ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20091215/index.shtml


e-journal, year VII, issue 149, 1–15 December 2009

Activity of Public Institutions

Economic Policies

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1. Legislative acts

Law for the modification and completion of the 2009 state budget law. Under the bill delivered to the Parliament, the national public budget for 2009 is estimated at incomes worth about 22.5 billion lei, expenses worth about 27.8 billion lei and a deficit of about 5.3 billion lei.

Law for the modification of the state social insurance budget law for 2009. It redistributes some expense positions, raises the family and child protection fund, the unemployment fund, and reduces the healthcare fund, expenses for the organisation and functioning of the public social insurance system.

Law for the modification and completion of some legislative acts. It entrusts the State Chancellery to execute governmental policies on local public administration via its territorial offices led by "Government’s territorial representatives" as public dignitaries.

Law for the modification and completion of some legislative acts. It removes the regulations which oblige local public administration authorities or Government to provide priority housing to some categories (prosecution organs, police forces, victims of the Chernobyl catastrophe, victims of political repressions, parliamentarians, judges, and others).

Law for the modification of Article 1 of the law concerning the use of some real estates. Under the amendments concerned adopted through derogation, the field allocated previously to the Supreme Court of Justice was made available to build the German Embassy to Moldova.

Note by ADEPT: These amendments are motivated with the lack of funds by the Supreme Court of Justice to carry out building works. The Court reacted to this bill, fearing that the draft aimed to lift the real estate from 85 Mateevici Street harms the national interests, contrary to the goal of the judiciary and action principles of the legal authorities in a democratic society (SCJ Decision No. 7 of 09.11.2009).

Decision approving the budget of the Constitutional Court for 2010. The Court’s budget will consist of incomes worth 5,929,400 and expenses in the amount of 5,929,400 lei, with the Government being due to include this amount into the 2010 state budget law. The Constitutional Court’s budget for 2009 accounted for 5.47 million lei.

2. Statements

PCRM parliamentarian Galina Balmos presented a statement regarding the modification of the state budget law and state social insurance budget law for 2009.

PCRM parliamentarian Ludmila Belcencova presented a declaration concerning the situation in the broadcasting area.

PLDM parliamentarian Liliana Palihovici read a statement on the International Day of Persons with Disabilities.


Government

1. Decisions

Decisions approving some regulations:

Decision concerning the extraordinary national public health commission. It approves the nominal composition and regulation of the commission.

Decisions concerning the allocation of financial means from the reserve fund of the Executive:

2. Sittings. Decisions

Meeting with Palanca residents

Prime Minister Vlad Filat has met residents of the Palanca village in the rayon of Stefan-Voda to discuss issues related to the 7.7-kilometre-long Odessa-Reni route, which crosses this village and is now used by the Ukrainian side, in accordance with the Treaty on the delimitation of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border along with Additional Protocol. Palanca inhabitants told the premier that Ukrainian border guards do not allow them to circulate and reach own fields and signalled problems they face with trade facilities located along the route, as their operation is almost blocked by border guards and their restrictions. Premier Filat noted that this problem is important both for Palanca and for all country and requires a many-sided approach. At the same time, the Agreement on the delimitation of the Moldovan-Ukrainian border is to be executed because this is an effective international document. The premier assured Palanca residents that his cabinet will take into account their interests during negotiations with the Ukrainian side and promised to not sign the document on transmission to Ukraine of the area adjacent to the route portion before reaching a consensus with natives.

Meeting with representatives of fuel companies

A cabinet-hosted sitting tackled issues relating to fuel imports and trading on domestic market, necessity of modifying normative acts which regulate deals on fuel market. The participants exchanged opinions regarding the formation of fuel prices, while the prime minister instructed fuel companies to be very responsible over this issue and to prevent groundless rises. He assured that his cabinet is open to a frank and efficient dialogue with business environment while representatives of fuel companies promised to prevent groundless price rises.

Meeting with heads of commercial banks

The sitting reported the condition of Moldovan currency market, assuring that the current situation should not alarm people, as this is a normal phenomenon, a result of consolidation of international reserves by National Bank of Moldova (NBM) and seasonal currency procurements by importers. NBM governor assured that the situation is stable and there are no reasons of concern. The sitting also discussed the situation in construction and winemaking and vine growing sectors.


Presidency

1. Decrees

The Commission for constitutional reform was constituted of 39 personalities from diverse areas and will be headed by interim President Mihai Ghimpu. It will identify and study shortcomings of the existing constitutional system, work out recommendations for the constitutional reform. The first sitting of the commission held on December 4, 2009 decided to set up a task force for constitutional researches and analyses to consider shortcomings of the constitutional system from scientific prospects, establish political, legal, social and other kinds of consequences of such regulations; study the constitutional framework of developed democracies with the purpose to provide a compared analysis of constitutional institutions liable to new regulations and work out recommendations for the constitutional reform.

Mihai Balan was assigned presidential adviser for foreign policy and European integration.

Under a presidential decree, Alexandru Roman was relieved from the office of rector of the Academy of Public Administration under the President of Moldova.

Mr. Alexandru Cuznetov, Mr. Viorel Furdui and Mr. Ion Manole were nominated members of the Certification Commission advising the Ministry of Justice.

The Honour Order was awarded to Mr. Petr Kypr, Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Ambassador of the Czech Republic to Moldova.


Economic Policies

1. Inflation and prices

2. Macroeconomics

3. Currency market


Foreign Affairs

1. European integration

Meeting of foreign ministers within the Eastern Partnership

The first meeting of foreign ministers within the Eastern Partnership (EP) was held on December 8, in Bruxelles. The meeting drew high level participation from the 27 EU Member States, the European Commission, the six Eastern European Partner countries – Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Georgia, Republic of Moldova and Ukraine, and European institutions. The participants discussed about the achievements realized during the first year of implementation of the Eastern Partnership and established the priorities for the next year. During the Ministerial meeting, four representatives of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum, presented to the ministers the conclusions and recommendations of the Civil Society Forum, which met for the first time in Brussels on 16–17 November.

As significant achievement was recognized the adoption of Work Programmes of the four thematic cooperation (1. democracy, good governance and stability; 2. economic integration and convergence with EU sectoral policies; 3. energy security; 4. Contacts between people) for the next two years and the launch of Flagship Initiatives on Integrated Border Management and Regional Electricity Markets, Improved Energy Efficiency and Increased use of Renewable Resources, as well the Eastern Europe Energy Efficiency and Environment Partnership. During the first quarter of 2010 the two remaining flagship initiatives for Small and Medium Enterprises and on Environmental governance will be launched.

The ministers underlined the need to make further progress in line with the priorities of the Partnership, in particular regarding the negotiations on Association Agreements, including Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Areas, where appropriate, mobility of citizens, availability of funding from EIB, EBRD and international financial institutions to the Eastern Partnership, the Comprehensive Institution-Building Programmes etc.

During the meeting, Moldovan minister for Foreign Affairs, Iurie Leanca stressed the commitment of the Republic of Moldova to use all opportunities granted by the Partnership, stating that Moldova’s objectives within the Eastern Partnership are: the continued strengthening of relations with the EU, the opportunities for an Association Agreement, a free trade agreement and visa liberalisation.

Note by ADEPT: Although the EU confirmed that the future Agreement to be signed with the Republic of Moldova will an Association Agreement, it will not provide an European perspective. There are low chances that one of the states partners to the Eastern Partnership will become a candidate country to join EU in the nearest future.

Bilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Romania

In early December, the Romanian Foreign Ministry made an inventory of actions to be taken at level of administration with the purpose to enforce decisions agreed after the November 13–14 visit by Moldovan prime minister to Bucharest. According to the interim foreign minister of Romania, Catalin Predoiu, the current relationship between Romania and Republic of Moldova is excellent of work and pragmatic.

The Chisinau Government welcomes the opening of Romanian authorities. According to a press statement, Moldovan Prime Minister Vlad Filat confirmed that the Republic of Moldova will keep very good and necessary relations with Romania, no matter who will be elected president of Romania.

Republic of Moldova – Russia

The Republic of Moldova keeps doing its best to establish pragmatic relations with the Russian Federation and develop economic cooperation with this country. The deputy Prime Minister, Minister of Economy Valeriu Lazar was on a working visit to Moscow on December 11 and met there the co-chairman of the Russian-Moldovan intergovernmental commission, Andrei Fursenko, Russian minister of education and science, as part of the 44th Meeting of the CIS Economic Council. According to a statement delivered to Novosti-Moldova Agency, Valeriu Lazar stated that Russia is the key strategic partner for Moldova and good cooperation with this country is the No.1 factor to stabilise the economy of Moldova.

Republic of Moldova – Slovakia

The Slovakian Government has provided a 35,000-euro grant to Moldova for social projects. It will fund 7 projects aimed to renovate social facilities in several villages and repair roads. (According to Infotag)

Republic of Moldova – USA

The U.S. ambassador to Moldova, Mr. Asif J. Chaudhry, told a news conference on December 1 that the Board of Directors of the Millennium Challenge Account of the US Government has decided to give green light to the 262-million-dollar Compact Programme for Moldova. The assistance will be provided under the shape of a grant within 5 years to assist two sectors: the agriculture (renovation of 11 irrigation systems) and the transport (renovation of roads). The Compact Programme for Moldova will be signed in Washington in the second half of January 2010.

At the same time, the Moldovan authorities seek a strategic partnership agreement with the USA, which would strengthen the bilateral political dialogue, develop commercial-economic collaboration and cooperation in international security area. While meeting Celeste Wallander, U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defence for Russia, Ukraine and Eurasia, Moldova’s Parliament Speaker and interim President Mihai Ghimpu reported that the draft agreement was already delivered to the U.S. Embassy in Chisinau.

Republic of Moldova – Poland

Competent organs of Poland and Moldova began negotiations on December 10 to provide a 15-million-dollar credit for covering the budgetary deficit of Moldova. According to preliminary agreements, the credit will be released for a one-year term and a 3–4-percent interest rate.

3. Multilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Council of Europe

ECHR decisions

In the period examined, the European Court of Human Rights has pronounced judgements in the following cases: Gavrilovici vs. Moldova, Leva vs. Moldova and Fedotov vs. Moldova. The Court established violation of the right to not be subjected to torture and degrading treatment, freedom of expression, right to a fair trial and effective recourse, right to protection of property, right to freedom and security, right to know the reasons of arrest. Overall, the Court granted 18,300 Euros to applicants in pecuniary, non-pecuniary damages and costs and expenses.

Republic of Moldova – OSCE

During December 2–3 Athens hosted the OSCE Ministerial Council, attended by a Moldovan delegation led by Deputy Prime Minister Iurie Leanca, minister of foreign affairs and European integration.

The meeting focussed on the dialogue regarding the European security architecture (known as Corfu Process) in front of new anti-security risks. At the end of the meeting the participants adopted several declarations and decisions concerning the future dialogue on the Corfu Process, peaceful settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, consolidation of energy security cooperation, etc.

The Moldovan foreign minister addressed the meeting and called for the immediate and unconditioned resumption of the 5+2 Transnistria settlement negotiations, complete withdrawal of Russian forces and munitions from the Transnistrian region and transformation of the current peacekeeping mission into an international civil observation mission.


Studies, Analyses, Comments

BOP at the end and beginning of governing…
Igor Botan, December 15, 2009


1. Perceptions vs. realities

The accession of the Alliance for European Integration (AIE) to the governing in 2009 to replace the Party of Communists of the Republic of Moldova (PCRM) was a turning point in the social-political life in Moldova. In this respect, sociological measurements are required to assess how people realise this phenomenon and understand the change. In this light, the last two measurements by the Barometer of Public Opinion (BOP) poll commissioned by the Institute for Public Policy (IPP) have a special meaning, particularly because the PCRM wants to take revenge in 2010, barring the presidential elections to challenge early elections.

The displayed plan of PCRM to revenge indicates the need to consider the evolution of people’s perceptions for all the period when this party ruled the country. Such an exercise is necessary for several reasons. First, PCRM took over the governing in 2001 after the country achieved an economic growth of about 2 percent in 2000, while AIE inherited an economy which already suffered a decline of approximately 6 percent. These remarks are necessary, as PCRM displays its immediate exigencies with AIE. Second, remittances turned over about 100 million dollars a year when PCRM succeeded to governing in 2001, and they reached 1.9 billion dollars in 2008. Thus, the secret of keeping the PCRM authority for eight years is explained inclusively by the pretty good world and regional economic conjuncture.

Once the economic conjuncture has changed, the PCRM accepted to release relatively easy the authority to AIE, hoping that the latter will quickly self-compromise by failing to overcome economic difficulties. In this regard, the PCRM propaganda-making machine did not even give "the 100 legitimate days" to the AIE government to normally get into administrative circuit. PCRM representatives and propagandists urge AIE components to honour their electoral promises, but forgetting the inheritance they had left. That’s why the PCRM exigencies toward AIE require a clear revelation of people’s perceptions during the PCRM rule.

2. Evolution of social optimism

By making immediate pretence of AIE electoral promises, PCRM propagandists know very well what they are doing. The PCRM made many promises in the 2001 and 2005 elections, but did not fulfil many of them and simply ignored others, while evolutions were others than promised. Expectations related to electoral promises of PCRM overcome the achievements of this party and therefore, BOP measurements assessed a pretty low social optimism level.

In 2001, when PCRM took over the governing, only over 20 percent of respondents said that developments in Moldova were moving in a good direction, while approximately half of respondents feared that the direction was wrong. Now BOP reveals after the eight-year PCRM governance that less than 20 percent of respondents believe the development direction of the country is positive, while the percent of pessimists has clearly increased, exceeding 6 percent.

This is rather a positive signal for AIE, since after it got the rule, the percent of respondents who believe that the country is moving in a right direction is now back to about 30 percent, this average being typical to the whole period of PCRM governing. Maintaining this level is a necessary condition, but not enough to resist to the PCRM revenge.

Table 1. Is our country moving in a right or a wrong direction?

Is our country moving in a right or a wrong direction?

The perception of economic evolutions was bad enough during the PCRM ruling. Thus, the percent of those not so content with the economic situation has increased from about 10 percent in 2001 up to over 25 percent in 2009, while the percent of those rather content has dropped from 20 percent down to below 10 percent during the PCRM rule. Last BOP carried out in November 2009 indicates better perceptions of people in this area, too.

Table 2. To what extent are you content with the present economic situation in Moldova?

To what extent are you content with the present economic situation in Moldova?

Responses to the general question about economic condition correlate relatively well with those related to the present economic situation compared to the one of a year ago. In particular, the number of those who perceived the economic situation worse than the precedent year was generally higher. The number of respondents who believed that the economic situation was better at the end of the PCRM ruling than the precedent year has dropped by about 20 percent, compared to the year when the PCRM took over the authority and respectively the percent of those who considered the contrary has increased to an equal extent.

Table 3. How do you assess the economic situation in the Republic of Moldova compared to a year ago?

How do you assess the economic situation in the Republic of Moldova compared to a year ago?

Expectations for next year revealed that the percent of optimists has generally declined by approximately 15 percent, while that of pessimists increased by about 20 percent. Again, it is worth noting that after AIE was elected to rule the country the level of optimism regarding the economic situation as compared with the last year and expectations regarding the next year are on the rise.

Table 4. How will the economic situation in the Republic of Moldova be in a year?

How will the economic situation in the Republic of Moldova be in a year?

3. Individual perceptions related to incomes and concerns

Objectively, the extreme poverty rate had decreased much during the PCRM governing. At the level of individual perceptions the percent of respondents who earned not enough at least to cover their basic needs has dropped by approximately 20 percent, while the percent of those who earned enough just to cover their basic needs has increased by about 10 percent. The percent of those who earn enough to have a decent living has also increased by about 10 percent. The percent of wealthy people is similar to that during the PCRM ruling, within the margin of error.

Table 5. How do you assess the present income of your family?

How do you assess the present income of your family?

These findings reveal that expectations regarding economic evolutions in the country were much higher and were not met, despite the improvement of people’s individual material condition during the PCRM governing. That’s why the concern about poverty dominated during the PCRM ruling. In general, prices, children’s future and unemployment were constantly following poverty in the top of citizens’ concerns after the first mandate of PCRM. A success of PCRM in the ruling period clearly remarked by BOP was the decline on concerns about crimes.

Table 6. What are you most concerned about at present?

What are you most concerned about at present?

4. Suggestions for authorities

BOP findings reveal that the tasks regarded as of utmost importance for the Republic of Moldova did not change during the PCRM governance: developing the economy, strengthening the order, combating the corruption, improving the education, ensuring peace and understanding among people. However, the intensity of pressures from these tasks has dropped much. These evolutions may have two reasons. First, the intensity would have declined after the resolution of problems in the areas concerned; second, the social optimism assessed above has increased. Anyway, the response to the question below is a suggestion for authorities regarding people’ expectations from governors.

Table 7. Which issues do you consider as prior now for the Republic of Moldova?

Which issues do you consider as prior now for the Republic of Moldova?

Responses to the question about measures that should be undertaken to improve the social-economic situation in the country could also be suggestions for authorities: improving the law enforcement tools, developing the industry, supporting the small business, encouraging investments etc. It is worth noting than citizens’ perceptions did not change in this area, too, for many years.

Table 8. What measures should be undertaken to improve the social-economic situation in Moldova?

What measures should be undertaken to improve the social-economic situation in Moldova?

5. Trust in public and private institutions

Shortly after the PCRM succeeded to the power in 2001 the trust in public institutions has increased much, after being very low before. Thereby, after the first year of PCRM rule, the trust in President increased by more than 40 percent, in Parliament by over 30 percent, in Government by about 30 percent, and in local government by approximately 20 percent. However, the trust in courts and police did not actually increase during the PCRM governance. But by the end of the second PCRM mandate the confidence rating of President dropped by about 20 percent, compared to 2002, and the trust in Parliament and Government decreased by approximately 10–15 percent. On the other hand, the trust in all public institutions, except for the Presidency which is ruled by an interim chief of state has increased after the July 29, 2009 early parliamentary elections and takeover of governance by AIE. The clear growth of trust in political parties is probably linked to the fact that they were main protagonists of the "change" in 2009 and party leaders ran key public offices.

Table 9. To what extent do you trust?..

To what extent do you trust?..

The table below does reveal that the trust in parties which were in opposition until summer 2009 increased much than the PCRM rating dropped, and this confirms the rise of the trust in parties. It is worth noting the rise of trust in the Democratic Party of Moldova (PDM) and Liberal Democratic Party of Moldova (PLDM). The trends revealed by the last two BOP measurements confirm that these two parties have a great political future in Moldova. One may suppose that PDM will likely fuel its rating on account of former PCRM supporters, while PLDM will attract supporters of lots of democratic parties which have a low ratings, as well as on account of coalition partners – Liberal Party (PL) and Moldova Noastra Alliance (AMN). At the same time, it is worth mentioning that the latest BOP revealed the lowest rating for PCRM, equivalent to the one recorded before the 2007 local elections.

Table 10. To what extent do you trust in the following political parties?

To what extent do you trust in the following political parties?

Suppositions made above are based on responses to the question about vote intentions in case of parliamentary elections. Plans to vote for PCRM, as well as for AMN are constantly on the decline, while the number of people willing to vote for PL is somewhat stable.

Table 11. What party would you vote for, if legislative elections were held in the Republic of Moldova next Sunday?

What party would you vote for, if legislative elections were held in the Republic of Moldova next Sunday?

6. Trust in political leaders

Surveys reveal that the trust in party leaders is the guarantee of electoral success of the parties they head. In this respect, BOP reveals that after the first year of governing when he achieved the highest confidence rating, the rating of PCRM leader Vladimir Voronin was on the decline, down to over 30 percent by the end of the second mandate of PCRM. Since the rating of Vladimir Voronin keeps tending to fall down, and this fact correlates with the decline of the party’s rating, one may say that plans of PCRM to revenge are somehow hazardous.

Table 12. To what extent do you trust in the following political personalities?

To what extent do you trust in the following political personalities?

The most important indicator of the political and party leaders’ potential is to be mentioned in responses to the open question on people’s trust. The table below reveals very clear the evolution of this rating for PCRM leader Vladimir Voronin. Given the correlation of this rating with electoral results of the party, one may also assess the effects of the work of the PCRM-controlled media holding after the 2007 local elections, which the PCRM lost to opposition forces.

Table 13. Which is the political personality you trust in the most?

Which is the political personality you trust in the most?

The strong rise of confidence ratings of PDM and PLDM leaders Marian Lupu and Vlad Filat reconfirms that the parties they lead have a much stronger potential than AIE partners. As well, BOP reveals that actions by PL leaders impress less than those taken by PLDM leaders.

7. Relations with foreign partners of the Republic of Moldova

Establishing good relations with neighbours and main international partners is a strategic goal for a small country with an open economy and a low potential. The way the citizens felt these relations reveals the conduct of the PCRM governance in terms of foreign relations. Thereby, while relations with the United States, European Union and Ukraine were perceived as being at a relatively constant level, the relations with Russia and Romania faced very dangerous breakdowns. The breakdown of relationship with Russia cost the Republic of Moldova the collapse of wine industry and all emerging consequences. After such relations with Russia during the PCRM rule, this party would unlikely regain the quasi total support of the Russian-speaking electorate, which is pretty heavy. Therefore, one should not be surprised by appearance of new projects aimed to assimilate some segments of the PCRM electorate. Even more, the loss of administrative levers will not allow the PCRM any longer to bar projects such as "Russia’s Friends in Moldova" in an arbitrary manner. This is one more argument that the locking of presidential elections by PCRM in an effort to revenge at early parliamentary elections in 2010 is a very expensive political adventure for the Republic of Moldova in general and perhaps for the PCRM in particular.

Table 14. How do you assess the present relations of the Republic of Moldova with the following countries?

How do you assess the present relations of the Republic of Moldova with the following countries?

8. Conclusions


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]