ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20090331/index.shtml


e-journal, year VII, issue 135, 17–31 March 2009

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Transdnistrian Problem

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Government

1.1. Decisions

Decision on building the Cultural-Natural Reservation Orheiul Vechi. The Public Institution called Cultural-Natural Reservation Orheiul Vechi is built to protect, preserve and save present and future generation of the ensemble of historical-cultural and natural-landscape monuments carrying an exceptional value which make the respective complex. As well, the Regulation of institution, the Plan on borders and protection areas were approved. The Ministry of Culture and Tourism is due to submit to examination the development strategy of the Cultural-Natural Reservation Orheiul Vechi. More than 350,000 lei will go to working out the urban plan, arranging the area and remunerating the staff and about one million lei will be necessary to prepare the facilities for the inclusion into the List of UNESCO Heritage.

Decision concerning some chess development measures. Under the decision, promoting the chess is a priority direction of developing the sport in Moldova, while the Ministry of Education and Youth will include a chess training modulus into the curricula on Physical Education subject and will educate chess trainers in specialized institutions. The Sport Agency jointly with the National Chess Federation will work out and present a draft national chess development program.

Decision concerning the approval of the land cadastre accordingly to situation on January 1, 2009. Overall surface counts for 3,384,560 hectares, including 228.3 hectares of irrigated fields and 69,200 hectares of drained fields. The surfaces coincide exactly with those from the land cadastre approved last year.

Decision concerning the transmission of a real estate. A building located in the Chisinau downtown and an adjacent plot are transmitted to the administration of the Chamber of Auditors as headquarters of this institution.

Decisions approving some regulations:

Decisions approving some plans, programs, policy documents:

Decisions concerning the reorganization and dissolution of some enterprises:

1.3. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Press conference by prime minister

Previous and current accomplishments have been reiterated at a conference which totalised the Government’s activity:

Zinaida Greceanii called upon people to participate in the parliamentary elections on April 5, saying that they have a vital importance for our country’s future.

Consumer cooperation

The prime minister has participated in the annual sitting of the Moldcop Board of Directors, delivering a speech on increasing trend of economic indicators of the Central Union of Consumer Cooperatives and efficient management of this structure. Moldcoop has more than 2,900 markets and shops nationwide and the Government traditionally says that it relies much on this structure in developing the domestic trade system. Zinaida Greceanii asked the Moldcop Executive Board to raise proposals and participate actively in building civilised domestic trade functioning mechanisms.

Fight against trafficking in human beings

Deputy Prime Minister Valentin Mejinschi has chaired a sitting of the council in charge with preventing and combating crimes and corruption, which discussed issues related to prevention and struggle against trafficking in human beings and prevention of delayed terms of penal suits. The council instructed competent bodies to take actions aimed:


Presidency

2.1. Decrees

The Order Gloria Muncii (Labour Glory) was awarded to:

The Civic Merit Medal was awarded to some heads who participated in the building of the Giurgiulesti Passenger Port, some employees of public services.

Honorific titles (Artist of People, Master of Art, Emeritus Man, and Emeritus Artist) were awarded to a group of artists.

2.2. Sittings. Decisions. Statements

Praising Government’s activity

The chief of state attended the governmental sitting on March 31, 2009 and said that the work of Greceanii’s team was professional and allowed the implementation of all planned projects. According to the president, the Government succeeded to handle many crisis situations and maintain stability. In particular, he stressed the rise of wages and pensions, continuation of national gasification, water providing programs, renovation of road segments, consolidation of farm land, opening of the Cahul-Giurgiulesti railway, etc. Vladimir Voronin believes that the Government has fulfilled all provisions of the Moldova-EU Action Plan. The next Government will have to do its best in order to maintain macroeconomic stability, increase the employment rate and honour all social commitments of the country. The bureaucracy shall be reduced, while the participation and real support for investment processes shall be increased.

Activity of popular guards

Moldova’s president has participated in a summing-up meeting on operation of popular guards, stressing the merit of popular guards in combating crimes and maintaining the rule of law. According to the Interior Ministry, very grave crimes and those relating to domestic relations and street offences were successfully combated due to the relationship between police bodies and popular guards. There are 1,220 popular guard teams in Moldova which have 16,000 members; in 2008 they helped hold red-handed more than 100 offenders, discover about 800 offences, hold 100 wanted persons and participated in the documentation of 15,000 offenders.

Concerns with financial-bank situation

Moldova’s president has convoked a sitting to discuss latest evolutions on monetary-currency market and execution of the state budget. According to the National Bank of Moldova (NBM) accounts, the domestic currency has maintained its stability versus main reference currencies, while the domestic banking system is very resistant, with the current liquidity indicator counting for 30.1 percent on average, compared with the minimum prudence rate of 20 percent. Currency inflows and outflows are more balanced than in 2008, so that the macroeconomic situation in terms of currency inflows is better than last year and fluctuations on currency market do not have an objective ground but are related to pressures exerted on people via the media. The chief of state stressed the importance of permanently monitoring the financial-bank evolutions with the view to maintain positive macroeconomic conditions. It was noted during talks on execution of state budget that budgetary incomes raised from internal taxes and fees are on the rise compared with 2008, positive dynamics being observed for revenues administrated by the Customs Service: the imports have increased by 3.7 percent and the exports by 4.2 percent, so that the customs collections to the state budget have grown by 5 percent. The current state budget incomes allows a rhythmical coverage of priority expenses, inclusively wages, pensions and other social indemnities, external payments.

Increased attention for state decorations during service term

Moldova’s president has awarded decorations to a group of people and said in a greeting speech that in 8 years of rule as chief of state he has attended many ceremonies on awarding state distinctions and awarding decorations to 1950 persons out of 4,350 cases was accepted. The chief of state stressed the necessity of awarding state distinctions after a period of hard and assiduous work in diverse areas, which stabilized the social-political situation and consolidated the society. The high number of persons who were awarded orders, medals and honorific distinctions in eight years is a proof of positive developments in all areas of life of society, the president assured.

First graduation from National Institute of Justice

The president of Moldova has attended a ceremony on awarding diplomas to the first graduation from the National Institute of Justice, saying that an efficient judiciary will be available only if ensuring a strong professional education and attracting persons with an irreproachable moral probity in doing the job of prosecutors and judges. Vladimir Voronin recalled that most of people’s discontentment envisages the work of the judiciary, who is also the topic of many applications submitted by Moldovan citizens to the ECHR.


1 The mortgage investment company Moldvinipoteca was opened in late 2007 to make vineyards and should have a minimum business plan for 2007–2010.


Economic Policies

1. Labour market

2. Banking system

3. External position of country


Transdnistrian Problem

Barvikha Declaration from 18 March 2009

On March 18, 2009, the city of Barvikha near Moscow hosted a meeting of Russian and Moldovan Presidents Dmitri Medvedev and Vladimir Voronin, with the participation of Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov. It ended with the signing of a joint declaration released by the Russian Foreign Ministry. It says that the "leaderships of the Republic of Moldova and Transnistria", parties of the conflict, have met in Barvikha in the presence of the Russian Federation’s President. The goal of the meeting was to strengthen efforts for settling the Transnistrian conflict through peaceful political methods only. The participants in the meeting agreed on the following clauses:

Transnistrian leader about meaning of the Barvikha Declaration

On March 23, 2009, Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov disclosed the ins and outs of the Barvikha Declaration, in an interview with the Moscow-based newspaper "Nezavisimaia Gazeta". According to Smirnov, Russia’s positions in the Transnistrian region have consolidated and this will facilitate the integration of the region into Russia. The Transnistrian problem will be shortly discussed within the Russian Security Council. In this regard, Smirnov also revealed some facts about the signing and contents of the Barvikha Declaration. In particular, he said that:

Draft "agreement concerning guarantees of Transnistrian settlement"

Following the March 18, 2009 meeting in Moscow, Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov has delivered to President Vladimir Voronin the draft "agreement concerning the system of guarantees for the Moldovan-Transnistrian settlement". According to the draft, Moldova and Transnistria are equal parties of the conflict; Russia and Ukraine are guarantors, while the OSCE is a guardian of the agreement. The draft agreement stipulates the following:

Transnistrian propaganda about Romanian danger

Transnistria’s mouthpiece published on March 16, on the eve of the March 18, 2009 meeting in Moscow between Presidents Medvedev and Voronin and Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov, a communication by the presidium of the coordinating council of public organisations and Transnistrian parties, which says that causes of the war in the region were not remedied yet, as ruling circles from Moldova keep promoting the policy on political, economic and ethno-cultural accession to Romania. Arguments to these facts would be:

Note by ADEPT: This declaration is the most eloquent sample of "laundering brains" of citizens from Transnistria. There is no need to describe the state of Moldovan-Romanian relations in order to combat the Transnistrian propaganda, it is enough to note that prior to the April 5, 2009 parliamentary elections the Commissioner for external relations and neighborhood policy, Benita Ferrero-Waldner, had to send the following message via her spokesperson: "the European Commission is carefully monitoring the situation regarding the alleged entry restrictions on some Romanian citizens in the Republic of Moldova signaled after March 26… The Commission considers that legitimate trips by Romanian citizens to the Republic of Moldova shall not be obstructed." That’s how the Republic of Moldova "joins" Romania.

Analyst Vladimir Socor regarding Barvikha Declaration

Commenting the signing of the "trilateral" declaration – Medvedev, Voronin, Smirnov – in Barvikha, Gamestown Foundation analyst Vladimir Socor notes that:

Immediate consequences of the Barvikha Declaration


Foreign Affairs

European Integration

European Council approves statement on Eastern Partnership

On March 20, 2009 the Brussels European Council adopted a statement concerning the Eastern Partnership, which is part of the Presidency Conclusions of the Brussels European Council. The statement reveals the following:

  1. The EU has a strong interest in developing an increasingly close relationship with its eastern partners, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Georgia, Republic of Moldova and Ukraine, by granting the prospect of political association and economic integration into the EU;
  2. The Eastern Partnership will be governed by the principles of joint ownership, differentiation and conditionality. Shared values including democracy, the rule of law and respect for human rights will be at its core, as well as the principles of market economy, sustainable development and good governance;
  3. The Partnership will provide a 600-million-euro financial support for the period to 2013; increased financial support will respect the resources available under the multiannual Financial Framework, including adequate margins;
  4. New association agreements with the EU, which would include consolidated and global free exchange agreements will be signed with those partners who have made sufficient progress towards the principles of market economy and democratic values and who are willing and able to comply with the resulting commitments;
  5. The Eastern Partnership will promote mobility of citizens of partner countries and will take gradual steps towards full visa facilitation as a long term goal for individual partner countries and on a case by case basis provided that conditions for well-managed and secure mobility are in place.
  6. The Eastern Partnership aims to strengthen the energy security cooperation of all participants with regard to long-term energy supply and transit including through better regulation and energy efficiency.

The statement does not say anything about granting of a clear European perspective to participating states.

The Eastern Partnership will be launched on May 7, 2009 within a summit which will be organized for this purpose.

EUBAM releases its annual report 2008

The European Union Border Assistance Mission (EUBAM) released its annual report 2008 on March 26, 2009. According to the report, the European Court of Auditors, examining the effectiveness of EU support in the area of freedom, security and justice in Moldova, Ukraine and Belarus stated that the EUBAM had contributed greatly to building capacity in the Moldovan and Ukrainian border guard and customs services.

EU-Moldova COEST Troika Meeting (Working group of the EU Council for Relations with Eastern Europe and Central Asia)

On March 25, 2009 in Brussels a Moldovan delegation headed by Valeriu Ostalep, deputy minister of foreign affairs and European integration, attended the EU-Moldova COEST Troika Meeting. The meeting tackled issues related to the electoral campaign for the parliamentary elections in Moldova; latest developments in the Transnistrian settlement process; future of EU-Moldova relations and negotiation of a new Moldova-EU agreement.

While on visit, the Moldovan delegation has met Hugues Mingarelli, deputy director of DG RELEX, European Commission, and political scientists, Michael Emerson, senior researcher of the Centre for European Policy Studies, and Antonio Missiroli, study director of the European Policy Centre. (According to a MFAEI press release)

MFAEI releases the Newsletter on Moldova-EU Mobility Partnership

On March 27, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration released the first online issue of Newsletter on the Mobility Partnership Republic of Moldova – European Union.

The newsletter tells in brief the negotiations on the Moldova-EU Mobility Plan, the mechanism for monitoring the implementation, evolutions in implementing the Mobility Partnership and events scheduled for the near future.

The next issues will provide information about implementation of projects within the Action Partnership aimed:

  1. To strengthen relations with the Moldovan Diaspora;
  2. To encourage the comeback and reintegration of Moldovan migrants;
  3. To consolidate the institutional capacity in the area of migration management;
  4. To invest remittances;
  5. To ensure border management and security of documents;
  6. To ensure social protection;
  7. To cooperate against illegal migration and trafficking in human beings.

(According to a MFAEI press release)

Bilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Romania

After Romania has tried in the second half of January to restore good relations with the Republic of Moldova the Moldovan-Romanian ties strained again by the end of March. This situation comes after many Romanian citizens were denied access to the Republic of Moldova without clear reasons. According to data by the Romanian Foreign Ministry, approximately 300 Romanian and Moldovan citizens were denied access to the Republic of Moldova during March 27–29, 2009. The situation raised both the discontentment of Romanian authorities and concern of the European Commission. In particular, Romanian Foreign Minister Cristian Diaconescu has told a press conference that "the restricted circulation of citizens in the European area reveals the lack of a real commitment (by the Republic of Moldova) in the European course supported energetically by Romania in Brussels,"[1] while a press release by the Romanian Foreign Ministry stressed that the "treatment applied on Romanian citizens is unacceptable and contrary to their status of European citizens, EU norms which the Republic of Moldova wants to join and fundamental human rights…"[2]

At a pres conference on March 31, 2009, Moldovan Prime Minister Zinaida Grecianii denied any abuse by Moldovan authorities, saying that the actions by Moldovan border guard and customs services were perfectly legal[3]. At the same time, the prime minister said that the holding aimed to prevent alleged destabilizing actions organized by groups of Romanian citizens on the eve of parliamentary elections in Moldova.

It is worth mentioning that the MFAEI convoked the Romanian Ambassador in Chisinau, Filip Teodorescu, on March 20, 2009 to inform him in connection with possible public electoral actions that groups of Romanian citizens would have been expected to hold in Chisinau during March 27–28. The ministry told the Romanian diplomat that the Moldovan authorities "will take all necessary measures with the view to prevent such a situation, which would jeopardize the good relations between the Republic of Moldova and Romania."[4]

Republic of Moldova – Russia

Two events marked the Moldova-Russia relations in the second half of March. The No.1 event was the visit of Moldova’s President Vladimir Voronin to Moscow to meet there Russian President Dmitri Medvedev and sign a joint declaration with his Russian counterpart and Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov (see the chapter TRANSNISTRIAN PROBLEM). The second, less important event was the visit of Russian Minister of Economy Elvira Nabiullina to Chisinau. While on visit, the Russian minister has met Moldovan President Vladimir Voronin and officials of the Ministry of Economy and Trade (MET). The sides discussed issues relating to commercial-economic relations between Moldova and Russia and opportunities to develop and extend them. In particular, Vladimir Voronin stressed the possibility to supply Moldovan agro-food products to the Russian market, inclusively via the Giurgiulesti International Port. In her turn, Nabiullina said that Russian economic agents will keep investing and implementing new investment projects in Moldova, especially in the energy and telecommunication sectors, despite the world economic crisis. (According to MET press release)

Note by ADEPT: Some analysts consider that the visit of the Russian minister of economy was part of the "electoral" visits of foreign officials in favor of the PCRM. However, cannot be ignored the version that this visit could aim to find investment opportunities in domestic energy and telecommunication sectors and/or establish conditions for providing a Russian financial assistance to Moldova when Chisinau will experience repercussions of the world financial and economic crisis.

Multilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe

ECHR decisions

On March 31, 2009, the European Court of Human Rights pronounced decisions on the cases Hyde Park and others vs. Moldova (no. 1), (no.2), and (no.3). It indicated the violation of freedom of meetings and association in all three cases and granted 9,000 Euros to applicants for all cases in non-pecuniary damages and 3,000 Euros in costs and expenses. (Source: www.echr.coe.int, www.lhr.md)


1 www.mae.ro, 29.03.2009

2 www.mae.ro, 27.03.2009

3 Info-Prim Neo

4 www.mfa.md, 20.03.2009


Studies, Analyses, Comments

International ratings, external deficits, exchange rate…
Iurie Gotisan, March 31, 2009


The Economist Intelligence Unit, part of the well-known British magazine The Economist, has recently published a report on vulnerability of countries of the world to consequences of the world economic crisis. The report ranks the Republic of Moldova, Ukraine and Bosnia-Herzegovina as most politically unstable countries and therefore, very vulnerable to economic developments. In fact, these are very natural explanations, as Ukraine for example has entered a full economic crisis with a divided political class, splitting and internal confrontations. Bosnia and Herzegovina faces a similar situation like Ukraine, while Moldova was introduced as a country with an autocratic rather than democratic regime, with a very discontent population which does not trust much in political institutions. So, all these factors influence directly or indirectly the economic and political stability in a certain country.

According to a rating by the international financial evaluation agency Fitch IBCA, Moldova is rated "B-" for long-term external commitments, "B" for internal commitments and the "stable" forecast for both of them. At the same time, Fitch experts say that the economic situation in Moldova is "very difficult" on background of the increasing external debt and persistence of an appreciated leu. In the context of these evolutions, hereby some comments regarding evaluations of the two ratings, outlining some aspects of the macroeconomic context.

According to the NBM data for the 3rd quarter of 2008, the overall external debt of Moldova accounted for about 4 billion dollars, by about 19 percent more than in late 2007 and more than 66 percent of the GDP (the GDP in 2008 was 6.03 billion dollars, calculated on the basis of an average exchange rate of 10.42 lei/USD). The state-guaranteed debt amounted to about 0.78 billion dollars of the overall external debt or about 13 percent, this being a generally accepted level. The unguaranteed private debt covers most of the overall external debt, about 3.1 percent, increasing by 20 percent compared with 2007, especially after the rise of commercial credits. In addition, the trade deficit reached a record level of over 3.3 billion dollars in 2007, counting for about 55 percent of the GDP, while the current account deficit has likely exceeded 6 percent of the GDP. Accounts above indicate a rising trend of external deficits in the last years with the decisive "contribution" of the private sector. Even more, the growth of external deficits justifies the fear of many economists regarding possible skidding in 2009 on background of the economic crisis’ effects and explains somehow why talks with the IMF are difficult.

In fact, the relation between current account and GDP (CA/GDP) is the key indicator which should be taken into account when the country’s external position is assessed. Therefore, both the trade balance and remittances are part of the current account deficit. For example, the current account deficit of Moldova reached 218 million dollars in the 3rd quarter of 2008. By using a simple extrapolation, one may estimate that the current account deficit will exceed 500 million dollars in 2009 or more than 10 percent of the GDP (IMF estimates 10.6 percent of GDP). Of course, it is hard for any economy to fund a 10 percent, but Moldova is relatively well compared with other countries from the region. The central bank has enough resources to protect itself against eventual speculative assaults, despite a strong use of reserve currency in the recent period. However, Ukraine or Poland faced serious financial crises at such levels in the last ten years, facing devaluations of domestic currency.

One more thing is worth to be mentioned: much of the current account deficit (about 50 percent) is raised on account of the private sector or the private sector borrows more than the Government. There is a very elementary explanation in this regard: the private sector is likely more reasonable than the public sector (as it meets market regulations) and these deficits finally have natural explanations. Statistics for 2008 confirm this assessment: imports of technological equipments, machines and appliances are increasingly larger, so that economic agents invest more in modernization of enterprises and expect larger profits in future.

On the other hand, the announced falls of interest rates on lei, higher wages, expansion of consumer credit, an eventual appreciation of leu will encourage a better dynamic of internal demand than of internal supply. The decline of interest rates would encourage the crediting in lei in an economy caught in the fever of consumption. While the reduction of taxes in 2008 and the duty-free corporate profit did not stimulate enough the budget collections, the expansion of consumption is found in higher external deficits and probably in slower efforts to reduce the inflation. The appreciation of leu versus dollar helped somehow a lower inflation in 2008 compared with 2007, but deepened the external deficits.

The macroeconomic evolution this year will depend much on regional trends as well. However, it is hard to tell Moldova’s possibilities to manage without an external financial help on background of internal and external negative economic evolutions. To recall that the IMF memorandum is almost over, while a new agreement could be negotiated only after the election of a new government. The granting of assistance by other donors is also conditioned with a new agreement with the IMF. If it fails to find alternative funding sources or give up some social and economic programmes, the Government will have to call on assistance of the World Bank. However, the exhaustion of reserves could free the spiral of prices and release new speculative pressures on the leu. An immediate result would be the rise of prices, devaluation of national currency and marking up of strategic imports such as natural gas, electricity, etc. All the more this could happen, as oil prices have suddenly increased on international markets.

We have often been witnesses of accusations brought against NBM with regard to the exchange rate policy, which were justified here and there. An appreciated leu may counteract the inflationist impetuses, but external deficits will deepen and effects will not be late. When the leu is appreciated including nominally, exporters face the consequences first of all, as collections from exports fall down. In addition, a long-term appreciation of the leu with some fluctuations erodes the economic stability if productivity incomes are inappropriate, bringing high deficits at level of enterprises and domestic economy. Staking on the appreciation of leu as a factor capable to reduce the inflation may be a very dangerous solution. Some signal an imminent financial crisis related to an eventual "escape of capital" which would make the leu fall down. But at the same time, Moldova does not run the risk to face the escape of speculative capital. Finally, governmental options should be judged in relations with the National Bank’s dilemmas, while the choices of economic policy faced by Government are very difficult since they imply important compromises and costs. Anyway, a good cooperation between Government and NBM is required, especially when the internal economic conjuncture in 2009 could be influenced inclusively by results of the April 5 parliamentary elections.


Eastern Partnership – opportunity or barrier for European integration of Moldova?
Oleg Cristal, March 31, 2009


During the March 20, 2009 session of the European Council, EU heads of state and government approved the Polish-Swedish European Commission’s initiative on the Eastern Partnership. Besides EU member states the Eastern Partnership covers six eastern neighboring countries: Ukraine, Moldova, Belarus, Georgia, Azerbaijan and Armenia. This regional cooperation instrument will have a 600-million-euro budget for 2007–2013. The Eastern Partnership will be officially launched in Brussels on May 7, with leaders of all countries covered by this initiative being invited to participate. Thus, the Polish-Swedish initiative is materialized with less than one year after being submitted (May 2008), and this is a great success for the notorious European bureaucratic machinery.

Which is the essence of this initiative and what new does it bring within the ENP? Is the Eastern Partnership an obstacle for Moldova’s accession to the EU or rather an opportunity? What advantages our country may harvest within this arrangement? These are some questions to be answered below.

Eastern Partnership in brief

As already mentioned above, Sweden and Poland proposed on May 23, 2008 to build an Eastern Partnership between the 27 EU member states and six Eastern European states. The goal of initiative is to strengthen relations with Eastern European neighbors over those from the Mediterranean area. Under Article 49 of the Treaty on the EU, any European state which respects the community’s principles may apply for the EU membership. This way, unlike southern neighbors (from the Mediterranean area), Eastern European states have at least the theoretical chance to join the EU. Therefore, developers of the initiatives noted, these countries shall enjoy a different treatment by the EU within ENP.

Although Poland and Sweden only are developers of the Eastern Partnership Concept, this project was supported through diverse ways by the Baltic States, Hungary as well as by Europe’s economic engine Germany. A negative reaction to this initiative came from Romania and Bulgaria only,[1], as they relied on another project proposed by these states for the south-east area – the Black Sea Synergy. Later, the position of these countries has changed and they became supporters of the Eastern Partnership.

A month after the Eastern Partnership initiative was released EU leaders convened in the European Council welcomed the Polish-Swedish initiative on June 20, 2008 and called on the European Commission to propose concrete methods to implement it in the spring 2009[2]. The August 2008 Russian-Georgian war enhanced the EU attention towards the eastern neighborhood and catalyzed the elaboration of the Eastern Partnership Concept. Therefore, the European Commission delivered on December 3, 2008 its vision concerning the Eastern Partnership to EU member states and European Parliament[3]. On that occasion, the European Commissioner for External Relations and Neighborhood Policy, Benita Ferrero Waldner, said that this instrument provides some prepared Eastern European states with the possibility to get an EU associate status[4]. In his turn, European Commission President Jose Manuel Barosso said that the Eastern Partnership is a political association and economic integration instrument.

On January 14, 2009, Czech Premier Mirek Topolanek presented in front of the European Parliament the priorities of the Czech EU Presidency. According to Topolanek, the Eastern Partnership will keep being the priority of the Czech Presidency. On February 18, 2009, the European Parliament approved the resolution on the annual report of the Council concerning main aspects of the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) in 2007, which indicates the "necessity of a stronger EU presence in the eastern neighborhood". Romanian member of the European Parliament Alexandru Nazare stressed when the document was discussed that the Eastern Partnership is a welcome stimulant for participating countries which will want to apply for the EU membership such as the Republic of Moldova[5]. European parliamentarians backed the European Commission’s proposal which says that the new relations within the Eastern Partnership should be built on association agreements typical to each country and this would be a better response to partners’ bids for a tighter relationship[6].

The February 23 EU Council’s sitting of foreign ministers discussed the beginning of work on the Eastern Partnership initiative under documents by the Czech EU Presidency. The Council stressed that a series of issues are left, particularly related to visa liberalization, establishing of equilibrium between the Eastern Partnership and the Black Sea Synergy initiative, participation of some third countries (Russia and Turkey were invited as observers to the Eastern Partnership) and funding, and they will be considered[7]. Next step will be the approval of the Eastern Partnership by the EU Council at level of EU heads of state on March 20.

Birth premises of the Eastern Partnership

The Eastern Partnership was launched on a field already prepared for changes in EU relations with eastern neighbors. Firstly, it is worth to note that the Eastern Partnership is part of the ENP. The Neighborhood Policy was launched in 2004 to encourage good relations between the enlarged EU and neighbors, without providing them with the prospect to join the EU. According to the European Security Strategy, this policy was drafted to ensure the prosperity, stability and security of all the parties involved. The ENP covers 15 states and the Palestinian Authority, of them 6 Eastern European countries which are now part of the Eastern Partnership.

The ENP-provided advantages include benefits relating to economic and social development and possibility to accede to the domestic market and integration into other European policies:

Starting 2005, ENP member states have signed individual Action Plans with the EU, with Moldova being the first country to sign such a document on February 22, 2005. These political documents set the program, strategic objectives and priorities of EU relations with the ENP-covered states for a three-year term.

In 2006 Germany started informal discussions on reformation of the ENP, in order to advantage Eastern European countries over Mediterranean states through differentiation[8]. The reformulated ENP was called "ENP+", with "plus" meaning "more" that provided by the Neighborhood Policy. Talks about ENP+ failed very soon "because of the opposition of some Mediterranean states," according to German Bundestag member Rainder Steenblock[9].

On April 11, 2007 the European Commission tabled a new EU cooperation initiative for the Black Sea region within the ENP. The Black Sea Synergy proposed by Romania and Bulgaria and strongly supported by Germany aims to develop cooperation in the Black Sea area and between this region and the EU. Along with the bilateral EU policies on countries covered by the ENP, the pre-accession process with Turkey and the strategic partnership with Russia, the Black Sea Synergy will complete the EU efforts to promote stability and reforms in countries around the Black Sea. This project covers six states which have boundaries with the Black Sea (Romania, Russia, Bulgaria, Ukraine, Turkey and Georgia), as well as other countries which have a tight connection with the region (Moldova, Greece, Armenia, Azerbaijan). The Black Sea Synergy will be based on sectoral programs and community initiatives regarding good governance, move of people and security, energy, transport, environment, maritime policy, fishing, trade, research, education, employment, social affairs, science and technology.

In the spring 2008 German officials launched new talks about a new form of relations with the eastern neighbors. Thus, the deputy leader of the Christian Democratic Union from the European Parliament, Ingo Friedrich, member of the EP presidium, proposed in the mid-April 2008 the building of a Union of Eastern Europe which would bring together Moldova, Ukraine and some Caucasian states bidding for the EU membership. The German lawmaker was calling for "a third way between the quality of EU member and non-member, between countries inside and outside of the EU." A couple of days later, Elmar Brok, member of the European Parliament’s Foreign Relations Committee, said that the EU was considering a new strategy for eastern neighbors, which would stipulate something between the quality of EU member and common neighbor. He noted that talks will already envisage "European neighbors not neighbors of Europe." The Eastern Partnership was proposed after a month.

Germany’s efforts to promote a deeper cooperation in the Eastern Europe made some observers say that this is the response of Berlin to insistence of a group of southern states headed by France to promote the Union for the Mediterranean, which calls for a tighter cooperation between the EU and its southern neighbors (former French colonies). After a decade of talks on the necessity to build the Union for the Mediterranean, it was launched in July 2008.

Essence of the Eastern Partnership

The Eastern Partnership calls for deep relations between the EU and the six eastern neighbors of the Union, being based on an individual approach. Association Agreements will be signed with these countries, but unlike those signed with the Balkan states, which have a perspective to join the EU. The Eastern Partnership calls for building a true and comprehensible free-trade zone and gradually removing all obstacles on way of free move of people (including visa free) and cooperation regarding all aspects of security, especially energy security[10]. The operational structure of the future multilateral framework of the Eastern Partnership will have four stages: 1) bilateral meetings at level of heads of state and government; 2) annual meetings at level of EU foreign ministers and Eastern European partners to assess progresses of the Eastern Partnership and point out new goals; 3) meetings at level of high-ranking functionaries which will focus on four cooperation platforms, in particular: democracy, good governance and stability; economic integration and convergence with EU policies; energy security; people-to-people contacts; 4) meetings at level of experts which will also focus on the four thematic platforms.

Moldova’s ambiguous position

Chisinau has hesitated much before commenting the Eastern Partnership, hinting via informal channels that he is unsatisfied with the essence of this initiative. The key reason is the lack of a clear EU accession prospect in this regional cooperation instrument. The clearest position expressed by Moldovan authorities with regard to the Polish-Swedish initiative belongs to chief of state Vladimir Voronin who stated to the Russian newspaper Kommersant on February 27, 2009 that the Eastern Partnership "is similar to a CIS-2." The president wondered "why to build a CIS under the EU control?" adding that it "looks like a circle around Russia". Voronin explained his discontentment with the Eastern Partnership through the fact that Moldova is far ahead Caucasian states in the European integration process.

The discontentment the Moldovan president has expressed a year after the initiative was launched repeats somehow the reserved reaction of the Kiev authorities from 2008. Without openly criticizing the Eastern Partnership, the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry emphasized in a commentary on May 26, 2008 that this concept should foresee a clear EU accession prospect for Eastern European countries. Former Ukrainian foreign minister Boris Tarasiuk, head of the Supreme Rada’s Committee on European Integration, criticized the Polish-Swedish initiative in July 2008. He said that "any new projects which do not bring the EU accession perspective to Ukraine cannot be regarded as priorities". Unlike Moldova, Ukraine has more reasons to dislike the Eastern Partnership. This country is at the final stage of negotiating a new legal agreement with the EU, being expected to sign the Association Agreement in the second half of this year. Negotiations on this document last for more than two years. Following negotiations between Kiev and Brussels, Ukraine has actually got for the new document all provided by the Eastern Partnership: the soon signing of a Free Trade Agreement; it started negotiating a simplified visa regime with the EU, so that to finally abolish it (Kiev hopes that the EU will abolish visas for Ukrainians by 2012); enlarged cooperation to ensure energy security, etc. To recall that as regards Moldova the European Commission did not finalise yet the mandate on opening negotiations on a new Moldova-EU legal agreement. As well, Ukraine is far ahead Moldova in terms of democratic reforms.

Ukraine’s tactic would be recommendable to Moldova. Kiev does not frontally attack the Eastern Partnership as such an attitude would raise the query of Europeans in the best of cases. Ukrainians try to give more value to this initiative, stressing the necessity to establish a European perspective for Eastern European countries which meet the EU accession requirements. For example, Ukrainian President Victor Yushchenko said on March 25, 2009 that the Eastern Partnership is not an alternative for Ukraine’s European integration trend. He noted that Kiev’s expectations with regard to European integration will be materialised in the Association Agreement.

Advantages and shortcomings of the Eastern Partnership for Moldova

The negative side of this initiative is that the project does not stipulate a clear prospective to join the EU for the six Eastern European countries, which Chisinau, Kiev and Tbilisi seek insistently. Nor the inclusion in the same package with the Caucasian states, especially Azerbaijan and Armenia, as well as Belarus makes Moldova happy. Moldova besides Ukraine are farer away on the European integration way than Azerbaijan and Armenia, as well as Georgia, while Belarus does not aim to join the EU at all. However, Brussels speaks about personalized relations with states which will be part of the Eastern Partnership, so that each of them to be able to take "what it wants and how much it can" from this project. Therefore, the approaching to the EU depends most on quality and speed of reforms implemented in Moldova.

The Eastern Partnership brings some advantages that Moldova should enjoy. The launching of the Eastern Partnership this spring will catalyze the process of negotiations on the new Moldova-EU legal framework. Moldova has chances to sign an Association Agreement with the EU by 2010. Thanks to the Eastern Partnership Moldova has the certainty that sooner or later it will have a deep and comprehensible Free Trade Agreement with the EU, a more facilitated visa regime or even its abolition. This way, Moldova will have access to all four freedoms of move of the EU: of goods, of capital, of services and people.

As well, Moldova will be able to benefit of various EU-funded projects within the Eastern Partnership, inclusively related to infrastructure, energy security, education, etc. By 2020, the EU will raise its expenses per capita in our region from 6 Euros up to 20 Euros. It will spend approximately 2.1 billion Euros for this change. Meanwhile, by 2013 when the new community budget will be adopted, the EU will allocate new funds worth 350 million Euros to its eastern partners, while another 250 million will fund regional projects within the multilateral dimension of the Eastern Partnership[11]. It is worth to recall that these countries are funded by the EU within the ENP as well. The overall ENP budget for the budgetary period of EU 2007–2013 counts for 12 billion Euros.

Therefore, Moldova shall use all opportunities provided by the Eastern Partnership in order to improve the quality of people’s life, really continue democratic reforms. The Eastern Partnership neither sees the EU accession prospect nor restricts countries bidding for integration, and Moldova shall be ready when the Big European Family will open its doors.


1 "Eastern Partnership" could lead to enlargement

2 Presidency Conclusions – Brussels, 19/20 June 2008

3 The Eastern Partnership – an ambitious new chapter in the EU’s relations with its Eastern neighbours; Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and Council; Eastern Partnership

4 Video address by the European Commissionner for External Relations and European Neighbourhood Policy, Benita Ferrero Waldner

5 Eastern Partnership on top of EU priorities?

6 Revision of the European Neighborhood and Partnership Instrument (ENPI)

7 European Council approves Eastern Partnership

8 German EU Presidency – expectations and prospects

9 Germany backs Moldovan package of Transnistrian settlement proposals

10 Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and Council

11 In parallel, the European Commission will recommend EU member states to increase the crediting rate of the European Investment Bank for Eastern Europe, which counts now for 3.7 billion Euros and will likely be spent before 2013. The EU assistance will focus on promoting democracy and good governance, strengthening administrative capacities needed to take over/implement the EU legislation, economic development and integration into common EU market, facilitating mobility of East European citizens to EU, developing regional electricity markets, optimising the border control, etc.


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]