ADEPT: Association for Participatory Democracy    Association for
    Participatory
    Democracy
Print version. Published on www.e-democracy.md
Original: /en/e-journal/20091231/index.shtml


e-journal, year VII, issue 150, 16–31 December, 2009

Activity of Public Institutions

Foreign Affairs

Studies, Analyses, Comments

Activity of Public Institutions

Parliament

1. Appointments. Dismissals

The Parliament appointed 6 members of the Board of Observers of the National Public Broadcasting Company "TeleRadio-Moldova":

The legislature assigned representatives of the Superior Council of Prosecutors:

Marin Molosag was nominated first deputy governor of NBM.

Victor Parlicov was appointed head of the Board of Directors of the National Agency for Energy Regulation (ANRE).

Note by ADEPT: The appointment comes after the legislation in the area was modified so that competences to nominate the ANRE administration were transferred from Government to Parliament and the number of members of the Agency Board of Directors was increased (to be noted that this law was not yet published and enforced when Pavlov was appointed).

The Parliament took notice of the resignation of Deputy Andrei Popov, elected on behalf of PDM, and declared the vacancy of this office.

The nominal composition of the Moldovan parliamentary delegations to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe and Moldova-EU Parliamentary Cooperation Committee was approved. The delegations do not include Vladimir Voronin and Grigore Petrenco and this fact revolted PCRM representatives.

2. Legislative acts

Key budgetary laws for 2010 were adopted definitively:

Law on natural gas and law on electricity. The laws set the framework needed to enforce the community policies on energy and to ratify the treaty on building the Energy Community.

Laws for the accession/ratification of some intentional acts:

Law for the modification and completion of the law concerning the special social protection of some categories of population. Under the law, nominative compensations for categories of population covered by this law will not be set starting January 1, 2010, while people who were awarded the right to nominative compensations before December 31, 2009 will get them until their right will expire in accordance with legislation and regulation established by Government. The amendments are motivated by goals of the programme on economic stabilisation and recovery and programme on optimisation of the social assistance system approved in 2007. Thus, the categories of people selected to get nominative compensations will enjoy this right in continuation as long as the right is effective in accordance with the law, while new applicants will be able to apply for social assistance in line with Law # 133-XVI of June 13, 2008 concerning social assistance. About 30 million lei would be saved a year under these amendments.

Decision approving the number of employees of the Chamber of Auditors. It preserves the same number of employees – 150 persons – though it was earlier signalled the need of seriously optimising control bodies and noted that the work of the Chamber of Auditors is inefficient in terms of sanctioning of the guilty and preventing public embezzlements.


Government

1. Appointments

The Government appointed 3 members of the certification commission advising the Ministry of Justice:

Tudor Balitchi was nominated Director-General of the Customs Service.

Sergiu Sitnic was appointed director of the National Agency for Regulation in Electronic Communication and Information Technology (ANRCETI). Sitnic ran this office in April 2008 – August 2009, when he tendered resignation.

The executive nominated several deputy ministers, so that administrations of ministries and central institutions controlled by Government are almost built.

2. Decisions

Decision concerning the establishing of the National Council of Participation. The council was created and its nominal composition and regulation were approved.

Note by ADEPT: The purpose of the council is to assist the Government to work out, implement and monitor policy documents, develop cooperation between executive and civil society. Such a structure was created in 2008, but it did not function, with the executive giving up cooperation in this area without any explanations.

Decision concerning the reorganisation of the state guard directorate-general of the Interior Ministry and territorial state guard services. In order to relieve functions of the Interior Ministry not related to public order and protection of human rights, the ministerial subdivision concerned turns into a state agency.

Decisions approving some regulations:

Decisions concerning the allocation of financial means from the reserve fund of the executive:

Decision for the modification of the Parliament Decision concerning the parliamentary investigation commission to elucidate the causes and consequences of the events that followed April 5, 2009. With the view of the necessity of studying many materials, the Parliament decided to extend the operation of the commission until April 2010.

3. Sittings. Decisions

Meeting with members of the National Confederation of Trade Unions from Moldova (CNSM)

The meeting focussed on problems faced by employees in budgetary sector and national economy and necessity of optimising the dialogue between trade unions and Government. Prime minister called for building a partnership with trade unions and welcomed the CNSM initiative to resize the tripartite dialogue format (Trade Unions, Employers, Government) with the purpose to optimise it. Speaking about increasing wages of budgetary employees, prime minister said that this will depend on state budget resources and development of national economy. As well, the premier stressed the necessity of improving the fiscal management system and reforming the pension system, actions to be coordinated with unionist partners.

Meeting with members of the National Confederation of Employers

The participants tackled a series of problems faced by representatives of the real sector of economy, inclusively the insufficient coordination between authorities in charge with drafting and promoting policies and employers in the process of elaboration and adoption of normative framework which regulates the work of enterprises, imperfect fiscal system and tariff policies, protection of domestic market and fight against illicit trade, necessity of technical regulation of products and goods, disadvantageous crediting conditions for real sector of economy. Prime minister welcomed the CNPM initiative to extend and develop cooperation between Government and Employers, stressing that it will also involve representatives of unionist organisations to ensure equilibrium in accomplishing common goals. He proposed a joint sitting with the participation of all members of his cabinet to discuss concrete problems and find solutions.

Talks with Foreign Investors Association of Moldova

Representatives of largest foreign companies in Moldova said that the situation is being improved in terms of investment conditions, but signalled some problems and bureaucratic barriers in starting up and developing business. Prime Minister Vlad Filat stressed the importance of developing an efficient partnership in the foreign investment promotion process in Moldova and noted that maintaining the zero tax on reinvested income for the next two years comes to confirm Government’s plans to facilitate the business development. The executive will focus against all negative factors faced by foreign investors in Moldova. The participants agreed at the premier’s initiative to convoke quarterly sittings and discussed existing problems, assess progresses and set goals for next period.

Statements on relations with NIT

The Government released a statement to express surprise with the way the television station NIT and certain political forces report the situation around the end of the rent contract between the Directorate General for Buildings of the Government Administration (now State Chancellery) and joint company "Noile Idei Televizate". According to the statement, allegations that the TV station NIT will become homeless once the contract is over are groundless, as NIT had privatised 1,732.2 square metres in the same building in exchange for 3,637 lei per square metre. Since the contract was not renewed, NIT should find new headquarters beforehand. The Government regrets that a common contractual relationship was turned into a political situation without any reasons and assures that it does not attempt on the right of NIT to function and will give a reasonable term to this TV station to find room.

Prime minister attends public manifestations:


Presidency

1. Decrees

Alexandru Luncari and Mihail Bodean were relieved from offices of deputy directors of the Information and Security Service.

The April 21, 2009 Decree by President of the Republic of Moldova concerning the establishing of the state commission for inquiring causes, circumstances and consequences of the April 7–8, 2009 events was abrogated, as the parliamentary investigation commission to elucidate the causes and consequences of the events that followed April 5, 2009 was set up.

Moldova’s interim president issued several decrees awarding state distinctions.

Note by ADEPT: During September – December 2009 interim President Mihai Ghimpu handed in more than one hundred state awards, including:

During March 2001 – August 2009 former Moldovan president Vladimir Voronin awarded about 2,000 state distinctions, of which more than 600 orders, more than 1,050 medals and more than 320 honour nominations. Under Law # 1123 of 30.07.1992 concerning state distinctions of the Republic of Moldova, the type of accolade is chosen depending on merits of individuals and legal entities to be awarded, and they are awarded under decrees by President of Moldova, in line with the regulation approved by chief of state. The regulation concerned says that as a rule, the request on awarding shall be submitted to the higher-ranking organ or organisation by the staff of the candidate and the candidacies shall be studied by a staff meeting. State distinctions may be also awarded at the initiative of public authorities, ministries, departments, supreme organs of public organisations, artistic unions. Applications for state awards shall be coordinated with city hall or district council, central authorities, who shall agree with republican unionist committees, coordinate them with the competent permanent commission of the Parliament of Moldova and deliver them to President of the Republic of Moldova.


Foreign Affairs

1. European integration

Meeting of Moldova-EU Cooperation Council

The meeting took place in Brussels on December 21 and the Moldovan delegation was led by Prime Minister Vlad Filat and Deputy Prime Minister Iurie Leanca, minister of foreign affairs and European integration. According to a communique by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration, the parties reviewed some issues relating to Moldova-EU cooperation; situation related to rule of law, human rights, results of economic and sectoral cooperation etc. They discussed the Transnistrian problem as well. The sides signed a joint statement at the end of the meeting, stressing the following facts:

As well, the parties signed an understanding memorandum on EU advising assistance for the Moldovan Government. EU will deploy a high-ranking advice group to key institutions of Moldova to assist Moldovan authorities in implementing democratic and economic reforms needed to join the EU. According to Prime Minister Vlad Filat, the meeting concerned opened the EU over Moldova and confirmed its readiness to support Moldova in exploring new opportunities of reaching the European integration goal.

Moldova – member of European Energy Community

The accession of Moldova and Ukraine to the European Energy Community was approved during the 7th Meeting of the Energy Community Ministerial Council in Zagreb, Croatia on December 18, 2009. The accession will be effective just in the case Moldova and Ukraine will get rid of shortcomings of national legislation on natural gas and will adjust it to requirements of the acquis communautaire. According to the European Commissioner for Energy, Andris Piebalgs, the accession of Moldova and Ukraine to the Energy Community will catalyse the reforms in energy sector of these countries and will enhance their energy security.

2. Bilateral cooperation

Republic of Moldova – Romania

The end of presidential elections in Romania and nomination of a new Romanian Government gave light to the Moldova-Romania relations. Shortly after the appointment of the Boc Cabinet, Moldovan Prime Minister Vlad Filat and Foreign Minister Iurie Leanca had telephone conversations with their Romanian counterparts, Romanian Premier Emil Boc and Foreign Minister Teodor Baconschi, about current priorities of bilateral relations. On the other hand, the Moldovan Government ordered competent authorities to issue the documents needed to remove the barbed wire walls at the border with Romania and decided to open the Consulate General of Moldova in Iasi.

Republic of Moldova – Ukraine

Ukrainian Foreign Minister Pyotr Poroshenko was on a flash visit to Chisinau on December 17 to meet his Moldovan counterpart Iurie Leanca and Prime Minister Vlad Filat. The agenda also included issues related to bilateral relations: demarcation of the Moldova-Ukraine border, settlement of the Transnistrian conflict, cooperation within GUAM, as well as within Eastern Partnership. The ministers summarised the Moldova-Ukraine relationship and agreed to go ahead with the demarcation of the Transnistrian section of the Moldova-Ukraine border. As well, they signed a joint letter to Mrs. Catherine Ashton, Vice President of the European Commission, High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, to announce the plans of the parties to establish the Euroregion "Nistru" and seek appropriate financial and technical support within the Eastern Partnership. The cooperation agreement on ensuring the right of national minorities was signed during the visit.

The process of demarcation of the Moldova-Ukraine border began on December 28, as the first border pillar was installed in the presence of official delegations from both countries and EU representatives.

Republic of Moldova – China

On December 17, Prime Minister Vlad Filat and the Chinese Ambassador to Moldova, Shi Longzhuang, signed an agreement on economic and technical cooperation between governments of the two countries. Under this agreement, the Chinese Government will provide an unredeemable grant worth 20 million Yuan (about 3 million US dollars) to Moldova as technical assistance. Areas to be covered by this grant will be established later with the Chinese side. The assistance is expected to cover spending for participation in the 2010 Shanghai world exhibition and promote Moldovan wines on Chinese market. As well, negotiations on signing the one-billion-dollar loan agreement for Moldova by China go on.

Note by ADEPT: China’s efforts to intensify relations with the new Chisinau Government match China’s current strategy on strengthening trade relations with Central and Eastern Europe. At the same time, China’s grant could be interpreted as an action preceding the signing of the one-billion-dollar loan agreement, a measure matching with China’s current strategy on diversifying reserve currencies.


Studies, Analyses, Comments

Political year 2009
Igor Botan, December 30, 2009


1. Who begins with farces, ends up with "broken heart"?..

As a rule, tragic events reverberate with farces. In this light, developments experienced by Moldova had a reverse succession in 2009. The year began with a farce but ended with a tragic finding – former president Vladimir Voronin and adherents of the Party of Communists of the Republic of Moldova (PCRM) he leads had their "hearts broken" at the end of the year.

Hence, the first resounding and auspicating event of the political year 2009 was recorded on January 15, shortly after winter holidays. On that day, Prosecutor-General Valeriu Gurbulea and Deputy Interior Minister Valentin Zubic produced themselves as showmen, telling the vox populi that they allegedly hold evidence proving that an opposition leader, Serafim Urechean, planned to kill deputy speaker Iurie Rosca.

Planned for the eve of the official start of electoral campaign for parliamentary elections, the event concerned should probably shake the public opinion by introducing the opponents of the PCRM as inhuman, as well as silly, unable at least to hire a killer capable to do his mission well. But the "broken heart" of the killer did not resist under the burden of crime that he promised to accomplish, making him come home by the weeping cross, leaving a mea-culpa letter revealing the names of criminal commanders to Moldovan Pinkertons.

Up till then, almost all leaders of political parties with a rating of more than 2 percent had criminal charges on their names for alleged crimes: Serafim Urechean had 4 criminal cases on his name; Vlad Filat – 3; Dorin Chirtoaca – 3 etc., but none of them was shocking. Therefore, the authorities probably needed an innovating approach to shake the opposition. The campaign for parliamentary elections opened that way, aiming to ensure the triumph of the PCRM at all costs, so that the latter to not need the opposition’s support for building a new government.

But the irony of fate wanted the PCRM to be short of approximately two hundredths of percent of votes at the April 5 elections to get the 61st out of 101 seats needed to accomplish the renewal of the PCRM governing. The harassment and introduction of opposition leaders as inhuman and criminals by the PCRM propaganda made the opposition leaders decline any political arrangements with the PCRM for election of a chief of state. In consequence, early parliamentary elections were held on July 29, with the PCRM failing them and former opposition parties building the ruling Alliance for European Integration (AIE).

It is important to note that the two parliamentary electoral campaigns contributed decisively to resizing the political scene. The new political configuration is not stable at all, but has two new strong pillars – the Liberal Democratic Party of Moldova (PLDM) and the Democratic Party of Moldova (PDM). Both parties have very comfortable seats – on centre-right and on centre-left, and that’s why findings of surveys last autumn which revealed that these parties fuel their electoral basins on account of immediate neighbours from political scene did not surprise.

A key conclusion of the political year 2009 effective for political confrontations in 2010 is that the best strategy to win is to be honest, to respect rules of reason and legal norms. This is the only way to enjoy tactical and strategic victories. The PCRM example should teach all. This party won about 50 percent and 45 percent at the two elections in 2009, but none of political forces, members of other parties wanted to cooperate with the PCRM. So what is the good of such overwhelming victories? Is it for having your "heart broken" at the end?

2. Millennium challenges?..

The Republic of Moldova set an absolute record in the first year of the 3rd millennium – a communist party succeeded to the ruling, for the first time in the history of humanity, by winning free and fair elections, not through a coup d’etat. Year 2009 will be probably also marked in the annals of the 3rd millennium, as the Republic of Moldova has become the first country in the world whose citizens set on fire the Parliament and Presidency on the 8th anniversary of rule of communist leader Vladimir Voronin. This coincidence is quite sinister.

The results of the April 5 elections surprised many of those who expected the change. They could not imagine the PCRM winning a categorical score after the failure at the 2007 local elections. The way the electoral campaign developed and the trend of authorities to fabricate charges and plan political farces made opposition political leaders and many young people protest against alleged election frauds.

By the end of 2009 nobody is able to indicate any systematised and officialised documents to prove the election frauds on Election Day. However, thousands and tens of thousands of protesters who improvised the funerals of Moldovan democracy after elections were right to protest against administrative abuses and political farces staged by authorities to discredit the opposition and preserve the rule at all costs.

The enigma of the April 7 revolt was not explained and will not be cleared for a long time ahead. It was not made clear who made some peaceful demonstrators go ahead and storm the Presidency and Parliament buildings; who were the instigators; why the police were incapable to reply proportionally and appropriately with the exclusive purpose to discourage instigators; who and why did he order the youth hunt after the storming of the Presidency and Parliament buildings; why the state commission in charge with investigating the April 7 events did not fulfil its mission etc.

The lack of answers to these questions and the proved trend of authorities to fabricate political farces made many Moldovan citizens believe that the diverting of the April 7 peaceful protests was an attempt of some ruling circles to discredit the opposition and destroy it within a campaign such as "Let’s defend our Motherland!". But the farce turned into a true tragedy. The Parliament and Presidency headquarters were really destroyed and hearts of those in charge with ensuring good governance and preventing the destruction of public estates were broken.

3. "Moldova Planet" did not disappear from the world map

Inventors of the musical Moldova Planet" project did not even guess how successfully they reflect the domestic realities. Unfortunately, year 2009 made this project useless, so that distinguishing real from imaginary, invented events became almost impossible. How heavy is the manifesto-programme of the Greceanai Government focussed on preventing the disappearance of Moldova from the world map. But it happened that by the end of 2009 the PCRM was not ruling the country for already almost half a year and Moldova is still part of the world map?! Given these facts, any citizen of Moldova is right to wonder what for an eventual PCRM revenge, if Moldova is still part of the world map without being watched by this party? However, PCRM leaders still believe that the phobias they have intensively cultivated in society should challenge nervous or psychosis crises among people on the 2010 New Year’s Eve, when interim President Mihai Ghimpu, declared Romanian and unionist, address population!

Up till then, the twitches of PCRM were manifested through the insistent demand of dismissal of Mihai Ghimpu from office of Parliament speaker, and therefore, from post of acting President of the Republic of Moldova. But Mihai Ghimpu is the politician with aces. The first ace he used to defeat the PCRM is that while introducing himself as Romanian and unionist he says that his party is not unionist and does not have statute-based tasks in this respect. The move is strong because the unionist electorate is happy, too, as its representative runs two supreme state offices and the Republic of Moldova is still part of the world map as sovereign and independent state. Nothing unusual, as the PCRM itself proved that unionist Romanians do not endanger the sovereignty and independence of the Republic of Moldova. Otherwise, Vladimir Voronin would not have nominated the leader of the Christian Democratic People’s Party (PPCD), a successor of the Popular Front of Moldova, as deputy prime minister in charge with coordinating the work of security services.

In general, Moldova does not face as many problems as acting President Mihai Ghimpu has aces in his hands to solve them. In this regard, it made no sense for the revenging propaganda machine of PCRM to introduce the acting President Mihai Ghimpu in a negative light. It alleged that CIS heads of state do not believe Ghimpu, as they did not give green light to his invitation to visit the Cricova cellars, or that he would endanger Moldova’s fate since he has no idea about the rating agency Fitch etc. Of course, Mihai Ghimpu would lose an image competition with former president Vladimir Voronin for the time being. For example, Mihai Ghimpu would unlikely dare to invite Vladimir Putin in Chisinau and further tell him that he changed his mind. Ghimpu would also lose to Voronin in terms of radicalism of decisions. In this respect, Voronin as leader of a communist party was courageous to declare the liberal revolution, but who would believe that Liberal Ghimpu is capable to declare a communist revolution? Another example – Voronin was ready to throw the Moldovan wine in the Dniester after the Russian Federation embargoed it, while Ghimpu was not able the least to serve the same wine to CIS leaders for free. Perhaps CIS heads of state did not give green light to invitation of acting President Mihai Ghimpu because they feared that Moldova does not have any wine after former president Voronin threatened to throw it all in the Dniester, or they thought that the wine is bad, as who would throw a good wine?

Ghimpu could compete with Voronin on an equal footing in high areas of arts, culture, and appreciation of merits of producers of moral and spiritual values. They even complete each other in these areas, like Russians say: ��� ������ – ���� (two shoes – one pair)! Respectively, one is placed on the right, the other one on the left. The propaganda-making machine of PCRM and some malicious commentators accused Ghimpu of being insensible while approaching some sensitive issues such as revealing merits of people, of "awarding lots of orders and medals." But this is a manifestation of the virtue of being generous. Former president Voronin gave in 2008 two pictures to his Russian counterpart being guided by his generosity. However, it was found out later that the pictures were fake, counterfeited, but it does not matter, since he wanted to be generous. However, after that story Moldovans defeated Chukchis in tops of Russian jokes, while Ukrainian president started calling Moldovans some of his talented employees.

Anyway, the life has become funnier since Mihai Ghimpu got the ruling in 2009. Even dreams of the innocent acting president make us smile, as he was so touched when he told journalists his wish for Santa Claus to bring him a cigarette which he would like to smoke and then stop smoking. Giving his joking nature, one may think that he would like a hashish and thank Santa later, decorating the Christmas Tree with the Order of the Republic for special contribution to overthrowing the communist regime and succeeding liberals to the governing. And he would be right, as the role of the Christmas Tree was important. Unfortunately, the epoch of coniferous populism ended once the change came in 2009, but it’s funny anyway to live on the "Moldova Planet", though it’s harder to survive.

4. "Gapon-style" public life

A series of provocations inciting to ethnic and religious hatred etc., were observed in 2009. The No. 1 provocation was recorded on December 13, when a group of parishioners from a church of the Moldovan Metropolitan Church broke into a public place and removed the mosaic Menorah installed by the Jewish community from Moldova on Hanukkah Day.

Two issues raise concern in connection with this incident. The first is related to the fact that in a laic state an action authorised by local public administration and welcomed by central authorities through participation of a representative who runs the office of deputy foreign minister was contested in a defiant and disqualifiable manner by a group of Orthodox Christians, declared protectors of the ancestral Christian Orthodox religion against "base tykes who try to besmirch us…".

The authorities had a prompt reaction. Minister of justice qualified this provocation appropriately, while Prime Minister Vlad Filat said later that the "protest was an ordinary provocation by a political party, which will be punished in front of law… As for the extremism, we will provide very clear evidence and actions by the end of this year." One may suppose that the party concerned is the one which worked in 2009 under the slogan "Let’s defend our Mothereland", as the Christian Orthodox parishioners called for "let’s defend our country" against enemies. Certainly, the provocation had several goals, with the group of protestors carrying Russian imperial flags from the 19th century and the slogan "Orthodox Church – mother of Romanian people" attributed to late poet Mihai Eminescu. The demonstrators were astonishingly selective, as Mihai Eminescu is also the writer of the poem Imparat si Proletar (King and Proletarian) and Viata (Life), in which he expressed his citizen attitude towards those who used his name during the protest concerned.

Second, the demonstrators who introduced themselves as Orthodox Christians justified their actions of profaning the Menorah because it would represent an unrecognised symbol and therefore inacceptable in a public place. But things here seem to be more than curious, as the Jewish Menorah is copied from the image of the candlestick that God commanded Moses in an imperative manner to manufacture. As for Jews, nobody else but the most genial apostle, Paul, told his opinion in the epistle to Romans: "Did God quit His people? Never! I am an Israelite, too, from the seed of Abraham, from the tribe of Benyamin. God did not quit His people he knew before." Then who is authority in eyes of Moldovan Orthodox Christians? By the way, Saint Paul developed the idea of relationship between Israelites and other nations by using the metaphor about grafting of wide olive sprigs on stalk with divine roots and prevented those grafted to not be prideful. Who will explain the root and the grafted sprig to Christian Orthodox protestors?

The reaction of the Moldovan Metropolitan Church to manifestations of intolerance and hatred against Jews was briefed to some regrets and admonition over authorities, but there was a certain clemency over protestors: "We consider that this disagreeable incident in the capital downtown could be prevented if the Jewish Menorah would have been installed near the memorial of holocaust victims. We call this way upon municipal authorities to take into account the opinion of majority of people who share the Orthodox religion, while sanctioning and coordinating religious demonstrations. The Moldovan Metropolitan Church respects the sentiments and religious convictions of members of religious denominations which are legally registered in the Republic of Moldova and expects the same attitude from them."

The context above reminds the fact that former president Voronin stated in July 2007 while addressing bishops and priests at Condrita monastery that "Jesus was the first communist." In all unlikelihood, "the opinion of predominant majority which has the Christian Orthodox religion coincides with the opinion of Mr. Voronin, but none of devotional Orthodox Christians protested and corrected the "errant son".

In such circumstances, given the very negative reactions of the embassy and Foreign Ministry of Israel to the December 13 incident, what kind of treatment should representatives of the Metropolitan Church of Moldova expect when they would like, for example, to organise pilgrimages in holy, Biblical places in Israel? Or what kind of treatment should an eventual metropolitan delegation expect while going to Jerusalem to bring the Holy Fire? Would the Israeli authorities be clement while issuing documents to delegations from the Metropolitan Church of Moldova, which was somehow reticent in condemning the barbarism and intolerance actions? Will parishioners be told that the new AIE authorities are to blame for eventual complications related to bringing the Holy Fire from Jerusalem? Are "the assault on Moldova" and "the assault on ancestral Orthodox religion" part of the same political project? – this is a legitimate question in this context.

6. Transnistrian settlement

The Transnistrian settlement stagnated in 2009, as expected in an electoral year. Even more, forecasts that Moldovan authorities will yield in exchange for the Russian electoral support have become true, as they had to sign on March 18 the Bravikha Declaration, in which the Moldovan authorities do not insist much on honouring of decisions of the 1999 Istanbul OSCE Summit concerning the withdrawal of the Russian military presence from the eastern region of the Republic of Moldova.

It is worth noting that in 2009, on the 8th anniversary of the PCRM rule, the Transnistrian settlement negotiation process was blocked for the third year in a row. In 2001, when the PCRM took over the ruling, the negotiation process was the least developing, and the electoral promise of the party was to settle the conflict definitively. It is true that the "5+2" format set in 2005 but frozen in March 2006 has a huge potential for settling the conflict, but the potential is due to the EU enlargement to borders of the Republic of Moldova.

After taking over the ruling, the AIE government decided on September 25, 2009 to dissolute the Reintegration Ministry, but the Transnistrian authorities did not care about this change. The Tiraspol foreign minister, Vladimir Yastrebchyak, said that the dissolution of the Reintegration Ministry is unimportant, as the Tiraspol authorities did never cooperate with this ministry. Contacts between the two conflicting parties have always been ensured by representatives of the Republic of Moldova and Transnistrian region. In 2009 the least an essential obstacle in the Transnistrian settlement process was removed – the personal animosity between former Moldovan president Vladimir Voronin and Transnistrian leader Igor Smirnov. Further, the new governance is expected to restart the negotiation process in the "5+2" format, in order to identify solutions to approach positions and definitive resolution.

In all likelihood, the conflict will keep being frozen for a long time. First, solutions of quick progress are impossible in the crisis situation and incertitude faced by the Republic of Moldova, which will last the least 1–2 years, period when contacts and consultations in the "5+2" format shall be preserved and developed. Second, it is worth to note that the No.1 phenomenon related to Transnistrian region observed in 2009 is that the intensity of internal enmities among political forces from Transnistria exceeded the intensity of animosities between Chisinau and Tiraspol for the first time in the history of the Tiraspol regime. This fact carries a great potential for the Chisinau authorities, shall they know to persuade with measures aimed to strengthen the trust of common people from the left bank of the Dniester that the country unification is the best way to get rid of existing problems.

The process of stabilisation and recovery of Moldovan economy should be accompanied by a supported external activity to eventually try inserting the Transnistria file in the process of resetting the Russia-US relations and Russia-EU relations. This will probably be the best chance to settle the Transnistrian conflict, avoiding the useless antagonising of Russia.

7. Foreign policy

The foreign relations of the Republic of Moldova had a crucial impact on internal developments in 2009. First of all, European organisations and envoys helped maintaining a minimum of calm in internal political life after post-electoral events. A month after the April 7 events the Electoral Parliament (EP) adopted a resolution on the situation in Moldova, giving an appropriate qualification to developments, condemning the harassment campaign, grave violations of human rights and all other illegal actions committed by the Moldovan government after elections, and urged the Moldovan authorities to stop any illegal arrests and honour the assumed international commitments and obligations relating to democracy, rule of law and human rights. At present, at the end of 2009, it is interesting to note that the then chairman of the commission for EU-Moldova parliamentary cooperation, Grigore Petrenco, described the EP resolution as an insult against Moldovan people, as it brought grave and groundless accusations against constitutional authorities of the Republic of Moldova. On the other hand, another member of the PCRM faction then, first deputy speaker Vladimir Turcan said that the Resolution of the Council of Europe and that of the European Parliament on Moldova are basic documents for negotiations between authorities and opposition.

In general, the Moldova-EU relations entered an impasse after the April 7 events, when the Moldovan authorities brutally breached the human rights and opened the youth hunt, as the Chisinau authorities, particularly former president Vladimir Voronin publicly disagreed with the EU strategy of Eastern Partnership, calling it an attempt to build the second CIS. Even more, the Moldovan Government introduced visa requirements for Romania on April 9. The decision was illegal, as no other political or juridical act was adopted to establish and prove the danger posed by the visa-free entry in Moldova of citizens of an EU state such as Romania, while a special law abolished on January 1, 2007 the visa requirements for EU citizens etc.

However, the meeting of the EU General Affairs and External Relations Council (GAERC) adopted the conclusions on the Republic of Moldova on June 15, which came to confirm the EU commitment for strengthening relations inclusively by adopting the negotiation mandate for the new EU-Moldova agreement to replace the Partnership and Cooperation Agreement (PCA). The GAERC conclusions confirmed the commitments to develop relations with Moldova on the basis of community values and principles inclusively within the Eastern Partnership and adopt the negotiation mandate for the new Moldova-EU agreement. The negotiations should begin after the Republic of Moldova would accept an equal treatment for all EU citizens, including Romania, and would respect the good neighbourhood principle.

Relations with EU were resumed just after the AIE took over the governing and cancelled the visa requirements for Romania. Moldova’s external relations have normalised by the end of 2009. This is certainly the merit of Premier Vlad Filat, Minister Iurie Leanca, other members of the AIE Government, who succeeded to attract much sympathy from foreign partners of Moldova after visiting other countries and receiving foreign officials in Chisinau – the IMF promise to fund Moldova, the US financial support to the Compact programme, the signing of the small border traffic agreement with Romania, normalisation of trade relations with Russia, development of contacts with Ukraine etc. However, the greatest success is the EU decision confirmed within the Cooperation Council in late December to begin on January 12, 2010 the negotiations on the Association Agreement with EU, which would foresee a deeper political cooperation and economic integration with the Republic of Moldova.

In general, the heterogeneous nature of AIE components has an appreciable potential for promoting a balanced foreign policy, so that the Republic of Moldova to be able to avoid useless political actions and statements on withdrawal from CIS, etc. As for relations with NATO, the Republic of Moldova has to accomplish lots of tasks stipulated by IPAP, which was signed by PCRM government with NATO. The plenary fulfilment of strategic goals in the limits of documents signed by the communist governance would deprive the PCRM of propagandistic possibilities against AIE members.

The most important capital gained in terms of foreign relations – the sympathy and support of key foreign partners of the Republic of Moldova – should turn in 2010 into a political, economic and financial support to overcome effects of the economic-financial and political crisis.


Economy: retrospectives 2009 vs. forecasts 2010
Iurie Gotisan, December 31, 2009


Effects of economic crisis…

The economic crisis had more or less devastating effects on Moldova in 2009 for sure. The Moldovan crisis does not have distinct particularities in general. This crisis is afferent to an economy which is quasi dependent on external factors, as the economic growth in the latest period was particularly due to earnings of Moldovan migrants working abroad, which means that the economy is mainly based on consumption. Political events, in particular those recorded during the two parliamentary campaigns have affected economic processes in country at a large or small extent, but not at the same extent as the economy was hit after the world crisis. On the other hand, the formal non-recognition and non-participation of the former government in concrete actions against some problems made us "hostages" of an ample recession. In particular, the GDP dropped by 7.7 percent in January-September 2009 and the decline for the whole year could be 8–9 percent.

However, the Republic of Moldova faced a prolonged economic crisis in evolutional terms. Ascents and descents of the productive sector could not keep the economy on waterline. The sectors hit by the crisis could sustain the Moldovan economy, as the latter was mainly based on earnings of Moldovans working abroad; in other terms, Moldova had and has a consumer economy. For example, the agriculture. The situation in this sector did not change much compared with the pre-crisis period. Moldova has the same extensive, primitive and unequipped agriculture. It lacks a real agriculture like neighbouring economies such as Romania or Ukraine and it would seriously hit the economy if ever perturbed. It does not have a developed market like western countries or the least like Romania, and this fact would strongly jeopardise the financial-bank system.

On the other hand, there is no solution, as the structure of economy was built this way. This is the true at the end. For example, the agriculture employs about 35 percent of the economically active labour force, while it contributes with 18–20 percent to the GDP formation. Even more, profitableness in agriculture depends more on weather than on state policies. At the same time, the crisis hit the building sector the most, after this sector has achieved a great progress in the latest period, but the funding was not lasting and programmatic, but sporadic, depending on international labour market that means on money of Moldovans working abroad. The transportation was another sector hit by the crisis seriously, as it dropped by more than 50 percent in connection with the downfall of exports and imports. Operation of hundreds of export-import companies was jeopardised in connection with the fall of demand and supply inside and outside of the country. These facts altogether resuscitated the rise of unemployment, as lots of companies discharged their employees. Formal accounts say that the unemployment rate could exceed 7 percent in 2009 (www.statistica.md).

So, the economic year 2009 is expected to end with a sombre perspective for sacral sectors, particularly for all of us who faced the dreadful financial and economic crisis. Preliminary data for 2009 already indicate a budgetary deficit of nearly 9 percent of GDP, an expected economic recession of 8–9 percent, and revenues worth 14 billion lei, which is by about 4.5 billion lei less than the budgetary forecast. A budgetary deficit of 6.4 percent of GDP was proposed for 2010, with expenses being reduced much. However, certain economists fear that even a 7-percent deficit followed by a fiscal crisis is a serious challenge for Government. The fiscal crisis involves painful adjustments, especially in areas suffering of a low economic growth potential.

Government Programme and enounced priorities…

Nevertheless, the instauration of the new Government, which people expect to improve their lives and already took revolutionary measures, seems to remedy the situation, but effects will not be immediate. The Government Programme Economic Stabilisation and Recovery for 2009–2011 aims above all to revive the real sector of economy, and optimise public funds and pays a great attention to social aspects. There are three major challenges which the Government will have to handle. Many actions have been taken to sustain economic agents in these difficult times. Many export restrictions for domestic producers, as well as business registration and licence issuance formalities have been cancelled etc., with these measures being capable to give a respiro to companies in order to recover from economic crisis.

On the other hand, the problem of quality, productivity and conformity of Moldovan products persists so far. The still low quality of Moldovan products bars the massive reorientation of exports to the West. Perhaps domestic managers invest too little in marketing and promotion of their goods, and this is very important. For example, the great majority of companies in Romania allocate 5–10 percent of turnover in promotion of their products, while businesses in Moldova allocate 1–3 percent of their turnover for this purpose. The incompatibility of quality, certification, standardisation and conformity standards with those from EU members hardens the access of Moldovan products to the West.

But if Moldovan enterprises will keep ignoring the growth of productivity and quality (a task of business managers rather than of state structures), they will face serious problems. Enhancing productivity and quality shall be a strategic priority of Moldova for the next future, as Chisinau officials shall provide concrete examples when they will negotiate a more advantageous trade system with the West.

Public funds and budget for 2010…

The draft budget for 2010 is austere that means reducing expenses while increasing some incomes with the purpose to lower the budgetary deficit. An austere budget would also mean a high budgetary deficit, giving the commitment strongly assumed in front of the International Monetary Fund. In fact, the economic crisis and myopia of those in charge with the public budget the last years pushed Moldova to an impasse, after investments in real estate sector had been fervently promoted, almost ceasing the commodity production. The Government shows a clear political willingness to normalise public funds.

As for the fiscal policy, the authorities are testing any possibility in crisis times to enhance fiscal revenues, which increase budgetary incomes. The heavy fiscal "burden" (annual budget incomes compared to GDP) is being discussed in Moldova for a long time. However, Moldova is part of countries with unstrained taxation in Europe. For example, the "fiscal recipe" in EU-27 exceeded 43 percent of GDP in 2008, compared with nearly 30 percent in Moldova. The "taxation rate" includes all taxes and mandatory social fees.

Therefore, high taxes and excises would not hit people, as rises would cover some luxury products with an elastic demand – tobacco, spirits etc. Higher taxes and excises would not necessarily have negative effects (this would mobilise companies to save resources, be more efficient and enhance productivity) the least for a long term. Higher fuel prices would certainly mark up prices of some services and products which have a heavy share in production cost, particularly because the fuel price is present in many consumer products. However, higher prices of these products should not be regarded as a serious threat in general. A higher fuel price is not necessarily a bad news for the state budget, as it would bring higher excises, larger budget incomes, and authorities could handle social challenges well.

Funding for social sector…

The (economic) ruling programme foresees a series of social protection measures addressing poor categories, such as increasing social indemnities for children, elderly, etc. A novel priority is supporting the employment of jobseekers and former emigrants. All these actions will depend on stabilisation and optimisation of public funds, a basic priority of the acting Government. The way the Government will implement this programme, its skills, perseverance and intelligence, capacity to take recommended actions, and not the last, the way the executive will explain this programme to people will be very important.

The authorities should think well about future jobseekers, as their number will be high. One cannot discharge employees by closing eyes, as the private economy does not open jobs. But shortening the work time as a social solidarity formula would be a solution. Many European countries use this measure. They do it because they cannot achieve any longer the economic growth rates of 6–8 percent like the precedent years, and the international environment has changed, becoming more complicated. Of course, people cannot like these assessments, but their meaning should strengthen economic policy messages promoted by authorities.

However, achieving again an economic growth in 2010–11 would be a relief. A massive absorption of foreign funds would be a great advantage. Resuming negotiations with IMF and other development partners is a great progress made by Moldova in 2009. The donor community (IMF, WB, EU, Millennium Challenge Account etc.) is open to cooperation and crediting, and this would compensate the volume of necessary adjustment of budgetary expenses for 2010 and opening of social and infrastructure projects aimed at economic redress.

Expectations for 2010….

The 4th quarter of 2009 could reach the bottom of the crisis and could be the last quarter of economic decline, so that the economy would start recovering in 2010, no latter than in the 2nd quarter. Businesspersons, exporters, Moldovan producers are probably waiting for redress signals from regional markets. There are signs that international markets have overcome the critical situation and the International Monetary Fund confirmed it.

In fact, Moldova enjoys an advantage in 2010, which would guarantee a relatively fast recovery, as the financial system (banking in particular) did not suffer, banks did not go bankrupt (Investprivatbank is a distinct case) and the government is not required to get involved like in other countries. A functioning financial system helps recovering from recession. The banking will keep facing disadvantageous credits in 2010 for sure, which according to official accounts exceed 15 percent of overall loans; that means banks will keep being restrictive in terms of crediting and very careful in terms of costs.

Prices on real estate market could fall in 2010, but those willing to buy a home should wait and monitor evolutions on real estate market. One should not forget that 2010 could also be an electoral year and therefore, the course of economic reforms or potential changes could go other way. Fiscal policy and afferent budget for 2010 are austere and restrictive, but nothing else could be done in the current crisis conditions. The internal and external debt, fiscal policy and budget for 2010 will be the big challenges of the year. Salary policy, exchange rate and evolution of prices will be the focus of talks between authorities and international financial organisations in general and IMF in particular.

The inflation will be the target of targets in 2010, perhaps more than in the precedent years. Other macroeconomic indicators which have an impact on population will depend on inflation rate. So far, one may assure that the annual inflation rate will not exceed the 5-percent target foreseen by the draft budget for 2010, but it could also overpass the forecast, should prices of hydrocarbon and energy imports increase, a fact indicated by authorities as well. The inflation will have the heaviest impact on economy for sure.

NBM will probably practise a directed currency regime in 2010 as well, in a special effort to control inflation. But evolutions on regional and international markets will be also important. The very good relationship established between authorities and international financial organisations in general and IMF and WB in particular will be a great signal for institutional and other investors in 2010. In addition, Government’s relations with the European Commission have improved, with the latter disbursing funding worth tens of millions of Euros. One should not forget the productive cooperation between Government and Millennium Challenge Corporation, which gave green light to the signing of the Compact Programme in early 2010.

The year will not be easy, given the economic conjuncture and potential indebting which could increase both at internal and external level, but efforts, patience, striving help overcoming at least some of them.


The contributors to this issue are:


© 2001-2015 Association for Participatory Democracy "ADEPT"
Reproduction of the materials is welcomed provided the source is indicated
   e-mail: [email protected]