3 million Euros for free and fair parliamentary elections

The European Commission has decided to fund projects capable to promote and monitor respect for international standards during the April 5, 2009 parliamentary elections. For this purpose, it will allocate 3 million Euros via funding projects and instruments[1]. Benita Ferrero-Waldner, Commissioner for External Relations and European Neighbourhood Policy, said that this decision of the European Commission is an important indicator of the active EU interest to deepen relations with Moldova. At the same time, the European official invited Moldovan authorities to do their best in order to strengthen the rule of law and implement all commitments on human rights and fundamental freedoms, especially throughout electoral process.

5th Meeting of EU-Moldova Subcommittee for Economy, Finance and Statistics

Chisinau hosted on February 27, 2009 the 5th Meeting of the EU-Moldova Cooperation Subcommittee for Economy, Finance and Statistics. The agenda included issues related to latest macroeconomic and financial developments in Moldova, implementation of economic commitments assumed by Moldova in accordance with the EU-Moldova Action Plan; implementation of the regulatory reform, etc. During talks, participants stressed the importance of EU support and financial assistance in internal reformation process, pointing out priorities and actions needed to be taken for strengthening the Moldovan-EU sectoral cooperation. (According to a MFAEI communication)

Visit by deputy foreign minister to Brussels

Valeriu Ostalep was on a working visit to Brussels on February 18, 2009 and met there Mr. John Kjaer, Unit Head, DG RELEX of the European Commission, and Mr. Janos Herman, Senior Adviser for Regional Cooperation, deputy political director, DG RELEX of the European Commission. Talks focussed on important issues for Moldova, in particular, the negotiation of a Moldova-EU Agreement, the EU visa policy and the opening of a dialogue on liberalisation of visa regime, the European Commission’s assistance to Moldova. As well, they discussed latest internal developments in Moldova and schedule of events organised jointly with the European Commission. (According to a MFAEI communication)

Bilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Russia

During February 23–24, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov was on a working visit to Chisinau. He was received by President Vladimir Voronin and discussed with Prime Minister Zinaida Greceanii and Deputy Foreign Minister Valeriu Ostalep. Talks focussed on international cooperation of countries, inclusively the information of Moldova about Russia’s initiative to work out a treaty on security, development of bilateral cooperation in some areas, particularly commercial-economic and cultural-humanitarian, Transnistrian problem; Moldova’s chairmanship in CIS. During the visit, the Russian foreign minister has attended the inauguration of the Russian Cultural Centre in Chisinau, signed a humanitarian cooperation programme between Moldova and Russia for 2009–2010 and a consultation plan between Foreign Ministries of Russia and Moldova for 2009, and handed in to President Voronin copies of archives relating to masterpiece and activity of Dimitrie and Antioh Cantemir.

Note by ADEPT: The visit of Sergei Lavrov came after a 8-year pause, when a Russian foreign minister visited Moldova last time, and in full electoral campaign. Thus, both Moldovan and Russian media, and opposition leaders said that the visit had an electoral purpose advantaging PCRM. Although the Russian foreign minister denied any electoral connotation of his visit, the fact that declared purposes of the visit were typical to a lower-ranking official rather than to Russia’s foreign minister reduces the credibility of Lavrov’s sayings.

Multilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe

ECHR decisions

On February 24, 2009, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) pronounced a decision on Decev vs. Moldova and decided on fair resolution of the case Dacia SRL vs. Moldova. In both cases the Court indicated violation of the right to property protection and fair trial. It granted 2,500 Euros in non-pecuniary damages and 800 Euros in costs and expenses in the Decev vs. Moldova case. As for Dacia SRL vs. Moldova, the Court obliged the Moldovan Government to return the Dacia hotel (including adjacent plot and inventory of the hotel) to the applicant. In the event it refuses to return the hotel, the Government will have to pay 7,237,700 Euros in pecuniary damages, 25,000 Euros in non-pecuniary damages and 6,000 Euros in costs and expenses to the applicant. (Source: www.echr.coe.int, www.lhr.md)

Republic of Moldova – OSCE

Launching of ODIHR parliamentary election observation mission

The mission of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) was formally launched on February 26 to observe parliamentary elections in Moldova. OSCE observers are monitoring the scrutiny at the invitation of the Central Electoral Commission. The mission is made of 13 international experts. Twenty-four long-term observers will join them in early March and another 200 short-term observers will arrive before the Election Day. According to the head of the OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission, Nikolai Vulchanov, the mission mandate is not to intervene in electoral process, not to recommend or advise Moldovan authorities how to organise elections, but to observe and notify facts, while the exclusive responsibility for validity of the scrutiny will rest with authorities, political parties and civil society. (According to Moldpres)


1 2 million Euros will be provided via the project Supporting Elections in the Republic of Moldova within the Stability Instrument; 0.5 million Euros will be allocated within the European Instrument for Democracy and Human Rights; another 0.5 million Euros will be granted via the Joint Programme of the European Commission and Council of Europe on Supporting Free and Fair Elections.


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Vote of Moldovans living abroad
Igor Botan, 23 February 2009


1. Those keeping Moldova afloat cannot participate in governing

Claims by some electoral contestants to ensure the electoral right of Moldovan nationals working abroad are absolutely legitimate. Even more, it is worth to mention that ensuring the electoral right of Moldovan gastarbeiters is more legitimate than that sanctioned by laws, by Constitution and electoral legislation. The big Moldovan paradox is that those keeping Moldova afloat cannot participate in governing of public affairs by electing their representatives in leading state bodies.

It is true that when governors, for example, praise themselves that they have managed to increase the budget twofold in one electoral cycle they forget the true source of the "phenomenal success" – remittances from gastarbeiters. Gastarbeiters’ remittances were equivalent to the state budget, representing approximately 1/3 of GDP, in the latest period between parliamentary elections!

Diagram 1. Dynamic of remittances, annual values, million USD

Annual value of remittances
Source: NBM, IMF

If so, what attitude should political class in particular and governors in general have towards gastarbeiters? The answer is clear – they should take care that their political interests and willingness be taken into account.

2. How many gastarbeiters does the Republic of Moldova have and how many of them vote?

The number of Moldovan gastarbeiters is big for sure. But those pleading the cause of Moldovan gastarbeiters exaggerate their number for rather noble reasons, in order to emphasise the importance of this problem. As a rule, a round number of 1,000,000 out of approximately 2.4 million people entitled to vote (without citizens from Transnistria) is given. Indeed, data from various sources correlated together estimate the number of gastarbeiters between 400,000 and 600,000 people.

Really, these estimated data released by the Chisinau-based offices of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF) correlate very well with accounts by the Ministry of Information Development (MID) and findings of surveys:

The exponential rise of remittances does induce the conclusion that the number of gastarbeiters is growing exponentially as well. Another explanation would be that those working abroad accommodate themselves better and better with the passage of years and they earn more, respectively. If so, the gravity of the problem of Moldovan nationals working abroad consists both in the very high number of approximately 1/5 or even 1/4 of those entitled to vote, and in the fact that those who left the country are the best citizens, enterprising, with ages between 20 and 50 years, capable to handle their destiny alone.

In the light of all these facts, it is almost impossible to estimate the number of gastarbeiters who participate in elections. The table below reveals the number of Moldovan nationals from other countries who participated in the voting in different electoral years.

Table. Number of Moldovan nationals who participated in the voting abroad

Location / year1994199820012005
Austria-392882
Belarus20355177
Belgium172657113
Bulgaria-5986134
China-111020
France-62107422
Greece---1005
Germany-2347148
Israel-7743118
Italy--237850
Poland-1828127
United Kingdom---108
Romania1709207919343264
Russia1606078522760
USA322860101
Turkey-294890
Ukraine103665127
Hungary--4685
Uzbekistan--1326
New-York (UN)-18-96
Geneva (UN)-121779
Strasbourg (CoE)-52694
Frankfurt (consulate)-2951112
Overall19483193380610038

I.e. approximately 2 percent out of about half a million nationals who are abroad voted at the last elections. Perhaps, students, tourists and those who are legally staying in these countries cast their ballots. Therefore, one may draw the conclusion that approximately 1 percent out of the overall number of gastarbeiters voted at the last elections!

3. International experience regarding voting by nationals living abroad

There is an ample international experience regarding the voting abroad. The general rule is that, since elections are a manifestation of sovereign willingness of nations, they take place in respective territories and in their "extensions" abroad – embassies and consulates. When there are reciprocal interest and willingness, governments of some states sign agreements on opening extra-territorial polling stations outside of diplomatic missions, and this is the only way to do so. Many citizens of other states are abroad, as phenomena of "globalisation" change the realities. For this reason, the "voting by correspondence" or the remote vote, by post, usually before the Election Day is often used. This method is widely used by the United States. The online voting has been extended much in the recent period. Last years, the OSCE has organised conferences to debate minimum mandatory standards for the online vote and measures to secure it. Suspicions related to security of the electronic vote make governments of many developed countries reticent over electronic vote. Find below latest examples confirming these facts:

4. Is it still possible to open polling stations outside of diplomatic missions?

The problem of opening supplementary polling stations abroad rests with the Government, not with the Central Electoral Commission (CEC). But even in the event it would sign agreements with authorities of countries which host many Moldovan nationals, the Government could not do anything, since Article 29(5) says clearly that "in case of parliamentary elections and republican referenda, a polling station shall open in each diplomatic mission and consular office of the Republic of Moldova for employees of these representations and their families, as well as for Moldovan citizens from countries concerned, regardless of their number."

Therefore, the legislation should be modified, in order to be able to open polling stations outside of diplomatic missions. The CEC budget shall be modified as well, though the problem does not consist in funds, but in allocating them on time, and the Government could use the "reserve fund". It is unimaginable to suppose that the Parliament and Government would convene to examine this issue. But problems do not end here; procedures of voting abroad, outside of diplomatic missions are very complicated, requiring a detailed preparation long before the electoral campaign. These problems may be resolved only in conditions of a reciprocal confidence between governing and opposition regarding a series of issues:

All these problems are resoluble, but they require very clear and verifiable procedures to avoid further conflicts. There is no time to elaborate and coordinate them with main political forces. This formula answers in fact the question why Moldovan nationals from other countries cannot vote outside of diplomatic missions, as well as why Moldova does not practice the remote vote. But the emphasis was laid on procedures of printing and disseminating ballot papers when the Election Code was adopted in November 1997. Therefore, printing ballot papers long before the Election Day and sending them to electors by post is a very delicate problem. Then, the voting by post is recommended only to countries where citizens trust the post. Confidence towards the post in Moldova, which had many cases when the correspondence was illegally opened, is a problem completed by the problem of confidence towards posts from other states. Let’s remember speculations about the 2005 parliamentary scrutiny that authorities of some CIS member states were interested to influence the results of Moldovan elections.

Finally, the perspective of electronic voting for Moldovans from other countries is very far because of reciprocal distrust between governing and opposition as well. For example, the composition of the electronic register of voters has raised the aversion of some influent opposition parties. What else to say about confidence towards software for electronic voting, when parties, both those ruling and in opposition, flow the example of blocked computers at the 1999 municipal elections as a electoral fraud, as reports by approximately 300 polling stations were available to everybody to make the necessary checking. Finally, the electronic voting will be available when Moldovan citizens will understand the procedures and the "electronic signature". Perhaps more than one electoral cycle will be over until then.

For this reason, the problem of voting from other countries will be present at the next parliamentary elections in 2013 as well. It is worth to mention this fact because current talks on this issue produce a "live" effect. These problems were discussed before the 2005 parliamentary elections as well. However, the situation did not change at all meanwhile. All arguments invoked four years ago are reiterated in this article almost unchanged. Just examples of international experience were updated.

5. Conclusions and recommendations



The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]